← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1793/2014dismissed

State Of Haryana And ORS. v. Cosco (India) Ltd.

2016-04-28Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan3 pages

         !! "#$! %!&& $'

()*+

$!  , -.#.%/ 0 1   

      



 

 */ 2 * 3 3   2 * 3 33  " # %!/ *"$4. 5!!36$"7$8 &5!9,4-$!  % "$'8$"9$%$ *"$"#6::$";$'8,4-$!  "!6 " #&%, %!  $< #6 .%,$'  6 ;".!& !.!.% .' ,=9!6 " #&%, %!6$4.%:= %$''; , =9!6 ' $"% ,3.%:'  5,: 8!6 ", "6$#= %-6$'' %: ,=9 .'.%:!6 &" # %!.%!"$>-5"!$&& $' 6 " '.

-'$.7 ,=9!6 " #&%, %!;$#!6$!.!;$# %!.!' ,!

" .:6!  #5=#.,9.%  ! "7#    !6  &'.-9 %!.

. ,  =9!6  4 "%7 %!  %

 16 .##5 #5:6!!= "$.# ,=9!6 $&& ''$%!#.#!6$!$#& "!6 &'.-98  !6  " #&%, %!  ;$#  " ?5." ,  !  &",5-  -6$%:     '$%,  5# - "!.

.-$! 6 #$7 6$4.%:%!= %&",5- ,=9.!8.!;$#%! %!.!' ,! $%9" '.

65:6 .!# -$# ;$#  .' , % $--5%!  %%> 5"%.#6.%: 

" ?5.#.! ,-57 %!#8.!$4$.' , " 7 ,9 $&& $'?5.! = '$! ,'9$%,# !6 " 4.#.%86 %- 8!6 ' $"% ,3.%:'  5,: 6$,!"$4 '' ,= 9%,6.#

  <5".#,.-!.%$%,$''; ,!6 ;".!& !.!.% %  !6  !6 "  6$%,8  ' $"% ,  -5%# '  "  !6  " #&%, %!

#5=7.!! ,!6$!5%.! !6 " #&%, %!.#'-$! ,;.!6.%!6 75%.-.&$'$" $! ;$## !5&;$9=$-@.%!6 9 $"

$ ! ": !!.%:& "7.##.% "7!6 '-$'

$5!6".!. #6$%:  '$%,5# $##5-6;$#%!" ?5." ,.%!6$!$" $$!!6$! !.7 $#.!;$#%!-%4 "! , "7$:".-5'!5"$'"!6 '$%,, .% , "$%9 !6 "5# !.%,5#!".$' 5#  6 " ;$#%-%,.!.%.%!6 &'.-9 "

&",5-!.% -6$%:  '$%, 5# - "!.

.-$!  %  $-!8!6 -$#  !6 " #&%, %!;$#" -77 %, , ":"$%! #5=#.,986; 4 "8 "!6 " $#%# = #!@%;%!!6 $5!6".!. #8!6 #$7 ;$#, -'.% ,6 " #&%, %!6$, &",5- ,  $''  !6  " ?5.#.!  - "!.

.-$! #  "7  !6  *5%.-.&$'  5%-.'A "&"$!.%85":$%6 -$# & "!$.%#!!6 9 $" B>14 % "!6 #5=# ?5 %!!6 " !8!6 #5=#.,9;$##$%-!.% ,$%,&$.,!!6 " #&%, %! %!6 =$#.# #$7 ,-57 %!#  ! "6 $".%:' $"% ,-5%# ' "!6 &$"!. #8; ,%! .%, $%9" $#%!.%! "

" .%!6 &" # %!$&& $',5=!8!6 " .#%-%,.!.% .%  !6  &'.-9  " :$",.%:  &",5-!.%    -6$%:    '$%,  5#  - "!.

.-$! 8 6; 4 "8  $#& "!6 &'.-98$&&'.-$!.%6$#!=  .' ,%&" #-".= , "7($+%  !6 ,-57 %!#!= $!!$-6 ,.%! "7#!6 "  .# .!6 "

-6$%:    '$%,  5#  - "!.

.-$!  "  2  =< -!.%   "!.

.-$! 2  "7  !6 -7& ! %!$5!6".!9% $-!8!6 " #&%, %!6$,&",5- ,2=< -!.%  "!.

.-$! 2,$! ,1   "7*5%.-.&$'5%-.'85":$%8;6.-6;$# #!$! ,!= %! "7!6 -7& ! %!$5!6".!9;.!65!$##.:%.%:$%9" $#%8 %- $,7.!! ,'9!6 5%.! !6 " #&%, %! $''#;.!6.%!6 75%.-.&$''.7.!# 6 '.- %- :"$%! ,=9*5%.-.&$'"&"$!.%85":$%85%, "3 -!.%

  !6 $"9$%$*5%.-.&$'"&"$!.%-!8

;$#$'#&",5- ,6 -$#  !6 " #&%, %!;$# 4 %" -77 %, , ":"$%! #5=#.,9=9!6  % "$'  *$%$: "8  .#!".-!  %,5#!". #   %!" 8  5":$%  !  ." -!"  

%,5#!". #8$"9$%$86; 4 "8!6 #$7 ;$#%!$&&"4 ,%' :$''9%%> C.#! %!" $#%# % $-!8!6 " #&%, %!.# 4 %&$9.%:65# !$C!!6 *5%.-.&$'5%-.'A*5%.-.&$'"&"$!.%85":$%$#!6 5%.!.##!$! ,! = ;.!6.%!6 75%.-.&$''.7.!#!;$## !5&;$9=$-@.%!6 9 $"

!.# $'#%!.%,.#&5! !6$! "!6 & ".,#5=# ?5 %!!6 " !8!6 " #&%, %!

  ;$#:"$%! ,#5=#.,9;.!6%-6$%: .%-."-57#!$%- #* $%.%:!6 " =9!6 " #&%, %! 5'

.'' ,$''!6 -%,.!.%# %- !6$!.##8; ,%! .%,$%9" $#%!.%! "

" ;.!6!6 .7&5:% ,", "&$## ,=9!6 ' $"% ,3.%:'  5,: 6 " .#%7 ".!.%!6 &" # %!$&& $'6 #$7 .#8$--",.%:'98,.#7.## , ($< #6 .%,$'+  5,:  ($".%, "3.%:63.,65+  5,: 

0 1 7@