Jit Kaur & ORS v. Naranjan Singh


  
 


!"# #$%&%'() *


          


( + ,
 ,



  

  





    

-.
!""!'%'/01 

  

  

   



 

!  

 "

  

# 

 



$%%&'%%% 

  "

  (    

  

"

"



  

#

 

) 

  %&%*'%%%  







 



 ) 
 + ,  -  .

  %/%''%%0

  

    # 



 

#



 ,
   

 # 



&1%$'%&' 



     '

  

 

 

 

      !

#

 # 

) 

" 

 "

 #   '0  !         , "   

    .

  ,    



 







 



' 2/ %%%3 

 

  $%%&'%%% 4

    " 5

1 $/ %%%3 #

 ' %% %%%3"



   0 $/ %%%3"



&&%7%1 $&%&'%%%  " 

8  ( ! , "  

 

 "  "   

      



'98  

#    



:





"

:

&/%/'%%% "

   

  

#

 :

 



 " 



#

:





;" 







 

 :





  

 

 :

 

 

#

 #  "

6  #    

  "

   

  #   

&' 2% %%%3 )

 

  



     



 

#

"



  $ 

:

:



 &/%/'%%% 

#  



 # "

   

 : 

 " 

##   

  

  

 

  



 "



    &1%/'%%%

  6  #  



:

  %1%1'%%%



#

#  



 "

   

 :  

  

) 

   

  

 





     

   

%7%1'%%%  6  # :





'1%1'%%% 

  

  "

   

 

"  





 

 

"  #

" 

# 



  

"  %&%*'%%% ;   

# 





  "

  

# 

       

   

 

   



 

* '/ %%%3  

  

   "

 

#

 & 7% %%%3 

  

 #    



#   ; 

  





* '/ %%%3

 # #

 

#



 

 

& 7% %%%3 

  

 # 



 0 <   



 "

 !    #    #   

 

   



#   

   ;"

 "    

 "

"




 9 =#  

  # 







"

  

 > 

 "

 "    "

 # #  

    

 

? #  

#  "

  

 

" 

 +






  9 =# - 





 > 

 "

 "  !

   "   

"  

  

"



 !   



  

   



 # =

 "   

 #  !

 &7& 

"  

&$%*&77*  #  !

 &7/%

@

 

 &*%1&77* &/%1&777 "



:



8 #   &%%7&777 6 !

  &7//  9    "  

  

   

) 

   



  

"

   


 . "   " 



 

 

   

" 6

#  " #







#  /

    

 "

     

# 

 

 

"   

 "  "

#



  ) 
 4&- B

 

 

 $%%&'%%%   

 

  

   

1 $/ %%%3 #

C?88 '



" 

#



 6 C?88 $

 #  

#C ?8, 0

 

 

 C?8, /



#

 

  C?8, 1

 

   (      "      

:



  6 C?8, 2  

5 1

:#

" 

# 

"

   

 6

 :



# 



 D







 

       +

 -

&77172

:#

    #



  



#  "





#   

" 

!

#  

  

'&%&'%%%



#

 





#   !    #   

&7/2/*=

"

# 

  !  "

  

# 

 2

   

   )  
    

 

     

#    

 #   







 

      

   * 

# 

  

:

    E:8&     )     "

  :#



   ##  "



"   

#  

"

  #    

$%%&'%%%

) 

##    

 "

"





+

 #

.

-   

  

  !#   !

  

 #  

0 $/ %%%3 "

" "

E:,'

  "

) 
 #

0 $/ %%%3

" 

 (  

  ##   

(       

 

7

#

 

   ) 

*



!

 

"   "

 "

  /

#      ' #  





## 

 ? 

#

  "

+

 .

- " #       # "

"

 



!

"  =

 "

) 


# 

## 



 

  !  

 

 

 "

  





 

!

   

  , "   ; "  

 

      

 D 

  "

  #!

       #!

F

"

## 

 

  !   !

 

  &%

: 

  



" 

  #    

 4      

  # 5 

:

  #

"

:#



 ) 
 ;"

 #

 

# 

   "   

 

# 

      



#"





   

) 

  

    !

@!,G "

  )  



"

 "

  #  "



   



) 9  


  '2%$'%%$ " 

  #

"   > 

 "

 D "  #

  





 

:



  

   &*%1&77*    &/%1&777 &$%*&77* &%%7&777 

#

  

)  

##  :#

"

  #  

    ) 

    &&0

;

 E

 "

 

 " 

  #     && 9  



 ) 


 





      

 ,B' 

 #

 !

#   "   

:  "

 

  "

  ##  "

"

      



:



##  "

 +

 - 



"



"   !

#  


 "

    @ '%%& 

## 

 +



##   

!

 @ '%%&

# " 

   

(    

"  





   #   "

 

 

#

'&%/'%%$-  

 E:8&   

  '%%%  



" "  # 

;" 

 

"

  .

 

4

 

     5 

# !

"



 

 "

##  

 

) 







""

   



# 

"

   

"

 

'%%1+

'%%1 





"

 #    

"

!



"

    @ '%%& 



"

'%%0 '%%1- =

   :# 



   # #

H9  


  

# 



  

     :#  4

 5 )  "

  

  # !

   &' =

 "

"  

"  

 ,B$ 8 #   " 

 , "  "

 !

  

#

"  

    

 !

 "

  "



D

! #"

" "

 ;  :#  "   #

"  

#

D 

   



"

"   " 

 

D 9

 

  



  '/%&&777



" " 



 ) 
 " "    



   



 =

 "

D +.

-    

## 

 !  



 

# 



 #

!

  .

 

 "  

 .

 ;   "

" 



#

 D

 $%%&'%%%9

 "

   



) 



 



!   



  

## 

 !  &$ # "

,B0H

  +

 - "



D 9

    &77*

  /% %%%3 #

 "  

& %% %%%3 #,B$ 8 #   ;"

" 

#

"    

D

 ##

' '% %%%3   I0J



 #  9

  " 

 !

   "   ;"

 D 

#

 "   

   

8  %'%*'%%%  =;" 

&1%*'%%% 

 



# "

 

   
  

  %&%*'%%% 



 ) 
  " 



 %'%&'%%%"4



5 .    "  "

)  

 :#   

 

"#





 





  (    "

 




  # 

D 9

  I.

 

! # 

      !  &0   

"  :#



   ,B/(

 

) 


" "4

 : 5 





    

 

#  #  

"

8  "

 

 

# 

 

!



  " "

!  ,   8

E   H

 # 

, "  









"

$%%&'%%%

( , "  



"

 

,B$8 #    

 8 #  

 

# "

=

 "

  )   !       

# 



  9

  I.

! 

 

 !  



#

 &/    

 

 

   )  


 "

  :#

 

# 



 ;"

#

# +

" :

 -  #



  +

 -" 

  

 

#

    

    



,B& H !

 

#

#"

#

 # "



     

 #

   "

  

 #     

 D  "

" 

E    "

   





 



#

"# 

    

 



0 $/ %%%3  

  

E:,' "

  "



# 



#  

" 

  =

  

8B& ' $   





 

#

* '/ %%%3



 6   #

0 $/ %%%3

' %% %%%3 

#  & '"





; $ 0 / 

#  

 !





  

#

 

  

 

 

"    

  #           "







&1    1 

 " 

   



    

2 "  

    

# !







  8 #   @

  "   

  



 # 

 "

" "

   6

 

 " 

   







 #

' '% %%%3

 @

 

  

 #  

 #

   

 & '/ %%%3 /% %%%3 & %% %%%3 @

  "   8 #    

"  

 



"





&2 ) 

  

  

 " 



 



 ) 


D

    

   

:

  #

 E:8&   

  

   

"

# #

 # 



"

 

 :

 

" &*

     "

# 



 ,
    )   

   

 # 

 

 #



 ) 
 

 #

# 



#  





) 9

  

  )    #

#  

    # 

  

3 &7 =

 "  ) 

"

   

      ,B$ 8 #     " 

   "

# 

 

  

 "

 "       ##  9  " "

     

 

"  "

 

 "

:

  

   "  ;" 

 " 

#  :# 

 #

 



 ##  "

!





  

6 " 

#  

)  '%       ,B/  (

      " 

 

    ) 



## 

 "

!

 ! 



## 

 

"

 

  

 

   E:,'  

  

 "

# # 



 =

  

  "       

# # 

 ! "

!

# 

 

   



: 

 # 

 



#



#

 

#   

!

#

  

   

 > 

 

  ) 



) 
 " 

"   

"

"



D ! 

## 

    !    8  "



)

 '&   

   

  ) 

 



# 

 







 

    '' (

  )  # 

  

 "  

 ##   "

"

D"

 

"  !

   "  " 

   

 #  ##  "

"

 9 "

 !

     # 

#  :# 

   

## 

("

  48#B5  "

# ,B' 09 "



 " :  '$

:# 

  ) 

"   

"  

##  "

! !

 !

 

    

   

  #   "    

    "

       

 "    : 

  #      

:#  

 

!

#

 ! 

 

 



#

=

 



E:,'

## 

  

  "



   

 

#

#

#

 ! > 

 

 :# 



"

# 

 ! "

,B/ "



" 



    

 D ## 

!





 

# "

   

   





 "

     

 "

  ) 

"

 



 

;" 

#   





" 





 



 

 

#  

#



    #



#

#

:



 $%%&'%%% '0

 

  ) 

 



"      

 '

#  



   

#  

 

 

#  :

  

   

 #

 #   

 )  "

 

"   



   

"



 !

"

"

* 

 ;" 

 

## 



 

##  "

#

"  

#    

!



" +  -

##  "



   " 

 ) 



##  "



:

 !  

"



##   

# "

   #!

 

##    

+ 

#- '/

:# 

  ) "

## 

#

#

 

    "

 "

 #   ! F 

   # "  

 : 

:#

  

     "

)  " #

# "

 

"

"

 

#

    "

#    

 

# # 

 



#

"

 E  #   

  

D     #

      #         



+

 - '1 ; " :

     !

  " 



 ) 


 "#  "

!



     

"

  #    

" # 





 @!,G

 '*%$'%%$"

  

 

 " 

   

 



"  

  H,

9  "



#    



## 

!

 ! "

 ##  

"

#  



    !

 



  "

 :#  "

!

#  

  

   

 '2 ? 

        

 



 ) 


 D 

  

" 

" 



  )  

 

 

  

   " ## 

# # 

  

  " 



 '* ? 

   

 

 "

#  '7 (

)     

  +.

 -   #

 " 6

"A 4-

  

 #   #   



    

"C -



  $%&'%%%"  

 !

   "

  

 

3 

 

#   

!

 K 

 K

##

##

  "

 

#  

  



  #     

#  "

  !    





#

 -

  

  

3 

    

:





C -

 "

 #

 5

 "

#

# 

)  

6

"     =

 "



#

   

    

  

    8B$  @!              

#



"      

C 



8B$    

#



E:8&  

 

"C   "

  

 

 

   

 



 

E:8&    

  

"  )   !

 K 

#  #      

   

      



 

$% 

   #   

  )   @     H   

    #

#

   

 :

       



  



  #



:

  '0%''%%$  E:8/ 

 ) 

 



  ) 
  ; "    

 

 @!    "

 

8B$ 

#

 " #

  &1

   

 &71$  E:  +-

?  

 

    @   H       # 

 )  !'4!567#!789,
&:!6"!6%'/0!'/0! +'%&%- &%))/&' !';%<!&07# 0=>!'%!'7!'"0#6:'75&%'7 !';

,"7'7"0#6& +'%%/-'))'&2 $& @H :





8B$

#

)      " 

#

"

  9

 !

"

 



  .

   :   "

"

)  " 



"    

 

 



  &/

 #

  )   

 

#

 

#  

 "

" 

  E 

"  

 

#

#

,B& H !

   

4 

     

 

#     (     ;

!

"     (    5 $' @H  #  

  8B&(   8B'+

  # -   #

  

   :#    

  

 "  

      9  

#

#    

.

   :  

# 

  )  



## 





 E:8&   



#  "

  

# "

##  "!

.

   :# 

#



  







 #  @H    

  #

# "



 

  )    

" )  .  @  H  #   

   

 #  

     

   

  

 

6   "

 

)   6 $$ ;   

 

  #   @  

       



 

  

" 

   #

 " 

#     "

   

   

 

         '

"  

  #  ##  "

 ! 

 

 

        ""

     " 

     

@ :   "

)  " 

    

"   

"  

  

 



:



 

    "   #  

""

      $0 ? 

 

   

  #   

   +- 

$ 0  #  



:



  

# ;   : 

   '$

 # +))  -   #  

        &1+-



&71$  E: 

+-

" 

! 



  

# 

## 

 

 

 # 

 

#

)  "



  





"  

:



  6

  :# 

  "    :







#   

 "  

  

 

  "  :



 ?     

  

   #

 )  !'"&0!'7!'"0#6:!-7#!'7 "0#6& ;'%&1+0-( #$'&   #

  (

( # 9 )   !'756!'/ %:!=%?"#:
!-$0!'76!!'/!70!6 &0"#;!67#!789,
&!'7"0#6& ;&7*&)''$/  $/ .

   :#   

    

#  

 

 "   

#     

# 

    #!



 ;   

  #

 )  

565&0""!-
#779!'7!'"0#6: 6!"!?"##.&,"7 ;'%%')22& #

 

  #

)  '7#6=%"

%'/0:!67#:%'/0 '%&1+&-8.
$&0  $1 ? 



# 

    

 

#  

=;



  

  #  #   



)  

6



 #  )  #

 

  

  #!



 $2  : @ # "

)  "

    

 "#   

      E 



#

 "

   

#     



 



 

  "

    "       

##    

 #

  ?        #



  (

)  5.!;0
!=:4%&0!'4!56 '%&0+0-))) $2' $* .   



 

 

,B'  

#

 

# "

"   !

#  #


"

   

"



4

5 

! # 

   ##    "

 " 4

 5 @ # 

#

 

 

# "

    



  



##!

 "

  #  "

   

!    

  ##!

   

  "

D

$7 ;  

 #  @ H 

  

  

  #

   



  &1+-

   

  

 "



  

D    D F 

#    

##!

 !  

##!  





   "

 ""



 : 

# #   







  "

 

   

!

  @  H  #  

 "  

  

 

 "    

"            "      

 ?

) ##

 "

"    



 

8B' $ ,B& '  : .

  

  

 #

 

#    )  



)

"

:#  0% (    

# 



 "  

:



 "

     

  

     

        

   

  

  

  

#        9

  

#   



  





 

 

 

6

" 

D 

8B$ @!        "

   

 "  

# 

 0& 9   

 #  

6

"  6 

  )  





 





 







  " " 

    

  #  E:8/ "



  8B$ .

  

  

 



  &1+-

   

 &71$  E:  +-



 #



  

# 

    





# 

" 

# 



   



# 

  &1   



  "A 4  #6&'!.8!6&"6#.%# L  

# 

  





 L +-

 

 

  F

+-

  

#     

#

  # 

#   

  "      



     

  

 

F +-







# "

  "   

# 

  # 

"



# # 

  #

# 

 "

  

 

  "

 

  E:  L=



 +- L +- "

 





#







   #

: "

 

F +- 

  

 #  

  

# 

     

"      

#  

              5 0'  



     +- E:  +-

  

#



  "  

# 

  " 6

#

 "

#

 

     

 

 #!



#  "



 #



# "    "  

# 

 ; 

:



  @H  

 

   +- "

 

.

  



 "A 4&& 



   

 +-

 

 

      

  9  

* +8#  -"

 







  "

:#   

 

 

  +
       -

:# 8B&"   "

 

#

" "

  

:







 &$&7*%

"

  

 

 "  

#



 " 

#

 "   #   

  

D    "    

 

#    &1+-

   

 &71$

 :5 ; 

 " 



 

D  

   :



 

  

 

  

 #



"

#  



"

 ?



 D "

 "

!



 

 

         #  #      

   

 # 

)  "  

"

       "  

  

D    "

    # #   !  ! 

 

    

  

4 5

 #

 

 D #

      

D "  

#     

#

   

 







#

3 

   

  D

#    

#

 



  

6

   #

!

"



;

"

 









 

D

D

"

   



 

     &1+-



&71$ 

 D   

  

    #     #

D

#   

  (

                 

 

 

D "  " "

   

"

  + 

-

" #   

# 

 

 

) ; 



 



"  #  



#





#

3 

 



  D 

 "

  

 9

   "

!

"



+

-  



 ) + 

- 

 !

"



 0$ ;      :    "  

 

   

    

 "A 4   

  

# 



#

 





  "  

# 

 

  #

+

8   #    ,   
  @

   F  8      # 8 @ # 
#  @     

## -5 +

 &' )) -

+E# 

) -

 

.

   

  "

 

" 

 "   

  



#

# #

   





# A
;

 



"" 

" 

#



   

#     #

  

  

 : 

 

" 

# 

   #  :#    

  :#  

"

  !

" 

 

    

     

"    "  



#



     



?

"



 

 

  

 

  !

"     

         

"   



 

B # "##



 



   # 

  !

" +- 

"



   

 

 !

"

    

#

 

 



 

 +-;





      



 

  

#

:# " 

   ;





 !

"

    

    

 

 

  :#  

   

 

+-







 

  



   

 

  

 

 !

" + -B

   

# 

 " 

   !

"

 

   

 

  





 

  

       

   

  

 #  3

     

2  #  







 +-B

   

  

 

   :# 

  

 

 +-B





"

# 



  

    

  



"

:# +-B

" 6  #

 

    

 "

4

# 5    4

5  #

     

    

 



!



   



4 

5

  

!    

# 



" 4  "  5 

        

  

       :   6   B

   

 

 

        #  # 

 

!

  

+"

#  

# # # - #   

 



4  "  5E:#

 

   3"

:

#  



3

    :

#  



 

 #  

3#

:

#  



    00

   #



 #  

:

  &1+-

   

 

   

# #

  #

!

"

 



   



 !

"







    

  6  

# F

  !

"

#    

; 

   

  

   

8B$ @!  #

#

"      # 



   



  

2   4 #    

 5  

      

     

   

  

   

D

!

" "

#









# 

#  

 !

"

 

    

 

@H # "





8B$  

# #

"

     

D     

  3

  

 



#





D  "  

# 

 

""

 !

"

"  0/ ;# 

"



  

   

 

  



 

   #





   +- @    

  

$ 0 "

  # 



:



 

 

  

# 



#

 

" 

# 

   

# 

  

  :

  

E:



@  

 D

 E:8' 8$ 80 

 

#  



" 

D  " 

0 $/ %%%3    

 #

   (    



+$%%&'%%%- 



8B$   

01       "



E:,' 



 #

  (   

 #  

0 $/ %%%3  " 

8   ( ! $&%&'%%% 

 

 # 



   



  





 ;   

 

D 9

    !

" :# # 



#

  



" 

  

" " 



8B$@!    # 

   

"

 







  

  3 #



"

!

"



 

 



  

   

 "

  

 



      



 3  ;         

       :#  8B$+

D

-  #   ##  "#!

   

"  

 "





 

 :#  



!



 

 

"   "





   

#   #

 

 :# 

" :

  

 

:



 "  "

  :#   



 





" 

   02   

 #  

       

  

  

 

  

   #  # 



:



 #

   # 

 

  

"    # 

 #



  

 



 

 



 #    

 !

"

# #

  

  

"

#





 

   

  +"

 



 -9





 



    



  



D

     

   

 !

"

# #

   0* ;  "

 





 #   

   +- 

#  4#&!6%!'5-!'

57:'=5- #0!' +'%&$-&'))10  

6

"





8B$ @!   



 

    

 

# 8B$   !

"



 

   

6













 D

:





#

 

07 ) # 

:6

" 



 

 

 

 



) 

 

 ;   :  

   



   

  #  #

  &1+-

   

 &71$  E:  +-

6

  



 



#   



 "

 

>  

 "  

  "#  "

!

 

  

#

  

!

 

#

   #     #

#  

  

 



  

/% ?  





      "  

  :



 #



    



" 



!

 

#

      

 

#4 5   

  ! 

  

3#

    

# ""



  



 

#

 # 



 /& ,  



"  

2) "

  #

 " 

#   9

  I.

 "



##  

 

 

 ! 

 

      

  

 )    " 

     

 

  

#

     

 #     

 "

  

  

 ##    

9

:  



  #    "

##!

#9

   "  ! "

  #  D D

    

 

   "





# 



  

6



! 



    

"#

  !  

; 

 

)  

  



"  

 " # #!

    !   

 # !

  #  

 

!

"

 

   

 

"

   "  

 

 

#    

:

  

  

!

" "

 

 

 " 



 



##!

 !   "   

     

 D D

    

 # 



 #

  # 



 



:

  " 



  #  





  

 

 D                 #      #

  

 

)  /'

 "





 :# 

 D ,B0H

  # 4

 #

' '% %%%3 9

   &77*5+9

   



  #  

)  

  - 

 #

  )  ,B0

 

D

#

D#

& %% %%%3 #9

 

     

#

#

#

 

   

  

" 

 D

# 

 

#

 D

 #  "

#

#  

  ) 

  

 #

" #

  "

 



2*

# #

#

   

#



 

#   # 

       

 #  " # #

 

  



 

 



#









   



 #  #

 #

   





 



     



 

              

   9  "



  



   



   

  ) 

"

  "

 D #

D 9

 

"

 ##      

# 

   # #

   ;    

##

#  "#

#

##   



;

6    #

 #

   



 F#  #   



  





" #

!

"

 

      



D /$

 

 

 

E:8&   " 

#   #

  &1+-

   



6

"

 "

  



 

/0 ) # 

$ 6

" # F"

#

  

    

 

) 



  

#  #  

  "

"!

 K 

)   #

6



 

#       # 

  "



 #

)   "

 

  // >   )   





 #   

   



 

$%%&'%%%" 



:



   

   

  +



- 

 # 

)       

 $  6

 "      

 "



   /1 )   

#  # 

)  " 





)   



 # 9

   "

     "

 

   

 



 "    !9 21 * ,


  &B

 ! 3 

C > 3

'B

  C > 3