Gulzari Lal v. Amar Nath & ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 07.09.2015 Gulzari Lal ,.. Appellant versus Amar Nath and others ,,Respondents
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh
! Kuldip Singh, J. (Oral) !"#
#" $"#!
%&&'&
()
*"# +
,- ." /" # ! $"#!
&0&'
() .*"#
" ( 1
1 )
1
( $
1 23 $
#1 (
&!
#
4 )! " #5-
6! ! #- 1 7- 88- 6'8
" # (
8&6, " (
/ , 8'&'' 9 "
()
"
&1 ( #
& 1
( # #
#)
!"
1 ( #
1 "
! ) ! )
"
1 #
# )
" () )
)
!
31 1
! 1 ! # )!
, (
:# /! ;
9 "
8'&'' " <"=>;
&,
1 :# /! #
*
"
. ) ) " !
"
*
"+!)+"
) 576 )!
/ 6'''23 "
"
))( ) )
!
/ &6'23 !
1 &') #
&1 ) #
1- ! " ( ?
& $
1
1 )
$
"!) )
)
! @" )
1 # ) 9 "
"
&
# !# ""# ("
9
) !
!# 1
& 9
)
# ! ! /- "
&6..
"=
# !
1 ) / &6'23 !
/- %8&''& +! 1 #
"
1 !
"##
"##
"#! $
"#! % ,
" & &: 1 ! &
'(
) * +
, -./-% "## &
'0 1 11 2 3 3 3 3
3
"##
" & &:1 - " # , 1 ." ) 1 @" )
1 ! "
& # A&
) 9 "
, 1 ." ! #
#1
@"
) 1 1
"
!
1 1
, 1
1 #
.
@"
)
" &1 #
1
" &: 1 #
.
@"
)
" &1 ) "
" & B1 #
"
")# "#
( "
:#
/!
" # ) # A1
"# 1 ("#
"
) #
#
! ! 1 ( ! , ) @"
# ( ." 1 ( (
#"
! 9 "
1 )C
!
"
(
! :# /!1 1
:# /!
9
! ) ! ! !# " "# 1
&
9
! " :# /!1 ##
!
" ! /-1 :# /! "
&6..#
! 1 1 )!
%8&''&, 1 9 "
8'&'' 1 ! (()
(
# " , 1
1 1 ."
" # ! 1
$
) 1
& !
#
" # ) 1 " 1
11 ." 1
5%&''5
!
"
8%&''5#
( # &%80&''5
! (-()
*"# / $"#!
&0&''
# # "
) ( ) # 1 ! 1
1 , # ) "
) 1
(9 ,
"( 1 "
3 >1 ." ) " !
&
, ! (
!
)
% 1
"!
) @"
1" 1 "
1( ! # 1
1
) ) #
11 1
!
1
)!
! ) ) !
( !# 1 ! )
1 " #!
") ) 1 !
!
()
( "!
1
)
D( " ! ." 4 , 5 6 7///8 9 :
: %; ( "
% <, * :
%11='
$3%11=' ,
2
3 3 3 3
3 ,
,
9 %$
#
(3-- , >'
?%$@9@
2
' '
9
3
,
,
3
,
3 &
,
3
,
3
,
! ,
,
6
3
A
(
,
6
& 3
3
?
.
3
3 3
?
'
'
? #
?
'
' ?
2
B
<,
2 3
,
11='3
" ! ." " 1
( "
-
&
?
?3
3
,
# 1
1 1
&1 ")
!)(
! ) )E "
) 1 ( ! # : ."
( 1 1
)
&
( 1
#)
9 "
!
( 1 #) 1 ( ! # 1
1
( # !"# $"#!
%&&'&
()
*"# +
,-." /" # $"#!
&0&'
() . *"#
" (
()
!
1
"#"
07.09.2015 (Kuldip Singh) 6 Judge