Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax 2 Ludhiana v. M/S Deepak International Ltd




  
 







































"#$%$&'(')*+ ,

--'((')$
)&-$"./ 012%3'")" 44$55")#    6   7($$4"8
)#$)"#')"51#%012%3'")"

 $(4)%$)#   *  91  
 
1  91  
 :
1

$($)#* ;"')<3:5"0%=&"#$0#3$"44$55")#   


10*

$=$)2$  '(  ')  "44$"5  "<"')(#  #3$  %$ %"#$%  +> 4"(($%?@#3$
)&-$".44$55"#$'?2)"50'='(')$)&303")%'<"3

(3#0#3$9'?2)"59!')
>77 0#3$"(($((-$)# @$" ,/0"'(')<#3$55A')<(2?(#")#'"5B2$(#')(5"A*/ C D3$#3$)#3$"&#(")%#3$&'&2-(#")&$(0#3$)9?5$
'('<3#')5"A')B2"(3')<#3$%$27(

)&-$".&#0 4"(($%?@#3$
/ 012%3'")"E

D3$#3$  )  #3$  "&#(  ")%  &'&2-(#")&$(0  #3$  )9?5$
A"('<3#')'<)')<#3$"&#(#3"# (325%3"=$ 58$%')#"55#3$$5'<'?5$'#$-(-#3$4')#='$A %'("55A")&$2)%$#3$&)&$)$%($&#')")%(')&$ #3$("-$A"()#%)$0#3$($'#$-(A$$)#(2?F$&# -"##$"44$"5")%#3$'((2$%'%)#-$<$A'#3#3$ %$#3$
 !EG
)#3$-$-<2)%("44$"5'#'(-$)#')$%#3"##".$$&#

H
I ')=5=$%')#3$&"($'()'5
#'("&"($')A3'&3#3$"(($((-$)##3$$(4)%$)#/"(($(($$ A"("-$%2)%$$&#')> !#3$
)&-$".&#0  (3#0 #3$9&#9!)  ,3$%$A"($='($%?@#3$--'((')$
)&-$". (3#9
9!0$.$&'(')<4A$(2)%$$&#')

&#)  3$"$("'%%$4"(($%?@#3$
2)%$$&#')

#3$&#A"(&3"55$)<$%?@#3$"(($(($$?$$#3$'?2)"53$ "44$"5A"("&&$4#$% 
#'(#3$"$("'%%$0A3'&3'(2)%$&3"55$)<$ ?$$#3'(2# ) "&3+0 J#3'(2#4"(($%#3$55A')<%$*/ C  4$2("5    "(($((-$)#  %$  %"#$%   ,

))$.2$/!4"(($%')42(2")&$#%$2)%$$&#')

   #3$ 
)&-$  ".  &#0     ')  (3#0  9#3$  &#9!  ?@  #3$ --'((')$   
)&-$  "./ 0  12%3'")"  (3A(  #3"#  #3$ (($((')<  '&$  3"(  -"%$  "%%'#')(   
J0+0+ 7/  ")%
+0J0J7/"(%'(&$)'?5$-4"<$>#3$4"4$?8 32(0#3$##"5"%%'#')-"%$&-$(#

0 0J>7/")%#3$#".

#3$$)KLA25%-"8$#3$#".$$&#-2&3?$5A#3$5'-'#  
5"&("(4$(&'?$%')'&25" +'((2$%)  +?@#3$$)#"5"%'$&#".$('5')< "44$"5(2)%$$&#')

#3$&# 1$")$%&2)($5#3$"44$55")#/ $=$)2$4"@(#'-$ #$."-')$#3$("-$ %F2)$%# , JG 3$"$("'%%$)#'&$(#3"#"#$#3$-"##$A"($$$%

H
I ?"&8?@#3$
##3$"(($((')<'&$0"(($((-$)##3$$(4)%$)#A"( "-$%")%#3$"-2)#')"55@"(($(($%A"(2)%#?$
J0+,0 7/(#3$ "-2)#A"(?$5A#3$5'-'#4$(&'?$%0#3$$)#"5"%'$&#".$(

(3##3$9"%9!'((2$%&'&25" 7 +0) +0'5')< "44$"5(')#3$'<32# %"@0"'%"='#=%3$(3:2-" '(3"0 --'((')$ 
)&-$"./ 012%3'")"0%"#$%,+ ,03"(?$$)'5$%$)%(')<#3$ ("-$='$A  ""J#3$"'%"='#(4$&''&"55@(#"#$(#3"##".$$&#"(" $(25#%$4"(($%2)%$$&#')> !#3$&#"#$#3$-"##$A"( $$$%?"&8?@#3$
A3'5$$.$&'(')<4A$(2)%$$&#')

&#0A"(
J0+,0 7/
) ='$A#3$"$("'% &'&25"'((2$% ?@#3$ "%0#3$ 4$($)#"44$"5&"))#?$$)#$#"')$% A$=$05$")$%&2)($5#3$$=$)2$(2<3##"'($") '((2$#3"##3$25#'-"#$#".$$&#"#$#3$%$'(4"(($%?@#3$
2)%$ $&#') 

   #3$  &#  (325%  )#  #  ?$  #"8$)  ')# &)('%$"#')   $."-')"#')#3$="5'%'#@#3"#%$ ""#3$')(#2&#')(4='%$ $.&$4#')(#3$$#4$2("54""#3$')(#2&#')(4='%$#3"# %$&'(')#'5$"44$"5')#3$&"($(A3$$#".$$&#'()#B2")#''"?5$)# ')=5=$%0(2&3"(#3$&"($$<'(#"#')#2(#(')(#'#2#')(2)%$ $&#') #3$&#'(#?$%$&'%$%)#3$-$'#($"&3&"($")%#3$ 5'-'#(4$(&'?$%")%#3$')(#2&#')(A'55)#?$"445'&"?5$ A$=$0A$"$)#'-4$(($%A'#3#3$"<2-$)#"('#'()#" &"($A3$$$'#3$#3$#".'()#B2")#''"?5$'#'()#')=5=$%"('#'()#" &"($4$#"')')<#$<'(#"#')#2(#(')(#'#2#')(2)%$$&#') 

H
>I #3$&#A3$$%$-"@3"=$5)<#$-(&)($B2$)&$(A'#3$<"%##".$( )#3$"(($(($$#3$$')3$$'()4"#'&25"4$'%')=5=$% =$)#3$&)#$)#')#3"##3$%$(4$&''&"55@4"(($%2)%$ $&#')> !#3$&#"#$#3$-"##$A"($$$%?"&8?@#3$
') $.$&'($4A$(2)%$$&#')

#3$&#'()##?$($$)0'("5( ##"55@-'(&)&$'=$%"(25#'-"#$#".$$&#"'(')<2#")@%$A3'&3'( (2<3##?$'-42<)$%?$$#3$'<32#'(#?$&)('%$$% :$$4')<')='$A#3$&'&25"'((2$%?@#3$"%'#($50"( $$$%#"?=$0#3$4$($)#"44$"5'()#-"')#"')"?5$ '(-'(($% H 
1I   

H :
1I + ,

  (3"-(3$






















D3$#3$(4$"8')<7$"()$% * $(7 D3$#3$$4#"?5$ *$(7