Arun Trehan v. Principal Commissioner Of Income Tax Chandigarh
ITA No. 240 of 2016 1 GURBAX SINGH 2018.11.12 15:08
! "#$% &'( ()"( '"* + ,* -.
(/(0
*&
(*'"
1(' 2233 ++"
4!
( " 3+-- !! "
(" - 56*'"
1(' 2
!3"
"
/# 78/ &9 / /8 78/ &4&
:;9)-(/
+* !
"
#"$ %&' %'!( &&) %'!* +
,
+-
.#"$ %&' %'!( % #"$ %&' %'!( + +/
0 %(' #. "
- !)(! 1 2 34
%!
'5 %'!(- 5 +/#. "
-
"+
6 1 2 "+
34 #"$ )7 7%'!( %'!!0!%
ITA No. 240 of 2016 2 "
. !* ') %'!(
+
8
0 4 29
. #."
-
"+
%(5 #. "
-
.
+
.
8 8/: 4 9
. "+
,/;
<
. %(5 #."
-: 4 9
. "+
+ +
- ='# . -
> !
%''5 +/
?+0 - : 4 9
#."
-
"+
.
='# !''@ +
- : 4 9
#. "
-
"+
. / .
:3 &
/ #" $ %&' %'!( .
/ + "
0 .%5 ) %'!! . / %'!!0!%
. =)>%''70
. ='# *!>('(570 !&51!4 $ !&51%4
ITA No. 240 of 2016 3 " A
B . =)>%''70 " A
.
.
='# +/ "
.. #. "
- 1 #"4 %(5 !% !!
%'!*
. ='# <
%(5 "
/'!
!% %'!* - . +/ #"
/ "+
?
+/ A
- %(5 " #"
5!
'!
%'!& - ! +/ A
.
"
+ "+
C
%!
'5 %'!(- 5 "+
A
='# /8/ ""+
+/
1 4
+/ #"
,
+/
0 * 9 (
!"
# # $ %&!
ITA No. 240 of 2016 4 ' ( # $ ) > 8$ 14D14
. +/ #" %(5
+ - %(5 1!4 * " + ' $ ) $, # ) ) $# $ $ ( $ $ - ) ) $ $ $ ) $ $ .' /'''''''''0 = +
%(5 .
+ #" / / 8 +
.
.
+/ A
<
%(5 +-
<
"
.
. < %(5 0 4
+E 1+4
+<
ITA No. 240 of 2016 5 # . .- + .. - %(5 B 1 4 E1+4+/ +< + 9 . +0
+<
+<
0 .
%(5
+ ) "+< .
<
" +
+/ +/ A
.
A
# + A
.
.
%(5 /
+ A
<
" < .
B + <
+
!'
%(5
+.
. " - 1%'''4%&5#"
=5+ 0 F> " + + + // . .. +/ A
E /
+ .
ITA No. 240 of 2016 6
/ 8. + # . /
/
<
. 3 !!
" .
/ + -
%(5
+
+ - +/ A
.+ .
+ -
1%'!(45=&#"
%''0 2%!
" + + +/ A
+ . + +/ .. %(5 . / + .
. -
+
/ . .
/ " .+
.
3
1 4 1%''>4%)*#"
%=% !% "
- + - + , + /
.
. +/ A
!&5154 . =)>%''70 , #" -
%(5
ITA No. 240 of 2016 7 - /
. G !''@ ='# 0 25 H.
. +
/
. ='# . / %''(0'> / / +
. !''@ - /
. / %'!'0!!
='# +
G%*@ - I
. !''@ . / %'!!0!% + +
- . 7 D#
/ %'!'0!!
"..
. 7 D#
/ %''*0 '( !''@ ='# +
/-+ . ='# + !
& %''& " + +/
. . !&5154 #" ,.
-
/
- . A
* #
+
. . !&5154 5!
!
%'!&
<
I 8 /
. . .
5!
!
%'!%& !&5154 #."
-!)(!
+
+/ %(5 #."
-!)(!
3 !5 B #" / . + +
='#
/ +
- +
ITA No. 240 of 2016 8
%'!!0!% "
0 2#
%*@ !''@
/ %''(0'> "
+
+/,?+ #""
%> * %'!* /
.
!
" # $ #" $ >)=7 7%'!% , A /
='# .
/
<
" A
!''
* / / +8
/ . +
.
. 3 !& #
. !''@
='#
-/
/ . %''(0'>..
. 7 D# +
-
%'!!0!%
.+ " A
- / +
+ . . "+
1 4
.
$ +,.
, - /
"+
+/-
% & '
$14 >%'= %'!=
%'
'= %'!=
ITA No. 240 of 2016 9 " + %(5 .
.
- + !* 8$ 14 14. /
. !''@ ='# %'!!0!%
+
/ %''*0'(
. / %''(0'>
+ .
+/ - ' 1 4
!( # ++
8
. +/ / 8 /+
. <:;9)-(/
+= ) &
-.
(*% <>"
!'' "1"= ?1!7 ) 9 7 ! 9 + !
ITA No. 240 of 2016 10 #
/
0 . - %5 ') %'!! %'!!0!%
. =)>%''70
. ='# *!>('(570 / !&51!4 $
0 !&51%4 " A
.
5!
'!
%'!& . =)>%''70 "
#"!% !!
%'!* %(5
. ='# %(5 "
/ - . +/ #"
" #" +/ "+
+/A
- %(5 " "+
+/ #"
,