Haryana Agro Industries Corporation Ltd v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Panchkula




    
 


 !"#"$%&%'(  )* ' +)
'#,&!)%"&)-) !%'.%/%!"# 00--"11 '!

2& //%&&%'")
'$/" 34 '$56,1 %)$1"4 '$56,1 0 "&-'#"'!

  ( 7.

 8
9

 
.

 7.

8 8
   .
 

 

         

   

   


  

       !"

  : *9,/ ) %!! 14

%#  %& '

(  "  
") *" +   , "- .

     ++

*(/#  %& 
") *##$$   $0

.




 )&

1'

+"$

. $$3 .(%

$4(  3'

,5  

"  "

"() " "

 6%$
") *##$$   $  0)) 

") *## $ "

7($

!  $ 3  4(

.   "       .  

"  .

# )(  #!

 "


") *" + 3 ( ##"

"

 ) # ) #" .(  "  3# .  !

" !

"

# $ #" .

 ( "  3 #!

  8 95  

"  "

"() " "

 6%$
") *##$$   $  0)) 

") *## $ "

7($

!  $ 3  4(

.   "       .  

"  .

# )(  #!

 "


") *" + 3 ( ##"

"

# .   )  3   )        %    %:" $&8 05  

"  "

"() " "

 6%$
") *##$$   $  0)) 

")  *  ## $   "

7($     :(

   4(

.   "       .  

"  .

# )(  #!

 "

 
")   *  "  +  3

 3   #  3 ( ")#$& .3 #!

 " ; 
") *" + <5  

"  "

"() " "

 6%$
") *##$$   $  0)) 

") *## $ "

7($ 3:(

"

)


 ;1 2') %&

"

""( # #  *#3 (" 

"

/

$

% &# & # #  *#   "& =  ( & ( 4(  )&

1'

+8 >5   )#(.  #  %& 6%$
") * ##$$  $   ((

 ) #!   !% 8-

  3 

"  $!

       "

     "!&

!$!           $ ) & %  "     

")# &.

 (  0)# " + ( ")   '

$  %&      

1  "$ .  ")   

;

111 2' )& 

1'

+3

3  (  " // "!

   

 ") 
/ +/ 2'?



" .   "3 ( (  "   1     "  %&      .  

"       

/  
3  " 

"$

) *# 

;1 2'

"

$& 

'

; ""( !

""

. # %$#"() .(&% .
3 %! %& 

"

 " ")# &3 $$3 .)"

$&)

""( . 

*# ("($ % $$3  (%4(

)& 

1'

+   %& ")

"

#  )

) " ; " 

$  (

") #  "( " " 

$

$ #$ &%:"  # )3

3  #    %&      .  

"  !

 )     



     :" .     (%)   )  %&     

"")#$  )  ") 
 ;+

2'

  ) .   

   
 ;1 2'    ""(    #   #

*#!

   

*( .. ! %&  

$  $%  0))  
") *## $ @0
AB     1

*( 0
# $&

$$3  $C $$

 

$  $%   $  B        ++

  *(  /     

)   $"   $%& '

 / 5

!  $  "($ '

 # & (

  #"

3 3    "( " " %  %:" 3 !

 ##"

!

""   $!

"

$ 3 # 

%"

. $$&"  %&  $

# &



  %:" 

"

*#3

#

  $  & 

%"$

)  "( )& D$

"3 #$ "  :( .) #*0( 
 



  +++ /;
D / $

# . %  %:"  "($ % 

)

"( $3 #  (%& # &3

%!$7 %&

"%(# . %   %:"   "($  %   

  %:"   #

    )

# 3 #  (%& # & # 3 $ %

"( $<

$  

%"  %& 0
:(

.# . %  %:" 5

$ ""( .3

."  %& 0
 3 ""$(  %&  ( '

,1E) 

%! 4( "$ 

# %&

" %  %:"

#$ 3 "

   

(# $ (#%&  ##$ %$ #"





 $  "

6%$C(#)0( "



  

   (#  3 $ 

# ."

%)  %  %:" 3

) # 3

:( .) 6%$ C(#)0(

% $$3 %& 6%$(:

%  &  .

0( "

  ! (# 
 :( .)  



(# 

3 $ 

# ) % 

#  (%& # & !

E) ": 

$$ :( .).

!%& 6%$C(#) 0( 

# . %   %:"  % 

) #  (%& # &

3!# . %  %:" "

% 

%:" #

) # 3


% "7.( 33 $&=

" #"


  

# &



  %:" 

"

*#3

#

  $ & 

!% "$

)       "(  )  &   3

    

$$3 %$ #$ 3

) ) %:" 

 %& # &

"$&#!

   % "7.(    ) .   %$

   ") 

"

#  )

  # 3) %& # &

:(

"( $#  (%&

# &


% "7.( 3 $ 

# . %  %:" #$ 3 .

!

" "() " "

   $  0
## $

!& #$& $&=  !

&  "( "

  "    3     

  &

) &    

. "  %& $  0
## $  3(# $   $  0
## $

""( + )  "

 $  "($  (%)  

# .!

""

. #("

 .(&% . E C(##$&<# )

F!)  & 3 %(& .(&% . (

C    &  $3     "

.    G

#("


 (%)  

 *%&3

! ) $$ C " *# (

% ""# %&  ( .     &   (   "      "" .$&    ( & ( "  

!

3 3 # &

 )) &% $$3  & ( "  
 $ ! 3 (%)  

 )*#) &%

$$3  &  3

&

! 

 5

!   $  # ! % #   #( 

. (  %$3  "   

$  !

%$    "   5    

     $  0
## $

.

!!& 

$ 

.

(

"   # . /#   /

 

 ( '

, 


!  .   (.

"     "

  3  (%) 

$ %&    )" 
  



$$3  )(" 

# #  *# # ( $#

 (

3 "

(  "  "    6 #$& (.



(%)  

!

""

.

% & ""( #("

 .(&% .  ( & %( 

#!

&!

" (## "$

)*"# "#& $ . ""( 

.

! 

. )   

)     .)  3   (%)   )   %&  

   # &))  ""( # # *# 4(

 %&   $$3 %$ # #!

 " /;  " /D.

 #(  ( *# (  

*# ""( !

""

.# %$ #("

 .(&% .

!% $$3  ""(  % .  #   #   *#  3!  &  *#

"( %&  ( & 

""(

$$3 %$  " !

&  . $  *  *#

""( 3

*# 3  "(  ( .     &   (   "   

;

#!

$ 

* *# (

.( 

# $& $$3 -  ?  "($ '

% %$ 3 &

."  %&  $ ##"

!

"  $!

"

$ 3 # 3  .  "%&

0( ((%

$4( 3 04($&    )   

       

    !