High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1339/2015allowed

Kanav Arora And ANR. v. Panjab University And ORS

2015-09-11Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri6 pages

"#$$% '

("")**""+"#,$* $# $*& -$*&.&

"/"0

#1"+#,$*& $&2+$#& 3'

43 5555 43 55(

*$&$#'

3*"60 *5 6,3"7 89+)%"#$ *#,$"22$77"#& 555 9 3* :"* - )$89 +)%"#$ ,"& 2.# "22$"*"%$ 0$,"7#,$*$&2+$#&$,"&&.0:

##$+:$:+"#$+; <

&&.$+ 01 #,$ ,"+ 6"*, +:

$%, %"7 +.%"# $2"*#:$# "++*$&&$+ # #,$ 2"7 ,"+ 6"*, 77$6$ *%, #$%#.*$9,"+ 6"*,=*$&2+$#>,$&":$ &#"8$ *$%*+ $"*+7$"*$+%.&$7*#,$2"*# $& , & $##$*& "#$# 22$"7 ,"& 0$$ 7$+ 01 #,$ "22$77"#&("")**""+:7"*"+"6"

&##,$/.+6:$#"+ *+$*+"#$+ 2"&&$+01#,$7$"*$+5 67$.+6$ !

,$"22$77"#&"227 $+*"+:

&& ##,$"%,$7* *%, #$%#=4?*%,4?*&,*#>.*&$ & @.

$&A%77$6$&

6 #,$ ,"+ 6"*, 77$6$ *%, #$%#.*$9 ,"+ 6"*, =477$6$4B*&,*#>=*$&2+$#>#,*.6,%%*+ 6# #,$*:"# *%,.*$? ;#,$*$&2+$#?77$6$9 #,$77$6$%+.%#& )$1$"*&?*%,+$6*$$%.*&$9C, %, " "#$+##,$ "/"0

#19,"+ 6"*,=*$&2+$#>

#,$"%.7#1$& 6"+

$*#&,$##"7&"%# $+ #"8$ &#*$6#, #,$ &$"#& * #,$ *%, )$ 1$"*& %.*&$ #,$ *$&2+$#B77$6$ &;

&$"#&%%*+ 6##,$ *:"# 0*%,.*$#,$&$;

&$"#& %7.+$+ &$"#&"77##$+01#,$3

&#*1 .:" $%.*&$& $)$72:$# =$2"*#:$# 5$%+"*1 "+ 6,$* +.%"# >9 )$*:$# + " * #,$ :

$$& 5#"#$&A

$** $&+$ "% $& #,$ *:"# 0*%,.*$#,$*$&2+$#?

77$6$9#,$ &$"#&*:

$$&#,$5#"#$&A

$** +$ "% $&"*$:$# $+"& %7.& )$ #,$ ;

&$"#& C, %, & #,$ &"%# $+ &#*$6#, C$)$*9 "%%*+ 6##,$7$"*$+%.&$7*#,$2"*# $&9#,$&$ )$&$"#& &,.7+0$)$*"+"0)$;

&$"#&"&2$*#,$+%.:$#&#,"#,")$ C0$$*$%$ )$+#,$*C*+&9#,$*$"*$;

&"%# $+&$"#& *#,$*%, )$1$"*&+$6*$$%.*&$ #,$*$&2+$#B 77$6$ "+ &$"#& "*$ * #,$ :

$$& 5#"#$&A

$** $& +$ $# #$%, %"7 $+.%"# "% $& , & "%# $) +$#*:#,$7$##$*=$@.*$?>C* ##$01#,$ 2"7 #,$*$&2+$#B77$6$##,$3

$&.*%$ $)$72:$# =$2"*#:$# 6,$* +.%"# > ,$ 3

&#*1

.:" $&.*%$$)$72:$#=$2"*#:$# 6,$*+.%"# > ) +$ #&7$##$*+"#$+ =$@.*$?>,"&%7"* $+#,"# #,$&$"#&"77##$+01#,$:

&#*1 "*$*&#.+$#&#,$*#, "&#$* 5#"#$&A

$** $& "+ * %$*#"

#,$* "6$% $&A:

&#* $&"+"*$&.2$*.:$*"*1 "#.*$,$&$&$"#&9

# &:$# $+9"*$)$*"+"0)$#,$&"%# $+&#*$6#,"++ # "$%# #,$ ##"7 &#*$6#,A #"8$ #,$ &#.+$#& #,$ *$&2+$#?77$6$# &.*#,$*&#"#$+ #,$&"

+7$##$* +"#$+ ! =$@.*$ ?> #,"# %77$6$A.

#1 %:2$#$###"8$""22*2* "#$+$% * 6.2#,$)"%"# &$"#& .# #& ##"7 &"%# $+ &#*$6#, C$)$*9 #,$ &.2$*.:$*"*1&$"#&#,$3

&#*1%.7+710$"77##$+01#,$ :

&#*1,$7$##$*=$@.*$?>*:#,$ 2"7*$&2+$# B77$6$##,$3

$&.*%$&$)$72:$# =$2"*#:$# 6,$*+.%"# >"+#,$*$271) +$7$##$*+"#$+ ! =$@.*$?>*:#,$3

$&.*%$& $)$72:$#=$2"*#:$# 6,$*+.%"# >C$*$#0$*$#,$ 7$"*$+5 67$.+6$C,$#,$ :2.6$+*+$*+"#$+

C"&2"&&$+ ,$"22$77"#&9 # &"+:

##$+%"&$#,$2"*# $&&#"+ ##$+# #,$*%,%.*&$ #,$*$&2+$# ?77$6$2* *##,$7"&#%.#+"#$ $

$7"&# +"#$* &&."%$ $6 .:0$*01#,$

#1D0$& +$& #,$1,")$"22$"*$+ #,$ *&#"+&$%+&$:$&#$*$@":

& #,"&0$$%7"* $+#,"##,$ *&#&$:$&#$*$@":

C"&#"8$ 01 #,$ "22$77"#& " 2* )"#$ %77$6$ "+ #,$*$"#$* #,$1 C$*$ ##$+ #,$*$&2+$#?77$6$"&#,$*$

C$*$)"%"#&$"#& #$*:&#,$:$:+"#$+; < "++*$&&$+01 #,$,"+ 6"*,+:

$%, %"7+.%"# $2"*#:$## #,$ 2"7#,$*$&2+$#B77$6$9#,"#,"&0$$27"%$+ *$%*+9 # &:$# $+ *$6"*+ 6#,$&.0/$%#*$&$*)"# &$"#& +$6*$$7$)$7#$%, %"7%.*&$&*5#"#$&A

$** 7"%8 6 &.%, "% $& "+* *$ 6"+#,$* %"#$6* $& &#.+$#&*"%"+$:

%&$&& ;? 9#,"##,$77$6$ &*$$# "+:

# &#.+$#& .2# #,$ &"%# $+ &#*$6#, "+ #,"# #,$ :

9 "1901#,$)$*:$#+ ""*$)$*"+"0)$

# ,$*$*$9$) +$#71":

&#"8$,"+%%.**$+ 0*%,.*$

%.# 6 #,$ &"%# $+ &#*$6#, ;

&$"#& * #"8$ &#.+$#&##,$*%, )$1$"*&+$6*$$%.*&$01 6

&$"#&#,$3

$&.*%$$)$72:$#=$2"*#:$# 5$%+"*1 "+ 6,$* +.%"# >9 )$*:$# + " * :

$$&5#"#$&A

$** $&+$ "% $&,$&$ "%#C$*$#0$$@%7.+$+*:#,$&"%# $+ &#*$6#,;

&$"#&"& & $) +$#*:#,$)$*:$#+ "

%::.

%"# +"#$+ =$@.*$?>9C,$*$ #,"& 0$$%7"* $+#,"##,$&$"#&*5#"#$&A

$** $&+$

#$%, %"7 $+.%"# "% $& "*$ )$* "+ "0)$ #,$ &"%# $+ &#*$6#, 0$ 6 &.2$*.:$*"*1 &$"#& $& +$&9 #,$ ,"+ 6"*, +:

9 $%, %"7 +.%"# $2"*#:$# ,"& ) +$ %::.

%"# +"#$+ ;< "++*$&&$+ # #,$ 2"7 *$&2+$#B77$6$,"&.*#,$*:"+$ #%7$"*#,"##,$&"

+ 77$6$ &*$$#"+:

#&#.+$#&.2##,$&"%# $+&#*$6#,"+

&9 "19 *$&2$%#&$"#&*$&$*)$+ +$6*$$7$)$7 #$%, %"7 %.*&$& * 5#"#$&A

$** $& 7"%8 6 &.%, "% $&"*$)$*"+"0)$#,$&"%# $+&#*$6#, ,$%"7%.7"# &+$01#,$7$"*$+5 67$.+6$ &01

6 #,$ &$"#& * :

$$& 5#"#$&A

$** +$ "% $&C #, #,$;

&"%# $+ &#*$6#,&$"#&, &C"&+$ "%%*+"%$C #,#,$*:"# *%,.*$? ;,$2& *$&2$%#C, %, &9,C$)$*9C + $*$##$*:&#,$*+$*2"&&$+01#,$7$"*$+5 67$.+6$9 0#,#,$"22$77"#&,")$0$$?&.

#$+*"+:

&& *%, %.*&$#,$*$&2+$#?77$6$ ) $C#,$"%##,"##,$,"+ 6"*,+:

,"&C%)$1$+#,"##,$*$&2+$#?77$6$ &*$$# "+:

#&#.+$#&.2#&"%# $+&#*$6#,"+:

9 "1901 )$*:$#+ ""*$)$*"+"0)$ #9#,$"22$77"#C, *"8& "# &$* "7 !! & C #, #,$ :$* # "+ & $# #7$+ # 0$ "+:

##$+,$*"8 6"22$77"# &"#;%%*+ 6# 5,:"*- )$89+)%"#$7$"*$+.&$7*#,$*$&2+$#&9,$

&"7&7 "07$#0$"+:

##$+ "6"

&##,$&$"#&")"

7"07$+.$# :

6*"# ,"*) 5"@$"D 0$& +$&9 0#, #,$ "22$77"#& C$*$ ##$+0$*$#,$%.#+"#$ ,$*$*$9 #,$ :2.6$+ /.+6:$# "+ *+$* +"#$+

! &"*"& #C"&2"&&$+ ! &&$# "& +$,$"22$"7#,$"22$77"#&("")**""+:+"*"+

&"77C$+"+#,$1&,"77%# .$ #,$ *%.*&$*%,"&$ #,$: $"22$77"#"77&C #, #,$:$* # &$"#&"+ "22$77"#9"%%*+ 6#7$"*$+%.&$7*#,$*$&2+$#&

%" 0$ "+/.&#$+ "6"

&# #,$ :

6*"# &$"#& "& #,$1 C$*$ ##$+"6"

&#)"%"#&$"#&0$*$#,$%.#+"#$

%&#& =555 > =5( >

,.:

8"A":

#$' ,$#,$*#0$*$$**$+##,$ $2*#$*'$&A