← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/338/2016dismissed

The Commissioner Of Income Tax Chandigarh v. M/S Ocm India Ltd Amritsar

2018-05-09Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan12 pages

Gurbax Singh 2018.06.01 15:08  

            

         !"#"$%&%'( )*+  ,"--%&&%'".'$-" / 0, '#%1 .,          2233"44 '! 5&

6&  '#% 7%-%!"#  #+,,", .! +-.%!& .          2 "&3'#"'!  (  87

 09

  7    0  87

 0 00   

               

  : )9;- . %!! 4+  1.

!  "" #

$%$&'!! (&$)     *   ( * ()&   ! " *+ $%)$ ,  - ./      $( ) (&$( +

0  1  ! " *+  *1 " 2 " ,   - *1./  !* #

3$',  /4(&$$    "  (&&'&% "     15  

-67 81!* *   " 

  !*, /     9 

       $%37 ! " *+  $%)$   "     3:;:(3%34<.

      "1  =  (& $ (&&%            4 9 ! >" ?*

  "  "     "   

  1"

3:;:(3%34  *   1   "   " +     *1   9  1

            *=      1     *

  9     +   

   "

 3:;:(3%34 1         

@+   $%37 *  "  1 +  $%37  "  3;$(:&;4    *=    "

):%;:$4    (&$,$ /   

 1         1      ! " *+ , / A!*, /B  C  $'

(&$$ +

(!*, / 1    #      1  

*1 C $( ) (&$( +

0*1"  1!*, / 6   :

! 1    $%37@+ ,/      -      1      7  "   1   ! D(&&$  "1  ,  1          $%3=/ 1

     "      "    " "  "  1 5  1 "

  "+     ++++++++++EEEEEEEEEEEE

@+ FG     -/- 1

 ."

1 1  1

   , 1    /    1 

                1   1   ++++++EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

. 9  $%37 +  1  1     1       " 1  -  1

 .

 * +  -  1

 .   "  "@+  

  - 1

 ."  1 1  1

  ,/ , 1   /H ,/         1  

  ,/       1    1  !  +" @+ ,/  $%37

 1  ""   1   ) 7  I            +"     "    1       >            J "   

       A(&$&B0(:!* (&:,K/  

      A(&$&B0(: !* $3',=/        

 

 A(&$$B00(!* (::,K/       

  ,(&$$/ (33*  ,/ $': !    "# "     $

  ,(&&:/%'**D,D/$  1 ;

!  %  ,/      ?

" !          "" 

"" "          1 =

  *    " 1 =

 "1 "   "      "   "          1    "  *  "

   "         $:L     1 1 "   =

     "      " " !

 "   $%3  @+ ,/   !     '

!   %,/=7   +"         1    1       !    * 1    1    1

         $%37   @+   *       1              11 !  ,! /              11   1 "  , / 1    "   1        * 7       J " *1            1   1 11 !

  % ,/ * J     =7     %,/ *7    %

,/ +    J " =K7   $& >   J "  & #      $

  & !

$%;;  $(;: ' &     ( 

 ,(&&(/ (:; !*  (&( ,?J /  

   )

*+ ,(&$$/ 0(( !*  (:0 ,2 "1 /  , !          ,(&&$/(3%!* $'),K/ $$ 7 1    ' &   %,/ *1   ?J 7          +     5   1     $%37      "   " "?

"    "   ?

"  "  ?J "     $%'; ,   $%'; /  !       " 1   "       $%';       + - 1

 . $%37

* 1  -!       1        #    -

1

 . @+   $%37          " 1   

1 

   1"   1

    "    $%37  ! 

     1       ""     "  

  "     "  "       1 1 $%37 *      @+   "  1 1  1      ,/     ,  1   / ,/ 

 1 

 ,/           1   *"   1    "1@+ ,/   $%37  !       "  "1   1    "1

      "      "     " ,   /  1 "     1    

    "      "    1   "      "   - .1 *J  

 1 

 6 "   " "

 "    "       ,1  "?

"   "/1 "       1  

 !     1       

   1  8      " 1     "        ?J "     $%';        +  - .  -1

 .   $%37   ! "+  $%)$  * " 

""  $3(&&( "! " + 9 *= 3 "1    * 9 "1 5    5  $% (&&(,+-=.  /1 * 9 "1      8  5 . $(

  "+" 1  "

 3:;:(3%34      -* * 

. 1   "       +    *  9 "

1           @+      $%37    "  *= (&$,$ /     9  1   !*, /           "

    3:;:(3%34  1J   *=   $%37 1  41

        1   @+      $%37  * !*, / 11 "

 $ '3            4      1    " 5     *  9  1 J        $%37    @+        1      14 "4     "   " 4     *   1!*, /

-! 81" 

   

8" 

       1 1    *       1     "

  3:;:(3%34  1J   *=    $%37 1   41

   1

8     @+  1    $%37    !    

     $00,)/ " 

" "81

  +"            1

       * 

"  1     1                   1

   1       1

    1 1  "

  $ '3                      4   8   1      " 5

         G 

    11      1

 1   " "" 1" #

1       " "                 "  9     1    8  

   "1 "1     "41          "

   8      "   "   !      "

"

    1 ""             "            !"   

    "    1         7   " "  "+               

  G!    1 G 

8  " 

   $%37    $ '3  11  N   !     "      1     J      

    J     $%37 @+        1   "  14 "4      "  " 4   

     " :0;((:'4 (&$,$/   (&$,$ / ! "*+ $%)$1 1   1  $%37 @+ " 1    " 1 + 1  "             4  4" . $0 *     1 " 1  *1     1  -6      *             1"

3:;:(3%34   "1 " *+    " " 1  11 9 

  * "  1  9        "   $%37  #        "  1   1    1   * 9          !    "# "  

$

- .//0 12

- - 3          * 9  1    !    "# "  

$ ,/  !    "# "  

$,/1

"     "  1          1      * 

"1 *= *= 

41 1 *=

"1 4$00     (&= (&&( 1"       *=1 "1  =   1   "  1 $D (&&( $% =  (&&(  1  G "   1      1   1 1 1  "

3;:((%(%4 7    *=         

 "    * 1    

"  "    1 

 " "   1 1   !* * D 2     *  "  1

          

 !1

      

 1  !* * D 2    ,(&&:/ %'**D,D/$ * "1       

1

   *>      

  1 > !*, /1  !  "             "    $%37    9      

   +        >  !*, /        9  * >  !*, /      " :0;((:'4     (&$,$/    (&$,$ /       1    1  6 "  > !*, /   "    *   

" . $3 !  1  1!*, / *111                    4            1 

 9  J  @+  $%37 >   1 1      $:

!     1  1 5          5"

: )9;- . %!! 4         $!%'1,%";&!%$"  

)*+      ":%'#".0%'1,,%'#&  <1&8        ;#1"