Bal Krishnan v. State Of Punjab & ORS
()( (
'
# #!
* '# )304,0+4+5 * '# +)0)40+4+5 ()+, -(+4)-6 78 000
.
/ 0
1
/ 0 ' '
()& " ' ) *()& " ' '( +) ' &()& " ' )*()& "
////
*(,
-
.
20
0 1) ,$ 2 .
!
"" #$ !
%& '
'#"
#(#
!
"
"
#
" $ !
% !
!
.
"
&
#$
(+( ( 9 "
" # $
(# , 29 )1$ $
!(# $
8 4*2 5#
%
6$ #( 2 @
,
, (:(:$" 7 0
(
!!( # , 8"
""9 & &
!
(
#" # # 9 # "
, : ( # 7 0
7 0
:$"
" ( "
# 9 ( "$ & 8""+$
7 0 0 "
# # ; # 8"" +$ &( # $
$
, 8""
" 9 ( # ; 7 0 ( ( 7 0
(
"$# # "" (&
<)"
)$&0 ( 4
=0>5(< < ) - % 2 :
%!(3
2:
%% .
2:
%% < (< < ) -
2 :
%%# (< ) -
% 2:
%! # 8"" 8$ 7 $ .
0 "#
"
7 ( # = > 2 (
% ( $ ? @"(#
# (9( ( ) +& (&
%
) ( $ , "
"
% ?
@ "
% %%) +& :
# #&("
" #
8&+& &( 8A"& 8( ) 8 ( ? @ ( &
2+& ( " # )""
$( & , , .
%% ) +& ( $ "(
% %%
, & A # # ( #" ( ( &
#""( =""
" "> $ "
( # #& "" "
&
" $$ 0 ( (A"
# " " 8A"& 8 ( 8"" ( <26( 7 ( (
% ( # # "
& & ;2
#$ ?"( $ (
"&( &# ;:
? @"( +& & ( #, "
"
( # #& $ $7 7 0 (
%
!
(5( ( < !
%%(0 0 (," $
$ ( (< ) -
2:
:
%%(;
;"
00
" &
% (# $ $
,"
$ (
# #02 =
6 ""$" # ; , # &
;$ $
"# ;
$( ,8""
" ," "
" 0
( # " &
;
; $ $ B"
>
0( !
%%(0" ( 8""9 ( &
; $ $
$"( < ) -
2:
%%( ( % 0
( & 0#@
" " , #"
(
$ , $ $ $( # " # ; 6$ " & $ # ( " "
29 #$ "
A
(-( ( 6 " "
0 !
% %%( ,"
$ " ( ( & " ( "# ($ "
( ""
"( & " "( ( # # # ""
8&( < )
0 # # $
(, $A)A 2 # 1C &)
:
D $ ( # # $ ,$
%
4)A2
# 5
) D"$ "
8"" +$
7 0 ((#$ ( & , ) +&
(&,
$("
#" A )A2%#
" " & "& ( # $ 0 ( & &$& +"
" ( 405
29 (
(
( !
.
(#"$ ( # " 8 "
"( # , , ( # " $ ""
" " $ 7 ( 0
( #
" " (:( ( ( "
& # , ( 6 " & " 8 8 $ ( +" ( ( "
< .
( $=& > > 8( '; " 4+ 5( "" ? @ "() +& & 9((# # # # , ( 3
( & "
$ 9 ( " 8
D "
# ) + +& 0 3
A A # (
E #&( $ (" & ""
" " ("
& # # , 0$ "
# # & &
(
(
!
(
!
(
.
!
( .
!
0 C, C& & $ $ (# $ &(
# , .
<
(
8A"& 8 4)
+& 5 (';( &
# # # , $ " =& "C""
" " $& ""> $ # , ) ("#
"" (3( ( ""
" " #" " # # "
& $ $( $# $ # ,
%
( # " 8A"
"& 8 4< + +& 5( ) ( # 8A"& 8(" 2 (7 ( ( %
%
(;
""
" "( #"
"
( & " # 7 0
( 6$# (
( 8A A"& 8( ';( " " +<"
" $(
% ( " " #
"
$ $ $ 7 ( :
#&( ( & # , (
"& (
.
(
" $ ," 0 (
##
"&& &( (
& A "
$
( " $ & $ ("( $(
$ (
6 $#(
.
( 8A"& 8 4<
+& 5(';( $ , , 2+& 1;#(# ,
.
!
(;( ( ) , ( & ( # "2
( 8 4 5( 9 ( $;
#" $2
! "
#
$
% %&' ()' ( * +,-- ./0-.-12 3 45
" ) 3 45
" 5
$ !
*
*
" +,2-812 ,0...-12 5 5
$
""
"
"
* 5
" 5 " $* 5
* ,/ /0-.-12 + 3 "
65 !
*
+.'7 &'
'$ " 5 " $
" 8
$
5 55 " 6 +900 8.- -11
&
$
&' "
&.202.--/
$ :
:
"
* 55+.02 20/ .--/ )5
55
,-01,0 000$ )5 5 5 ; ) ) 65
"<
5 *
"
(,( ( +./2 ,/0/, ,00.
5 < !
*
$
"
$ < " 3 45 5
" " +,2- ,0...-12
:
* ) < * = > +.91?2 ,002,00. & & ) ;" * 6 65 !
*
<
=> +.9,@2 ,002,00.& ) ;" * 65 <
= > +-/ /@. .-02,00. +.
.0@.20101,00. 5
"
" 5 * 5 :
5 ; )
.20@,00,'
'
' ' $ " ,?0-.-12 ./0@,00,
$* 85
5
" 5
() 5 5
55 .-2.A $ 5
B
6( # #"# $ " !
%
.
% ) (
"$#& $ # # ( #
# & $( # # B %435 45
8$ $ ) B B ( 4 = = B
>5 29 0
(
$ ()4 4(
.
3( $ = =
"& & ">
)( "$ #& $ $ #(
$&" "
3
3( # "( & $
"$
0 $ ( #&( "
( ( "$;
# ("
( $ $
## (
$ "
0 $
"$ ( #
0
"
( ( #
$ ( & "
"
&
; $(
$( B ( $
E"( # #($& " $" &
) "( (#&
#$
&
;
; ( #&( "
$
!
.
="
$ #
>(
" 0 ""
( ,$
$ ($
"
2$ (; 7 ((#
& ()) )( &
4 4
5 5 ",
.
0(
( ! $ % ( # (""
( & #
$$, ( &$
, 4)A2%5( $ ,$ 4?" (
() A23(# &
$ ,$
(#" ,
# $ )
+& ( ,$(#"
%
.
07 0 ( 2 -
-
.(& (&
& $(
% "
"
$""
" "
"+$
8""
6
#& D
& "( " $ $ $ !
%
!
.
6 # ( $ " (7 0 $ $# 29
!
0 " #
# =
" &$>
" $ ( $ $ !
% !
.
( # # " &
;
()+ +( 0( $ !
% 3
%%#
.%
&# ( $3
%% 3
% % ( ..
&#
$ .
% % !
.
( .!
& # 0
.!
&# ( (
&# # &# (# "
"$
% 0 & "
$ (
822 #$ # & # 822 ( #"
" %
(
#"
& & # ( # & (
"( $ .
% % %
$
!
.
#
="
$ # >
) ($ # &,$
:"(1 )
1"
"
"
" "
$
" (
(
"
" 0
( #,$
()9 9( "
( "
,$
"
#
$
&"
# "
" B&
,$
"2 .- * "
" 5 * * 5 ' "
$* &
'
5 " :
: $ ' * $
: 5 5
0..0.-12&
" 5 *
5
5 "
: ' $ : '
' 5 " ""
"
" "
!5 7 &
'
#
" *$ * ;" : * ' ;" "
5
' $" " "
5 $ : '
* $
* "
5 ' ;5 5
5 5 "
"" "
()5 5( 5 ' 7&'
"
"& 5 ' $* $ '"
' $
5 5 ""
55 " $ $
$ &
$ ' ' 5
'
5 ,,
' .-?/.-12'5
$ 5 ,/0- .-12 & " 5 5 * *
5
: * 0..0.-12 2'
$ " $" '
"
5 ./0..- -11' ,@09.-11 .001.- -11'
5
8 "
' *'* '55 "
: 5"
5
& "
5
,00,' *
" $ 5
7 &
'
'
5 )5 3 ' " ' $ .001.-11 .-0-,000' .,
' *
' 5
:
5" 5 +
" $ '$
* :
5" 5 '"$
()- -( ,0 $ :
5 .@09.-11 .001.-11 ; (? (2' $
;
;" * $
!
*
' &
$'.?0/.-11'" $5
'
" 5 * 5
'
$ = ' "
5 5 B 5
' 5 "
*
$ ' '
5 : ' $
: 5 .0 001.-11'
.,
& &
$
*
$'
" 6 +900 .-11
5 ' 5 ' $* *
* :
" 5 '
5
$ $"
5
5 "
* ' $ * 5 "
' $" "
" $ &
$ "
""
' " 5 "
" ' 5
():
:(
: '
5
5 "
)
' 5 ' $
' ' *
: '
'
"
' 5"
.,
$ .-11 ,000' " $ *
$ " '"" " 5 5 ' :
'
5 "
$ 5 "
8 5 '
5
.?0/.-11
$
&
$'
5 :
'
* "
5
5 "
,.
' *
" 5 "
5
5 " ' ;" ./
5 *
7&'
' 5 " 5 C
$ "5
5 * '
"
5 '
.?0/.-11
D ' 5
' "
' * '"$
' $ " *
' '
()3 3( 5"
5 "
"
" ;
,, & "
5
5
$ " *
5
'
'
"
' $* "
"
5 " 5 '
" ' *
* *
* " 5 $ " .F " 7$ '
5 ./0-,00/
* " '$ 5
E$ "5
5
5* '
$ 5" "
*
" '* E E : ./ /8.,
*
"
5 ' * '" * * "
5
$ " * '
'5
5 '
*$ $ $ 5 $
"
$ 55 $
$ " 5
* A' 5
' " 5 5
5 ' 5 "
* ' "
*
' " " "
();
;( 5
5 5 ' *
5
' *
$ 5
$ " * *
& ' $ $ ' "
5 '
$ *$;5 ,9 " 5 "
5 "
*
"
' ,/0-,00,'
9.0/,009& &
5 $ * $ 5 $ "
'
'
5" "
'
55
'
#
* $ *
"
5
5 " $"
5 "
' 55
* * " 5 '
* ' 5 " " 5
* $5
'
""
" ,@ *
;
5 * "
* &
$'.?0/.-11' * "
' $* ' $ *
*
' "
5 " : ' * 5
$ *
&
;
;" $ $
(), ,(
5 "' &
$ " '
5 : ' "' " * $ 5
$ 5 '
"
" ';
;"5 * 5
./
*
'
" 5
" * $ &
&
$ .?0/.-11 * '
5
4 '
5 $* 5 '$ *
: ' "
$
" &
$ & 5 $ $"
: 0-.
.0,000' $ $ $ 7& &
' 5 )5 ,-01,000* '" ' 5
' "
: '$ "
*
' ,00,'
$
$
:
: 5 .-0-,000
'
" 5
"
5
.-0-,000 5 " : ' .20@,00,' " 5
5
'
' " 5
$ 5
'
$
(+4 4( ,/ & " < )
' " 5 '
5
"$
4 5
,?0-.-120 010-,000'
$
' * '
".-11 1 ,000' 5
5 *
5" : '
" )5 '
5 0-.0,00 00',0.0,000,?.,,000 "'
: D* "
$" :
,00,' 5 *
$
$ " 5
' 0-.0,0 000 "' 5
' ,?0-.-12 010-,000 0-.0,000 .?0@,00,' " $ C "
$ * '
$ * 5 $
5 ' ,? * $*' 5 $
$ " $./
' $ $ 5 * *
5 & 5
'"
" C '
,2 ) " 5
*
5
'
* 5 ' * $ "
"
(+) )( $ = 5 '
" = .0'0008 ' $5
>) * "
&
5"
" $ $ 5 5 ' *
"
:
' .F" B )
&
# &
; &# "
&
; 3.
0 ,$
2; ; " & & "C& " "
0
(# # $ $ $ 3 6 &#
&( $ &
$ 3!
" 45( (
6
+)0)40+4 ) F 1
8 6 8 4+5
;C G
B G C- C-