← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9384/2018dismissed

Naresh Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-12-01Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl18 pages

   

  

 

  

 !"#

 $" % &  

'(  

        )

!#* % , & - .* 

)

.# ( / - .0- &

   2  *3  

3  .3  "

  " 6

"   7"   

9.

:"  ;

* 6  +"3 7"&



&

# 7" 3 33+ 

9.

:" 4;

"

="  (&

#  " 6

" # #"  (   >( 7"&

<& 33 3"

3

=5'

8 

9.

:"  ;

,  (   ? 

*

& 3  <3





&

- 6 6> @.%5 9@:#( . %"< (;

46 (  + /"3 )3>  - .#<3 6 

=5'

8 

 %

, 5 6 +

#(3 %5 %" 3 !"# +  (   <30"( %

33+   <30"( % + - 6 3 < (  /"3 )3>  -  #<BB3

#"

'

- -4 C ( + *3<3

)3>  # *"    3 % "

 .#<3

 +   

9.

:" ;

6 # +  0"( %

3

6   + +  0"( % 6  &    (&   0* # C3 (# <& #<BB3

#"

'

- -4 C  "-  ##   %

, 5

5 6 "  33+ 3 6 0"( % 6 " 6  #"

'

- -4 C

)3>  # 

#((( <&  #  "-   %

5 6 ## <&  #

 +  %

- 48- 8

5 6 # +  0"( %

$  

9.

:"  ;- %"(   3- .#<3- "(  0"( %  +"3 7"& +   # # 6 " )

.

3 !"#- %C,- 6  6  #(3 7"& <& 3 & &

2  3



33+ 

9.

:" 4;

6 " <& 7"& A - ("& %"(   3- .#<3  

6  - 6 33+ 3 6 0"( % + - #(((

#"

'

- -4 C 6 3 < (  /"3 )3> 

- "

 6 - 6 6  *

:#  6 

"

&  ( <&   ,    *  

-

"  * >

(3

D  "

3  "<#

( -    "

##

6  (& 33 # "

##

6  

:# 

- >(

<& #"

6   :# 

 3 6 3 :# 6 

"(( +"# - 3  "

3  3 "(

%"(#

3 F

 

  - ( 

 !

D  "

3  "  (  " "

##

6   %5 %" 3 !"#- .%5 % ?& !"#- .%5  #(3 % 3>- A %"(   3- .#<3

5 "  "<# " 0"( % 6  ( <3  33+ #(((

(



D  % "

3-

  - ((



( 6

"<# # 3 

( #"3 "3&  

<

  < " #"3 "3&  "+ (3&

5   & 

 "  3 #  

 & #   (# 

6  3& 33 #  33& ?"

5 "   

  *

3

*

3

 "- ((  

#(3

5 "<#

( - (  %

8  

3&

3

#  6   %

 

* 3&

  "- (3  <&  % #(*    :# 

##

6 

# *

5  

#(3 7"

 

(  "- (& ( 6

# #  

*  <3 (# ( 6

5 "  "<# 33 (3  <&

# 

# 

?" <&  :  (6  .3  "



2   3  "

3  ( (" ((<>   ( 6

#3 * #   6  *

3



 

,   ( - 3*  %"(#

 

"#   $6 

3 "(

<& 3  "

3 

*"    %"(# "-

(3& 3

& +    < & +- 6 ( "

- 6   *3* #(3 7" 

+(

 

" #  

("  <36

  

            



 

                   

   

              

  

  

 



         

         

     

              

        

          



     

  

!        

         

   

              

   

   



4

                

 

     

   

    

                              



     



    

   

  

         



            

         

    

      

  



 

     .

("3 <*  6 %"(#   *"   6

3"

6  6 +*

<* (+(

5 6 3



( #"3 "3&   6

<

  < " #"3 "3&

5 6 "  3  <

 3 #3  

 +

+  3 7" #(3& +*

" 6  *3* #(3 7" -

" "# - <3 & 33 3"

2 "- 33 +  - *# C 33+ <  3- <

#3  

8

 + <

+*

" *3* #(3 7"   7" #   #(3&  + &

"< 3" 9;- 

# * #3 33 " *+

3

 +   >



 ("(  6  

"  +

+*

" #(3 7"   *3*

 5#( 3&- ( "< 3" 9*;

*

("3 6  "

+  "< 3" 9;

9;

 :- *

# 



3 - & +- <" "  + +*

 

"3& 3&

%"< 3" 9*;

(33& (*  

(  (3 < "3& 3&-

*

&

+ - 6 ( +- # 

"# ( 6

%#33&-

%"(# 

F%  &' ($

  

'    $  )**+  ,*  

(33& <* + 6 ( #    7"  6   # *3* #(3 7"

2  3* (

("  <36 F## !      

  

  

$ 

   %  & #'

      

   

                

   



      

       

       

              

 

   

    

 

        (    

    

#)              

           



 

            !          

                            

 

   

  

*** *** *** #+ ,   

         

   



 -               

    

     *

 

  % 

   

   ( 

                      -   #. #/  0 - ' '  . *** *** *** ..

  

         

    

    

/    

    $ 2     2 3 -    & 4#5 6  

   





  

 

  

           (     

            

%  





 

     

     " .7 8      

         

  

   8  

 

          

                     

         

    

   

   





 

   

! 



   8  

 *

        

  ( 

      



   

        

  

 



6  

   8  

                

     



   %      1  .  . ' '#. #/  0

-

<* - *

,  +  ( ((3

+"

  6

("  

(3 & 6 "



#   (3 & 6 33& < "(

#(3 3+ <&  *3 

, > 

" & (  7"& <  #("+   "- 6 ((  33 #  6 

2   6   <& %"(#

<& #> <* 6  *

("  <*

2  %"(# 

F2    3   4&  5 '$  )**6 !

66)$   <*    "3 (3 

 (" & *& 6  3 6 + # # " (  +-

&

5 6 <*

(( <?* (3 &  3+     #"

(3 & +- 7"

6   #(3& +"3& " " # #*3 # * 3 ("

 # #& <-

6 

+- 7"

6     6  #(3& 33+ * ##-  <3 

-   <3    #(

5 6 "  <*   (- # 7"& "3 +* 7"& 3

<     

- 2<"

 # 3"

6 3  +

6  3    + 6 

  +3&- 2<"

 & 33 # ((3  

3 

3

2  6

+   6 # %"(#  

( -    <* 2<"

+  (

  " ( (3  + &

(3 & #"

*& 6    3

#  +

2  3* (

("  <36 '

   



           

        

   

         

 

  -

    8   $ 8          .

.557 

    -        

  

   

   3   -    -    % 

 & 

  # .



      

    

 

   

 

   

   

   



  

           

 

 

    





  

*** *** *** ##

        8   - 0  -0 .1 - '#  # 0#0  # - #    .   . 

# 3  :

              8         

            

          



 

 ;    8     ( 

   

    

                  

        

    

 

  

 / < %            %   

 

  

 

                

     

 

    

  

    

 



 

     

 



   

      

         

               

  

  



  : 

 / < %         

  

                     

   

 

*** *** *** #'

!       8                   

  (  

       

  



 

     

 



  =="

2  %"(#

F (0%  & '7 .73 

$  )* 6-  <* 



F#7 !      

     



 

 & 



&  

   

   



  

8   

% (        (   

        

      

     



#'



   1  ( /<

2 > ?

 < .5#.#/''.  

 

  4 

  



  



   

  

  



          

%    '

 # 3 - 1' 1 

 # ' ' 3#. 8/  00# - 

 /    



  

             

 

 

              

    

*    

      





 "

<* - ( #   # 3  

3+3 <

" (3 & 3 #"3 "3&- 3 6 (3 "(

%"(#

2 (95'  9$ 6  6 <* +"

 > &



*3<3 3&

 *3* #(3:

7"  6  6

<

3& 3&

2 "- ("3 <*   6 ( #   - (#&  6   < *

 6   & + 

("3

6   * 6 

>(

<& 33   :# 

-  6   #(3 7"   *3*

( -

#(3 7"

-

<"+ 

  

2  " 6    

6   3 6   <3 0"( % 6 3 < (  /"3 )3>  - .#<3  #((( 0* # "

 "

'

- -4 C

"# - 

& #(3 7"

 

)*-

 <    6

" "

#(3 7"

 

)*-   "

  

(3 

(  ("   + 3 "+ -   33+ +  0"( %   &  #(((

#"

'

- -4 C 0* # "



2  +"#  <& 3  "

3 

#  6   <3 0"( % 6   #((( # &

( 33   (3  <& 0"( %  " "



*

( "   "  +   (

33 (  33 (3 3 *

"(( (3

@*

+"# 3  "

3  

##

6   :# 

(?" " - # * #"

( - (  %

8  

3&

"<# #  33 6   %

 

* 3&

 (& #

+*

" ("

 (* +"3- * 3& "(

#    %

 

(  %

8  

 "- 7"

(?" 



. & -

3 <*-  

#(3 7"

 *3*

(

2  *

,   

F: -  2 .  . ' ; "1    <1     ;   ;3       3 93  $=>!, >)*)$# )+*,)*) 3  4      

       

         &                     @        

     



 @



  -   

          

 @ 

    

  



 

  

   

  

  

4

   

                

 

     *     

   

    

  







        

  

 



* 



   

  



    

         .5#A            7# 5# .5.53&##    

    

     -  

 

       

     *





   2 3 -   

*** *** *** 6  

     / 

'5A '.5 #.5&$ .5#3  

     /       8  

 (   

      @    



  

( 

   

   

     

-   



    3         -  #A++     

                    

  *      C(     C  



   

  (      &  8  

 %   

   



 

"

8

<* -   3& 3"

*

+ 3+ 

"  <* 

6 33&  3 3" (*  3&

3 <" #(3&

5 "  <*

3& 3"

6

&

 6 "

#(3& 6  +&  

(" "<

"



 ("( # 

(3

*  & ("<3 *

5 6 <* " (  & +-  #(3& "( -  "- #(3& + # ( (& 6 "  6> 6  #"

3& 3 <"

: 7" +  ("<3 

2  3 6

<* "33& ((3& 

( - 6 

 +   6 "

"  * >

(3

#

( 3( #  

&

"

# & +  <&   ,    *  

" " -

 ?" >( (  & " 

5 3*

 %"(# 



" 9"(;- 6 

3 "(

<& 3  "

3  -

(+(

"< 3" 9*;- 6 

("  <*-



<*



(-

+- *

  & *

&

"

(  & - 

"# ( 6  3" 

3&  #

 33- #"

  "

+"3&-

 "3 +   # 3& (<3

 & 

+"3&

"

  "3 *   3 633

!(

*6 <*  "#  3 6

<* - ( 6

* #  +3& #

!!"



 #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0