← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19069/2023disposed of

Goverdhan Mines And Minerals v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-08-31Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari6 pages



        

 !

          

" # $"%&&&' # $"%&'$   !!""# $#  %&'# $

 " (" )%# $ "    *+ '# ' #& ) "

+,"-# #&  &&' %%()*+, .

" "+-""

 )   

* -"/+ -" 0  1123224

5+6278# ,0

 ,&"0 ''+" &   2

" '&-+ )" "    ,"

9+ 

 "

9+0*)   #",&/+ "      + "+0#""''+" &  #) 0) # 9'+ .+':;" &   

-  +' #  23.2#  $

 )"  ,0  5 " # 0*"'$

#   "0

- $ &#, -  ,&"   $"'  '



<:;4.8," &"  

 - 0 ' 

$ '   &"  

 ' -    0

   '    + *  0

-  ,&   &  +" &  "''  ,  '  

+ 6 4 8"  "''#+

  ,&" 0 ' &  " 0   - &$ ' 

0+ -,",& &"0 +" &#

+  "0 ' 

"'  ") + ) "

"      " )"&" ' 

, 0+'&0  ' ) " +"0+  + &# +'' "#  +"0 '' &5$ )" '+ * -   

=> ?  ",$ $# 

&5" $ -"@

5+627#)" ",0 5 "  < "' -" 0&, $  $ &0'   "' 0#"    .3@2322     #     '-&  ",& "  "0) '', %+   ",&- $ + & " -    A $ "   

 '

#"&  ,   '

9" & $& # '-&

.2132322..33 "' "'  0 '

   "0+   0 $  '

0

  " B,'

" + ' &

-> C  -",$5 -"$'

#"" ''+" &/+ -" 0+-   # 0 

.3@2322,&" # '-&#" " 

 "'  - ," 0 .212322..33

+"60#   "     )  0   +  "  '   "' 

 #  "0+   0 $  '0

"  0 ,&" B,'

)'' #  ""

  + + " ;

"'  +

' -"   " -+ "    "+  /+ -    "  0+-      ,&  "  '' +" &#""  ,00  # "+ '

" ) +   0 '$ ',',"''+" &#0* "'$

#  +"#"  ) 

&  " ''+" &#&0*   + "'  -   # "'$

, -0 #"+ ," 0

.212322     +"60  +,0   "  "  )   0) %+   "''+" &#

+ "' "'   #  "0+ 

-  0 $  '

0

"  0 ,&" B,'

#'

 

  +  "  "  + ' /+   

  + #  "+  ,0    7

",$0  +,0

)+' "$$ -# '&  - 0 '"5  ,"''+" &  # 0*"'$

 )$#"

 " #") +   0 '$ ','  ,"''+" &  #$    - ""   0+-  , #"+  0*"'$

 : (  "      0&# "+-"  "  '   +

'    "    " &-+ ""/+ -" 0+-   # "''+" &) ,0* -  0 " " # '-&  # ) 0*" '$

)$#$ ",$- #

"

  +



5+627#+ #"+  , ' & "  )  .3@2322#)",&"'  0  0+ +

"     ",0 +  "#)"  0  "  )  2;2322) #"+ 0  ""  900 #) " *  " #"")     5$ 

"0 0 '

#",&#"+ 

& 

 -) "" '&   0+ '

" " 

,0  0  #  + #  "     #  "+-"       0   

2;2322   "    0    +  

    "     + +0 '&#"+-"  0  .3@2322#0"'  0   &'& "+-"       0   2;2322# "  ,

+

 + ," 

-

/+""D 900 

 + #+ "9" 0

" D+   0'#   D+ -"

9+#"+ "+-"  0  2;2322 @  +" * " 0+-  

5+# "" '$

# 0 "+-"  )  .3@2322#)" "

,0 0+-  ,"''+" &  #)" " ) " 0+-  

5+#",0' * 

+0 

 

", "0*'$' +' # ,&"+ ' "'  "&23.@ +,0   "&23.1 "#" +"

5+627 ) '+ )",&  +, " +"   &    "  0#     0           

  &

 $'+" 

 '&#",$)   , -

#""D 900 "  ,&D+   0'# )" "#")$#0* - ''  0-&     "'$  0 #"+ ' -"'  '

 0

# "" 0  0*  "#"   ''  0-&  0 

 +"'$ 0 '#"

,0  "+-"  0  2;2322 " " ,

"  #" +, /+   )  .3@2322,&"   '# '-&0   #,0 "   6    '&  "    0 '    

+--  $"" ''  0-&   ,&"900 4 +8# ) '* - +"   &#"+ '  # ' " ,&" +"

5+627   0  ,)''0  '  "  +' '&#"  0

 ,0 )''  "  1

" *)" " 

"

9+0

+''

-" 0+-   # 0",$0 , $ 

#"+ '

- #  +  "     +0#  "  "    ''   0-&#  



-    "  '   ' 8#   &  /+     , 

-"+''& '&E #)" "")$

,  ,&"

9+ "#"

+"

5+627#0& *"

 5 #0* '& "   ''  0-&# #0&"'

  "/+ +0 '&" + /+  , 0  + "  "#) "",$0 '

$ ','     #  "+  "  )       "  '' +" &$ /+ -"'$  0+-   #0

"  "+" & ,')  9

 ++ '&

"'$

4 8     0     ,0  )''   "  " 8   '&#"'$

# 0 ,'+ "    ,0 , #"+"

5+627 "    "  

   0* " '$   0   #  +  "    .3    -'& (&&',     ('$ , 

 !   %&6.

F"" * -A  

A F"",'

A