High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5026/2023dismissed

Sandeep Sood v. Ms Bagga Singh And Sons

2023-12-13Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti10 pages

"# "

$ "%&'(

)*+,( $ $ )"+ $++, # $ %& ' !%(")*% + '! $ %,%$%-' %(")*% + ' .....

$ $ )"+ $++,- ) '! /% "!/"+-"*)- ) *- +' + "%%0% 1! 0 " "%"23234 !%"5&-%

" )- "06 ) 7(8 "'% % )-/ 9+34-"%$:%00%/ ) !; 1%

! " '%'!

'%"+-" +

! % 0'"+ (' %0 (%

&( )% (*+ 1 + 0 !%*+ -! "! 0'1 + 1'!

&1% 0<=9>% "5% 0;'% % 15

%"% --%0% %+/%"% ('-% " *8 "'% %%- 0?'

"% & " * 0'"+ % "'% ") '

0 %-%0 1 :-1 "%"334'! :!-% ++ %- 0?' -++! + 1" & 0 %1! 0' %" -1 :%0 1 "%" 334 8%

" * - + ' ! 51"'%'!

'%"!

*'%"'!

& )" 0 " %- "" "%" 933= % " 1 % ?% %- " '+%) '"+ % "? ! + ' !

& % ' !

) ?

(@3(33(333:?% % 0%0% "+ % "+ ' -%9&% '' *-+'! :!-% ++? %--& '!

& > '1% ?%-"5? '!% ?'

' ) +"+ < !%-;

'% ?%-"'%' ! ?-- *-%1'%+ %" %' ''%--!%&% ' 1 + <3(33(333: "+ % " - + )%*% 0 ' &'! '%"0) @3(33(333:"+ % ?'*'?%!%"%+ ?'"

%? 0'%1 + 1 %** ?% + ' -"'%'?--!%&% ' 1+ 3(33(333:"+ % " +?'*' @(33(333:? !%" *%'% "5%-% *+

@(33(333: ? !%" '

0' *'> ' + ( % %- +

<3(33(333:? !%" '5%+%"-1 "%"334 !

*+'-1 '"+ % ")%*%"' 1% "'% "") '! '! :!-% ++

343234('"+ %- 0?'1% *%--1 " "!'! :!-% +++ 1'!

& > "+ '

% (' + ! ?%+-"'*!&+!-% % %&%!!-*%

% " !*)-&'-%

" %-

%+ %!!

*% 0'+%*+'*%% "'"* 1 (0 "

4 A!% +% > +%) +'! )" "%"

3@3234?'*'

4'*!&+*1!

"%"334

9 '! 5 0?

+' &'%"+-" /* 4+% ,%5

* *(=9=%0% '"+ ?'*'?%! *3+ 'A* +*1!

1('%" ?% ?'"

323234'*!&+ "%"=393

@% "*!&+ "%"323234

:!-% ++ '%" %- +-" % + "*-% % % '&% 33% "%&?%0 " '%"*)- ' *!&+ )-/ "%"3333

% "*!&+%& "%"33=39

2 / *'1% ?%-"

5? ' !% % ! -1 :%0 1 "%" 334 6

97(' %" +?'"

%? 0 ' 6

7 1%" % %1 5+ ' " & 0 ' %"

*1!

1'*!&+ "%"3=3234

+-" %!!-*% + )%*% 0 ' %& "%"

3@3234 ' +-"5&'! :!-% ++'%"%!!-*%

3 ' -%

" %- ?' %!!

*% 0 ' !* -% +%*% "* * 1% *+'*%)%*%"'%&0 "

+%) + ' ! :!-% ++ 5& !% 0 1! 0 " "%"

3234?'*'

' %+ ('!

+-" ' !

*)- ) ?'*' ' !% ? " *" 1% % 0% 0! )" "%"43234 ?'*'

' '%%-+-" !

4= - %" ?' /* @ + %

9 * 1!!

*" 0+ )-% 0' "%"33=39'*!& +%"!

4 ' +-"% '

%!!-*% + !

)" 0!-*%"?'*'

9'-%

%- ?' 0 0' !-&"*""'%!!-*% "0 "

!-*'-! 5&" * 0'/% ++* 1!-1 ' "%"33=39'*!&+1! 0 " "%"

23234%-%

A"' ?' ' -%

" * - + ' ! % 0 " '% ' 1! 0 " !%" 5& ' -%

" %- ?' % & , +*% *%

5%", "*%" 11% -&?'' ' % & )-% + ' %& "%" 33=39 ' 1 + -1 :*1!

1"%"3346

97?--5 % '1++ %-%", "*% +'*%$ ) (* 1!%!!-*%

%-+-"(' + (?--5 5&' * *

"?'' ' % &)-% +'%& "%"33=39 $ ) (

'%!!-*% +!

('*)- '%5 +

"5& ' -%

" * "0 % ' * !& + ' "%"

43234

@ +%* ' !

! +!

& > '5%+*1!

1"%"

3346

97'!'0 %!'+'! %5-'

<'1% %-+%*% "'"* 1 '%) 5 %--& 0 " ?'- !% 0 ' 1! 0 " "%"

23234)"?'*''/% ++* (-*/% )

<(8 "'% %'%5 " *"1!-1 ' 1 "%"

33=39!%"5&'-%

" %- '%+ %"*)- 51"'%'%+ %" ?' , +*% "'%1

@ 1%&B "-&5%"% "'*%1%&5"*"" 1 4

' ' '% "( ' -%

" * - + :!-% ++% 0 "'%'! 1 "'!

*+-%?5& * *%- 01% %-+%*?%$:%00%/ (%!% '!

+ 1'

0'/'%? / 0''%"+-" + "*-% % %- 0?'

! %0% ! ; 1% % " ' ?'*' ' /% "!/"?%%

%&"%"+ 2'*!& +!-%

'%"*)- (%!!-*% + %&

4= -% " %"?'/* @ ?%+-"% "'%& %!!-*% ?%"*"" ' +%) 5&!% 0 "%"33=39 ?'*'

2 %-%"'%/% "!/"'%"+-"

,*1 %0% $:%00%/ /* 4+ % ,%5

5% * *(=9= '&% 3'*!& +,*1

@''*%? ! 05+ "++ * % " ' !

*" 0 ? 0 0 *1!

?% %

)" % )" *1!

1 "" "%"

3346

97 +%*%+%B"* 1 % "' 0 %- + ' %1 '% 5 !

" *" 5& ' ! ' !

! +-"% ' *)- B 0! %?--% "% & %0% $:%00%/ "' %0"5% %& "%"3@32345&* *%- 0'!

) -0% ?'*'?%%- %"&0 0 '!

" '"! "*1!

"%"334+ '+ 1 0'!

*" 0+*)- +-"5&$:%00%/

3=3234 ?'*' ?% *%0 *%--& " " 5& ' '

-)% C1 "%"3=3234

< % 0 "'%) %+ '%--0"*1!

"%"334('!

*" 0 '*)- * "'!

! ?'"

?',*1 ' %5 *( '?

+%* *'*1!

1?%)

)"%' '

*)"% &%1 '% "") ')%*% ! +''! '!

+%*'! '

0'% *%--1 *%1' '!% ""%1%0"' !

&% "-% ! ' -*B ''!% 0'1% "' %+ (0'!'0 %!'*-*B" %5-''! *%' ?%% &*1!

"%" 334 6

97 % *-%1" 5& ' !

! :"+ 2(' ?% % %B+ *5-!

%?%*%! " %

*%1 %'! "

)+%"+%0 %-!-%&" ' *-% +&'+%* %-! '-0'+ %+ %"* * 1% *('* 1!%!!-*% ?%+-"% "% '

%!!-*% ?%+-"+ !

)" 0!-*%"' :!-% ++ + %!!

*% 0%--'+%*('1! 0 " "%"23234?% !%" )" ?'*' !-* '-! ?% ! )"" ' !

:!-% +++ '1!-1 % + "%"33=39)" ?'*''"+ ? % "+ 1 + 0 '!%*+ - ! +'!-% ++$:%00%/ ) ' & "! 0'1--0%--&% "+ *5-&% 0 "'%' -%

" )- "06 ) 7(8 "'% %'% 0'-&!%"' '! '% ? 0 $:%00% / (%?%% - ' + ('*)- ) !

"5& '!

?' 1 9 '%)* " "'% 0 1 %")% *"5+ 1% "

'%)*% + --&0 '

0''"* 1 * "%1% +

* "'%+ -&($:%00%/ (%!% '!+ 1'

%? / 0' +' 0 "!% +-" + "*-% % ! 0% 0''!(? B'!(0"?

%"%-"

' !-% %0% ! ; 1% % " ' *- " 0 ' !

! /% "!/"?'?%%

%&"%"+ 2 '%"

*)- ?%+-" '&% 34 !&+'!-%

$:%00%/ '%)%-+-"%!!-*%

4= - % " %"?'/* @ (?'*'?%%--?")" "%"

33=39?'*'

2 ' %+ ('!

/% "!/"+-",*1 /* 4+% ,%5

5% * *( =9= + ' )* + $:

%00%/ + 1'!

&1% 0<=9>&% "!% + &%"%-" '! '*!&+,*1

@ 0'! *&+%+ %"-0% ('!

! /% "! /" *-%1" '% ?' ' ) + !%- ;

'% ' 1% ?% %--0"-& *1!

1" )" *1!

"%"334?'*'

9 ' ! %-+%"*1!

97 "*%'%%+

*) 01 &%"%-" '%"*1!

1($:%00%/ / '% "") ! +'!

& +%) +! /% "!/"% "?%%-"*""5? '1?'"

%?'*% ?'*'? +-"%0% %*'' '%+ %"*1!

"%"3346

97" "5&$:%00%/

"?%*-%1"'% 1 &?% *)"5&'1' '& '% "") '! +!

1 +%) +/% "!/"

2 ' ?%% &-1 0% 0?'"

%?%-+'*%+-"%0% %*'' '! %-+ * "'?'%',*1 +-"

5&/% "!/"?%?'"

)" "%"323234'*!& +%"

< '! %-+ "%"3=3234 6

=7 "*% '% ?' /% "! /" *-%1" ' *1!

"%"334('%1?%" "5&$:

%00%/ '

0'' !% %? / 0''*!&+ C1 "%"3=3234

= 0'-&! " 5& '-%

"* -+ ' '%"!'%--0"*1!

1 "%"3346

97('!

*" 0? 0 0 ' + "*-% % "'*1!

?% ) %--0"

3=3234 + ' 0'-&! " '%',*1 ! ?%?'"

5&'! 3=3234% " '%

*+ ?% 1% B""1"-&(' ?%%& "%"33=396

27 +%) +$:%00%/ / !'%+ %"-0% ('!

+-" +

! "1% "% & %0% $:%00%/ 0'

" / ' *!& + !-%

' *!& + %& %!!-*% +-" '%"*)-

% "'A!% % > "%"3@3234 +%) +/% "!/"

4 '*!&+!-% 6

7('!

:!-% ++ 5%"' *% '5%+"! "*1!

"%"

334 !% %4+'!-% (?%1 "'%D *' 1-% !

*" 0

'!% ' '%1 5,* 1% ' ! 0 '%5 "*""5&% & +-%?A*! '!

) -0% 5? '!% ?'*''%"?'"

= *1!

1E ' !*+* + *+' + "*-% %

+-"5&$:%00%/ ,*1 +-"5&/% "!

/" ?'*' ?% ?'"

% ! "%" 323234 '

:"+ ?'-"! 0' 1+*1!

1"%"

3346

97'%" -" ! %

+%0 * ""

?'*'?%" -&!-%&" ' '? 0'1%

?'*'

1% *%-! "'!

& > "'-*B?% ! ''!% 0'1% "-% '!'0 %!'? 0*-*B"

+ +'%"'! ' -%

" * - !

0 ' 0-& "'A* +%"*1!

"%"334% ?%%--0"'%%+%B"* 1 /!% %* 1!%!!-*% %- +-" ?'*'

4 ' % ' *& + *1!

"%" 334 6

97 ?-- 5 %", "*%""

0'!

*" 0+*)- +-"5&$:%00%/ 0'

B 0"*-% % "! /1-% -&(' ?'*'!-%&" ' ?--%-5%!!

*%""

0' %-+' *%''!% ?--5 > "-%"' !*))" * )' ) 0'! *&+' 5"&*% 5 ! 1"%B'-%? '?

'% "'> *+) % '"* 1 *- " 0 !-%&" ' *%

50 "%' %0' 5,*1% * ) &'%5!

)"%?%% '1++- 0+'*%

" 0 ' %+ %" +%*( ' -%

" )- "0 6 ) 7(8 "'% % 0'-&!%"' "%"23234

'% +!

&?'*'?%% - %'1+!% 0+

3 %& "%"33=39' + (?' A!

01&1 "

'1 +'*%(" + "% &--0%-&

0 -% &*11"

5&-%

" )- "06 ) 7(8 "'% %?'-!% 0' 1! 0 " "%"23234?'*'%** 0-& !'-"% "' *)- ) !

" 5& ' !

! :"+ 2 %** 0-&"*- " 0%!!-*% 67(+% &('%--%-% ""!"+ 434 .$ $ )"+ $++,/

)*0( F'' !%B 0:

% "# : F'' ! %5-# :