Punjabi University Patiala And ANR v. Jasbir Singh And ANR

  

 ! "#$#%&'

(") * +
,%- .#%#/ ($#0 # %! %) ( 233 11 %$ 4 ($,$ ( $.#(#%5) %! %) ( 2 $3%! %$ 6 ,%- .#%#/ ($#0 # 233 11 % 4 ($,$ ),3#%! (#%5) 2 $3%! % '&7
'4

 7
''
   
























 81

%#%5)*
!



"

"#

 $#
%

&%'



%
% 
(( )* +)(*
%
,-
. /012

+)()

,- . +)*++

+)(/
!


3
"#

%
 '
,-
. /012

+)()


"%

'

" 

!


4

5
. (+11

+)(* 


5
. (+10

+)(*6

3%

 ,





"3"
 3#
%
"





#
(70/
! 


5
. (+11

+)(*


"
 %

 


"&

#
8 +



'


#


#

% 
#


9 0)) (2))



 ''


#
,''


 %

(77:


#


9 ++)) 2)))


)( )( (70:

!
#



'


%
 5


'



%
%

 
'


#
 !

+2 )( +)))

#


 



9 0))) (/*))

)( )( (77: 

%

'
#



"%
%
 5



'




"



%
%


#


"#

$# 



"
#
 /

!
#


5





)( )( +)):




%

#

 9 /12)) :1)));

<
#
4<6

9 7)))
! 


"
%



"#

#
 #
%% =

#


#



 "


%
%

#
"
%






'"


5

(77(
 %

(770


%





+)):
%


 !#


#




''
" 
%

$#




 '



,
!

 
%



%


'


 





#


 "


$#
"#
%
'
% 



=

%
#




 

 6
> ?

@

$

=
(77)
4 

,,
:00

=


'

"#

 $#


3

'#
"&


 



'

 %
'




'




'
#
 5


'

#
8


 %
'
@



A "





5

>



&%'


B
, 
"

%

B

#

3%
 



&"

3
'
"#
 

%

'#


%

 '#


B


%



 A

&"



3


,
 
'#



' =


"



#



:




'

&%




 #

"%



,



 ' 
%
"
'

'



 ''




'


'  *

>
'

#



'
 
'#
"&
%





 






%

%
, 

%
#

"#
%%
%

 
&%'
%




@#










A

 

,





#
8 


"

"#

3 $# >





$#

 
"%

#
'
"#



# 
A


,

5



'

#
8 :

!
#







 %

$<,






'

 
5

#

'


'


 


,
'
'
4

$<,6

 #



"



'

"% 
 %
' 
%




%   %




$#
"



%
%




%



#

A"
%




'

'
A 
5

!


4
5
. (+11

+)(*6
 






#
"



%
%
%


#

'%
 '



"%
'
"#

5



'

#
8



%

% #








$#
= 

#

B


'

@
 
'

#
8


$#
 (7 )* +))*
%



"
%
4  (

5
. (+11

+)(*6

%#
3%
"
# 







4#
86 
#
+))(








 =


"

"#



 

#


%
B'

 
'3%



$



 
$# '
%


 ( 4
5
. (+11

+)(*
#6
'%



 "
B

C


3




"#
 


#

B
#


'


$#


'

# 8

#


3%


 '
 
'

#
8




# +))(

+ !


#
+))*


'
 "


'

'


 
'

#
8 =







"# 

$#


&%'

 '

!)0

( ! $)/ 8 $)) %! ( -3 #4+))76
(/
,,
:/*
 ' 







#
!% =



%
"#

$<,
% =


"



'

 




A
'

5

# 8
'
"

"


5

# '

'
3

A#


 
'
#


!

%
%

%

 





'%
&%'
'# #%




&%'


,


 

    

  

 4,-
. //*/

+))(6


#%


" '
"#

%
%


,


       

  


4,-
. ((:2(

(7706
4
 



&%'


'
,
 







 

  

 4=9
(771
,
/2//66






,

 3
$#



"


 %#

 @
#%





 &%'






%
%



'%
&%'





,
 

$#

"


 % 



#
'

#


5 =





'%
&%'

 $#

%
%

'


5
 





)( )( (70:

%



)( )( (77:




#
'

' 4A6
#


"%
#

%

 
"A# ()

,A#





%
 



9 /1))) :1)));<

9 7)))


)( )( +)):

A
" .


%

%


#
 




'


%

 %

%
#



%

(77(
 (770 ((

%%
"#


&%'

 &"
$#





%
 




"#



 

"

"#

$#
4"



%
%6
3%





"



'

#
8
4"#

%
 
'

6

+) )* +))*
 



"
%


,
 

'
5

#
8 !


'
"#

5

 "


%


'




'%
%


%'



%
%
 



"
 %



 %
>






5

 A

'
'


"%
%
 
"#


'
"
 '
"
'
'

' =








%



,





#








@

%

%
#
3 "


%
%


"
#

 
"






"#
 

"
' (+


%
%'

"



 4
 ,
"%

. +6


 







 '

"


@


'
 "%

"#


,'"



#
 



'

%'

 ,


$#


#
"


 
5
,A#

%

"

 


%


D!


5
. (+11

+)(*
 '#


$#

(70/E

# 

%
#

#


 5
#

(77:
%

)( )( (70:




(777

)( )( (77:


 
#

"#

$#



 
"#


"


%

;

%
#

%



'
 







#
#
 
#



B



 '

C






 $#



#



#
+))* 
'



#
8
 "
"


'

 #


#
3
"#
5



'

#
8

 ,

%




#% 

!




 


3%
#


 
%






 '

"

'
'


"

 
"



=

'
 





"
 ,

5


$#


=



"




 '

)* (( +)(*



 

"



%

+1 (( +)(*

,







 
"
'




 % F
(/

!

'
'


%
 

%





. (
4 5
. (+11

+)(*6




+1 )( +)(: %



$#G



 ,





%


 
#

5

#
'
'
 
4
. (

"
%6
D
"

# %




"


"
%#
3%



G
-3

,
%''

 #
8
4 86F

!
"


'

. ( B


'



@
 8
'
&"
$#



 

4

"
%6

,




'

%


%'


"& %
D,

G
-3


#
8
,F
 "#

'
%


+)(+ (/
+)(/ (2
 +)(2 (*







+
 
5
. (+11

+)(*


'
%
3" ,


"
B




 
. ( 
B


"#

!& 
@



8
'

 
$#

+7 )0 +)((


"
B 




. (







"
%
3
0

46


+ B'
"
+0 ):

+)((

)0 )1 +)((

 ( 


'"



B'
% 
'


 + @


7


+
B'
  (
%


(+ )1 +)((

++ )1 +)(( (2

!





9%

 
$#




 (( )+ +)(:
%




%

 %
%


G
-3




 ,
%''



#
8
4 86


 


"


1



 #
"

%'



!


 9%




'

 8


$#



#
#
 %







3 B'#
(2





"
 3%


B'

"#

% B'
%#





 3




4"#

'



86

#


%

$# '


'


"
%
%
"
 9 +0)))H



%







%
%
"

9 (2*))H

=







9%G
 




"#





'


8


$#
#
 
B
'



B
3

 



'



"

 
'


$#


3 (*

!





#

 $#

3



(+ ):

+)(2

G 3%


$#




%
 
$<,


9 (*:))H /7())H ;:)))
<


 

%"#



B


" "#

$<,

"

"#

,
'

'
'
"#

$<,
!

"



H
%


'



 %"#

#
"
%


 %







"
% '

9 (77+)7*H



)( )( (772
 /) )2 +)(* '#


%


 
'%

9 (:7)72*H




5 . (+10

+)(*


%

"

 
9 ():)7+/H 


)( )( (772 !








 %


#

%




 
%
#
%%
'
9 ()))H

9 +)))H 
 %




&



 '
A
"





  %
'


5


% #

(:

@




$#
'

' 
5


,

"
A

 
"


%"#
"
"#

$<,
#
 %%




'

%
#


 ,
'
'

(1









$#
"'

'

'
 
"#
$#







 #
%
#




'
 3

"%

"#


#


# %
3



"#




 '





$#



9 #


B
'
@

 ''
"#

$<,


,
'

'
'#
"%
#


%
#
 

'




'

%
= 
#

#
"
%
%


'
 
%"#



"#

$<,


 %




'

@



&%'

G"

' ,

 '

!)0 ( ! $) %!) ($

 8 $) ) %!(  -3 #
4+))76
(/
,,
:/*


% 




#
%



<' #
,%


'
#

#
 


"
%

$<,



 

%




<'


#

%





# %

3%


<'

# 









%
# '






! 
"


# %



"
A

 !
%
%
'


&%'
'#
" 


%

D""

!



 ! 





 "#$%   "##&    '





   



  !  '

  

 ( 

  

 ! !'  

 !

      





 

   

 

 )

 "#$%     



* +++
    ,

-
   !

  

 

   ! 

:

 



+ 

 


   

.

 "##&     





!

  

 / 

  0*     1  



 !

  2 "3  !



 5  

  !   

 "#$% 

 

 "##&  ) 









 

 '

 !



   !  





 !  

 "6 +

! !



  !



.

 8





  * 

'



 

 

   

 

 !



9  



' 

  

+  

 

 





    ! .

' ! 

 

  



'

   

  

 

 ! 





 ! 

 



   

+  

 

'

  8

 

 !

  

 





 *  



 

0!1  

'





   



   

+  

  ! 





 ": +

 .

 !!   !

 '

   

 ;   8

   

  +   





 

 

 ( !   ( 9

'   9

 

  !           

 







 (



 9 

   

 (  





 !   *  



 

 9

   



 



<!!





.

( 

.





 9.

 

 .

!

' .

' .

=! .



 .







.

  +

 .

 (  

'   9 





 ! 

 

    

  ' 

 



!

 

(0





%

 

"'


&%'


"# 

"


%
%





&


4,-
.
//*/

+))(

 +0 )1 +))+6

#


"#

&%'
 
'
,

   8) %   

 5(#",1,( 1%#/ ($#0 %! %) (*4(7716
0
,,
/*)

!
&%'
%
"

"A# 
 8 $)) %! ( -3 #$7

46

"

 #












 


'


$#


 




%
#

#


'% #
%

#


"

 '

+))* (7

5


"'


$# "%

'
"#

"#



 A



A
#
%#

'#

 %
#
#
#


#

 

$#











&%'

'') (!< -$7

46
 #






%
%
 

%





&%'
 '') (!< -$7

46

=



<'

@#

# 




"




 %
#



"

"#
 3
$#
@

'



+ "A#
"#

$#

3

"#




!





 

#




 8 $)) %! (  -3 #$7
46

"



'

'3 
"





 +)





%
 
H

"


 "'



"%

% 


"#
'%
%
3
 




'

"


"  

#
 

#
+))*
#
 %





'


" '
B
 (*





"#

@ 

'

#
'


$#
 (7 )* +))*





.
(

3% "
#






#
8 %#

#
+))(
@
"'




 






%
'
3 

"


'



 "
%


'




 


'

#

%

 
"#

$#








"# 
9%


 $#

+1 )* +))* 4B
 (16
%



.
(
 
'



9 '



 '
(:

)7 +))/

+* ):

+))2
%







,
@



"'
 



$#

5

'% '






 #
 +(

I







 
#


<
.3

$#
' 
+) )* (707
4B
 06
"#




#
8

,

 $#


%

'


5


)( )( (70:




%

 

%



%
@
 "'


@'

$#

 %






,


" 
'



(( )/ (707
4B










 <'

=
4 #

@'
9

'6

+2 )7 (77+
4B
 (+6
"# 



$
!
%
 


"
 @

"'



 '%
%


%



# %



$#
%


 

#

"
%
 '#
'

 "

#


$#

%J
 




%J%

A

"# 

A#
%%
'

A 


)( )( (70:





6 )( )( (77:

++






&%'



'
,


(='$ >,$$ #%

%#% %!#

4(77)6
 ,,
:00






 


'




" 





#


%

"# 
#


 +/

=
"





% 


"#

<'
 $


"
"%


 $# 
"%

#


%
"#

 





'


+2

@%


%'

"

 





&%'



%

%
%





"#

 


 $"#



%



%
 





'#

 %


'#
#





' 
"#



$#



# 

@


'
'
"# 
"#
"
"
"#

"
 -


%'



"
 %'







'# "



<'

3
 



$#

"#
 "



'
@







;


3
"#

$#


%

 



"#
"%%
'


 5


'

#
8
 A#
'3%


"


 A#
"





 
#






 
%



"#
%#
A

 

5
.
(+10

+)(*

"%


 #
4

6
%


#
8 $"#
#

%
A
#
 


5


)( )( (70:


 

#


)( )( (77:

>"#
 $#

#


#

%#
A 



'%
%
3


 




.
(


%
' "

+*

>





%'

 %'

"#





 


#
%#
A


" '

"
 

#
'


 


%'

#





C
#
'#

"%
"

3%
# 

%
#



"

 

A




&
" 
$#
"

'

#
8 


+))*
"#
%

'

 
'

'

#

!

"

3
#

A

 "




A#
'#

 
%



#


'%
%
 



#

%


 
$#


"%
#
A



 
5 +:

-
'#




#


"
 

#
3%

'%



 
#








 



%



%% '


'
%



+1

!





#


, 

'
%



GG

# 


"


'

%

 '
>


"
'



      

  ) ,( $#
=9
(707
,
(7
! 

"

'#
'


@

'#
#






 




&%'


#

 




 $#


%
 A

#






 







 #



A

"#
 





#

'% 
"


"
 %
#

!





#




 %
#



"










"

"#


$ 
<'
%

<
.3

$# @'

$#


'

 <'

@#
4"#
%J%

% #6



#
"


 '
#





5




$# @







&%'
 
%
%
,A#


 '
"