← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4739/2011dismissed

Mahabir v. Kamlesh Rani And ANR

2017-02-01Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages

 

    

  

      

           !"

#   "$

!!!!

"   #$  %& 

 &

    $

' (& 

 &

    !!!!

  

)  *  

+           %    ,

  

 

-. /  

  0

% &

$  (  / % ,



     /    1  0

%  *0     +& 

$  (

 2 / &  '

!

 *   

+         

       ,    %  



%%&

% %/ 

 

 (34 (  

  % 



5%/

&(

(    (34 (  

  %



  %  

  

!!

  & 

  6

 '

& 7 '

&#% ,  '%&) ) &

$ &  

8...&  %9:

 / ( 

 (%

 !

 



  





  

 



  

) 

 

    

 

    

(

 (

 3 4 5(

(



/  %/& 

, ( / 

 ) 

     (        %    /   

  / .;.   /      

 

 / 

)  

(

     (  !

  (&(%  / 



    %

  

%   !

&  ( 

     (   

8...   / 

&     ) 



 !

  %      /   (       

 '

<2  '%&) &  % :

 /  8 '

9< &

 !

  

" # "

$ 

  

  

  

# "

$  

 % 

 &"



!!

= 

    %&   1

 

 

 (% !

'   





 )

 " * )

 



"

" " 

) + (











 ( '



, -..

  







)

 )

) 

" 

(

, -./ 0   



(( +   ) ) )

"

 

(

, -./

1   





))





" 

)

"



) , -./ 2

) 

 5    "7(   %   ( 

  /*35"+6  (   ( 

    /  

8...*35"+  

    /35") ( (35"

  3 4    & 



/ 

5

  3   /

 

& 



5  

 ( 3 4&

( &     ( =    & 

  5

  7&( &(   %

357<&         

 (       )  1

 

,

 

      !

 2 $

(  3



"

3 )

 ) 

) 



) 3



)

4.0 

 

 (  + 



 

"





" + /'

 

)

&

4"

 !

(  3



)  4.0

"   



 ) 



)  

 4.









 

)+ 

)

  

* 

!8!









*5)""   

"

(  ( "



 )

 



) 

 ( + 5  











8  



3

+  



)""

   + ) 





)""

 + " ) "+ )

"

 







 "+ 

 

(







9" + 



3

(  5  

( :



)""

 )

(

)""

   



) 

 ( 

 







; ) 

  



  (  

 5 

 )



 )









7 ; 3

3

  )

 



 " * )  

)  







"



 "  " 

)""

"

(  ( + +

(  + 5 





 

+ "

    

 )+



 



3

+ (   

)""









  

" * )

  + 



<  

5 

 )"

  )   

   



* )

 3 "

( )+



 "( )"(

* )

 

(

 

) 



) 3

 



 

"+ * )  ) 



 )



 ) (











: 9)) +

'

) 

3 





 

 %%  % 

  ,



 

& 

    6 (  &   (   ,



  -. > 

  

 &  

    %   

 1



!9!

? 

 

  %

  *35"+  

/     

  5         &  (               5 6 

 %

  

&  /& 

    "7  / @    "

(  

   /   &   

 &     ( 

 ,

   / 6 A   1

           !"#  $%%  &'&     

! 5   

  (  

   /     

 

    6      

  (   

     

   $ ( %     %@  "

( 

  / 

/ (  (  /   ( %

  

 /  

  6 

 %

  *35"+   /      & (     &   5  =    & 

 

   & (  %  ,



 6 A   1

 

 ( )($ *+$(+

 &!",# "%+-#.,/&%

   

 

% 

/  

  (       1

   :



(& ,  

1"1    5  6 

 %

    %/ ,



 

!-!

 / 

  () 

 

    

 :

/&    %          *35"+    /  !

&    

 /7 ! 5  35"    (      

  35"&  %/ 

 / 

  ((

%  *35"+ >    

 

   ? 

  

        

  

 (% !

=>   





 ) 





"

+ (( 3 +



)

   )+ 

)

 ), =>   

* "

)

 ) 



"

3 +

(() " 

3 )

 )

 

" 

( )

3 )

3



 ) "()  ) 



)

, =>   

"(  * "

)





3 

, =3>    + 3 + 



5

(



)  ) "

+ 

5((

 " 

 "

    

, =3>   

? 6 



3

 +  (  )3  



 " * )  "+ * ) )

 + 





 

) "

+ 

( 5( 

,   '

!

  

    ,    %     !

 

%%&

% %/ 

 

 (34  %     ( 

  (

!!

   (

 

 &  

(

 (

 A3A A4A/ 5%(

(<

( ( % 

 

)     % %

( 1 34   *35"+     %

 "7&(   %  ( 

  /& 

& 

 &    / 

 

   *

A  +  % ( 

  /         (      

            

      $ ( % &   

 6  ( 



 :



     $ ( % 

   (      (      $ ( % 

   

    ) 

 & ,

   * +        



     

:

  %   ) %



  

 

   35"! (   

 ((

%  , 7          

 

 !



  !

  &   %/  / 

  (   !

  % %(

 %/

%          

&         

  ( ) 

 &1



  / %/ ,



  / 

  (

!;!

) 

   % 

  

 /  

   (         ( 



 '

 :



(     %      &

%/& 

  "$

   ,  7   $%<  B C <'

7     B C <'