High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2983/2017allowed

Parmali And ANR. v. Gopi Chand And ORS.

2019-05-16Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta5 pages

"

!#!

!

!"#$% &'()*%(' *% +',) $!

$

%&'

(

! $" ) %&'

( !*+ $ # %&'

( , (-./.+-01&.2 $ '' !-#%./

(

( ! 0

-#01 & 2

+,**+3*4 2 ' ( 5%46%33378(

($#9 .#/

( !:

;1 &

' '' 2

- < <!

84*85*5* /

( !0

(( <&

' 01 + !

= (

! !( '

!2 -=-#%

('

'!

- < !9 (

!9 (- & = ,

' 2 -=

-# 2! ' #

! (2!>8

/1

$#9 .#

/1 <

+?= ! /1

('' ,3*3+3*? /&1 $ !

#!

/&1 '

@333

/&1 ?3A(/&1-& 2!!!( (# # !

@333B+3331C 4333

/&1 D ( /&1 -& #'

2!

! !

43338,3331C ,333

/&1 ''#

(

=<

# (*6 /,333F*+F*61C 4@6333 /E1 2!!!(& (( *33333 /E1

2! (#

!

! +3333

@ '#!

( !<#

2! <'# #!

2!!<=(<-#! !!%

-= < *3%33378

! - <

'# #'

= '# = & '

2

< '

-#

-# ! 9

! !@33378

( < ('

+**3+3*? !!# -= & ( =%

! <#

#2<

% & (

!'! !#!9 -# %'#- 9 !543378

!(#

<#

'

# - ! 2

-= E # '!

(

!"#$ $!

#

% ? '#!

( , ! <#

2!!

- +6= !(< << ('

! ((

-# !!!

< !+?= !!

= !

% 2 '

! #

' = 9< <

!+6= !%

#

'

!'!

!*5' @3A '

2!!!((# # !

!,3%33378#

'&

!

H# (

'

!!!

-=

-#%

!<#

! 2! 9 ! @33378

-!

'

( = & '

#'

-='

2!2<=<'# # '

( #< = (< -#! !!

<< ('

+**3+3*?!!# -=& (=%

!<#

# 2< !2 (E 2 (3***+3*?2

!'!

'' 9 '

,3*3+3*? !# <

8$#9 .#%!!#'

#2< !! !'- -=)

(= '-

! '!

4

!

=% 9

H# (<

!!

-= '#!

( ,

-# ! 9

<! -!

&

' ! < <

! +6 = !& 2(!

'(' <(' ! <<<

-#'# !!

!!

-!!( = & '#( !

!'-< !+?= !(

'!

-# ! < 2< 2 !!

!!< <

- !! !'!

<

!

( !

%'

'!< -= 2

# '=<# =

9< = & '

%!!#'

%< ! !

'# - <& = & ! < ! !'- -= ! ! 9 <

!+6= !!

(+? = !!!!

-=

-# 5 '#!

(

! ('

+**3+3*?!!# -=& (=2

-==2< !'

# =

! #!9 %!

!9 %!9

'

< (-# !2 !!

2 (3***+3*?

'' 9 '

,3*3+3*? !# <

( 8$#9 .# .

< & 2 E =(

3***+3*?2

('' ,3*3+3*?% (

#2< ! !'- (#!9 -# ! ' - -!! 2 !!

!!< '

! ! !!

!543378

! ! @3A '

2!!!((# # !

!' (,3%33378#

'&

! 6 & 2(-& %' 2 '

' !8 %! !!

!(2!>8

/1

$#9 .# /1 <

+6= ! /1 '

5433

/&1 @3A ( /1 -& 2! (# # !

5433B,3@31C *34@3

/&1 D ( /&1 -& #'

2!

! !

*34@38?,+31C ?,+3

/&1 ''#

(

=<

# (*5 /?,+3F*+F*51C *36?+63 /&1 2!!!(

*?333 /&1 2!(# !

*?333

.-//

I !!

H# (=!'#!!-&

! !

! ! ''

2 (

-# ! (

2 ' ! (

( -34 5-6. !

'

( 1

78 1

78

'

# 2'=

J5?A #(

((< (

'

# K

,- <!# (

(( <&

' 2 !

!

(' !8 !

-9 ''# =

!

#< (

'

#

!

- !

-=' !! 2 **

& !

(=(

' /!1- ( (

! ! (

! % ' ( !7

!

!

- !#&&<' 9 1 (' *% +',) L9 &'+%