← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1020/2015dismissed

Punjab Small Industries And Export Corporation Ltd And ORS v. Ram Dulari And ANR

2018-03-06Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

  

        

  !

" #$%&%'()(*!"+ ,-#./0#11&,)$2(%)#& 342$ 242#$($& #&$5%2) 644%11#$) 7%2),) #0,1#2(#&#$5%2 6%)4&%$)

 *

8 / 

 / 

8 / 

/  2%)%$*

2#9#- ,4$#:&;'#$%2$5%#44%11#$)

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

 2(.,#1<#)$5#$$%20(#$()%2;('%)2%)4&%$B4%$($(%2<#) ( ;(%<  (2',1#2 %3,2% >D &#$%& ! ()),%& .A $5%

;%20%$  ,-#. #) 4%2 <5('5 '$2#'$,#1 #44($0%$) 0#&% .A

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

,2$( 

 !"#$$ % &  ' $"

:()) (*.A.)%2;(?$5#$'%$5% 2(.,#15#&#22(;%&#$$5%''1,)($5#$ $5%$%20(#$()%2;('%2%)4&%$B4%$($(%2<#)(;(1#$( $5% 42;()()  /%'$(     $5% &,)$2(#1 ()4,$%) '$: ED@ 5%2%(#$%22%%22%&$#)C$5%'$8:$5%2%<#)''#)(2$5% 2(.,#1 $ &%A 2%1(%  2%()$#$%0%$  5% 2($ ,2$ #1) 2%1(%& ,4 $5% -,&?0%$  8.1% $5% /,42%0% ,2$ ( +

,- ./ '/ / 0  #  $ /

'"&,2"#'&-& 3))3(<5%2%(($ 5#).%%5%1&$5#$(-,2A),%2%&.A#4%2):<55#).%%&()0())%&2 2%0;%&2$5%2<()%$%20(#$%&20)%2;('%'#$%#)(1A.%0%#),2%&( $%20)0%A/,%2(?$5%#0(1A5#)$.%19%&20#11'2%2) ;(F>#>;(F &%42(;#$(  ,$2($(,) & #& #11 442$,($(%)  %&,'#$( #&#&;#'%0%$(1(%#&<5%2%$5%#'$($#9%.A$5%%041A%2<#)

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

 %5#;%')(&%2%&$5%),.0())()1%#2%&',)%12$5% #44%11#$)#&4%2,)%&$5%2%'2& ! &0($$%&1A:2%)4&%$B4%$($(%2<#)#44($%&#) #1( '04#))(#$%.#)().A$5%#44%11#$)> 242#$(<%!2 #4%2(&)(30$5)0$51A)#1#2A+B>$5%&%#$55%2 5,).#&#0#2)5#&<5<#)<29(?#)# 5<9(&#2 29 5#2?% #)() ( $5% #44%11#$> 242#$(  5% #44($0%$ '$(,%& .,$  D@ )%2;('%)  2%)4&%$ B4%$($(%2 <%2% &()4%)%& <($5 4,242$%&1A#'',$ (2',1#2%3,2%>D&#$%&!()),%& .A$5% ;%20%$,-#.#)4%2<5('5'$2#'$,#1#44($0%$)0#&% %#21(%2('$2#;%$( ;%20%$41('A?,(&%1(%)<%2%2&%2%&$.

% &()4%)%&<($5(00%&(#$%1A$('%22%$2%'50%$'04%)#$(<#) 4#(&$2%)4&%$B4%$($(%2.%2%$%20(#$(?5%2)%2;('%) @ '% $5% 0#&#$2A 42;()()  /%'$(     $5% '$ <%2%$'041(%&<($5$5%(;(%<$5%1#<1#(&&<.A 8.1%$5% /,42%0% ,2$ ( #)0%2 /(?

( %%4#1( ,&,/,2<#)%8)'#)%/,42#:($%2%2%'%()'#11%&2<($5$5% 2&%24#))%&.A$5%1%#2%& 2($ ,2$%%2%'%'##1).%0#&%$# &%'()( 8.1%$5%/,42%0% ,2$(452/  +6$#75&1/  ./ " 2

8))3( + ''2&(?1A: (&(?  0%2($ ( $5% #44%#1: $5% )#0% () &()0())%&<($52&%2#)$')$) 45 " '-  -  /'!

 /'!

!"+ #0($  5%$5%2)4%#9(?B2%#)%& * %)B  5%$5%22%42$#.1% * %)B