← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2969/2017disposed of

Sham Kaur v. Sarbjit Singh Etc

2018-10-16Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

      



!" #"$%&%'( 

) *+ ,- ./ 00"11 '! 2"/&.& * /34%!*%'5+ '#!+"/& "&0'#"'!&  

 

/"&"'!( /&6! + 6./7#8$ !" /!+" 00"11 '! /2%0.1*+ /, 7#8$ !" //"&0'#"'!9'&./ '$" ,0 ':



 +%& 00" 1+ &3""' %1"#3:!+"$1 %, '!&""6%'5"'+ '$","'! !+"$,0"'& !%' ; /#"#!+"/3:!+"1" /'"#!/$$%#"'!1 %,& /%3.' 17 + 1% </%3.' 1= / &+/! 8%#" ; /# # !"#



 ' $$.'!   #" !+  + 1"'#/  *%'5+ %'  ,!/ 8"+%$1" $$%#"'! '  

>"!%!%'.'#"/*"$!%'

!+"!/2"+%$1"&$! /&+/! <!+"$!=; & %1"#3:!+" 00"11 '! 1'5;%!+!+" ./# .5+!"/&, //%"# !+"0/"&"'! 00"11 '! '#!+"#"$" &"#/"&"'! 00" 1+ &+;"8"/3""' 0/"

"//"#3:!+"$1 %, '!;%#;'1: +" $1 %, '!& 3"

/" !+" 1" /'"# /%3.' 1 %" !+" ;% " '# , //%"## .5+!"/& !+"#"$" &"#7 %1"# 0"!%!%'.'#"/*"$!%'

!+" !/2"+%$1"&$!&""6%'5$,0"'& !%'' $$.'! #" !+ + 1"'#/  *%'5+#."!%'4./%"&/"$"%8"#3:+%,%' ,!/8"+%$1" $$%#"'!;+%$+!6 01 $" '  

>    # !"# 

? ; & /"5%&!"/"# .'#"/ *"$!%'&  '#@@ 5 %'&!/"&0'#"'! !; &01" #"#!+ !!+" #"$" &"# !!+"!%," +%&#" !+; &5"!!%'5,'!+1:0"'&%' &@ 7?>9A

 3"%'5 /"!%/"" /,./.3%'#*%'5+*.0"/+"/, 11 '!70 /"; &

):" /&1# !!+"!%,"  $$%#"'!,0"'& !%'; &7!+.&70/ :"# / +"1" /'"#/%3.' 1'$'&%#"/ !%' !+" $!& '#"8%#"'$" '/"$/#+"1#!+ !!+" $$%#"'!%'B."&!%'!601 $"#."!!+"/ &+ '# '"51%5"'! #/%8%'5   !+" 

"'#%'5 8"+%$1" 3: %!& #/%8"/ +"/" %& ' #%&0.!" /"5 /#%'5!+" 38"& %# %'#%'5 !+"1" /'"#/%3.' 1'!+%&%&&."7;+%$+ + & !! %'"# %' 1%!: C" /'"# /%3.' 1 +"1# !+" #"$" &"# ! 3" ) :" /& 1# ! !+" !%,"   +%& #" !+ '# &&"&&"# +%& %'$," & &@ 7?>9A 0"/ ,'!+

"#.$!%'   ?

D ; & "

"$!"# !; /#& !+" 0"/&' 1 "E0"'&"&  !"/ 001:%'5 ,.1!%01%"/ ?7!! 1#"0"'#"'$:; & &&"&&"# !& 7>7 9A '!+"/&., &?

9A; & ; /#"#!; /#& .'"/ 1"E0"'&"&3"&%#"& &

9A !; /#& 1&&   $'&/!%.,  &.,   &)7

9A ; & ; /#"#!; /#&"E0"'&"&%'$.//"#'!+"!/" !,"'! !+"#"$" &"#+.&7 $1 %, '!&;"/"+"1#"'!%!1"# /!! 1$,0"'& !%' & )7@7 9A 1'5 ;%!+ %'!"/"&! F D 0"/ ''., /, !+" # !"  %1%'5   $1 %, 0"!%!%' !%11 /" 1%& !%' C" /'"# $.'&"1 / !+" 00"11 '!&7 ;+%1" /"1:%'5 .0' !+" 4.#5,"'!   '=31" *.0/"," ./! %' *,! * /1  2"/,  '# !+"/& 2&

"1+%/ '&0/!/0/ !%' '# '!+"/7 



&.3,%!&!+ ! #"#.$!%' ?

D&+.1#'!+ 8"3""'"

"$!"#3:!+"1" /'"#/%3.' 1 & !+"#"$" &"#; &'! 3 $+"1/+";%#;; &!! 11:#"0"'#"'!.0'!+" #"$" &"# !+.5+ # .5+!"/&   !+" #"$" &"# ;"/" , //%"# +"/"

/"7 #"#.$!%'  9@/# &+.1# 3" "

"$!"#  ! %& ./!+"/ &.3,%!!"# !+ ! !+" $1 %, '!& &.$$"&& .11: 0/8"# ' /"$/# !+" ,"#%$ 1 3%11& ,.'!%'5 ! & 77 )9A ;"8"/7  &.,   '1: &)7

9A ; & ; /#"# 3: !+" 1" /'"#/%3.' 1!%&&.3,%!!"#!+ ! &., &>

9A' $$.'! 1&&

@  $'&/!%., %'&!" #   &

9A , : 3"

/#"# ! 00"11 '!  C" /'"#$.'&"1 ./!+"/&.3,%!&!+ !$,0"'& !%' ; /#"#!!+"$1 %, '!& 3" /";/6"# %' !"/,&   !+" 4.#5,"'!   !+" '=31" *.0/"," ./! %'  5, "'"/ 1'&./ '$",0 ':C!#2& '. , 1% &+.+/. , '#!+"/&7%'%8%100" 1 ?)

)#"$%#"#' )

) C" /'"#$.'&"1 /!+"'&./ '$",0 ':7+;"8"/7&.3,%!& !+ !!+"/"%&'&$0" / ./!+"/"'+ '$","'! !+"$,0"'& !%' ; /#"# ;"8"/7 +" %& .' 31" ! #"': !+ ! !+ ! !+" $1 %, '!& + # &.$$"&& .11: 0/8"# 3%11& ,.'!%'5 ! & 77 )9A ' $$.'!   ,"#%$ 1 "E0"'&"& %'$.//"#C" /'"#$.'&"1/"1%"&.0'!+"4.#5,"'! !+"'=31"*.0/"," ./!%'";'#% '&./ '$",0 ':C!#2&2%'%&+ %' '#!+"/&7

)  C? !&.3,%!!+ ! &!+"#"$" &"#; & ):" /&1# '#%!%&'1: 00"11 '! ;+; &#"0"'#"'!.0'+%,7#"#.$!%' ?

D&+.1#3" , %'! %'"#  + 8" +" /# 1" /'"# $.'&"1 / !+" 0 /!%"& '# + 8" 5'" !+/.5+!+"/"$/#;%!+!+"%/ 31" &&%&! '$"

"#.$!%'   ?

D "

"$!"# 3: !+" 1" /'"# /%3.' 1 %& %'#""#7 .'4.&!% %"#+"/"%&',"/%!%'!+"$'!"'!%'/ %&"#3:1" /'"#$.'&"1 / !+" '&./ '$" ,0 ': & #,%!!"#1: %' !+" 4.#5,"'!   !+" '=31" *.0/","./!%'!+"$ &" 2%'%&+ %' '#!+"/&&.0/ 7!+"$1 %, '!& ;"/"!;, 4/&'& '#!;5/ '## .5+!"/&7!+.&%!; &#%/"$!"#!+ !? D #"#.$!%'&+.1#3""

"$!"# "#.$!%' 9@/#; &$'&%#"/"#!3"'!+" 1;"/ &%#"  ' !+" 0/"&"'! $ &"7 00"11 '! %& #,%!!"#1: !+" ;%#;   !+" #"$" &"#+":+ 8" ./# .5+!"/&;+ /", //%"#!$ ''!3"%5'/"# !+ ! %' ./ &$% 1 &"!A.0 '# !+" &$%"! 1 '/,&7 !+" #"$" &"# ,.&! '"$"&& /%1:3"&0"'#%'5&," ,.'!'!+",+"/" /"7%!%&$'&%#"/"# 4.&! '# 00/0/% !" ! "

"$!  #"#.$!%'  9@/# %' !+" 0"$.1% / $!& '#

> $%/$.,&! '$"& !+"$ &".1!%01%"/ ?+ &/%5+!1:3""' 001%"#C" /'"# $.'&"1 / !+" '&./ '$" ,0 ': %& .' 31" ! #"': !+ !  &.,  & 77 )9A + & 3""' 0/8"# ' /"$/# +"/"

/"7 !+" & %# ,.'!  & 77 )9A' $$.'! ,"#%$ 1"E0"'&"&%'$.//"#7+ &!3"

/#"# %'&!" #   &)7

9A ' 8%";   !+" 4.#5,"'!    !+" '=31" *.0/"," ./!%'!+"$ &"    5, "'"/ 1'&./ '$",0 ':C!#&.0/ 7!+" 00"11 '!A$1 %, '! %&"'!%!1"#!&>

9A!; /#&&0.& 1$'&/!%., %'&!" # &

9A+" 00"11 '!%&"'!%!1"#!& ?7

9A" $+ /1&&  "&! !" '# .'"/ 1 "E0"'&"& %'&!" #   &?7

9A 1/" #:

/#"# !; /#& .'"/ 1"E0"'&"& 1 %, '!%&7!+.&7"'!%!1"#!$,0"'& !%'7 ;+%$+ %&/"A;/6"# &.'#"/(A  

  

'$," @ 7?>9A0, %"7 @7)7)))9A 0"/ ''.,  '$," !"/#"#.$!%' 9@/#' $$.'! 0"/&' 1"E0"'&"& @7)7)))G 7 7 @7)7)))9@ H7?7? 9A @ ! 1#"0"'#"'$: !"/ 001:%'5 ,.1!%01%"/ ? 7?7? ? 7 7

9A > C&& "&! !"

?7

9A ? C&& .'"/ 1

?7

9A

C&& $'&/!%., >

9A  "#%$ 1"E0"'&"& 77 )9A   7

7)) +" ,.'! $,0"'& !%' 1/" #: ; /#"#!!+"$1 %, '!&7 '""#1"&&!& :7&+ 11&! '##"#.$!"# /,!+" ,.'!$ 1$.1 !"# & 38" $1 %, '!&&+ 113""'!%!1"#!%'!"/"&! !!+"/ !" ?D0"/ ''.,'!+" "'+ '$"# ,.'! /,!+"# !" %1%'5 !+"0"!%!%'!%11/" 1%I !%'

? J%!+!+" 38"& %#,#% %$ !%'%'!+" ; /## !"#



7 0/"&"'! 00" 1%&#%&0&"# 



   $!3"/ 7

) &+; / J+"!+"/&0" 6%'59/" &'"#(A"&9 J+"!+"//"0/! 31"(A"&9