High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4529/2011allowed

Gurdial Singh And ORS v. Bachan Singh

2016-08-17Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&" + ",- .

)/0%!1%'*, ",#/& 22#11!'"& 3#/&)& !$,!'%'*, #&2'0#'"

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

/#&#'"( /!*!'0##2%'*,%/2,%4,%-05$!"#- /",#!22#11!'"& / 6!""!-#'%/05$!"#7%", /%4,%1!""!-05$!"#- /",#/#&2'0#'" 88888 *)+%,' 22#11!'"90##'0!'"&!/#!**/%#5#0",#:)0*;#'"&!'0 0#$/##&<",",#)/"&<#17-7,#/#<=",#$1!%;",#/#&2'0#'"9 21!%'"% &##4%'*0#$1!/!"%' ",!",#%& 7'#/ %' 2&&#&&%' 1!'0 ;#!&)/%'* 4!'!1& ;!/1!&<#!/%'*>,!&/!?

@@ 9 - @

@@ .9 -?

@A 9? !&2#/:!;!<!'0%/",#=#!/ ?9 &%")!"#0!"3%11!*#6!0,!)'0!!'0%'",#!1"#/'!"%5#/0#$1!/!"%' ",!",#%&7'#/",#1!'0!'0",#0##'0!'"&,!5#'/%*,"!'0"%"1# 7%",$'&#B)#'"%!1/#1%#2&&#&&%'-,!&<##'!117#0

/!*!'0##2 %'*, %/2,%4,%- 1#!/'#0 $)'&#1 / ",# !22#11!'"90##'0!'"&&)<;%"&",!"",#&)%"-!/#;#'"%'#0-7!&%'&"%")"#0 <=!$,!'%'*,&',!4!/%'*,-7,,!0#C$,!'*#0",#1!'0- !/#;#'"%'#0-7%",",#0##'0!'"&",/)*,/!1#C$,!'*#!'0%'1%#) ",#/#-;)"!"%'<#!/%'* .0!"#0. +7!&#'"#/#0%'""

'1=",%&-",#!22#11!'"90##'0!'"&7#/#2)"%'"2&&#&&%'!'0",# :!;!<!'0%#&@4,!&/!*%/0!7/%#&%'",%&/#*!/0,!5#<##'</)*,"' /#$/0-%#-:!;!<!'0%/",#=#!/ .9+ C -?9 C? - 4,!&/!*%/0!7/%/; " C -" C -+ '7!/0& C. !'0:!;!<!'0%/",#=#!/A9 C+ !'0& 7!&",#/#&2'0#'"921!%'"%-7,7!&2)"%'"2&&#&&%'",#1!'0 *%5#'",%;%'#C$,!'*# #)/",#/&)<;%"&",!"",#21!%'"%,!&'"&"#22#0%'"",# 7%"'#&&<C!'0-",#/#/#-",#2/#&);2"%')'0#/#$"%'

* ",# '0%!'5%0#'$#$"- A+7!&/#B)%/#0"<#2/5#0'/#$/0!&%"%&! $!"#*/%$21#!0%'*%'",#21!%'"",!"",#;)"!"%'-!/#;#'"%'#0-7!& ##$"#0<=21!=%'*/!)0",",#)/"&<#17,!5#0#$/##0",#&)%" '",#*/)'0",!"",#/!1#C$,!'*#$!''"<#"!4#'%'"$'&%0#/!"%' / 7!'" /#*%&"/!"%' ,# /!1 #C$,!'*# ,!0 "!4#' 21!$# <#/# 7,#'",#!;#'0;#'"%'#$"%' +",# #*%&"/!"%'$"

7!& $!)&#0 !'0- ",#/#/#- /!1 #C$,!'*# %& 2#/;%&&%<1# 0)<"-

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

!/!*/!2,A",#21!%'"",!"#70!=&!*-",#0##'0!'"&$!;#"",# &)%"1!'0!'0",/#!"#'#0",#21!%'"%",!"",#=,!0<#$;#7'#/&",# 1!'0'",#<!&%&&;##C$,!'*#0##0-7,%$,*!5#",#$!)&#!$"%' "%1#",#&)%" '/0#/"/"%=,%&$'"#'"%'7%",/#*!/0"''9 !22#!/!'$#",#21!%'"%-/-",#;)"!"%' C </#",#",);< %;2/#&&%'21!%'"%-,#/#1%#0)2'",#/!"%0#$%0#'0%$)11#0)"%' *4:$12 86;$ 1$1286544"21$1 , < 6'

7, =-

0>%4 544" 2 1 1,

' ?2>

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

",#E$"F A+",!"",# $!&#&#")2<=",#21!%'"%%&'"$//#$"'#G D,#",#/",#$!)&#"&)#%/&"!$$/)#0"",#21!%'"%9 /#&2'0#'"!&2#//"%$1#AE$"F .?'. + 7,#'",#;)"!"%'%#C ,!5%'*<##'&!'$"%'#0%'",# %;;#0%!"#2/#&#'$#21!%'"%9/#&2'0#'"!'0",#21!%'"%9 /#&2'0#'"",);<;!/4#0",#&!;#G ?

D,#",#/ %' ",# !<&#'$# ",# 21!%'"%9/#&2'0#'" ,!5%'*#'"#/#0%'"",#7%"'#&&9<C-%"$!'<#$'$1)0#0",!" ",# $!&# &#" )2 !'0 21#!0#0 <= ",# 21!%'"%9/#&2'0#'"

&"!'0&2/5#0'",#2%'"$!)&#!$"%'7,#'",#&)%"%& '"7%",%'1%;%"!"%'G / 6!""!-#'%/05$!"#!&&%&"#0<=/%4,%1!""!- 1#!/'#0$)'&#1/",#/#&2'0#'"921!%'"%&)<;%"&",!"",#&)%"$!''" <#",/7')"/7!'"1%;%"!"%'%'5%#7",#/!"%0#$%0#'0%$)11#0 )"<=",#%5%&%'#'$,",%&)/"%'*012324-1352#4

44 #)/",#/&)<;%"&",!" %"7)10'"<#!05#/&#"",# %'"#/#&"",#/#&2'0#'"921!%'"%%'$!&#",#2!/"=0#&'"!22#!/%' ",#7%"'#&&9<C!&&)%"7!&<!&#0)2'",#/!)0!'0;%&/#2/#&#'"!"%'- ;)$,1#&&!22/#$%!"%'1#*!12&%"%''&)22/",%&$'"#'"%'-,# /#1%#&)2'",#/!"%0#$%0#'0%$)11#0)"%' 36 : = 6

61 544 3 1

614, )1 8 A0%: 6/B

#*!/0%'*/#*%&"/!"%'",#/!1#C$,!'*#-,#,!&/#1%#0 )2'",#/!"%0#$%0#'0%$)11#0)"<=",%&)/"%' 6>:

614544102, 8%'B "$'"#'0",!"!"#/",# !;#'0;#'"#$"%'",# #*%&"/!"%'$"-'/!1#C$,!'*#%& 2#/;%&&%<1# / 7!'" /#*%&"/!"%' !'0- ",)&- )/*#& ",%& )/" / !%/;%'*",#%'0%'*&/#'0#/#0<=<",",#)/"&<#17 ,!5#,#!/0",#1#!/'#0$)'&#1/",#2!/"%#&-!22/!%&#0 ",#2!2#/<4!'0",#5%#7",!"",#/#%&;#/%"!'0/$#%'",#

9 &)<;%&&%'/%/2,%4,%-/-'2#/)&!1",#/#$/0&",#)/"& <#17- 2!/"%$)1!/1= ;)"!"%' C - %" /#5#!1& ",!" ",# 1#" ,!'0 %;2/#&&%'&/#&2'0#'"!$,!'%'*,!/#",#/#,#/#%&!$!"#*/%$ 21#!0%'*%'",#21!%'"7%",/#*!/0"/!)0!'0;%&/#2/#&#'"!"%'"%&",# 21!%'"%-7, $)10,!5# $;# %' ",#7%"'#&&<C !'00#2&#0 %' &)22/"",#!5#/;#'"&;!0#%'",#21!%'"!'0",#0##'0!'"&7)10 ,!5#,!0!$,!'$#"$'/'"",#",);<%;2/#&&%'!'0"!4#",#,#12 C2#/"';=5%#7-",#)/"&<#17)*,"",!5#2/#&);2"%')'0#/ #$"%'

* ",#'0%!'5%0#'$#$" &/#*!/0&",#21#!1%;%"!"%'-",#/#%&'0%&2)"#"",# /!"%0#$%0#'0%$)11#0)"%'*012324-1352#4 44

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

&%'",#4'71#0*# ",#/#&2'0#'"921!%'"%-=#",#0%0'"!5!%1",#/#;#0=/!2#/%0 !1;&"&%C=#!/&!&",#&)%"7!&%1#0%'",#=#!/?-",#/#/#-",#/!1 #C$,!'*#!"",#/#1#5!'"2%'""%;#%&2#/;%&&%<1#!'00%0'"/#B)%/# !'=/#*%&"/!"%'-",)&-&)<;%&&%'/!""5%&9!95%&''9/#*%&"/!"%' ",##C$,!'*#0##0%&,#/#<=/#2#11#0!'0/#:#$"#0/#;#'"%'#0 $'"#'"%'&-%';=5%#7-,!5#'"<##''"%$#0<=<",",#)/"&<#17 !'0-",#/#/#-",#/#%&%11#*!1%"=-!

/",#/#*%'*/#!&'&-",#:)0*;#'"&!'00#$/##& <",",#)/"&<#17!/#,#/#<=&#"9!&%0#!'0&)%"",#/#&2'0#'"9

B 21!%'"%%&,#/#<=0%&;%&&#0,#B)#&"%'&1!7-!&'"%$#0!<5#-!/# !'&7#/#0 %' !5)/ ",# !22#11!'"90##'0!'"& !'0 !*!%'&" ",# /#&2'0#'"921!%'"% 22#!1&"!'0&!117#0 46761,9 *)+%

341 '(-.& +1614?2 C4

D4C

+161 60!

D4C