M/S Glaxo Smithkline Consumer Healthcare Ltd v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax
GURBAX SINGH 2018.12.06 11:49
!"!#$% &'"( )*+!
,-(!# #".+ /
( , / 0!+!
1122 (( # 3" ""!"
# ++!""!# /# + ) 1
"2# # &$ 40& *5 & &06 40& * *&
5 0
! ""
"# 7 85.+ /&!
(6 $ % & '
& "(% ) *+, -+$./+//+0 /,1 -++0 "
2 &"' 3(% ) *+, -+$.
- (% ) *+, -+$. & &
4
-.+ (3 % ' $5.$ 6 7 89
"
/ * -+$. '
,
&(3% '
%& # "
6 7 %& 89 (% ) *1/:#2!:-++- 3 $551450 3" " & ;
4 9< 3 %& 64 9
" .$5,*./.:4
=! % ' ,$ , $551 " 3 *,>
? &9< 3 %& " =! %&
3 ' & 3 *,> ? 9< 3 %& "
"
&
3 6 " 2@&
3 # 9 =! % " '
3 ? ,
(% ) *+, -+$.3 & %
4
&33
"
"3
3 ( 3 3 $551450 -.
$$ $551 " 3 .$+10.$*+:4 %
3
(
=! % 33&& "
& 3
& " 3 " 3
&( # (
: =! % " &
3 % =! % "
'
& 3
& % ' =! %3
3 *,> 3 ' &" !
" 3 ;
' ' & #33 # A' $1, 6$9 # A' $5** 6 7 89 3 " /1/.,-$5:4 =! % -,
3 " .$5,*./.:4 " 3 $$5*5101/:4 3 3 $551450 *,> % ( ;
&3 "
3 $$5*5101/ :4 ' 3 " & " '
& *,>
3& % "= 3 $ - -+++
'
$
$*,6,9 3 $$5*5101/:4 3 *,> " ' &"
3
" 3 &
' " 3 & '
3
3 3 *,> %
3 & #33 (3 % '
9B#(%6 9C" *,>
3 " " &
3 &
3 "
%
3
3 ' &3
$1, 3
;
'
'
&' & " "
.
, -++- '
- #(%6 9 3 " $$5*5101/:4 3 & *,>
""&
& %& ( 3 33 3 & "= &;
" 3 -++$4+- &#(%6 9 " .
, -++- 3 $551450 ""& 3 -++$4+-
& %& % , * -++.;
%& 3 %& > " & %& #;
3 -++$4+- & & 33& =-+ +1 -++1 & %&
4 3 -++$4+- "
4
& D =! % -, 3& *,> +/ +* -+$. '
, %&
3 $551450 3 3 & E
" = &
& > %& %
& #(%6 9 .$5,*./.:4 "
D =! % -, *,>
3 2
&
4
* <
!" ##$ % &%'%%%%'%( ( ) * % % + , -%( .
/%%%% 0( ) * % 0( -%( .
+ %%%% 0
01 % % 0( (+% + , 0( % 0+%%%% 0 0+, , (,+ % '% %0( %/(+ +'%% ,(%/ , % %(+ +%% (%%%%0 ) * % (,%+,%% %(' /'%( 0+ , % ( 2%3+%%(+ +' ) * / /%%%%'%( 0 % (,%
%& 0('45 6! 7 % % 0 %0 0+ ) 8 ) (2%/, (,+ %
+% % +%0 % ,( %- ,%% $( !
9 (2%$(%/ #%%0
, % ( % + % +& '
% % / / %(%
/ %05(:
;:; (% / % 0 (+%%0 0+ + / %% ( ( 0+%%%%$ % % -. % ,0(+ (% %%%%/ % -+ ( % + 1% ( %-./ %% 0%% % + & % , % % % ,(<(% % %/ ( %(/'( 1 %+ (%%( + + = > , % %0 %%% 0( %'% 0+$, 0+ %%%%5? . / (( %%%% +% % % % 0, 0% + ((
%% 3( - 0@A+A %/ %(( '( %((00(%( %
%(%% %0%( &% (' %% 0( % % % (
$, 0 % % % (+0% % 0+ %%%% %
% 'A %&%
&%:%;% 0 % (+0, 0%%>'((/ /, %' % (( 0+$,%(% # 3% ( 2% 3+ -. % %+ & (2%$(%/ #/% + % + % +(,0(
%% % 0 (+ (,+ (( % + ' 0
! (% % %% 30% % , % -. , 0 % % + +0( %0( % (
,% % %
% % ++0( ,( 0(% 1 (%< ,( ' '( % %%0( (0 ( 0 %%'%& %% %%%% ' ' + -.)05(%:
;/:;/:; :; $(
!
9 %% , %%+0% 0+ ( % % ' ,( %0( % 0+ %%%% %( ,( % + + $(%((+ %'% %-. % % % % $, ' %%%% ,
, :%; %
## " #=$# :B;
! " #
"
!=< $=:-;/ */ A % B1 - %%,(+ %% %' % ?(%%%) C %( % (%%% , 0+ %%%% % 0( %%%%%D % /%%%% (, % % %%%%'%(% ( ' ' + ' ,( %C % ( 0 (E (+ % % % %%/A ( ,'(+/ %% / %( % %%%%/ %0( % %%%%> %'+% ( +'( 0 (0(%
3( A (% % % %% 0+ % (% 1 ,' %
= ) * ( 2% :) 5; '% ( (( % ' %(0%%'&% 0( %')$%((+/ 0%% 01 % %%%% '% ( (
'((++ )A, 0 0 ) * %%%%/ '( 0 %% ( ( %(, '( 0 , 0+ , 0
%%%% , % (%
+ '%
% % %
% %0%& (%< ,(
0, %%%%/( '( % %/ 0, %% ((' 0+ %%%% 0+$,F %% ' A % , %%%% ' ,
(+('F +,' +A 0 0 / %( ( % (% A %' % 1 ,' , % ( % + %% ( + + ' ) * ( 2% :) 5; / / %%%% % ( 0 % G ) ((+/
$% & ' !" # $
:-@A;/%%0 %'%'0('% (' (
) * ,% + ''% 0 (%%%(% %'% ( '% % 0+0(% +% %+,%%0 +0(/ %' %%%% '% 0( %
# 6G % % 6G0 0(/ '% % , + 0
% + + &% ' % ' '% % 6G'%
( %'( (+(+'
% ' '% % ' ( %%0(+0 % ,(,%
%45 6(+% 0+( %( $, %% %&%' , %% %%%% + &%/ + '( 0% ,0 , (+%%%%'%(
+&%%%'%( +' %' , ++ , + %/ ' ( %%%% +&%/% %%0( 7 /( %( %%%%%0 %%%%'%%(+& % + %/' '% 0( 1 +%(( %% 65G %%%% '% ( % 65 G/',/ 0+'% ,( % +A%(
9A ( )
## " $!# A, ( %( %/ ' % 0+ ( %( $, 0 ((+ %, 7% % 0+0( + % %+ ,%% 0 +0(/
%' %%%%'% 0( % 65G % % 65G 0 5 0(/'%% /$, + 0 +&%' % ' '% % 65G % '( (+ ( +' %' '%
% /'%%0(+0 % ,G 3 E & ! 2" #
6-+$$9,,*(%$+.6!9
!"
(% ) $,+ -+++ -.
-+$, ! ,' ('( '0+ * % :%; ( , % ( 2%
+%%(+ +' ) * %%%%'( 0( 0 % /%0%(&%% ('% %(% %' , %%%% % % 5, %&(+/ (( % (% ((' % %% 0+0((((%%% 97 85.+ /&!
(: . ;
< += /6% 9& #7 /! ,/.5 .(: >;"4 . ;
< E": " < & "