← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1864/2012allowed

Gurpreet Kaur And ANR. v. Harbans Singh

2016-10-06Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

   

       

  ! "#$%&'  (&)&%%#*+(&+,-+,#.%& /))%00+,#1 2%&1(1 +&$+,13,4.  / %1),-%,#  !5 67   87

&%1%,#! &+,9%%2+,&+3'%,3&-2"+#%:3#. &+(&+2+0:+&'-2"+#%&#.%+))%00+,#1 &*&&+'-2"+#%&#.%&%1),-%,#  87' .% -%%,-+,#1 +&% +))%00+,#1 $%&% #.31 (&# .%;+&%+44&3%2%-#.%","(&&%,#3,-3,41&%"&-%-$;$#. #.%(&#1$%0::.%&%$;+1(3#&-%"0+&+#3,:+1-%"&%%-  1(3# & -%"0+&+#3, :+1 30%- $; #.% &%1),-%,#5 )0+3,#3"0+3<3,4#$%:,%&+,-3,)11%113,#.%1(3#0+,-' <%+1(&3,4  =+,+01  3,"% #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 :+1 1(%&3,4&<<%,#+0-%)&%113,'+))%00+,#5-%%,-+,#4# %>%"(#%-1+0%-%%--+#%-?

@:%2%&'#.%+))%00+,#5 -%%,-+,#1 -%,3%- #.+# #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 :+1 1(%&3,4 &<-%)&%113,'$(#1#+#%-#.+##.%0%4+0+,-2+03-1+0%-%%-

55 -+#%- ?

@ & + ",13-%&+#3, 

B5 :+1 %>%"(#%- 3, +2(&  +))%00+,#5-%%,-+,#    .% 1+0% ",13-%&+#3,

B5:+1&%"%32%-$;#.%&%1),-%,#5 )0+3,#3  +# .<% +,- (#  #.+# +<(,#' #.% )0+3,#35 &%1),-%,# )+3- 1'@

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

 +&% +,,%>%- +1 ,,%>(&% ':.3".1.:1#.+##.%1(3#&)11%113,$;:+;  1)%"33" )%&&<+,"%  +4&%%<%,# # 1%00 -+#%- @

@ %>#%,-%-,@

:+130%-$;,%.+<3,-%&3,4.+03+1 (=.<+,-%&3,4.'+4+3,1##.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 +&$+,1

5@5 3,4. D -%%,-+,#  3, #.+# 1(3#  +,- +))%00+,#5-%%,-+,#  ()&%%#*+(&D-%%,-+,#3,#.%1(3# &%>%"(#3, #.%1+0%-%%-3,&%1)%"##.%1+<%2%&;0+,-,&$%&% A@

A' &",13-%&+#3, 1'A

B5 ,#.+#1(3#' + ".+00%,4% :+1 <+-% # #.% 1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@ %>%"(#%- $; +&$+,1 3,4. -%%,-+,#   3, +2(&  ()&%%#*+(& -%%,-+,# :%2%&'&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3

+&$+,1 3,4.  -%,3%- #.% %>%"(#3,  +4&%%<%,# # 1%00 1#+#%-#.+#1+<%:+1&%1(0#&4%-+,-+$&3"+#%--"(<%,#' <(". 0%11'   &%1(0#  &+(- +1 , ",13-%&+#3,' :+1' %2%& )+11%-  ))%00+,#5-%%,-+,#  ()&%%# *+(&  -%,3%- #.% %>%"(#3,+4&%%<%,##1%00.%0+,-<%+1(&3,4=+,+01 23-% 1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@ :+1 )(&".+1%- &< &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 & + ",13-%&+#3, 

B5 0#.(4.  #.% 2%,-& +&$+,1 3,4.   +))%+&%- 3, #.% %>+<3,+#3,53,5".3%' $(# -3- ,# "<% &:+&- & "&115 %>+<3,+#3, 0#3<+#%0;' #.% 1(3# :+1 -%"&%%- ,0;' & +0#%&,+#32%&%03%&%"2%&;.%#.%&-"(<%,#1(4.##$% )0+"%- , &%"&- 31 + ");  #.% "&3<3,+0 "+1% 3,1#3#(#%- $; .+<3,-%& 3,4. E (=.<+,-%& 3,4. +1 ,,%>(&%   , #.+# "+1%' #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 .+1 $%%, .%0- 4(30#; (,-%& 1%"#3,  .%#.3&--"(<%,#31+,+3-+23#',,%>(&%

@'(&,31.%-$;#.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#31.:3,4#.+#.%.+- %>%"(#%-+1+0%-%%--+#%-?

@&+",13-%&+#3,

55

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

@:+1 ,(003#;%(&#.%&1($<3#1#.+#3,#.%+&%1+3-03#34+#3,'#.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 -3- ,# -%,; #.% %>%"(#3,  1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@' &+#.%& +-<3##%- #.+#3#:+1 %>%"(#%- & + ",13-%&+#3, 

B5  % +01 1($<3#1 #.+# #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 .+- %>+<3,%- #.% #: +##%1#3,4 :3#,%11%1  #.% 1+0% -%%- :. +-<3##%- #.%3& 134,+#(&%1 $(# -%,3+0  1+0%",13-%&+#3,.+23,4,#)+11%-'3,#.%3&)&%1%,"%.+1, 1($1#+,"%' 3,+1<(". +1' 1+0% ",13-%&+#3, :+1 )+11%- , +# .<%2%,#.%1#+#%<%,#+""(,#1>+,->&%2%+0 #.+# #.% +<(,#  1?A'

B5 :+1 -%)13#%- 3, #.% 0+, +""(,##.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3.(1',#.%$+131

5A5 %23-%,"%+2+30+$0%,&%"&-'#.%1(3##.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 3103+$0%#$%-31<311%- &*&&+' 0%+&,%- "(,1%0 & #.% &%1),-%,#5 )0+3,#31($<3#1#.+##.%1+0%-%%--+#%-?

@3#1%0:+1 23-' 3,+1<(". +1' 3# :+1 :3#.(# ",13-%&+#3, .(1' #.% (&#1$%0:.+2%&34.#0;1%#+13-%#.%1+0%-%%-%2%,3,#.% +$1%,"%<%-3"+0%23-%,"%2%,#.%1#+#%<%,#+""(,#1 )&-("%-,&%"&--,#1.:#.%+4&%%-1+0%",13-%&+#3, 

B5  .+2% 432%, <; #.(4.#(0 ",13-%&+#3, # #.% +&4(<%,#1+-2+,"%-$;0%+&,%-"(,1%0&#.%)+&#3%1

,-%&#.%)&2313,1(,-%& &-%&F (0% ' #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 31 &%G(3&%- # -31".+&4% #.% ,(1' 3,+1<(". +1' & 1(""%%-3,4 3, + 1(3# $+1%- (), #.% <31&%)&%1%,#+#3, +,- &+(-' ,# ,0; #.% )0%+-3,41' $(# #.% "4%,#%23-%,"%31#$%0%-#.+#.%:+11(%&3,4&<<%,#+0 -%)&%113,$;#&%+#3,41+0%-%%--+#%-?

@+1,(003#; $(#  , 1(". %23-%,"% .+1 $%%, 0%- 3, #.31 &%4+&-  & +00 3,#%,#1 +,- )(&)1%1' #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 +-<3##%- .31 134,+#(&%1,#.%1+0%-%%-.%",13-%&+#3,:+13,#%&<1 <,%;  .% %23-%,"%  #: +##%1#3,4 :3#,%11%1' ,+<%0;' +=+< 3,4. +,- +3$ 3,4. &%4+&-3,4 -%,3+0  1+0% ",13-%&+#3,3,#.%3&)&%1%,"%.+1,1($1#+,"%'3,+1<(".+1' 3&1#0;'#.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3+30%-#-31".+&4%#.%,(1

55 &+(-+,-<31&%)&%1%,#+#3,+,-1%",-0;'#.%&%31,-%,3+03, #.%%+&03%&&(,-03#34+#3,:3#.&%4+&-#%>%"(#3,#.%1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@  &%2%&' #.% ",13-%&+#3, "+, $% )+11%- # #.% 2%,-& +# +,; )3,#  #3<% & )0+"%  , #.% )&%1%,#"+1%'#.%+))%00+,#5-%%,-+,#"+<%(#:3#.#.% %23-%,"% #.+# 1+0% ",13-%&+#3, :+1 %+&03%& )+3- +# .<%' +1 )0+3,#3 .+- # &%)+; #.% 0+, +<(,# $&&:%- $; #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 .31 %23-%,"% 31 1#&%,4#.%,%- $; #.% +--3#3,+0 %23-%,"% 1(4.# # $% 0%- $; #.% +))%00+,#1 :.3". 1.:1 #.+# +# , )3,#  #3<% #.% &%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 .+- ,%2%&-%,3%-#.%%>%"(#3,#.%1+0%-%%--+#%-?

@ 3,+2(&#.%+))%00+,#'&+#.%&(&,31.%-+,+3-+23#3, #.%"&3<3,+0)&"%%-3,41#.+##.%1+0%-%%-:+1%>%"(#%-&+ ",13-%&+#3, 

B5 &%2%&' #.% &%1),-%,#5 )0+3,#3 1#%))%- 3,# #.% :3#,%11 $> ,0; & %>+<3,+#3,53,5 ".3%$(#-3-,#"<%&:+&-&"&115%>+<3,+#3, %&.+)1' #.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3:+1+&+3-'$%3,4'.+23,4",&,#%- #.%+&%<%,#3,%-+"#+,-'#.%&%&%'3#"+,:%00$%3,%&&%- #.+##.%&%:+1,-%,3+03,#.%<(#.#.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 :3#. &%4+&- # #.% 1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@ & + ",13-%&+#3,

B5,<;23%:'+00#.%1%+"#&1 .+2%$%%,34,&%-$;#.%(&#1$%0:.(1'#.%-"(<%,#1

5?5 ,#3"%- +$2%' +&% #+=%, , &%"&-' $%3,4 #.% &%"&-1  #.% (&#'$;:+;+--3#3,+0%23-%,"%  -($#' #.31 (&#' , %+&03%& ""+13,1 .+- $%%,&+<3,4#.%1($1#+,#3+0G(%1#3,10+::.30%-%"3-3,4 #.%+))%+01$(#3,23%:#.%&+#3-%"3-%,-3"(00%-(#$; 32% 0%+&,%- (-4%1  #.% ,6$0% ()&%<% (&# 3, +,=+9+=1.3 -%+-  #.&(4. 7 1 +,- #.%&1 F1 .+,-&3=+ +,- #.%&1      @I' :.%&%3, #.% )&)13#3, +&1% +1 # :.%#.%& 3, 23%:  #.% )&2313,1  %"#3, C?

   ' )&2313,1  %"#3,   #.% (,9+$ (&#1 "#'C:(0-+))0;&#.%+))%+03% :(0-$%30%- (,-%& %"#3, 

  -%  3230 &"%-(&%' 1 #.%&% 31 ,%%- # &+<% #.% 1($1#+,#3+0 G(%1#3,1 0+:& ,# .% ,1#3#(#3,+0%,".,6$0%()&%<%(&#.%0-#.+##.% -%"313,3,H*(0:+,#*+(&+,-#.%&1F1(&-3+03,4.+,,

-%+- $;7 1+,-#.%&1

  ',+))03"+$303#; %"#3,C?

  31,#+"&&%"#0+:'3,%11%,"%'#.% )&2313,1%"#3,#.% (,9+$(&#1"#'C.+- $%%,&%1#&%-$+"= 

&#.%1+=%$&%23#;'#.%&%0%2+,#)&#3,#.% 9(-4<%,#  32% 0%+&,%- (-4%1  #.% ,6$0% ()&%<% (&#3, +,=+9+=1.361"+1% 1()&+ &%+-1#.(1!5 H3,"%%"#3,#.% (,9+$"#31%>)&%110;3, ",03"#:3#.#.%+<%,-3,40+:'23J'%"#3,



55 +1 +<%,-%-' 3# :(0- $% -%%<%- # .+2% $%%, &%)%+0%-.(1:%.+2%,.%13#+#3,#.0-#.+# #.% 0+: -%"0+&%- $; #.% (00 %,".  #.% 34. (&#3,#.%"+1%+,)+#K C?

@?!  (,9 7  

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

% (,9+$ (&#1 "# :+1 ",#3,(%- $%3,4 + 0+: 3, &"% 3, #.% #%&&3#&;  ,-3+ 3<<%-3+#%0; $%&% #.% "<<%,"%<%,#  #.% ,1#3#(#3,,-3+$;23&#(%&#3"0%@?   #.% ,1#3#(#3,  ,-3+ .31 $%3,4 #.% "+1%' &#3"0%A#.%,1#3#(#3,,-3+:(0-.+2% ,+))03"+#3,#1(".+0+:&#.%13<)0%&%+1, #.+# 3# 31 ,# + 0+: <+-% $; #.% 7%4310+#(&%  + #+#%$(#31+,%>31#3,40+:",#3,(%-$;23&#(% &#3"0%@?#.%,1#3#(#3,,-3++#+00'3# 31&#3"0%@?  +0,%#.+#:(0-+))0;#1(".

A @

   5C5 0+: :.3". 31 # ",#3,(% 3, &"% (,#30 +0#%&%- & &%)%+0%- & +<%,-%- $; + "<)%#%,# 7%4310+#(&% & #.%& "<)%#%,# +(#.&3#; 8% .+2% +0&%+-; (,-#.+#13,"%%"#3,C?

 #.%-%3230

&"%-(&%

<%,-<%,#  "#' C? .+1 , +))03"+#3,#%"#3,#.% (,9+$(&#1"#' 3#:(0-,%"%11+&30;",#3,(%+1+0+:3,&"%I ,23%:#.%+&%1+3--31"(113,'#.%+))%+0#.% -%%,-+,#1 31 +00:%- +,- #.% 9(-4<%,#1 +,- -%"&%%1  #.% (&#$%0:+&%1%#+13-%+,-#.%1(3##.%&%1),-%,#5)0+3,#3 31 .%&%$; -31<311%- ,1%G(%,#0;' #.% 1+0% -%%- -+#%- ?

@ 31 .%0- # $% 0%4+0 +,- 2+03- $; 23&#(%  :.3". +))%00+,#1+&%:,%&3,)11%113,#.%1(3#0+,-<%+1(&3,4 =+,+01   "#$%& '    87  *   8.%#.%&1)%+=3,4B&%+1,%-!%1B 8.%#.%&&%)&#+$0%!  %1B