High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4599/2011dismissed

Sukhdev Singh v. Vijay Washishat

2015-01-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'(!')!*+ , )-./#0%'1.

22#33!'"

4#*&)& 5"4%6!+7!&.%&.!"

#&2'/#'"

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

7.#".#* #2*"#*&3$!32!2#*&5!+8#!339#/"&##".#6)/15#'": 8#*##**#/"".# #2*"#*&*'":

; 7.#".#*".#6)/15#'"&.)3/8#*#2*"#/%'".#%1#&":

*#&#'"( *!*9!'%'1.,#'%*/0$!"#9%". * !2*%,/0$!"#, *".#!22#33!'" <<<<< *)+%,'

.%& %& ! #1)3!* #$'/ 22#!3 !" ".# %'&"!'$# ".# !22#33!'"=23!%'"%!1!%'&"".#6)/15#'"&!'//#$*##&8".".#)*"& 8#39,9.#*#8+".#&)%"*/#$3!*!"%'".!".#%&9'#*%'2&&#&&%'".# &)%"3!'/5#!&)*%'1>?&@+!*/&!'/;&@" ;?&@5"*& 8#!*%'1 *%0!"#

3"& A, >!'/ !&&.9'%'".#&%"#23!'!'/".#&!3#/##//!"#/ A; ,!33#1#/".!0#8##'*#1%&"#*#/%'!0)*".#/##'/!'",8#%'1 8!&#/'*1#*+,!8*%$!"%'!'/')33 0%/!'/!&9#33!&*2#*5!'#'"

%'6)'$"%'*#&"*!%'%'1".#/##'/!'"*5%'"#*#*%'1%'".#2&&#&&%'0#* ".#&)%"2*2#*"+,.!&8##'/%&5%&&#/ *!*9!'%'1.,3#!*'#/#'%*)'&#3!22#!*%'1'8#.!3 ".# !22#33!'"=23!%'"% $'"#'/& ".!" 8". ".# )*"& 8#39 .!0# $55%""#/!'%33#1!3%"+!'/2#*0#*&%"+%'/%&5%&&%'1".#&)%",%#,'5#*%"&

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

5/ /%2

5/,1 %78 9%: ".".#)*"&8#39.!0##C!5%'#/".##0%/#'$#8*)1."' *#$*/!'//%&5%&&#/".#&)%"!'/!22#!3%3#/!1!%'&"".#6)/15#'"!'/ /#$*##".#"*%!3)*" &!*!&".#%*&"$'"#'"%'".#3#!*'#/#'%*)'&#3* ".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%%&$'$#*'#/,".#&!5#%&/#0%/!'+5#*%"'".# #'/*&#5#'"".#&!3#/##//!"#/A; C ,".#'!5#".# !".#*".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%9!&$**#$"3+5#'"%'#/!&7!/.!9!%'1. .#!*#5#'"%'#/#'/*&#5#'"%&*#3#$"#/%'".#&!3#/##/ C 7D

8*)1."'*#$*/!"".#%'&"!'$#".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%!'/,".#*#*#, 8".".##'/*&#5#'"&$**8*!"#".##'/*&#5#'" C .#!22#33!'"=

; 23!%'"%%&&"!"#/".!0#"!-#'".#8#'#%"%3%'1".#&)%"'".#8!&%& &5#$3#*%$!35%&"!-#!&'!5#.%&!".#*9!& !*"!2%'1.%'&"#!/ 7!/.!9!%'1. "%&!5!""#**#$*/".!"".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%.!/,".*)1. 0!*%)&&!3#/##/&,%#,C;,C!'/C>,.!/&3/".#3!'/" 0!*%)&0#'/##&,'!5#3+,.!&.%E!'", !/5! !'%!'/%&.%%'".#+#!*

!'/".#!*#5#'"%'#/&!3#/##/&.!0#'"8##'$.!33#'1#/.#&!3# /##/%'".#2*#&#'"&)%"%&!3&".#+#!* 0#'".#*%1%'!3&!3#/##/ .!/'"8##'8*)1."'*#$*/8+".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"% & *#1!*/& ".# &)%" .!0%'1 8##' 8!**#/ 8+ 3%5%"!"%', ".# $'"#'"%'".#3#!*'#/#'%*)'&#3*".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%2!3#& %'&%1'%%$!'$#%'0%#9".#!$"".!"".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%.!/!3*#!/+ &3/ ".# #'"%*# 3!'/ ".*)1. 0!*%)& &!3# /##/& !& 5#'"%'#/ !80# .#*#*#,.#$)3/'"8#&!%/"8#%'2&&#&&%'".#&)%"2*2#*"+ #0%/#'$#.!&8##'3#/"".###$"".!"".#!22#33!'"=23!%'"%.!/8##'%' 2&&#&&%' ".# &)%" 2*2#*"+ .# *!"% /#$%/#'/% !& 3!%/ /9' %' . / 0#2 2 &)2*! $!''"$5#"".#!%/".#!22#33!'"= 23!%'"%".

".#)*"&8#39.!0#*#'/#*#/!%'/%'1!$"!'/3!9, 8!&#/'".#!22*#$%!"%'*!3!'//$)5#'"!*+#0%/#'$#&)8&"!'"%!3 @)#&"%'3!9!*%&#&*/#"#*5%'!"%'".%&)*" $$*/%'13+,".#!22#!

02/ '(-.&