← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4619/2011disposed of

Municipal Corporation, Gurgaon v. Sarika And ORS

2015-02-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj8 pages



   



  !"# $%&""' ()* + $,-,

. /0"12%&"3  

   

44'-* 5        

  '-* ).6 74)  

 

          



  

 



  !   



#

$ %

& #' #&  () ******* 

 

2 +

  -   '.%

())(/ 

 

 1,  

  

 

  



3  

  

  4 







4 

   3  "

,#.5%  1  4 6 -  3  #')  #'#/  7 

4      

 1     34 



3  

   

  9 + 

  3   

4 3  

#')  #'# 1   34

,(,

()  (#        #:)$#::)  )$):#::& ;   3

   ,

()  (# 5 4< =>  +   ? 

  @  - ,

((/  

       >  3  1  

 



  (:):#::& +  1         

 

      

 1 

()  (#

 

 1 

3  

  A 

 4 1 3

   4     4   1 3

 1 1   (')(#::: + 

4 1 



    1   

 1  3 4   >  >   

 4     



 3  "

'$'&   #&#)())( 1  

 ()&  ():

4   #:.$ -



C/

 1 4   3  



 3  <   

      (')(#::: +   

  

      

 >

 >  



3   

  

    1 

6   D  1

        34

  , 

    

()  (#   

 34 14

        



4 1  



 3        (')(#::: +

,$,

 34

()  (# 1 



    (')(#::: +  1  34  E -E

8  /    + 

,

   ()&  ():

 3  

>  



3 1    

 



3  34 1 

F   1 

 

1  3 1   F 

1  3 1  3    

 #(

4  7 74,1

+ 1    

3   6 34



4   >F

    ()&

 #&#)())( 1     0  +

 

  ()&

 1  3 

 1  

       ():

     1 

 3

  

  1 1  1 34   8

 0     1





3       

1 

  4       0 4

    

  4 







4 

  



 0     34

 

        1    D       

 

      

 1   +  



 3

,G,  

  (:):#::&

 1 

 

4 34

()  (# +

 1 

 

    4 1  

 1  

    1   6

 1  

 4

    4 +  

()  (# 1   (')(#:::  4      

(.&&&( + 

  ()&

3  "

'$'&   #&#)())( 1   

()  (#



 3  

    + 3  <

1 1  

      

 1, ',* - +  89+9 +9  +6 $

+ 8-  :+ + 

+9 ,; + ,--

+,

+,

%&< $+9++ -

 +-6, +,$$-  %& 

 %" -=,  :

> $ >, +,

-, 

+> +,

$+9- +,

 -,+ + %!&%"###? ',,* @9+9 +9  +6 $

+   / -+,   $ :   , , -++9-

 +-6, +,$$-,    8,+98



+9 >,-,

- $+9+? @  

  

1     

 34

 

 



 +   1 

()  (#  

 3  

 1      (')(#::: + 

 

1  

  1

 



,%,

 4 1  



 

 +

   

  1  

4  

 

     

1     



 



  1 

  34   

 1  

 3  

      1 

 

1

 3  

 1



   1   

   ()&

 3 

>

  

>   



3 + 3

  

  

     4  1  





3 4    

 1  34

()  (#  <    #(

4  7 74,1 H   

 1

    

   #&#)())( 1  

 

>  



 3  

3

  4

 1  

     

 1 1  >

 

 

     

  D 1



 4  

 

1  

 

   3  + 

     1 

1

1  

 

 

 ()&

  3  + 

  1

 3

  



,',   D

 1 



   3 

4

   ():

 3   D 



4







 1

 

6 

1 

   4    

  + 4  1

 

 34

()  (# 1   34   1  

  1 1 

 34  + 3

 1  

  

    1

      (:):#::& 1 

  

 1 

 1

3   

 1   



 4 3

   

 4

  +  1

  3   

    1 4 



  34  4    +

1  

 4

 

 4  

    34    



  

 +  1 



  



  

  #&#)())( 1 

  3  

3  

 +

1  1     

 4 

    



 

  3

   34  =    

 4     

    

,.,





 

1 

 4  

  @  

  

1  

 

 3     

 



1

   3  34

 ;  ()&

 

  

 

 

 

 

6

 



   

  3

   ():

 D    

4



 

     <4 

 

4  3 





  

 

 

 4    

1  





  1  1

  3  

()  (# 



  3 

,

((    

  

  

 1 

#

#:   4 1  

 34      

 ? 4   



#

#: 4     







 

  ,

()  (# + > 1 

 34

()  (# 

4   3 



 

6 

 +   

 

 

()  (#  4   

  <    #(

4

,&,  7 74,1 #:&(

 4 B"

A30

C



  

#

#:



4   34  ?

 3

   D 

 

1   1

 34  

 

 >

      

 

 +   

 

()  (#  

 1  1    E -E

8  /      4  

  4



3  1



  <

4

 3

  3  <

1 

       



< 4      + 0     34

   

 E -E

8  /    

 !  1

 

   3      3

 

  

 1

  #&#)())( 1       1C



()  (#

4   

  

 1  1 '

 

*

/0"12%&"3