High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23089/2022disposed of

Boota Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another

2024-04-19Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!"#"$"

%"" ""$"

& '()*+,'*-./.+0 11 2++)(3.045 111*).).+0*6 7*6/8/ 95*3)()*+,80:(;(0<(0+)5*6 111=*/>+0<*0)/

"?@ A#B?

D"?""

% EEEE 6*/*0)

613800F3.04G(HI<J+-()* ,+6)5*>*).).+0*61

61 (0.>(G3.045I)K(GH'ILH80:(; EEEE "?""

%M!C 1 95* >6(F*6 .0 )5* >6*/*0) >*).).+0 ./ ,+6 N8(/5.04 )5* />*(O.04 +6<*6 <()*< 11 J.<* K5.-5 )5* -G(.P +, )5* >*).).+0*6 K(/ 6*:*-)*<H K.)5 ,86)5*6 <.6*-).+0/ )+ )5* 6*/>+0<*0)/ )+ -+80) )5* K5+G* >*6.+< +, >(6)).P* /*6J.-* (/ N8(G.,F.04,+646(0)+,)5*;*0*,.)/80<*6)5* G<*0/.+03-5*P*1 1 Q*(60*< -+80/*G /8;P.)/ )5() )5* >*).).+0*6 K(/ (>>+.0)*< (/ >(6) ).P* /K**>*6 +0 R11 (0< 5./ /*6J.-*/ K*6* 6*48G(6.S*< +0 111 +K*J*6H 5* K(/ <*0.*< ;*0*,.)/ 80<*6 )5*

G< *0/.+0 3-5*P*H J.<* )5* .P>840*< +6<*6/H +0 (--+80) +, )5* /*6J.-*/ 6*0<*6*< ;F 5.P >6.+6 )+ 5./ 6*48G(6./().+0 ;*.04 >(6)).P*H .0 J.*K +, )5* .0)*6.P +6<*6/ >(//*< ;F )5./ +86) .0 T H K5.-5 K(/ /8;/*N8*0)GF <./P.//*< (/ K.)5<6(K0 +0 1R11 95* .//8* ./ 0+ G+04*6 6*/ .0)*46(H 5(J.04 ;**0 <*-.<*< ;F )5* '.J./.+0 2*0-5 +, )5./ +86) .0 UVWUXY BUZ [YC D\U\] ^_ `XaUW UXb ^\c]VY H RH <*-.<*< +0 11H (4(.0/) K5.-5 )5* 3Q (/ K*GG (/ )5* =*J.*K I>>G.-().+0 K*6* <./P.//*< +0 1R1 (0< 11 6*/>*-).J*GF1 d+GG+K.04 )5* (;+J* (0< -+0/.<*6.04 =8G* 1R +, 80:(; .J.G 3*6J.-*/ =8G*/ (/

! "

#$%&'()""

#*$+$,""

-./""

0,$,1""

23"

4&'($%""

$'5""

2,*16.7"

8 99 :

; <= >? @

A ;

@ B@ C

A CE8 ;

8>8

8 99 F B;8 8 D

@ 8 8 8 H:> > ??:D > D E 8

8 8 I D8C 8 E: ?

999 JA 8"

K11L$'""

M$,$""

-./""

0,$,1""

23""

4&'($%""

$'5"

2,*16."

! :

8 99 > @ >? @ 8 D8; D8C :> D@ ? 8 8

E8 ?

; NO P 8

; 8 >? @ E:

C ; D E 8 D@ F 8 8 H:>

8 8 H:> 8 @ 8 ;8@

? 8Q D ?

; <8 9 O BE 8 R8:

;

: 8C 9 !

; "

S$6%$'.""

M$T"

U6./""

0,$,1""

23""

4&'($%""

V""

W6./" :

8 8 >? @ 8 E:

C E: >C E D8

C ; D E 8

8 8 H:>9O

E8 ?

8 ;X C>8 8 NG

> E :

8 E :

> :

8: 8 8 @ C E:

; ? 8 ;

;

C Y 8 D :

8 P ;@8C E: ;

; ?8 89 D > D 8 E9 H E: ?

999 O 8 I

B;8 8 D 8 8 8 H:>

Z88[

D8 8

: ;

8 8 8 8 8XD \ E 8>8 H E: 99;9 99 D ??:D ? 8 9 O >8 >8 > E Z88[

>8 8C 8XD E H E: I :88 D ;

>8 D@ 8C : ;: 8]8

: 8 99

Z88[

O ? 8 :

88 D E 8 D@ \G H:> 8 8

:E ?8 @ D8; ??:D >? @

8 8XD\ E9H E:?

999 <8 E

; E ? 8 9 Z::

8C@

8 8

: ?

;

A : C E: P ; E: ;

?8 8 D:

8C@ : ;: 8

8 99

Z88[

8 ;8 8 D

@ 8 8 H:>

D ??:D >? @ E D8

A8C ?

!" # $ % & % '

% ((" " & " ' ) *&" '%+, & # + - & '" '# )'

% # ')"'# ( &'#('&+'# %'

" .''

" %'('%%/ 0 ' % " 1"

) % "+ " # + & ' '

3& ) ' '# " % 3&( $ '

# " % % " 1"

) + 3 '# 1 % "+ " %) %%" 0 #'

, # % '1( '

- (

%&'

" % 5 ' " + & '

# '# & % '

' " & '

" + .- '

+ ' " 6 "% 3() '"% '

' " " % ' 1(" 0 %('

" '1( '

- ( % 5 +

%&'

" % % #

" % '

3() % && ( &'

& '

, 5&

- & ' % '

% '# 7 8 9, % (

" " + & '

& ) % % (

' (' " % : #+

% ( #'

'# & % '

+ # % 0 % " 7 % "+

& " + % ' - "( "

.' ;; '# " <

=% 3 '# + " ' % '

8 - %' % ) :% '

'# - '% % " (% %' )&'+% -'

& ) % %, - %5

# '# & ) % ( ' " % : #+

% ( #'

'# & % '

+ # % 9#

)

>% " =% 3 '# 1 " ' %, % ' - "( "

.' ;; '# , '

8, " '

( )&'+ % -'

5" -

%&'

" % ' '

& ) % %, " % " & ) % ( % 5

' ((' #'

% '

'# % ( '# )&'+, # '# % " % (, (

' " " ' (' " % : #+

% ( #'

'# & % '

+ # %0 &'

'#1"

) %% " ** ** ** % % " '

" $9 .' ; '# ; -% # " + ?'

) '# + " " '

" "" ;, #

' (

& ' % '

'# 7 89, @ % '

A ( " '

+ %'

) & ) )&'+) " '' " %&( # ( ('

(+, % '

" - (')&

& % '

+ # % 0 @ % '

A ( " - )&'+ % -'

5" #'

) " ('

'%+, - ( % )'

"(", %) (

' " % & )

) , " (

" - (')&

& % '

+ # % 0

'# 1"

) '# @ % '

A ( %% " ** ** ** 0 :% '

'# - % ' - , & ) % ( % ' (' " #'

(')&

& % '

+ # % () & #'

% " '

% '

.' '# ; " % B A - = % 3 '# +

%, "( "" '

% " (% %', 5&

- "( % '

'# ''

A (

2 % %

3& % - '

" &%%"

$9 .' ; '# ;,

! "#$% !&

& & #!

" !

$% " ! %!

!$$ & "#'& !

! ('!$%)

* +

$ ! # ,'&)" !

'& -. !

& ' $ #!

!& !

) ') & !$!

!* ' $ # & ! # !&

& &

" !

) " /** $$ 0**1

!" $!$ '& !

! ('!$%)

) ! # !

% * ' $ # '

& ! ') # !

2) #!

" !

1 ' !

2& !' %!

1 !

!& ! & !

)& &' #!

" !

* 3'

1 !

# !

2) !

$1 !

!& ! !

& !

)) &' #!

" !&

!" !

& & !

)'$!

"#$%" !$$ !&#'

# * !&1 ' $

! ! !##" !

"!& #!

" !

!" ! & & !

! ('!$%)

# 4 *0

5 46 7$..1 ! &) 1 #!

! !&!

!('!$%)

* . ! "! ! ! # 2& #!

" !

$% %!

* 5 #

)!)& #!

" $% !

# , !&

#& # &* . !

!& ! ! "#$%1 2) ''

$% %!

$1 !

! #!

" ,* +

!& !

! $) ""#$%" !$$ !&#'

# * 5 3'$$ 8 '

9 !

!&:

'# ! !

$& ! &!$% !)

1 $$ & %

)'$!

1 '& !

! ('!$%)

) ! # !

% *

1 &!$% !)

'& !

! ('!$%)

1 !

!& ! ''

!##"

& & % # %!

') !

" !

1 $

! &!$% !)

& & % ! "#$%* + ,'

! ) %

#& &%

!& 1 <# 6'$ *0

5* +

!& 6'$ !

!$ !&% & & 9 !

!&:

'# ! !& !

$& ! &!$% !)

$$ & %

)'$!

)& ') !& !

('!$%)

"#') # !

% * + 1

# !

& & %!

! " /** $$ 0** ! ) & "#') # !

% # *=

! " #$

#! " %&"'( ) * " + &,- # #,

(

%&"'( . ! #

" #!

( !

/&, $ ' !

. '&, 0") 1 !

#!-

" #%

. # " #$

( !

" " #$

(

,, )) # & " /&, $ ' !

, #,

# % ") 2

" #$

, ,. " ! , "$ # % "-

$ #

, ,'

," +()

,,.") " "

," +(

$ #

" . , " '

$ #

," +(-

" " #$

(

,, ,, , #

" /&, $ ' !

( &

$ #

) *

,&,

$ #

# " #$

" .

. ( (

" $

" " . ! (&

,&,

,, # ,"

"3 .( )4 ) * " + &,- "

# - # &#,

" " . & $

(

"%&"'(

$ $,.) ) 1 .5

(

%&"'(

6 7889:;66 <:=:6 -6 >:?@:;A66 <:B6 "6 C:@D;EF66 CG:H:=6

& ) I6 JKJL6M>JNO>JPQ6 R6

, - 7NOST6 5 ' UVW #, UVW