← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/1/2016dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax Gurgaon v. M/S Itw India Ltd Level-1 Lotus Plaza 732/1 Mg Road Sec 14 Gurgaon

2016-04-23Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta6 pages



      

  ! "#$#%&'( )  *#%"#+ ,--#$$#% *%"-  ./0*1 % 22++ ,, %

3$4%!# 5#-# ! 2 $+%! % & 65

 78

5  65

 7 77  



      

   

   7

  

    !" #$

 %&'





 "

#

%&'





  9 :80- * ,/ 



  

('

*+&

, -&%.*/  %0&12 

3 +4&-&5

, 

-

  %  6  7  878%  6  /  %  0

12   , &  9 +*:6;:++. 

   

    ++5(+4 

  <

!(

2     

 %,

 

     



=+66>=+,7 



     

       '

=+,7/ 2 

=+,&/.2

&

2 '



   

 %

     



 

=+,7  



      

   

  =66>     

 ,

2     

 %6 8 ,       

-

 

      

   -

    &?        

' 

-

/@:(2 4A  &B 



 

1  &      ' 

    

     ' 

' 

  

 



    

 

    

    ++5(+4 

++++5

5+%.%

%*:(  



=+66>=+,7

&&



5 / 2

&  .++*%&-& 

  5 %+ %4%.3.:( 

 

=+,7

& 

  '   

) '

 

 %.+%.*%.+:(

  

)

=+66>

&  =4%5+%=3:( 

 ' -

   '



  

) '

 &

% '



'



=+,7/ 2 

=+&/.2

& 

%.

%%4 :( 

=+,7

&

 +A

  *%55%+=%55:( 















 



=+66>

&& %&

  

)

=+66>

&33%34%==:(  

8   

 =4%5+%=3:(    

  D  

 

  

  





'

-



 

   .%% 4%+.:(  

 



&

  

 

 / C2)

.>&/2

&  &8 B /&B 2

  

 

 C

C8

% 

%**%4.%3=:( &

        

   

      

 

    & ' %







 >

 

 ,   -  /&

 2  E>, /&2F   G     

++=%  &-  & %    >, /&2         

  

 

&

  



=+66>

&  33%34%==:(      





  



 

=+,7

&D%>, /&2  

  %+%53%*5:(   

    

 %54%.=%54*:(

'

-



 





 



    



+%*+%3:(9 

  %







    



G   3 +4%&-&5%   



 



'8

  6



'

 ' 

   5  

' 

     

     %   

           ++*%&-&)

.>&/ 2

& 

)

45

& =++*

 &

>

, -/ 

  2%6





 .++*%&-&

  >

, -%> /2%6?'







>, /&26D





'





6)   

  6



 &

 6%

H

   ) --#$$#% *%"-  ./

*#!

;

!<$ 3$ *,

%!# 5! ' =   

  !"#$ $  %$  !

 &&!  '$ $ &    ($                !   )$ 



    ! )$ 

*

*$+  , -     '$ !&!!

    $.

*   

   6   >           

  >           

     

  -

 

           -    



,  %

6  > 

   

 6 >  

>     

      

    

 

  



 6 >  

% <







 %          6   >      -

  

'



&







            

      

  

      

      7   

H

 6 >  H'

 

H   % 

 '

  

'              

  6   >  

 7   C    

 





% '

7 







(

/2/2

)

4*

&'   > 

7 

  

        



  

 

  

  >   & %            





 



(



 ------------ & 





'

H '

 I > >

>



 

      &

  C

            

,

    



  &

 

I > >

>



  &

  C

  

          

I%> >

>

 







-

8 8

 

    

   &

  C

 

 <          

 6 >  

  3 

   &        

    

           

%     

 

   '

 

      '  





  ,'



 '%





 

   

    

 >        

' 

&

 7   & %     

         '



 



  



  1  )     

    

 >     , &  9 5. 

 + E 

       

  !  ++ 4 ,'



 '%

 

 



' 

&

%  >

, -%> /2%6% 



H

  

  





('





  



   9 :80- * ,

0!1  +*#,'/  *$) %7#%1)

1$> 0!1