← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20866/2024dismissed

Mrs. Prachi Garg And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-12-04Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages

 

      



    

 



  ! "

 

""  #$ %"

"& '



(  "



  )  

"



""  #$ %"

"& '



(  " *

+ 

  ( , !- ( ,.

 ! "



""  #$ %"

"& '



(  "      

         "

 %/"

1% ) "2"

 % 3

/

1) "

  "

,1) " 

 %   "

/1) "1"

("" 

 ) 3 ""

,1), ) "   ,1& '

2"

 .

 4  ,1)) 1& '

1(  "

 ) 3 ""

,1) "

 .

,(.

1) " 

 %

% !, 1) "1(  "

* 55555     61"

 , " ,  ,,"

"

2"("" 1 ' 

,, 7 (  7' 2 '   //  0!/ "

 8   "  (/ ,'7 !/9 9 1"",   !

"

 #$ %"

"  & '

 "

 "

!

   " "

  " 

9

9 9   9 +9  

,, , 7 /  2   '

 (""  ( '  "

     2"  "  :   !"

 " +

;) <912 "

:" "

(""  ,,"/ ","

*1%") ," *1 %" )1 = 8 %

1 7"

 /  !   :

 /" ;

 " " 7  "  "

 >(" (,"? 2  ,  (" "

 ("" 

 !/! "

"7 "

9 "  "( "" 9 "  " "



;) <9 8 (""  ,( '

(  "7"  /"

 "  !"

("(," *  "1 71 "

"( ""9 "  " "



1"

("" ( "( " "

9 " !" " "

 /2 ""

"/



2 " " ",,

8 " "

"  "  "

"  9 "  2  "

" " 7 2 

 2  8"

 " ,(," "

@ "!' :

/" 2  ,"7 )("

A9B ;) <9 1 ((, " (("( ' C"

(   "/ '

8 7  ("

("(," "!' = 8%

9 :/12 < "   (:

/" 8 ("" !"2"

 "

"(, "(

( "( " "

9 "  , * 

,(" C



1*+1

$9   "/ ' , !2"

( ! 8 '2 ,  ,  /!  "

" 7 :  "

 (" (," &  ! 7/"" "

 , 71 "

 (""  2 " !"

&97"7 ("7'"

/(" " "

"'"

" ',( 'C"

""

,(2"

 + "

("



9*9

 7  (   ,  ;;

   2"

 A;  "

 A9B  &21"

(  " "  ' "/ " !

 ! (( , &97 %7: ",'19/ , " 

;) <91 ("" 2 /"

7"

("(,"

 " 7  ("   8    9/ ,  "

" " 7       2 / "    9 ("

  "

7  " ' "

" "

7

7 0"

=""

 "

("" "

"(""



 !!  "71(,"2 " ,,""""

/ 8 //  "  "  

 ;) < 9 !        9 ("

  "

7"

(""  "2 /(,'/ " "

&7

 " 7  (" =""

 "

("" "

//  " $/  " 

 : "

,( !2

,, !7'"

/

/, ,'" "( 7"

"7', !(  "2" ("" 1 "

 ,  !   7 ! 9  *    //  0!/ " "

*

 ,,"

2"("" 2(  " ""

 1"

(  "9( " / , "



1

 !  ((" "'   ! " "

 (""    8  ("" 

 !,' ((  7 "

 (  "  /  "

 7/  &21 " +

1"

, /2 0",  !" , !"

 "

"2"("" 

 %/"

1,  %  ,"

("" 

  ) 3 ""

,1 ,   ),  ) "   ,1 & '

( " !"

(  "12 

  ((     ('

 !7 12  + =" 2 7/"" 7' ,   %   , "

 ("" 

99

" "

(  "  " (" !"

"7! 7' ("" /(,",',,!

7" '77 ! ,'



    !  7' "

 (  " "

" "

 (" (,"  , (// ! , ( "0" "

(  "9( "  ",<"

/ //(  $9(:

/" ," *1 = 8%

7  $9(:

/" ,"

* 7   

$9 ( :

 /"   (  "9( "     / "  ""' ( "2"

"

70"",( " ,  ""   %"

"  & '

 23  "

 "

7, ,(/ "  "

%"

"$%"'1  ! "

( (,> (" ,?1  , "

",3  ("

,"

 2 ,/ ""

/ ""

*++"

/" !"

B D"&%==D , 



*12  " ,"

"  &7"7/  "/     "

 *+  /" !  "

 B   D" ,  



 ;) < 9  =  "

   /" !1 " 2 (( "

" "

(,"@(" :

/" 1 ,,&7 7"

 (7,"$ ((  "/ ="2 7/"""

" "

/"

1"

&72:"7 ("    1 ,    , ( " ! "

 (  " 7/"""

 ,,!

,"' "

" "

(  " "

" 720""",' ("/  " , 2  "

7  ="2 7/"""

"/  " "

7   7  !( 7"

   /  "

(  ", ""

 /   ) !

 "

 / "  "

 /" ! ;) < 91 " 2 7/"""

 /  " ((, 7,""

"  :" 1 "

' 2"7 ((,"7: " "

9

 &  ! ,   ,"

( "12 "

2" ("" "7/"

  B   "

  ! "

 (  9 " 

,,"/ " " ,(,"  ) <9

, B;

 B     9 

  

  

  



   

   

   

     

            

  !"

   

       #$



 

 

  



 %  6"

1, ;;, '2    9

&!''(

  



 

 # #$

   

     $

 # 



 #   

 

          

 

%

="2,,"","

"/  " "

97 

" "

  (("  / / "" 7  !(  7"

   E  "   "

3    "/  "

 (  "

(    !     / "1 "

  /  " 7   " 7 ,,!

,1 7" '



* =  9 9   9 +9 1 "

  "  /, ""

"9 9 = 9 9 1"

(""  "

"7," 1 /  ! :

/" " "  = 8%

 9 +9 ,"

1/  ! :

/" =  ,,"

"

 1//  " $9/ , " 

1"

("" 2 /"

7"

("(,"

 "7 

("   "   "

 (  "     /"' 2"

 "

99

( ,  2    "

 7   "

 1 "

1 "   !, "' "

 // , ,,!

,"'

=" "7/ " "

"  (,' / " " 2  ", 7,"7 " 2"

 ",  ,"

   2 "7(  2 "

 7  "

3   / <"    "   ) ( ,  "

/(!    2 "

" "

  /   "

,    2  '

("

7    

7 / ""

, ",  "

A"

"

!/ "1"

7  "

 ,9

"    ,  "   ' ,,!

,"'   "

   "

3  7' "

(  ""0""

"7   ",2$,(// 7 !"   "

77 ! (" 8 (  ", "

 7  <(" " "  "

 (," "  , (1 1 "

1 ,< !"

(2" "

/10""

"7"

("" 

  2/ !""

, 2 "

70"1"7' 22,,"",

"   "

7     ,  " "1  !

" 2,  " "

"7 8 %(/"=  2  , !2"

    "

 &

)# (    *

+,- *

 '    (   .  /  012 33   145 2  " "

 0"   "

 7  $ E  =  "" D,(  " F/"1  "  ,  " 

 7  ,  =  "

" 1"

(,  "

! "

"72 1 ("

(,  "

7  ("  6/ , ,""  ,,"/ " 2 1 21 "  ,"/ ",'1"

C / "("7'"

(,  "2   "

! "

7

 "7  (" 8 " 2 

,, !7' ' "2 2 7'"

" ,"

&21 ((  "

9+9

 /2 ,,27'"

""

D""4! "

"2 / 8 &!

""

  ,,2"

  (( ""

0!/ " "

" ," "2 "

/ "" "

)(<" "

)(<","/ ",'( ,"

 "

6" )((,, "" ,"

" !

"

""

"7 8 %(/"=  2 ,,' !( "

  "

  6!  ) .  *

++$



! *

7 189  ! :;5 6/ <=   *

 + !

  *

7 188; 4 ! 09 6,

 (      +     , 

 !   

7 008 ; ! 121 6,- !  >   *

+ ' (    ,

 /  *

71880:!90 6?

3  $  

 + (

 (      

7 00910!;8;

  @ 2 

 !  ) .  A* +$

 

 ! A * 189  ! :;5

   

 

   #   

 



 #

B     

  

 





 

    9'/ <= A*!

A*188;4!09  

    

  

#

   







#   

    

#

    

# 

 



#    8 ' ,

 (           , 

 !  A 008 ; ! 121   



 

 # 

 

  # <



99

 

  

  

   

  

 

   $





#   ::C   #  

 



  

  



 

 <       

  '



      #

 



 

 852

* 

 

 



 

   < 

 

 

 

    

   

   

< # 

 C



#



 

    

   =     

 

   

  

   &

 

  

 





 

   

 #

=

 







 

 

    

 

  

  

 #

     

   

 

  

  =  

 

   $

 

#  

 

# <

D

 

  !  &



#  













 <

  







  

  

  

 

E 

 

#&)(







  



 

 # E  



   &)(

#

 <  *

 F $ = 

#

 <  



 



 



 

  009  

  

   

  !

 8 B      < 

 



 

 :4 .



  

     $   

      

 

'

 # 

 





  

   

   

  

#







#  311125   

#

 



  

  

  

 

  

 #

 

 # #



& .





 



    

 

# 

99

:53    







$  

  # 

&    

 

2 14



  '

   

 



  35 = 

 

-   #    @/5 = 



7C

D  35 =   

 !

  > 

7 C

 D

       

%    )/,  7  "B  "

"      ( !

=  B   *

 + &

 !

 +=  .  =  &!+.  *

 C.1844201 

   20801 8 ("" "

 

7/""  , 7 (,"  %"*1 ! /₹1+11*$9 D("7 !"

"71"

 / 2  " ("  2 ' (  (   / ! "

(""   !

 "

  " "

7  & ,1"

 ,   "

 A9

" (,'2  "2 ,"

2,7 " !

"2"

"

("" 2 2,7,!

""

(  "" (""

"7"

(""  ="2 ,"

"""

 " '1"

" 7 ,'

!

"  "  7"7 , "  "   ( "/  7' "

 //""  8   " "  !

 ! / ("

"

" 7 2  0" ,  "

 (,'2 7,!

""

("

0" "

&972"

(  + 23 !  ' 2 , < /   " 2 , "

"  (  2 " /  "'  "

'   ( "  ,' " ( "   , '   "

 ( "  "

 /(" " "

"'   "

3 !    9 14

#

 #   

 >    



  #   

    





#

 # 

    

   

 



# 

  

99

    

 #  #     

 

  # 



 15'

 

 

          

 



 

#



   

  

  



#  #   

#

 <   

 # 

 <    

  

 = 

! 

 



#

# !  

 

1 









#

   

#

 



 

&G# !

  

 , !  * 1821:!15:@'31821:! 2::@!   & 

H 

182!:;@'3 182!191;I) '  !

C

3   18;8:!14;@'31821!85 !  ).+$



! 189!:;5!



 = # ( 

       / < E  + !   &

 

008133 55; 1;

     #       





   



 #   

 #  

   



   

 #

 

   

  

     9 

>

  



 % ) "

 22 "

3 7' 9 "B  "

" "

,

! +&

!

+= .  = &!+.

*



 !"   #$#%"& & 2 "2 ,   9

 < *

'   G

 

<   

     



   

   

   $

 

 #   

 

 



    

$

   

 # 

 





 



    

  

 

     

   

   

  

   #   

 #    

  #     11 '   

 

 

   

  = 

 









 

   

  

      

99





#

 

 

  

 ,

#

 

  





# 

    



# 



  

#        

 



 





  $

 #



    #

 

    

 

 #

   

=

 





   #  #     



  #

   

    

   < 

    

   





 





#  =    

   

#

#   # 



  #

 

  < 







    

 

  

   

 

  



    

!  

 <      



 

 =  

#

 

 

 =

 C   

 #  

 =

 

=



#    

   

   

 

   

  #



#  = 





% + , 21"

1', "

"72,

  !

"   "

7   "

 7

 ! 7  (" 7' "

/(" " "

"'

   &  ! "

!/ " 7',   , "

( "1"

, ", "

7  :" 

7     "

 ( ! (  ! (  "

 /(!    "

+

 ;) < 91 2   "

   (   "

"   "  ,, "

/(! 2 2,,   (",' ,!

  ,   2  "

 (2 "   "

 (  "9 &%==D7'""

,  ( " "

7  8 /(!   , " (( "

7 (   2 / '7  "7<" 

2  " ! " 

9 9

= 2"

 " /"

 / " 12   2" (""  " 7   /"  "

  /   !,' /  

 "    "   



    

 !

!  "

( 3 !$   G$  "

("

7, G$