Shish Pal v. State Information Commission Haryana And Others
! "
$$% &
'(
)
* ) +% ,-
)
'+ ."(% ,
, .
% & (
////
- " , 1 2 " # " 3 % ( & " 4" 5 6
7,8" 29 (
$$% & ( ; ,(( ; 6
<
=
5 ( 3 (
: $
7,8" >9 ( ( ;
7,8" ( ( ;
? (
(( :
": @ " '5 ,%
< ,
=9% % 35 $ 3 "5
! "! #
$ %" #
!
&' &()*&+ , # %*-!
.
+ /&+ 01
&2/+2/&+ ,
& !
" #
$ %" #
# %*-!
. + /&+ 0
3
3
/ !
!
4
** 5 !
*
3
1 '+
3
1 +/ !
# ( &% -
7,8" >9%
#@ $ "5 3 ( $ 3 8$( $ " "
>797+9 ,
,55 - 5 $%
((
7,8" 9%
3 $ -
7,8"
( % %
" & ((
7,8" 9 5 " (( % ( 3 $ +"5$
> ( $$ % ( ( % 4" & - -"
,(( ," &
$$% &% - 6
7,8" 29 $ (( 3 " $*5 & +"5$
> "(
A "
":$ "% ( % < : &
: ":$ (" " ,- $ ;
> : 5-
$
( ( (" " - $
$ : 8 > B=
# ":$ $$% 5 $ %
: - " " &
( 4" $ :1 ( : " 3 5 :$ ( - ( "$
3" : (": "$ 3 $5
# C- ,
: " (": " & % :$ (": - : & (": $ : : &% " : : D( -E D( E :" "$
(": "$ (
2679 : "
2 # C- ,
# +"5$% ( -
>797+9 3
79 ,
3 3 : - % : & : ( "$ 3 "$: "( " " , 8$ " 3" " "3 - ( -& : & $ (": -&
# 5" %
: ( & 5 " (( % % 3 "$: "( " &
- +"5$
# " 5" $("5 6
%
& : ( "(
"
& .- $ &%
%
: $ - : 5 (":
# ":$ $
: " & - 5 $ " 4" 5 (": :5 - -
A "
" "
5 5 " : "( +"5$ ( E:
"( $ "
% ( ! !"#$ %&'
5" - +"5$ " $(
- :
$$% &%
5 " & ((
A "
" ( "( ( ')!& ! * ( " + ,'-)- , ! * .(
( % % "
- : ( & ( (*5
- : 5- 3
( & (
4" : $ +"5 " ,
# ":$ $("5 - +"5$
A "
( & $("5 6
:
$$% &% : $ *5 +"5$ ( E:
"( $ "
"( 9% +"5$ ( " .(
"( 9 +"5$
> 7,8" >9 ( $$% (
5 5 " (( "&
5 ( 1 ( -
A
"
":$
$$% & 3" $
*5 +"5$ ( E:
"( $ "
"( 9% +"5$ ( " .(
"( 9 +"5$
>
7,8" >9 ( $$
"
" (
( " (( :*
>
, ( " ,8" 7 (5 (( :*9
" & (( :
$$ 3" 3
$ (
5 " (( +"5$
> 7,8" >9 ( $$
' - ( ( 5 " (( ( "
: 3 * / 0, 7 8 *9: -:!
*5
07 87;8 1 - *&++(
-
!
< * # # !
) . ##/ /-/&+ 0/ +((2+
=>= 1 1 ,2
3
4
-% 54 10 -%
7 8 " * 78 !
* 78 * 78 *
!
*; ?
!
*
# * @ # * = 7&8 %
!
=2=
* !
*
!
? 3 *
A !
A A
A A / *
2B 78 6
-) 54
-)
, C!
! *
* !
*
*
*
* * !
D % @ C!
!
*
* !
*
* *
*
>
* !
D %
@ = C?
- *
* D !
*
!
= 7
1
&"'$"($ ''"'$ .6 78 *9: -*5
" #
"
D
!
<
# # ! ) . ##/ /-/&+ 0/ +((2+
=,=-
*
# !
?
! !*
!
E!
? 3 *
*
07 87;8 - !
*
!
6
4
1 4 2 1 1 6 1
4 4 5 1 8
4 1
1
6
, ( " +"5$
> 7,8" >9 3" 3 $$
% *5 ( - # C- , $ %
2
>797+9
79 ,
% : - : & : ( "$% "
- " 8$ " 3" " "3 - ( -& ( & : & $ (": -&
# 3 " : - $( & F
5 - & 5" : & " : : & 5 5" ( $ 3" - ( & $ ( - "(
:- +"5$
: 6
7,8" 29 (
$$% & ( $
-5 : $ 5 " (( :5 - 3
( "
$ & 6
: $ "
& .- $ &
: "( +"5$ ( E:
"( $ "
"( 9
A "
5 5 ( 5 (
+"5$
( "
: 3 2 4 9(
4
. !' : ;* "
5 # ?
1 -
& 7 8* 7&8* 7'8 7B8
! !
/
* 3
!
%
*
7 8
!
!
%
7
< = 9 4 6 " !!%$ ;
)&)@ !
; #
/ 4 > 9 < '
1 *
7 8
%
* ? 1 1
4 @1 1@
''
2
+ ?
''
1 1 4 1
1 1 *& . !'
: ;
2
6
< 4 1 < < ? / A 1 41 1
4
1 4
* 6 6* * ! !/ < ? *
!
*
!
!
%
7 8
? < *
!
6 6
< ? * $9 * !
$9 *
7 8 %
! ?
*
1
*
*
7 8 *
!
* 7 8
??????
> * 7 8
<
!
! !
!
!
7 8
2& F 7 8
!
!
3
%
* %
!
% ! 7 8
?
*
*
*
!
78 7 8 0 , 1 -
1 1 1 4 1
1
( 1 1#
!
3
7 4
1
( ,< ? 6 ?
1 1 1
44 1 1
6 1 1 1
? 41 4
1
? 41 6
1 1
1
1 1
6 4 4 ''"'$ .6
, ( " :- ( " ( 5 ( 3" 3 ( %
: : - - $ ( & % " & 3" : 4" " ( &
5 $%
6
" & 4" (": " "35 & (:
$ +" & ( &
# 3 " : - (": ( 5 & ":+ 3 *3 8(G :5 (": " 4"& : & & - -5 3 55% :5 (":
: $ :5 " $ (":
# ( % E:
"( $ "
* +"5$ ( 4 9(
4
% (
. !'
: ;% 5
"
- (
79 ,
% $
: "(( ( &% " &
8$ $ : ( & 3 $- ( " "
,
: 3 " 5 (": 4" " "
$ : " &
# 3 " : - $ ( 8 : 5 ( " "
,
4" : 3
# 5"$ " 5 3 3 :- +"5$ 3 ( -
>797+9
,
% 3 "$: "(
$$% &
- $ "5 3 : ( & " & $ " $ : ( & ( " $ "
,
3 4" : 3 3 4" : " ( &
5 ( % 3 "$: "( " & (": " "
$ "35 & (:
$ +" & ( &
A "
( " ( ( -
769 ,
-
$$% &% $ " 4" : "
$$% &% " ( & ( % $ 4" : $
$$
# " % " & $ " $ " : ( & $ 3 4" : "(( 3 " 35 ( " "
,
3 " "5 & ( &
, ( " 6
3" 3 (% - ( - ,
3 - 3 "
%
- : (5 6
"% *(5 -3 :-
"$% ( - ( & 3 6
7,8" 29 3
$$% & " & (( % ,(( ; 6
<
=
*5 +"5$ ( E:
"( $ "
"( 9% +"5$ ( " .(
"( 9 +"5$
> 7,8" >9 ( $$% 3
3
5 ( % 8(" & (: % ( : & 3 ( "
$ $ ( 1 ( - ( " (( :
$$% &
( (( :
$$% & 6
!"
#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0