← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20243/2025allowed

M/S Fair Style Embroidery Works v. Debts Recovery Tribunal Iii

2025-09-12The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry23 pages

    

         

    !"#"    



!"$"   

%&     '    ((")*+*+,-)./ /   

 &0           (("")/1,-2)-*/    3

    !"#"    



!"$"       ((")*+*+,-)./ /"

  

  &0

  

 "

          ((")/1,-2)-*/"  

 !  4&  "   &

0   

4&  "    0   

  

  

 

 !  

 " #   

$%    

& '  # 

 ('

 ))))  &

0   

 *

 (     ! + ,

 -.-/0 # -.-1  + *2-0- #-.-1  4 #5# !"  

-

 6!

  4 #5 #  5 +   #73 

! 

 #8*9 #   

# :   ;# 3 # " 6  -..- :;6# !"

<

 (   !#!"   !

 55  #    "3 #       #  :;6

 5 5  !"    !

 5   $ &!  " !!"5" # ,

/1= #-.-/ >3&? 6(' @ ,

/12 #-.-1 >A3 ? 6(' @53 ! 3 !"   *- .2 -.-1  *B .1 -.-1  "     #!#!"

   #3 #/1" ! 8*9 # :;6 /

 :

  ' #    " #  5  !

   "    

#$ #  #  5   



            

! "##  $    %  &'! 

  



    



 



   

      





     

   !     

           

 "    #   $   %

 &



   

    

       

  '

!(

           

  

      

 

 

 

"

!)*

+ ,

      

       

  

  

   



   



& 

   

    

         



    

        

    

       

  #  $  %

 





+ - 

.+" ! 

 



     

 #  $  %

    

&



   

 

 

/      



  /

    

       

    

        

  

    +"

[0 %  #   $   %

  

         



 



  

     



 

   

 

   



      +  1   #   $   %

   *               

  

    

   



 



 



     

   

   

 

             2



     



 

   

  

     

 

  

   



    

   



 



 



  

     

  / 

   

  

      

  

 

 

     

 



    / 

  

 



  

 



   

    

 



  

 +"

 1   #   $   %

  

  

    

  

  



   

  

 

     

 

                      

     

      

         

   

    

     



   

   



  + [ 3

  

    

  



      

    

        

   #  $   %

  *         

    



     

   



   

 

  &



  *     

 

   * 

   /



    

45  %   (

660/



     

 /



    

         7 



0 

  /

  # $  %





  



   

       

          



  

   

                        

     

  # $  %





     

   



+"

5  

  



      #   $   %

   * 

   

   



* 

    

'

(

  #  $  %



      *     





  

  



      

         

     #   $   %

   *    

       

  



+

4 1  

 

  #  $  %

  

         



5      

      

  

     

         %

 

      #   $   %

 

 * 

 

     

     

   #   $   %

       %

    

   

 

 * 

 

        

 #  $  %

+ . - 



  

 #  $  %



    

  



   

   $    #   #    7   ,   1 

88 5 88       +"9  (    ##  ) &!

:%  

 

 

            

       



   

  854  854 - 

  $ 

854 0 854  - 

  )*  7    1   880 5  880   $   #  #  7 ,  1 

88 5

88 

 

     

 +9 ))5*+,-,6*7))5,8).9,6):*/;-2;-<.=1*595*0$$ :;



% 

 ;



84  4 84         

  %

+9

 : 3  !  #  #   "   

 *9*  ! 5 !   #/1" #  3'  

  8 *9 !"  !

 58     :;6   !C 3# #

 !"

 /1" *  : # !    !   9 #   *9 5 

5 5  &

   

 # 

     *9*  

 5   #  " #&!(' "*BB0   #*BB0# !"

-  

  :;6      #  # *BB0 5   # 3    #   09 5     # :;65 !      #  #*BB0 0

'# 3 *99 # :;6 -/ #

#*BB0 73  #*B20

" 

 3 ! !""

 3!# &

  #*BB05 !3!    #73 *B20   $  # *99 # :;6 -/ # # *BB0 "    "    

  8 *9* #  :;6' #73 *B20 2 

 5   #  # ! #"C   

 #73  *B20  "        :;6      # 5     -B #  73   4" 

  D*  #   $  $ +,  *) - . / 0 / 1 $  / 2*34 ##      5 6   6      7$+ $   2

4

 # . . ;.;," E! 

     C" #$  #  3 

  5 #& (

#  #1+)#  $ 3% $1 

  5 :. / 0       "

9 2 4 9( *; 8'

  5  

( #  F : +% 

  

  *  

      1 < =          2

        

  



   

 - 

.

       - 

 6    0<<0  *



  *           

      - 

   0    ;



 

   + 

  

  

=   -             ;



84    

    

  #$% - 

.  0<<0

 - 

6 0<<0  

   #   $      %



   

           '

:- 

 0     ;



     > > 

   

;



+- 

     



 

   +% > 

> - 

0        



 

 

 +% %



     ;





  +% 

  

 



  # $  %

 - 

 .    

            - 

 0     ;





 

 

  +1



 

    

    



   -     1 .

   - + % 

  

 # $  %

 - 

.  

 

    

 

    

  +%   



   

  

     + %  

       

 



 

 

    - 

.  +% 

 

 

         

  

  

  >

+ 1

 

      

& 

        

        

 

  

     

& 

     *  *   

 

 

 - 

.  +% 

 

   %

 

   

 

      

  

     

  

  

+

% 

   

     

 

 

  

 & 

 

   

    

+ %  



 5 ? 4  - 

 .    

  



 

 

    - 

.     



 .        #  $   %





  

   

   

 88  $      



      + -   

      

      



0 - 

6  +% 

      

 

    &



  #  $   %

       5   

        

   



 - 

.+ - 

.     

 

 $     

   



88 

 

  - + %

  *

 *

- 

 0  ;



   

     

   #  $   %

       

  

   

884 & 



*#.  .!   - +)     

     

   #  $   %

         

 

   

              

   

 # $  %

+ -



. - 

.@





0 - 

6        

 

  88 + 1 

  

 

      

  

      +% 

      

  



  

  

    

   - 

.    + -



 

   

   88 +1- 

..60   

 

   

 %

   88 +% ;





 *    

             

     - 

8       +% 

      

   * 

     

        

   

      + % 

     

   *          ;



      

     

   #  $   %

   - 

 .

  

   #  $      %

   - 

 6       

 

 

       

 %

    %

+% 

 

         (  7 =         *

 =  + 1       '  %    

     

   

  - 

.  

  

 

      

 

   

  

   

& 

  

    

+

% 

- 

 0  ;



     

        



   

 

 # $  %

 - 

.  +

 %  

 - 

   0    ;



          

 



  #  $   %

  

   #  $      %

  - 

6  + 3   





   

 

2

      # $  %

@

 # $    %

     +9 5+ 1  

           

   7         &        + -

        

    

*0 %! ) >/ 1$0<<-  .8/  )  > ?# %! # @  8860 $ $ 000/ *0  -!@ %!1   0<< 6- 

/1$0<< -  58  #,%! 1;8841$- 38 +-  

    

      

2

          

0<<0

88 +%      

  

 

   + 4+ ,             =    0  .*%!;!   %!># .

0&   

1$0<<  6    &  7 =  

:. / 0A      - 

5  ;



 84  

      

         

   ;



  84   + 1 

    '

A00+ B         

      - 

 .

  

             - 

 5    ;



      

      

      

   + %  =  

 

 =       0 .*%!;!    ;





    

  

     - 

.  0<<0+  

     

   

 

  =  + .+% #$%     

  *         ;=  

  -  

 

   &



       + %  &          ;=   

       

 + %

  *      

        %

            &            

 

        

   



  - 

<  88 +%  *  

    



  

  - 

<   88     

  @%

                        

    

  

  +%    

  

  #$%  

   - 

.  0<<0+% 

- 

<  88                      

   $   B        - 

..  0<<0  - 

0  88  #$%  &



           

 - 

.  0<<0+ 6+,

 



    & 

    2          

- 

.  0<<0 

   

  

  

+=   

 

- 

5  ;



84  

    - 

.  0<<0     

 



            

+ %  

   ;



84      

    - 

.

0<<0 

 #$%   - 

0  88  

   



 5    ;



  84       

   +, 0<<0

  *

 *   

 

 ;



 84 + 8+ 

     

     + %   



    #$% 

    

  

 .    0<<0  

 # $  %



            2  +% 

   #$%      



  

 





   



 

 

9+ = (#   3

 5  $  3

!"$ &

#  3   $

!"&

5#  5  1.

;  5!:       B4B..(

 ?#5!>  2 B4B..  1+  5!:        E2

4..

DC  / 0  /      5! 1+ *  $ *%!;    

#.(E(C  / ) , @) 5! / 0       

8 2 4 ..BBBC  0 .*%!;!   5!># .

0&     

. (E2.-$ .4C

 1+ 5  $  $ 30 *%! ;! >  # 5!  F +.

 1 $    / 0  .  >  #    

91D9821-$ .4C       / 0     5! >!@! ?$      

.. ; >BEE82>-$ .4

 3

 5 ##  $  3 !"   1.

;  5!:       B4B..(

*.

6 C 5"54 

# 5  3     00 #  $3 5    ! 5  3  

              

    

          

       



C

 3   

         - 

  .  

  2   

 

  

        & 

@

 

  

          

    - 

 C

 3        - 

.   



 

   



         

  - 

                 

  .5D     



      C  3     

 *



            

 

    

 



  

 

       

    C  3  



   

 

  

   

  

   )



            &



   C   3   

 

 .0

   

  

   

      



C 

 3     

               

  

        C *.

*  :" # $   #  4  # 5 C  5#  53 :6<+ F     



       

 

   4< 2         

 

         

  

  

.    

 # $  %

+%     

   

   

  

  

 

 

     

+ G          

        

  

 

   '

+ F -



0 - 

 

      



 4<    

       

 

  -



  - 

  +

       



  & 

   





   

        

   

    

 

        & 



   

         

+ 1   

   

  

          



    

      & +%  

      

  

   



@      

  

 

 

  # $  %

 - 

.     + 0+     



  

   

      -



  - 

  

    @

 

       

     

 - 

.   

 # $  %

+

+ % %

  *

  

   &



   

  @ 



&    

   





+

+ 1   



   

      2    

 .5D       

        

  - 

 .    

  

 

     

     



 

+ -   

   

      + 5+  



  



&                  

          

      

   

  )



  

      

  +9 : 3!

 ! #!" C 44 # "" # :;65 3C #' 5

  *9 -  5 !      3"   *9 

91G #3 3 ( C      #

" 8 *0 #  :;6  !#  '   38*0/  !  " :;653 !"

 *00 5### 3** ** -.-/!"

 #  

 #91G #3 3# 

  *9

*.

- 

# 3# 4  5    #73 

! 

  *9

# :;6#/1"5   1.

;!= 

 ?#5!>  2 B4B.. ** C       5  5 

!" #  1 #73  

  = #+( 7 # 3*B11  ="  #  3  !"    #  !$ #+( 7 # 3*B11   #  3   C   1 #73  !   #!

!3 = ##   #  3   # = "!!5' !C"3 #   #4"   ** * 

  # 5   !" C    ?# =   !""

-0%7 G%5!;7 1   B4 .. ((C. 5!*   *  2 D4B..

C

 )/%<*5!

2 99(4 ..8(8 (""

  $3  C      C   >C " C@ -B- #73   C C  !#C  #  !$ !      3" 5   5

3 3 ** -   !$! :;6 

# 5  5 3    

 !$ #+ ( 7 # 3  *B11      ?# =      !" 

        "  "  

 1+  5!:        E2

4..

DC *- C 55 "!5   " #&!(' "*BB0 :;6 4

!" C # 3  * # $35 ! 5 : 

 2

   

  

 

  

      B++    

 

   - 

 8     #$%  88

    H + < 0<< 

 

      

     - 



  $  

 ,   

  )

   - 

1

0<<0:H(9



+9 :  = #$31+  =   C  

# 3 #  53  3   

   

    

    #$%88      H(

 0<<0 

 I      

      

  B+   

 #$%  #$%+

 3 

  

   

 

 - 

    H(        

    

+

 3  

  

  $ .   #$% (

   $  88

      

  - 

.  H(             + *- *  #$ # 5  ##  4 5##35# 3  *0 # $35 ! 5# "#  : + 

            2

      

   @,1   

 

 

 @1++ 

  

     @1++    @,1     

  

+9 *- -   " !  1+  =    5     #   ! #

 / 0  /      5! 1+ *  $ *%!;    

#.(E(C *0 C 5#5"" #    "  # "  !"  A   # %  !7' 5( 5  55#

 

!"&

(# & !$53!" &

#8*9 # :;65# #  # 

*0 * 

/ 0/=  5 3   #  33 #/1"# #

 8*9 #  :;6#!3  #1+  =  

(4  (' #(   !#  C  # 3  #  ** #$35

! 5# "#  :+ 3         2

       =     &    

   



   *   

   + %

       

         

   

   + 1

      # 

   

      - 

. 

+)    

       # 

     

 - 

.+, #$%     

  

 

 

   #$%     

          



  

   &    

 



    &



+ ,

   



      



    

  

  +9 *0 -     C   5 "  5 "  " #3  !"A  #%! 7' 5(5   #53  !$ ! !/1"H33# #

  *9

#  :;6  #  

 # 1+  =    5



*0 0 

 "# 1+     #   5        #    

*0 / 

 5 3  3"    33    / 0  /=     3"   !  #        "   

*0 1 

 !

'# 3##   #*BB05 3  3!" ' # 3  # !3 "  # 12--  "! !   ('  0B*   "!    : 6   0.

.B *BB.

  33 5      !     #  #  #*BB053 #  -/ .2 *BB0  *0 2 

 #*BB0#I

 H8-!

 3

 3 &!  " !&

 *B # #*BB0! 5  

 ('  : 6  # 

  ' 5  J

     J

     " ! # 3 "  !$

" $  ! #*BB0 *0 9  &    #*BB0# #"

!$ #  5  5 3 !"     

3 :;6 *0 =         *B *    # *BB0 5 

 ** ** -../ #  3   ## #  :;6    

     ('8:6  55J #8*B* # #*BB0  

 3  ## 3 #"  :;6   !'  :;6  *0 B   -/ # #*BB0C

 #73 *B20 

 3 &

8*B* # #*BB0

*0 *. : 3 -/ # #*BB0 !   

#73 *B20!# ('8:6  !  5   J  8 *B* #   # *BB0

   ('8:6 !C!" 55J #  *B* # #*BB0  4'3"  :;6 3 ! *0 **  3     :;6  5 #    *9 C !"   !

 55 !"" #3 #  *0/ # :;6'!"  3'  

     &

 5 /1 " # 3    5  35'

*0 *-   01 #  :;6       5

   # :;6## 5 " 5 " 5# 3! #  "3##!" #"5 *0 *0  3      8 0/ #  # *BB0 5

  ##    # *BB0  "  5 #   3 !  #   !"   #   "   !5    #  :;6     # *BB0 !

 5 

 

          #    # 73   *B20     3  3 ! !"  #  -/ # #*BB0 "J #!"('8:6 8 *B* # #*BB0  *0 */ " !  #   *9 9 #  :;6  3#3"!

 8*9* # :;6

! 3 #   #*BB0   #*BB08-/

"   #73  

   #*BB0

 #73 "5!!

 55  3!" #

 8*9* # :;6# # /1 "    $   #   *9 9 #  :;6    -/ # # *BB0 #       *B * # # *BB0  ! #" "!5 #*BB0 :;6   5#   $ $ +, *)-./ 0 / 1 $  / 2*34 ##      5 6  

6   7$+ $  2

4

#. .89

;.;," E1+)#  $ 3% $1     5 :. / 0       "

9 2 4 9( *; 8'

 3'  3 "   73   *B20  

! 5   3!" #

 8*9* # :;6

*0 *1 C !

 C ! :;6   

 #    # 73   *B20    :;6  C "C

 #73   !"

" "   # -B- #73  *B20  !#   # 73  *B20  !  !"      !

 5   

  # 8 *9 #   :;6 *0 *2 5  

! 5  3  5"

# 

 8!

 58   !#73  # 

 8*9 # :;6 #3!"  $3 ###A  ##

 8*9

# :;6' # !# # 1

#73 *B20 ! *0 *9

 5  # 3 #

(

#  # %/ />;?/=1.;

  :;6 !5IH # #*BB055 3 3" 3 # # *BB0   !#!  # *BB0 #

 #73 *B20 J  #8*B # #*BB0 "!! 

 8*9 # :;6     !

   5 !"         -B - # 73   *B20  5  5   5 !"   C    #   $ $ =2#4"*7! B'! */   5" 

'J # 8*B # #*BB0   #73 *B20

!  J  # 8 *B   # 3  # ('8: 6     # 3 "  #5 3  #  

  8 *9 #   :;6 5  

 !

 5 '!"('8: 6  8 *0/ #  :;6  #    

   " 3" 3 ! 8 *B  #   # *BB0    ('8: 6         3" 8 *9 #  :;6   !

 5

  8 !     # #  3" # 3  *B20#! ('8:6 8*B # #*BB0   !! 

8  !

 5 8*9 # :;6 

*1 6   #!

 5    # 73 *B20! &

55

    *9*  # #  !   # /1 "   3 !"

 81 #73 *B20 *2    4"3  *- .2 -.-1 !"&

 ,

/1= #-.-/5 *B .1 -.-1  ,

 /12 # -.-/  !"   5 #      &

  ## 

"    #

 # # "

 '    # " 8 1 # 73   *B20  # 3   55  #   # "  5  #    ! !

 #  $#   4 !5 3

*9   (    5

*=       

   # "    

 #   D          &

  

         

"$"       

';@;? ;-27+ + '8  K8,

+

! K8,