State Of Haryana & ORS v. Subhash Chand
!
"# $
% & ' )) * %#( (( ) ! "#
+
,"
* % & ' ) $ ## $
% & ' )) * ( ) ) - %& $
% & ' )) * % ) # & $
% & ' )) *
%( . ) / #%' $
% & ' )) * ," ) " $
% & ' )) * 0 1 % ( ) '
$
% & ' )) * ,( 2 % ( )
' $
% & ' )) *
" ) '% $
% & ' )) * % ," )
% '" $
% & ' )) * ," ) '$ $
% & ' )) * * 4 ) $ '& $
% & ' )) *
," ) - "
$
% & ' )) * 0 #'4 ' ) "
$
% & ' )) * ) / "
& $
# % & ' )) * %( . ) ""
$
% & ' )) * + " %( " ) "' $
% & ' )) * #( ( )
''% $
% & ' )) * 5 ( ) ( ) *+* , ) ***
+6 .
(%( 4 & ' + 4 ' ( )
**, 8(5 "
( ) 6
))
6
6
-- 6
$ 6
- 6
-$ 6
/ 6
6
6
$ 6
/ 6
6
6
/ 6
/ 6
/ 6
// 6
/ 6
$
/- ( ! 6
)) (
#' ( % & ' ( !
""
5 "
-/ (
6% 9
:%#( (( %
& ' : !
!
/- ( #
#'+
," ;) !( ! !
! ( #
$ (
( 1 ) 1(!( ( ) 6 1 ! ( )) ( 1( #' ( '( ! !
! ( ) < ) ( #
* !
""
5 "
( 6% 9
(
1 ) ( ( ( ) 1 # ( )
!( " ( = ! / (
% & ' 1(!( ) ( 0>?+> ))! 1 ( (
) !# ) (
( "
1 ( (
"
") '"
@!(
# ! "
#
)) "
( ! ))! 1 # !
1 (
) "
'1
' )) ( # 0>?+> '1 # @
()) - ! ' !
! .
"6
* "
? /B @ < C 8 !( % ! 0 B ( D ( 0 EC ))! ) ( )
4 8 !( B 48C&>%<==B4 )<0C % !
#5 ! 8( 1 ) 48B&C
'$ 1 ))' 8( ))! # ) (9 / # '!
""
) 1
! !
"#"$%"
&"# " # ' ($ #" )"
" )" )) )"
" )"
)) #"*"'"$%"#"* **"+$" # $ + ," -"
"."-*#)) ""/"0
&" "-" ""/"0
" ($ # 1 '""
2 !" 0304 "
+" .
'"*" $ 5)"
"$**" "" .
""/"06
$ ))
@ # ,"-""."-*"# "#))))8"-"
' $**" "" .
"# "#-"
#"$" "($""'"#"9,8$""9" # " $ # " "" " ," -"
-*" ** **"# * $ "#*"# '""-" /$"."-* " ""$"($" '""-" 7 8(
( ) ! %) ! = ! 1 )) @< <$ (
< & " **# *-$"$" "#$#
""" "# ** :# '"# -" "#" #" " " ".
- "'" **-"+#$ " #$# #""#$ " #- #$" # " " " $"" "" 7 ) #" ( ))! # ! < < &
/ #" ))! 1 -$'
/"
( - ' ( !
" (
))! "( "
( ( 1
1 ( ( ") '"
@!(
-'
( ( "
@
") '
8( ( ))! "1
< ;" /$-" 6 3366 2!**"# 2<) & / 6 !** =/ -" $ & 2,), "=/ -" )"$;
-
"=/ -" '9"' "# >?> !" ?
46"
?-4
$ <""
"
$
" / :/9:!/ & " <"" $& " 9 " & " /, !"$ <$" )"
" /, @**"!"" .
"($" 6"
?-4 &"# "# ' ($ #" )"
" )" )) )"
" )" )) #"*"'" A $%"#"* **"+ $" # $ + ... ... ... B"""""-*-" A7 . ""#" "
"#4 "
-"".
"""$"-*"C ) 1 ! 1?! ' !"
" ! / & )) # !
!
""
$ 8( ""
( !"
8(
1 ! #' ( 0 1 # - 8(
) 1 ( 1 F ? & )) "
1 (" & ( 1! !
- B @ <C! ) (" ( 1! 1('(! ( ! !
( (# <
8( ( 1!
!
( ) ( "
(
! ! "
48 -'
8( )) "
#'& ' %
%!(
B4 )<0C% !
B ( D EC
& ) ( (
) !# )) "
( ( ) ( (
'
"
( ''
( #" ))! "G ( ( ) @ ' ) ! !( 1 . 4 "
?
"
!(
@ !
#' ( "
!( #5 ! " @"" '
8( # ( (
) # / ( 1 "
( -'
( ))! 1 ( !
# #
8( ) #" )' ( 1! !
( ( ( #
1 ( ( >") '"
>@!(
/
&
("
-/1(!(
1 ) + !( &
) !
!
( = ! ( 4 "
/ ! " @
) ( )'
!
)) "
( ) 1 .
&
/ -
.
! ( ( )) "
8( ) 1 ) -1 ( ! !
")
( ' ) ) .
( ! ( ) ( ) B&C8( --1 ) ! (! "
( ( ( 1 # <
! ! "
( ) @ 1 ( ! / 1 ( ( ! ( #
!
) ( ( !
!
)
"
( @ ' ( ) ( 1 ( )
'! !
' )
6 % 9
( 1 ) #!( !
1 ) ( ( ( !
" !
( (
! / !
@ (
) 1 " (
8( )) 1 ! ( ) !
)) "
( " 8( ' 1 ( (
F # '8( % & ' ( (
( 5 "
( 6% 9
)
( 1 # ' ) !
!
( ! ! "
48 !(
#' ( & ' % >! %!(
B4 )0C% !
(
) !# (
# ' D /*" " **""*""'"
" "$-" " """"
-" #"
# "$ " #.""<'"-"+#--"-"" "# $-# ** ""$ " 2'" "
"*'
"- " <'"-" "+"" <'"-"+ "'" "" .
$**" "-""."# "'"""""- "
"$%" - .-$-# #'""
"'"+" " .
" "-"
-"
$"7 ( @ )
B"""<'"-"#"* "" ".*""+- +"+#"
""" +" . #"*'#""$""*" "*" 7 ( ) ! <
)" "$ :*"
& " <$* "'";$"+>>3 " "
$ E"$"& " <$*& "'";$"+ >>3# " " ** ""*$" ""'" """"*"
" 2'" "- " "$""
$""*"
" """-" '"""- " " $""**'#""$" 7 $ ( ) " ( % !
1
#' ( & ' % >! 6 ! %!(
B4 )<C
B ( D
EC 1 ( )
< DD /*" " **" *""'"
""$-"" F"
-" 6D"
# ""#" #"-*"""
"#$-# ** "&-- 7 !
( ) @ <
B"" " <'"-" # " * "" ".*""+- +"+#"
"""+" . #"*'#""
$""*" "*" 7 ( H ) % :! < D
!$" ** """'" "*
#""$"+"#"--" ""#"
"--""-"#""$""""*" "G7 -
5 #>! % !
< ===%!(
B ( D EC1 !
- ( ) !# H '
F ! :
! -B#CBC 1 ( (
<
""-" D"
# "G 2'" "9"+- #*" "
"""+ ** *"'" D"
# "
2'"#$" "- .-$- "-#"
-"-" # " "$" & ")" & " "6 "
7 - ( ) @ ;" .
#$"+" 0B"""<'"-" #" "*" # #""$" $" $$"
* * $ "+- "+*"" " .""($"-"# $"$"." $%" $ - """ #"
" " %$ "($ "- " 2'" "" $$" ** "" "# *"+ " " ""
- ""# '$ "
- *'" $" 7 = ! ?
/ ) !
# 1 &*""/ 6 43 0$ :::
" D ? >3" 9"+ $ + + & #- # &--" 8 "" + <' # + 9"* -"#$ $ 0." "# )"
"#"<'
% "'"
)"<'"-" """$" "" # ) " ** " "*""
*"";$" -"""""-*-" ,##" '" ""#"""$ "-*-" """ ** $""" "$* " -" " " "$ **" " # 5*$*"+" .
""'" *"""($"-" A$ """"($"" *" """##"$- "'""
*#" -"- """<' 7 &*"" 6 43 0$ 00:: "
>3 " 9"+ $ + #- 5 &--"8"" +<' # 9"* -"# $ $ ." "#&8HE"$"#"<' "'"
)"#"""$"" 34 F0 40FF"'"
" >3"$%"" '" )"'"-" "" " $" "" # '" $ E"$") " ** " " *"" *" " ;$" -"
""" " -*-" ,##" '" " "#" " "$ "-*-" " ""
** $""" "$*"-""
""$ **" &8HE"$" 5 *$*"" .
""'" *"""($"-" A$
" "" "($"" *" " "" ##"$- "'"" *#" -"- """<' 7
# / F !
( )) 1( ! / !
@
"
( !
@ ( ) " ( )
!
( " '# '
!
) #' ( ) !' (
)) ( ) ( % I / ( 1 1 ) < @"">>3;$"#" >>3+;$"D - " *"$"-" 6D"
#
""#" #"-*""" "
#$-#" ** "&-- )""
;$""- "#""""*"
"!*+
""#;$" B"""2* "" + $ 9"* -" #" $ "*0$-0 ## ' ""$"*"">>3;$"""#"+" ""# "" .
*"<'"-"$ "
? >3 !".$"2D
>3 !".$"2?
" " " -" "" """ "
-*-". "+ " # "" ;$"D#>>3;$" $"C E
>
? 7
(
) #' 1 ' %( , ( % ! ' 4 "
& ' %!(
>! ) "
1 =) )($ 1 ( )
! ( ""
( & ' #! % !
"" %" 0 ( ?
%(0("% 1 )) 6 ! % .
& # (1 /$%( 1 -$'
1( ) 1 / ( "
1
1 ( >") '"
>@!(
, B ( .C
/ ( 1 ))
@ ) = ! / = ) )( - ( 1 ( (
) "
= ! / 1 1( ( 5 #>! % !
<===%!(
!
1(!(" @""
'
"
!
1 '
8
( " @""
" $'
%
# @ ))
" 1 !
. ") '"
) "
"
( )
) "
= ! / I/- ( 1 1 ) < :"#""""" " >
?+ 2I + ! &"# "" + <'"-" # + $ 9"* -" #" ## ' "
?
F".* +" + "" -*""# ""*#- .-$- "- #""
;$" '"
-"#"+#$""";$"" "-#" <'"-""'" 4 "
"" #$" " " 4 "
'" # "
?
4 :- "$" "" "-"# "-# " <'"-" "'"+ " :$ "
? >3
>3 '""-""$ $"
# #"- " ":$ '"""
" " #$"+"":$ " ";$"+ " "$**"-" + """ #-""#":$""*'" "" .
"-$""":$ "
"'" '""- .-$- "-*"" $"""'";$" :'"#"- "+"" "<'"-" "
$" """$ " ? >3
>3 " C"+" " -#""*" '" "
""""" """#"-"" .
" $
##"" "* - " !#" # :$+" "<'"-" "- " " "-$#$$"""" *"";$" E >
F E" * # " " " '"
E" +! ! < ##- "" -* " 7 5 % '>!
& ' !(. /1 1(!( ( #
( 4 "
= ! / (
1 ( 1 -/# !
' )
@ ) ( < D<'"-"#
$ 9"* -" ,"/ 6440
D2<)0:
9 " 4 ?
F )$"$/ 6 43 0$0:::
"
? >3 6 43 0$00::
"
>3
' "-"""'
#" # - #"$-" $"
*'#$##" #"$**" "- "
" .
#""
""'*'
"+"+ #"#- "+""$ """#- #$##$- $
2 I 9
! &"#"" <' +$ 9"* -" & 7 = (# !.
( ( F
" ) "
= ! ?
/ 1 1( ( 5 # >! % !
<=== %!(
1 !
8( " @""
) !# #'
1 '
8( !
( ) !
# )) ) '
8( " @""
%!( ?8# 0 !.1 1 $'
-
") ( 4 "
@ ( F "
' ! ! ( () ) ! ! I
( & ' %
>! 6 ! %!(
B4 )<C
1 # (
!
8(
' !
#' ! ! "
1 ) ! ( '
"
( $'
# ' ( "
() #" ))!
"" (
) 4 "
@ ' ( ( ) ( 1 ( ) ! '! !
' ) ( 1(!( ( ) % ! ) ( ' ))! #
!
!
) ' ( 1(!( !
$ ""
'# !
""
!
"
( 1 ) $ = ( !
! ( )) <% & ' ( @ ))
" 1 !
. ") '"
) "
"
( )
) "
= ! / = 1 ) ( % @ " ( ! 1 # ! 1( ( (
1
@ !
( ' !
#
( ( (
!
) @ ' ( @
#' (
? ! 1 ) "# ) ( )
(
= ' ( (
!
( ( ! 1 #
) "# " ( - ! ( )) <% ( ( ! (
#
!
) ( ( !
!
) 4 "
( @ ' ( ) ( 1 ( ) ! '! !
' ) #
1 ( (!
( 1 "
BC 8( ! / 1 " '
1 ( 1 ' -/8( ( "
1( ( ) #" ( ))! 1 ( ! 1
@ !
BC8( ! ( % ( ( ! ( ( 1( (
1 @ !
!
) 1( (
& 1 ))! # ( !
) ( 1 ) "
( '1 !
) ( & !
!' ( ( % 8(
! 1 1( ( 1 ) 0'
(
( 1 ) %" '
#' ( (
1 ) = ) ( ) ( #' (
(
! !
@ ( ! 1 (
#
@ " (
( ( 1('
! 1 !
) ( ) (
#' ( 8( ) ( !
1 (
"
@) ! ( ( "
! 1
1 ( 1 ( " (
1 # # BC8( "
(
( (
)
@
( 1 ) !!) @
) !# 8 !
' (
) !# ( ( ! ( (
'
"
( ''
0 (
) !# D !(
@ #' ( 4 "
" "
"
E8( 1 (
) !! ') !# #'
4 "
" '@ '
" "
"
8( # 4 "
@
1 8( ! ( #
" '
1 ( 1 !
1 #
#' ( !
) !! @
) ! (
1 ( (
") '"
@!(
@ F "
!( ! " BC8( ))! A " ( ( ! 1 !
) !! !
"
( HG))
@ F :
:(
>") '"
>@!(
''
"
@
") '
:= " ! 1 ( 1
)) !
) !(!
" ( ))! A " 8( 1
' " ' ( 5 "
(
6% 9
( ( ( )
@ " ( = ! !!
'
))
" 8( 1 ) B </-<C / ) 1 ( (5 "
1
" )) )
1( ' # #! )) "
@ "
'(
"
#'3
#'# ) 8( .( ))' ( 1 ! ! ( ! !
# ' !
")
1 ( ( ! ( "!
"( 8( "# !
") '
)
"
! "# ! ( #!( ! #
'8( '( '! (
''
8( ) # #' ( !( !
"
") '"
8(
)#! )) "
1(!( ( ' ( " '
( '
! "
! 1 ( ( ! '
) ))! A "!
!
"
1 ( ") '"
@!(
( " ( ( '1 #
1 ( ( ") '"
@!(
! ( 1#
1 ( 1 -/ 8( () # #' ( # !( ! ( 1
. (
# ( ! +* ** -./0.1%, &
( %) . ? 3 ( ) #
?