High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/101/2015dismissed

M/S Vardhaman Crop Nutrients P Ltd v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-05-12Mr. Justice Hemant Gupta,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

" #$% &'"% &( %'&!&%'

$ )"&" "& "% '

* *+ ,-.*/),0)* ,-.*/),**1,,) ''"% "

" &2

3'"& (4 %'35&% *&6 .

" 73(4 %'3

"% 78/ &"3(4 %'3 '"& "'7$"'7 )"&" "&

'#"'"%%9 "&70$!

73(4 %'3

'#"'"%; <<< &&"%

+4$ ##'

7$"'

7 $'= % ''%%'

%'"% 2''" &7' &"%% ' %'> ;# '26% '7'

"'&":7'

/$:'35 '

'26% '5 &%#'%&%&" ?9 @A &7'26% '

"64 77'":&":% ' %' > ""'B$ '+

# ' 26 % ' *':&"

7 & '4% % '

" *':&"3 &"&% 6

'&"& '4%&":% ' "6

+ + $"'

'4%&"

2 "&'4%3A C '&"

D% '!# "&'4%-%'7'%'% '5 E *,F

!&% 'B&%&":"

!'3 2''"&!&' ?' (' '

"'4$"'7 % '#

%&' " (':"'

$: % '&!#$:"' # '26% '7'

"'&":7'/$:' 5'77 % ' # '26 '2 &'

4% % '4 '

'% '#"'"%;3"

!'76

" '

%&7&G'

" '' &( %' &!&%'3 & '":

:' &"

2$&"' !

4%$ &": "!

8'%&":7 %&7&G'

35 7$27'

%&7&G'

"!&4 "$% &'"% '!# "65 &'77&":&%# $4% $"'

% '2

!' "%

8E *,F&"4'% '6'

AA ' "65 &"4 #

%'5&% % '*':&%

"&'" A >A@>5&% % '"

!'E

%&7&G'

'' &( %'&!&%'F ' "6:% '&%

8E *,F5&% % '

8*':&% 6" @ > "

% ' !'&( 7& #'

& 6'

$#% @ > ' "% "6 :% &%'7 &"4 #

%' 5&% % ' *':&%

!# "&' "

A A "%

%'&%2$&"' !

4%$ &": "!

8'%&":7

%&7&G'

35 7$27' %&7&G'

"!&4 "$% &'"%3&'&!&7

%% '

2$&"' "63$"'

% '2

!' "%

*,F " 3 % ' '#"'"% !# "6 &7' "

%&"$"'

'4%&"

"&'4%''8&":& '4%&"%% '

+9+

"6%4 ":''7'%'% '2

!'E *,F3% '

8 % ' '#"'"% !# "63 % ' !' 5 $"'&

27' "4 $&"::

%7 2$&"'3 '#$% %&" ":5&77

&%!# "63 "% ' "63&":2$&"'&"% ' !' &'73 "%'"%&%7'%:'%&%!# '5&% % ' !'"

&$&":"%&4'%% ' "63# (&&":## %$"&%6 '

&":

%2% % '!# "&' "4"&'

&":% '(

&$4$!'"%# $4'26 % '!3 '#"'"% (&' %' > 775' % ' &

%&"3 5 &7' '4 &": &"&": % % E *,F & % '

8 "6&"4' @ > "% '

"64 ""%'

7&"% ' !'2$&"'5&% % '2

*,F3 % '

'3 $' % ' !' 2

" 26 % ' "% "6&&"

&":'!'"% &: % "6$"'

84%3AAA '&"

'% D% '

84%-3

"& '4%'% ' "6%'7'%'% '5 E *,F

!&%'B&%&":"

!' ' "% !# "6 4 77'":' % '

' &

'#"'"% 26 &7&": ? 9 @A 3 5 &4 2''"

&!&'26% '7'

"'&":7'/$:'(&'% '&!#$:"' '

"'4$"'7 &7'% '

# '26 "% ' 775&"::

$"+

+;+

& %&"% '

4% "4& 4$!% "4' % '4 '3 '#"'"% 5 (&":"H$ &&4%&"#5'

%& '4%% ' "% "6 % '7'%' % ' 5 E *,F

! &% 'B&%&":"

!'3"% ':

$"% %&%&"

&":'% ' &: %

'#"'"% !# "6 $"'

% '

8 4% " % &%$ %&"3% ' % ' '!'6$"'

4!!"7 5% &7'$&% &"H$"4%&" '%

&"&":% ' "%

!$&":% '%

!'35 &4 & '&"% '

!' "6

&& %% ' "6&"%'"%&%7'%% ' '7&'

$"'

'4%&"

"&'4%3 5 &7''"%'

&":&"% "

''!'"% %' 9 @ A5&% % ' "63% '

'#"'"% !# "6 5 &(' 4I$&'4'

48"57':' % ' $' &% %

' !

8 26 % ' "% "6

&&& % '#"'"% 3 5 &7' # &": % ' > 3 & "% '4 &"&": % % % ' 4% % '

"6&"$&":% '

"635 & $"'&

27'?&% $% '4 &":

$4 &"&":3 4$7"%# % ' $"'

'4%&"

"&'4%

+ +

&( %% '

'; &

'"%!# "&' '$"'

"&'4%5&% % '*':&%

!# "&'5&% % '"

*,F3 % '

'3 % ' "% !# "6 7"'

$7"% ('2''"& '4%'26 %'7'%'% '

5 E *,F

!&%'B&%&":"

!' '

&":% '

:$!'"% 7'

"'4$"'7 % '#

%&'3 5'"% &" "6$2% "4'&" "6 % '4"%'"%&"

&'267'

4$"'7 "6 " % & 4 '3 &% & " $"&#$%'

4%$ 7 #&%&" % % % '

"6:%&%'7 &"4 #

%'$"'

"&'4%"

A >A@>5&% % '"

!'E

%&7&G'

"'' &( &!&%'F35 '

% ' "6:%&%'7 &"4 #

%'$"'

"&' 4% " A A 5&% % ' "

!' E

" # $% &'"% &( %'&!&%'F.% % '!# "&'

7&":&"% ' !'

2$&"'3&'!

4%$ &": "!

8'%&":7 %&7&G'

35 7$27'

%&7&G'

"!&4 "$% &'"%3$"'

% '2

!'E *,F%&

7$"&#$%'% %% '2

!'E *,F '77&":7

%&7&G'

35 7$27' %&7&G'

"!&4 "$% &'"%3&% '

8 "6&"4'% '6'

AA %&% '4"%'"%&" "6% %7: "

# :&": &%# $4%

'4!#7'%'76&

'"%

!% ' '#"'"% "% '

'&" ''!27 "4' #' 47$ # :&":

+C+ % ' "6.$%% &4"%'"%&"5 "% 44'#%''&% '

26% '7'

"'&":7'/$:'3 "&% 2''" $"

4%% %2% % '!# "&'

7&":&"% ' !'# $4%$"'

!'%

8"% ''

4%35'

' % '#&"&"%

!#7'#5'

$"'

'4%&"

"&'4%%& '4%% '

"6%'7'%'% '5 E *,F

!&%'B&%&":

!' $2+'4%&" '4%&" "&'4%# (&' %E4!# "6 772' '26 "

!'5 &4 3&"% '#&"&" '"%

71('

"!'"%3&$"'&

27'F$2+'4%&"

7 65"% "'5 4!# "635 &4 &&'"%&4 75&% 3 %"'

76 ''!27'+

& % ' "

!' 26 5 &4 4!# "6 &" 'B&%'"4' 2''"

# '(&$76 'J

83 %

85 &4 &$2H'4%

" %&" ':&%

%&"3 "6% '

"$"'

84%3AAA3 62'''!'%2'$"'&

27'26% ''"%

71('

"!'"%5&% &"% '

"&": $2+'4%&" '4%&"

"&'4% $ % '

7 65"% %&

4!# "6& '26 "

!'5 &4 &"% '#&"&" % ''"%

1('

"!'"% 5 &4 & &"% '&"% "%4 '&&'"%&4 75&% 3 %"'

76 ''!27'3

+>+

& % ' "

!' 26 5 &4 4!# "6 &" 'B&%'"4' 2''"

# '(&$76 '3

8 $4 4!# "6$"'

% '

84%3 &% '"%

71('

"!'"%3" " %&"26% ' & %!'"%&"'4!# "63 6& '4%% '"'576 '4!# "6%4 ":'&%"

!' '# (&% '4%&"

"&'4%# (&'% %"$4 %&" 772'

&('6'

4!&":%"%&4' ':&%

%&" % '4!# "6 ' #5'

$"'

'4%&"

% ' !# "&' 4% & "

&"'#'"'"%#5'

# (&'%% ''"%

71('

"!'"%3 "% ' '!'6

&7&":$&% &"H$"4%&" '%

&"&":% ''

$7%&":4!#

!$&":&%

' %

' "

!' " !

8 & &

'"% '!'6 ( &7 27' % % '

&'(' 4!# "6 ' 7'

"' &":7' /$:'3 5 &7' '76&": $#"

H$:!'"% % '0

,&: $ %&"

C "%/

3 &: %76 '7 % % '!'6 $"'

'4%&"

% '

"&'4%5 "%2

'"4'% ' % 8'"

'!'6 4!!"4&(&77 5.% % '' '!'&'3"'$"'

'4%&"

% '!# "&'4%3 "% '% '

$"'

% '4!!"4&(&77 53#'

%'&"

'"% &'7 )"'

'4%&"

% ' !# "&' 4%3 % ' '"%

1('

"!'"% "H$ &&4%&"%:

"%&"H$"4%&" &"%% '$' "

$"'&

27'"

!'26 4!# "635 '

&" $&% #'

"'"%&"H$"4%&"

+@+ % '$ %4 ""%# " 4$72'# '$"'

'4%&"

"&' 4% 26 % ' '"%

7 1('

"!'"%3 & '4%&": % '

'"&":

4!# "6%'7'%'% '

8 % '# '(&$76 4!#

!&%"

!' 'H$ &&4%&" % ''"%

71('

"!'"%$"'

'4%&" "

"&'4% "% 'H$ &&4%&" % '&(&7 $ %#'

%'&"%5&

'"% &'74"%

6H$:!'"% 2''"4&%'

'$ $35'"% &" 4'&"% ' & %4"%'"%&"

&'26 7'

"'4$"'7 "6 ' '4" 4"%'"%&"

&' 26 7'

"' 4$"'7 % '

"6% %&"% '

4% "4& 4$!% "4' % '4 '326&% 4"$4%35 &('

4I$&'4'"4'3% ' "62''%##'

!:'%%&":% '5 E *,F'7'%'

!% ''B&%&":"

% ' "63& 7"%$% &"

27'"$## % % &4"%'"%&"3 7'

"' 4$"'7 % ' "% !# "6 '7&' $#"

8'%&":

''!'"% %' 9 @ A ""'B$ '+; 77':'%2''"%'

'&"% 2'%5''"% ' "% ' "635 '

'26% '

"% !# "6 '' % !

8'% % ' %&7&G'

$##7&' 26 % '

"65&% % '%

!'E *,F% 2''"

:$' % % 5 '" % ' & ''!'"% 5 'B'4$%'3 % ' '#"'"% "65 5'77

' % '"

!' "&%$'

% ' !'2$&"'35 &4 &2'&": $"26% ' "6 '

"'4$"'7

:$'%

!% &4"$4% "63

+A+ &% $72'&"

%% ' :%&"4 #

%'&%'7

5&% % '*':&%

!# "&'5&% % '"

!'E

" # $% &'"% &( %' &!&%'F 5&% % ' 4"'"% " 8"57':' % '

"6 ' :&('"&%5"('

5&% ':

%% ' & ''!'"% "4"$4% &''#&"'

&":

* "

35 5 '

7&'

5 8&":5&% % ' " "5&"4 #

%'% ' "6.'% &%!

63% 'I$'%&"

&" %5 '% '

&"% '

4% "4& 4$!% "4' % '4 '3% '#7'

&('

4I$&'4'"4'& ( &7 27'%% ' "6% &7% '

# '26 )"&#$%'763&"% '# ''"%4 '32

!'E *,F & % ' ' %

8 '#"'"% "6&"4'% '6'

AA % %&3% '"% ' "65 "%7':

776'"%&%7'%:'%&%'7 '5&% % ' !'"

!'3#

%&4$7

5 '"2% % '4!# "&'

7&":&"% ' !'2$&"'3&"(&'5

'I$& '!'"% $2+'4%&" '4%&" "&'4%35 &4 47'

76# (&'% %"4!# "6 772' '26 "

!'5 &4 3&"% '

#&"&" % ''"%

7 1('

"!'"%3&$"'&

27' " $2+'4%&"

47'

76# (&'% ':&%

%&" 4!# "6&"% '"

!'5 &4 &2'&":

$'26 # '(&$76 ''B&%&":4!# "63 (&":

83!

62'''!'%2'$"'&

27'26% ''"%

71('

"!'"%"

$ #&"&"3& "6"' % ''%5

''% 27& '3&' &% %"

% '"'54!# "6%2' '&&'"%&4 75&% 3 %"'

+ +

''!27'3% '"

!'265 &4 4!# "6&"'B&%'"4' 2''"# '(&$76

'J " && & % ' # '(&$76 ' 4!# "6 & (&":

8&"% ' !'"

!'3&"% %&%$ %&"3&%5&772'''!'

%2'$"'&

27'26% ''"%

71('

"!'"%% % ' &4!# "6&"

% ' !'"

!'$ % '

3&"% %&%$ %&"3 &: % 2''":&('"%% '

&'('4!# "6%!(' " %&"2'

'% ''"%

71('

"!'"% ''8&":& '4%&"%% '"'576 '4!# "6%'7'%'% ' !'"

!&%"

!' '7&!&% %&"# '4 &2'&% %"$4 %&" 772'

4"&'

&('6'

4!&":%"%&4' ':&%

%&" % '"'5 4!# "6 $ % '

3'4%&"99 % '

84%7 65"% ''

'4% 4I$&'4'"4'$2+'4%&" % &'4%&"# (&' $"'

&# (&&" $ % '

# (&'% 4I$&'4'"4'5&% ':

%$' %

826 "% '

4!# "6!$%2' 4"%&"$$#'

&('6'

"76&"% %&%$ %&"3# # &'%

++ 4!# "6&'2

!% 8&": 4%&" &"%% ''

$7%&":4!# "6 .'4 $' % &2

37&!&% %&" &('6'

2''"# (&'$"'

# (&%'4%&"

"&'4%"% '# ''"%4 '3% ' 77':'

4I$&'4'"4'26% '

8'%&"::

''!'"%5 " 9 @ A35 '

% '

%&" '4%& &4 %&" 5 &7' 26 % ' '#"'"% !# "6 "

3&'5'775&% &"% '#'

& &('6'

'3&"$

#&"&"3% '#7'

5 &('

4I$&'4'"4'% 8'"26% ' "6

2''" &: %76 'H'4%'26% '7'

"'&":7'/$:' ' % & 4"%'"%&"

&' 26 7'

"' 4$"'7 % '

"%& 75&% $% "6$2% "4'? '% '

&" :&('"4 '3% ' 4%

" 4"$4% ':&%

%&" 4!# "6 5&% #

%&4$7

!' & $"'&

27' "%3& I$'%&" &"

'"4'"% '2 & % '# ('"

4%3% ' &&"

'"4'4 "2'

5" '

'3% '4"%'"%&"% %&"% '

# '26 3&%5 "% '4 %% ' 4%

"6&"$&":% '

8 '#"'"% "635 $"'&

27' "'

'4%"% '

4% "4& 4$!% "4'

% '&"% "%4 '3&% 2''"# ('% %% ' "6:%&%'7

&"4 #

%' 5&% % ' "

!' E

" # $% &'"% &( &!&%'F3 5 &4 5 &'"%&4 7 % % ' 6 &"4 #

%' '#"'"% "6J% %E *,F5 6

"6J "% %2% % '4!# "&'

7&":&"% ' !'

2$&"'"% '2 & % ''

4%3&"

'"4'4$7 ('2''"

5"%

+ + % ' 4% "65 $"'&

27' $35'"% &" "6

4'&"% &4"%'"%&" "$## % $ % 4"%'"%&"% %% '

'; &

'"% "&' ' $"'

% ' !# "&' 4% 5&% % ' *':&%

"&' 5&% % ' "

!' E *,F3 7'

"' 4$"'7 % '

5"$ %%'"%&"%% '7&% ; !# "&'3 ""'B'

5&% % '5 &%#'%&%&" ""'B$ '+

&4"%'"%&"& 7'(&

"6!'

&%32'4 $'$% % &7&%3"76% ' "% "% ' '#"'"%

''":

:'&"% '2$&"' !

4%$ &": "!

8'%&":7 %&7&G'

35 7$27' %&7&G'

"!&4 "$% &'"% '6

'#'

%&":

&"% ' !' &'7 "2$&"' '% '

4!# "&'

'$&":% '5

*,F32$%

''":

:'&"&

'"%2$&"''('"% '

5&'3 &%& 6 '4!# "6%

&':

$'%% ''"%

1('

"!'"%$"'

'4%&"

"&'4% % '"'576 4!# "6&&"

&":&":% ' &: % 6 '4!# "6$"'

84%3% '7 4 " ## 4 % ''"%

71('

"!'"%$"'

'4%&"

% ' !# "&'4%" % '# ''"% 4 '3% ' '#"'"% &7' %&"$"'

'4%&"

"&'4%"76

&"%% ' "6"% %&"3 3

%& 6&": &!'7 % ':&%

%&" "6&$"'&

27'3 & '4%'% ' "6%'7'%'% '5 E *,F

&%'B&%&":"

!' $35'"% &" "6&77':

7&%6&"% ' && '4%&"

+9+ &$'26 "(&'5 2('35'"% &" "6!'

&%&"% '&"% "%

##'

7 "% ' !'&3 '

'263&!&',5'('

3% ' "6 &:

"%'% ''!"% -%&!'

!% ' %' '4'&#% 4'

%& &'4#6

% & 3%4 ":'&%"

!'%!'% '

!'3

'7'%&":% '5

*,F

!&%'B&%&":"

!' !"