High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/459/2016disposed of

Pooja Mittal v. Vinay Mittal

2018-02-14Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri8 pages

! "#$$%&'&() $*+,"+- .

0"&##"1 233$11"(# 4' 4&("-&##"1 2 $'3(5$(# ) 67 88 67 8

4 877

+$'$(#) +8"#-"9&+8&(:;"5"9.59%"#$+#;$"33$11"(# +"<&#=;,+"(".59%"#$+#;$+$'3(5$(# 33$11"(#>&$;"'&(9?$5#;$0,+&'5&%#&(#;&',+#,(5$+ 8$%#&( / #;$ &(5, "++&":$ %#. + ';+# @#;$ %#6. "::+&$9$5 *- +5$+5"#$59$<*$+.

3"''$5*-&'#+&%#,5:$."<,("":"+. 5&+$%#&(:#;$"33$11"(#>&$#+$,(5"',< 1"%'##;$+$'3(5$(#A ;,'*"(5 ( "%%,(# #;$ "33$11"(# >&$ ;"9&(: 3#$5 # "9&5 ;$+ "33$"+"(%$"##;$'#":$'$%(5<#&(&(3+%$$5&(:',(5$+8$%#&( B #;$%# +&$ "%#' +$1$9"(# + #;$ 5$%&'&( #;$ 3+$'$(# "33$"1 "+$ #;"##;$"33$11"(#"(5#;$+$'3(5$(#;"5&1$5"3$#&#&(,(5$+8$%#&( B #;$%#(,1-

+5&9+%$*-<,#,"1%('$(#;$+$'3(5$(#

;,'*"(5 ;"5 ":+$$5 # 3"- " ',< ' 1"%' # #;$ "33$11"(# #>"+5' $C3$('$'<"++&":$.5>+-"+#&%1$'*$'&5$',#,+$"(53"'#<"&(#$("(%$ $;"53"&5"',< 1"%'"##;$#&<$'#"#$<$(##;$&+'#<#&( "(5+$<"&(&(:"<,(# 'B 1"%'>"'#*$3"&5"##;$#&<$'$%(5 <#&( ("(,"+- .

>;$(#;$<"##$+>"'&C$5++$%+5&(:#;$ '#"#$<$(#"#'$%(5<#&(.#;$"33$11"(#>&$<"5$"'#"#$<$(##;"#';$5&5 (#>"(##:$#5&9+%$"(5>"(#$5#+$'&5$>&#;#;$+$'3(5$(#;&'>"' 11>$5 *- #;$ '#"#$<$(# <"5$ *- #;$ +$'3(5$(# #;"# '&(%$ ';$ ;"5 >&#;5+">(;$+%('$(#.#;$+$'3(5$(#"1'>&#;5+">'#;$3$#&#&(+$'$+9&(: ;&'+&:;###"?$*"%?#;$"<,(# 1"%'>;&%;;"'*$$(3"&5*-;&< #>"+5'3"+#3"-<$(##;$'$##1$5"<,(#;$3$#&#&(,(5$+8$%#&( B #;$%#>"'5&'<&''$5.11>$5*-"("331&%"#&(,(5$+8$%#&( &1$5*-#;$+$'3(5$(#+5&+$%#&(:#;$"33$11"(##+$#,+(#;$',<

1"%'>;&%;;"5*$$(+$%$&9$5*-;$+&(3+%$$5&(:',(5$+8$%#&( B #;$%#"1(:>&#;&(#$+$'# ;$&'#+&%#,5:$&(#;$$C$+%&'$3>$+',(5$+8$%#&( +5$+$5*->"-+$'#&#,#&(#;$+$,(5#;$',< 1"%'>&#; "( *0$%#&9$ # 31"%$ #;$ 3"+#&$' &( " 3'&#&( >;&%; #;$- >,15 ;"9$ %%,3&$5*,#+#;$+5$+5&'3'"1#;$3+%$$5&(:',(5$+8$%#&( B #;$%# 33$11"(# 0" &##"1 >&$ ;"' %<$ &( "33$"1 ":"&('# #;$ +5$+ +$,(5 #;$ <($- D;$( #;$ "33$"1 %"<$ ,3 + ;$"+&(: ( $%$<*$+.

.&#>"'*'$+9$5#;"##;$+$>"'(<$+&#&(#;$"33$"1 *,#>&#;"(*0$%#&9$#'$##1$#;$<"##$+*$#>$$(#;$3"+#&$'+$:"+5&(:#;$ +$#,+(#;$<($-.#;$"33$"1;"5*$$($(#$+#"&($5

;$ "33$11"(# "33$"+$5 &( #;&' ,+# ( ,:,'# .

E "(5 $C31"&($5#;$%&+%,<'#"(%$'##;$,+##;"#';$>"',("*1$#+$#,+(#;$ <($- "(5 #;"# #;$ <($- 3"&5 # ;$+ *$ "50,'#$5 #>"+5' #;$ ,#,+$ <"&(#$("(%$"<,(#+#;$<&(+"(5;$+'$18;$,+(&';$5"("&5"9&# # #;$ $$%# #;"# ';$ ;"5 *$$( <"&(#"&(&(: ;$+'$1 >$ ,($

&( "55&#&(#*+&(:&(:,3#;$<&(+'("1($"(5;"5*$$(3"-&(:$$#;$ "59%"#$' "(5 #;$+ 1&#&:"#&( $C3$('$' &( <+$ #;"(

%"'$' 3$(5&(: *$#>$$(#;$3"+#&$';$%;&15&'(#<"&(#"&(&(::5;$"1#;"'',%;';$ ;"5#&(%,+$C3$('$'(;&'<$5&%"1#+$"#<$(#&("55&#&(#$C3$(5&#,+$( <$5&%&($'"(5#;$+"%#&9&#&$'"'',%;';$$C3+$''$5;$+&("*&1&#-#+$#,+( #;$ "<,(# # #;$ +$'3(5$(# 8;$ %1"&<$5 #;"# "<,(# 1"%' +$%$&9$5 *- ;$+ ( ,1-

>"' #;$ "<,(# ;$+ 3"'# "(5 ,#,+$ <"&(#$("(%$&(%1,5&(:%'#;$+5>+-"+#&%1$'8;$,+#;$+5$3'$5#;"# &(%"'$';$&'+$F,&+$5#3"-"(-"<,(###;$+$'3(5$(#.#;$'"<$<"-*$ "50,'#$5 #>"+5' ,#,+$ <"&(#$("(%$ "<,(# + #;$ <&(+ %;&15 "(5 ;$+ <"&(#$("(%$ "' #&11 5"#$ (1- " ',< '

A ;"' *$$( 3"&5 "' <"&(#$("(%$$C3$('$'*-#;$+$'3(5$(#;,'*"(5 '<$(#&($5;$+$&("*9$.#;$"33$"1>"';$15#*$>&#;,# <$+&#(#;$9$+-&+'#5"#$;$"+&(: ,('$1+#;$"33$11"(#;"5<"5$"("##$<3##3+$''+#;$ "50,5&%"#&( #;$ "33$"1 ( <$+&#' %1"&<&(: #;"##;$"33$11"(# ;"':#" +&:;# # &1$ "( "33$"1 ":"&('# "(- +5$+ 3"''$5 *- #;$ <"#+&<(&"1 ,+# ,(5$+#;$ "<&1-,+#'%#;$9"1&5&#-#;$&<3,:($5+5$+;"'*$$( %;"11$(:$5 ( #;$ :+,(5 #;"# #;$ 1>$+ ,+# 5&5 (# ;"9$ 3>$+ ,(5$+ 8$%#&( #+5$++$,(5#;$"<,(# 1"%'"(5#;"##;$

',< 1"%' %"((# *$ +$%9$+$5 ( "%%,(# #;$ %&+%,<'#"(%$' $C31"&($5*-#;$>&$ D&#;,# $C3+$''&( "(- 3&(&( ( <"&(#"&("*&1&#- #;$ 3+$'$(# "33$"1 ,(5$+ #;$ "<&1- ,+#' %#. >$ ;"9$ %('&5$+$5 #;$ 3+9&'&('8$%#&( >;&%;+$"5'"'11>') G

" "#$ %

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

J 3$+,'"1 #;$ "*9$ '"&5 3+9&'&( &(5&%"#$' #;"# " &9&1 ,+# ;"' :# 0,+&'5&%#&( # %",'$ +$'#&#,#&( # 31"%$ #;$ 3"+#&$' &( " 3'&#&( >;&%; #;$- >,15 ;"9$ %%,3&$5 *,# + "( +5$+ 3"''$5 *- #;$ ,+#;$0,+&'5&%#&(#<"?$+$'#&#,#&(&'#;$+>&'$&(;$+$(#&($9$+- ,+#"(5&'#*$$C$+%&'$5>;$($9$+&(#$+$'#0,'#&%$5$<"(5'';$ "*9$ '"&5 3+9&'&( %"<$ ,3 + %('&5$+"#&( &( '&<&1"+ %&+%,<'#"(%$' *$+$"&9&'&($(%;#;&',+#&(%&'(## )%" *$ +, !

!.'.

B! &(>;&%;"(+5$+3"''$5++$,(5#;$"<,(# +$%$&9$5&(3+%$$5&(:',(5$+8$%#&( B#;$%#>"',3;$15>;$(#;$

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

1"%'&(#;$ &(#;$("<$<&(+'(,(5$+;$+:,"+5&"(';&38;$ ;"'31"%$5(+$%+5#> ' 'B1"%'$"%;<"5$( %#*$+.

E #&11 %#*$+.

/&(5&%"#&(:#;"#"(&(#$+$'# ' A>&11"%%+,$( $"%; "##;$+"#$

K3$+"((,< "?&(:&(#%('&5$+"#&(#;$##"1&#-#;$%&+%,<'#"(%$'"(5 5$3'&#&(&(;$+"&5"9&##;"#';$<"-*$:+"(#$5#&<$#+$3"-"(-"<,(# &(&('#"11<$(#'>$5$$<&#"33+3+&"#$&(#;$&(#$+$'#0,'#&%$#,3;15#;$ +5$+5"#$59$<*$+.

+$:"+5&(:+$,(5 1"%'*,#&(#;$ &(#$+$'#0,'#&%$#;$'"<$"<,(#>&11*$"50,'#$5&(#;$11>&(:<"(($+ >;&%;>&11*$*$($&%&"1+#;$+$'3(5$(#;,'*"(5.#;$<&(+%;&15>;&' #;$<'#$$%#$53"+#-"(5#;$"33$11"(#>&$)

/ &! ',< 'B 1"%' ,# #;$ '"&5 1"%' >&11 *$ "50,'#"*1$ #>"+5' ;$+ <"&(#$("(%$ "<,(# #&11 5"#$ >$#;$-$"+

."'#;$3"+#&$'"33$"+#;"9$*$$( 1&9&(: '$3"+"#$1- "(5 "+$ &(5,1:&(: &( 9"+&,' #-3$' 1&#&:"#&(H &&! ',< '1"%',# 1"%'>;&%;"+$ <"#,+&(: ( %#*$+ .

/ &' 3$+<&##$5 # *$ >&#;5+">("#$+#;$"*9$'"&55"#$#*$,#&1&L$5&("(- <"(($++5"-#5"-$C3$('$'+#;$<"&(#$("(%$ #;$<&(+%;&15H &&&! ',< '1"%'';"11+$<"&(5$3'&#$5&( '&(#;$ ("<$ <&(+ %;&15 "+9 ,(5$+ #;$ :,"+5&"(';&3 "33$11"(# #&11 #;$ %;&15 "##"&(' <"0+&#- ( ,:,'# . >&#;1&*$+#-#,#&1&L$#;$&(#$+$'#"%%+,&(:+<#;$

3$+&5&%"11-&(%"'$5$'&+$5*-#;$"33$11"(#+#;$ >$1"+$#;$<&(+%;&15H &9! ',< 'B 1"%'. ;>$9$+. >&11 *$ +$F,&+$5 # *$ +$#,+($5##;$+$'3(5$(#>&#;&("3$+&5#>-$"+'&( ,+$F,"1&('#"1<$(#'3"-"*1$*-"+%; . &$&+'# &('#"1<$(# >&11*$3"-"*1$*- ,:,'# B .

/.'$%(5 >&11 *$ 3"-"*1$ *- $*+,"+- /.

. #;&+5 >&11 *$ 3"-"*1$*-,:,'#B .

"(5,+#;*- $*+,"+-/.

0 (%"'$"&1,+$#3"-#;$"<,(#&(#&<$.#;$+$'3(5$(#>&11 *$$(#&#1$5#'$$?$C$%,#&(>&#;&(#$+$'#(5$1"-$53"-<$(#'"##;$+"#$

K3$+"((,< # &' %1"+&&$5 #;"# !

!. 1#!

!#( ! '

$ "(#" 2 % ( "#3%(

# !4 "

##( !.$

" 1 ! #!!

# #!( !. 5#

"# !4 6 %"

!( "

1 1 ! #!!

# ! !4 '#" "

##( !.$ %!(#"

2 ;$"<,(#&(1&$,<"&(#$("(%$:+"(#$5##;$"33$11"(#>&$ "(5 #;$ "<,(# 3"&5 # #;$ %;&15 >&11 (# *$ "50,'#"*1$ &( "(- #;$+ 3+%$$5&(:'"(5>&11(#"$%##;$"50,5&%"#&("(-#;$+3+%$$5&(:' D&#;#;$"*9$<5&&%"#&('.#;$"33$"1&'5&'3'$5 8!

$*+,"+-E.

4 877! '"(0"- D;$#;$+'3$"?&(:A+$"'($5) $'A D;$#;$++$3+#"*1$) $'A