High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2157/2012dismissed

Jagdish v. Jagdish And Others

2015-02-21Mr. Justice J.C. Verma10 pages

!"#

$%&'%() '* +, ---..

//'!0 %+&+ '* +,'! 0, %+ ---

!0+ 22222 %*& $("#3%'!

.4,'%5') 6

%0, //'!0

!0+ 7#.'%0

5 '%8'+,./'!0)!9

)% !0 0,%&*,,+ *'/, %+)% !0+'! !0,+'..

'/),' / '+&0%+

8!* '

%5'!

!0!:&!

0!% +0%'!!*0, ! '!0+%5!0 % %!* !,+.

&/.++ ++!6 /'! 0'/+9, ,,' $

!*6 !!

./'!0 90, 7./'!'0%( $&! '% + '! 0, % !& %

% 0 9'+

/'5 0,'00, ! '!0+9!

'./009'% +0, 9 +0 %!+ ./0 0, ./'!0'! 9 0,% !!*0 ,&.!0, '// * ./00,

./'!0$( 0!*'9'//%9, ,0, (9 ,'6!*!%*,0 ! '!0+ '54&5'%'! '* +,);!9'..

//'!0<)'! 09 0, %+ ,' !0 +0 0, +&0 ! '!0 = '5 ,'% &%!* .

(0, +&0'! 9'+0, !% !0 0,%&*,,+/ *'/, %+6>

! '!0+=#0=#9,'% !9.%%5'% !0+?0@!

0,+'..

'/ '54&5'%) ! '!0)+% !0=!0,+'..

= !(!*0, ./'!0)09'+ /'5 0,'0)!'

0) (9 9!

%+!.++ ++!0, +.&0 ./0$(9'(+&

++!

%50, %'0, %&%'0!*,09'+ 7./'!

&%0, %0,'0&%'0!*,)0, '0, %,' .'%00!

+.&0 ./0'5!*0, ! '!0+'! 0, '0 %) (,' %'+ 0!0, !+5++'/0, +&00, ./'!0 9'++&*,0A, '+':!09%00 !+0'0 !0,' $

!/ $( ! '!0+ '! =0)'+ .'%'0 9%00 !+0'0 !0,' 5 %5 ! '!0 $&0 ./ '+ 0'8 ! $( ,5 '/+ !

90, 0,+ 0'8 ! $( 0, 0,

! '!0+ ?

%' :& '0!%6'/ /'5+0, .'%0 +)//9!*++& %'5 /9 &%0!@

% 0, ./'!0 + 9!

% ! .++ ++! 0,

+.&0 ./0'+5 !0!

!.'%'0, ./'!0B % 0, ./'!0 + !00/ 0 0, % !:&!

0!B

= ./'!0,'+! '&+ '

0!0/

!0+&0B ? +&0+!05'!0'!'$/ !0, .% !0%5B % 0, ./'!0 +

'/!* 0, 5'0 %'/ '

0+ %50, &%0B @

0 %%

6!*%'/'+9 //'+ &5 !0'%(

%50,

.'%0 +'! .%6 !*', '%!*00, %% +.

06 &!+ /)

!*'//0,

++& +!'6&%0, ./'!0+)0, %+&09'+

6 :& *5 !0'!

'0 @

$(0, /9 &%0, ! '!0+9 , / 0$

, %+&.!'.'%0 &/'%.%0!0, +.&0 ./0'! 9 %

0% +0% .++ ++!0, +'5 00, ./'!0+'0 %% 56!*0,

,5 !0

@ ! '!0+'* +,'! / *'/, %+ '5 ,'%/ '/ '*'!+00, +' :& *5 !0'!

, %+0'..

//'0 &%0 &%%

90,0, ! !*+0, /9 &%0!'//0, '+.

0+! +.&0 '! 6 0+ :& *5 !0'!

'0 )'%5 ! !*+0, /9

&%0 *'!+00, &%% !0! !*+$0,0, &%0+$ /9)!

! '!0+ + ! '..

'/ 9, '+ 0, % ! '!0+ '% .%%5'

!0+!0,+% *&/'%+

! '..

'/, ./'!0+'% 5./ '

'+ !0+'! '! '% !0 +0!*0,+'..

'/00,'! !'/ C , +&$+0'!0'/D& +0!+/'9!

!* %5!'0!$(0,+ &%0!0 %5+

)'% '+&!

% 0, 5.&*!

:& *5 !0 '!

'! @

.'++ / '%!

&%0+ $ /9 '% // *'/) %%!

&+) 5+

&!9'%%'!0 /'9'! '

0+0, % 0, ! !*+ %

% $( 0, / '%!

&%0+ $ /9!++& +'! '% '/0* %.

%6 %+ 00,

%'/ '+ 9 // '+ &5 !0'%(

'6'/'$/ !

% B = % 0, / '%!

&%0+ $ /9 ,'6 %% ! !0

% !*'!( *% ! !*!++& +='! ?B ? / '%!

/9 %'..

//'0 &%0,'+ %% !

!0 '//9!* 0, '../ '0! % ' 0!'/

% % %EF &/ / //'!0 9, !0, +'

,'+*% '0$ '%!*!0, :&+0'!

.%.

%' :& '0!0, '/'+9 //'+0, 5'!

+&0B / '%!

&%0+$ /9,'6 %% !% /(!* &.!0, .%0F %)9, !0, +'

.%0 '*'!+0 0, %&/ '! !+0%& 0!+ % *'% !*

5'% '0!'.%.

%0(B G 0+ /'5 0,'00, ./0! +.&0 +5 '+&%!*4'!'/

3'%/'+'! + &/( .

!% !&

% 0'/+% !& !&5$ %+ '! $&! '% +0, ./0'% !0! +.&0 0+),9 %) /'5

'..

//'!0+0,'0!0, '0 /!*0, +&0)0, ./'!0;!9

'! % !0 $(% !0+'! !0,+'..

'/<9'+!0!

.++ ++!0, +&0.%.

%0('! ,

)+&0%.

%5'!

!0'! 5'! '0%( !:&!

0!9'+!0 !5'!0'!'$/ 0+ '!6'++ 0,'00, //'!0'!

0, % .%%5' % !0+ 9 ! +0'$/+, .++ ++! 0, +&0 .%.

%0(0+&%* 0,'00, %+0'..

//'0 &%0,' 9%!*/(% :

'../ '0!&!

% % %EF &/ 0,&*,+& ,' 0!'/

9'+!

++'%(0.%6 .++ ++!0, //'!0# ! '!0 /'50, !0+#./'!0+)!0, 0, %,'! )+0,'0 9, !/ '0!0, +.

06 ./0+!0 +.&0 )0, !/('+.

00$

%5!

+'+09, //'!0'! .%%5'#% !0+9

,*,/( '5$0&+ '! ! 0, % 5.% '/ +*!+ 9 +.% ' !* 0, !0'

+'+'/+ 5'!'! +9

.6 ./00, ./'!0+B !0+' !0 ./'!0+0,'0./00,

! '!0++/ !9 +0 %!+ +.&0 ./0)0, //'!0#

! '!0'! .%%5'#% !0+,'6 '//0,%&*, 7+0

'!(./00, ./'!0+'! ,'6 %'0, /'5 +.&0 ./00$

%+H9! , +! +.&0 0,'0!

9,'++ %0+''

0+% D&% 0 .%6 +'5 !

./'!0 5 '%8'+,;!9

'! % !0

0,%&*,,+F +<,' !68 :&%+ 0!0,+&%0 /'5!*9!

%+,.

!.++ ++!0, +.&0 ./0), 9'+% D&% 0.%6 +'5 !

.& '0!) /'50, ! '!0+9'+0,'00, +.&0 ./09'+!, %0

$(0, 5%50, %'0, %&%'0!*,9,,' .'%00!

+'5 '5!*+0 ! '!0+ '! 0, '0 %) 0, !0 +0!* ! '!0+ ,' 5 !

.++ ++! 0, +'5 A, ! 0,

$%&*,0 ! %

% $( 0,

'..

//'!0# ! '!0'+'/+$(0, !0+#./'!0+9'+'..%

$( /9 &%0'+9 //'+$(0, %+0'..

//'0 &%0)$0,0, &%0+,'

!0/( 5 00, /&+!0,'0!9 +0 %!+ ./00,

./'!0) 7+0 ./00, ! '!0+ '0, ! '!0+0,'00, ( 9!

%+0, ./0! +.&0 $(!, %0'!

%50, %'0, %&%'0 !*,)9'+ +$ = !+0'0 !0% !0#./'!0 5 '%8'+,;

A<+ '..%

)0 %* +0,'0,+'0, %,'%0&'! &%'0!*,)'0, %0,

! '!0+)9 '/$%0, %+0'/+$

5 + '%0,'0,&+ +0,

.'%0 +9 7+0!*!0, %% +.

06 ./0++ %++# 7'5!'0!+ *% '0% 6'!

, ! '!0+,' .&0'+&** +0!0,50,'0,+'0, ,'%0&,' 0'8 !5!

(!/ &0, /'! &.!9, ,0, ! '!0+,'

%'+ 0!( '%+'*'! 0,'00, ! '!0+9 &+!*0, +'

.%0!/'! '+0, (,' !+0'// '4/,&0, ! ? !.

%&+'/+0'0 !0 ! '!0'* +,'+A+ 5'

!0, !0 %'

+0'0 !0./'!0 5 '%8'+, A)0, + '++ %0! ! '!0 '* +, 0,'0 , ,' %'+ 0! ! 0,

+.&0 .%0!0, ./05& , '%/ %0/!*0, +&0$(0, ./'!0

.%07 0, F %90, 7./'!'0%(+0 ./'!7 +,9+0,'00, ,' $

!.% .'% $(,5$(6+0!*0, +0 '! , ,'

$0'!

+*!'0&% +0, .'%0 +.% !0A, !0, +' % .%0 9

+,9!0'* +,;A<), ,' *!

*!%'!

'$&06+00, F '/ 55++!

%'! ,' /'5 .%0'! 0, +0 ./'!0$ '/+ '!

'$% ,&*, ! '!0'* +,! ++9

.!*'! * %'/+&..%0 %5''%'!;A<)'*5,'!;A=<'! 50!' 6;A?<)0,

+! !'/0, '

00,'0 %(!

.00, ./'!0,' /!*$'

%'+ 0!!0, %% +.

06 ./0+ ! +& , +0&'0! '! '00 ! !* &5+0'!

+) &5 !0'%(

'$/ ,'%'

%!/( &/ ,'6 +/6 '/ +.&0 ,&*,>' !*,;

A<)'!

*,$&%0, .'%0 +,' %'//( 7./'!

0,'0 ! '!0'* +, ,' 0% 0 ,&.!0, +.&0 ./0$( %'+!* 0!$&0,'++0'0 0,'09, !% ++0'!

9'+

./'!0 '! !

*,$&%!* % !0+ +&..%0!* 0, ./'!0) 0, ( ,'

+0..

%'+!* 0! $&0 +! 0, '0 %) 0, ( ,' 5'

// *'/

,5 !06 +.&0 ./0%'+!*'+0%& 0&% 90,$% 8+'!

9 !$'0!+09'+'/+ 7./'!

$(>' !*,;

A<0,'00,&*, '* +,'! ! '!0 '5 ,'%,' %'+ 0!!0, %./0+) '5 4&5'%,' +0//!0%'+ '!( 0!0+!0 +.&0 0,'0./0!

D& +0!++0&'0 09'% +0, !%0,0, ,&+ +0, ! '!0+'! )!

0)% '%9'//0, ,&+ ! '!0++09'% +0, +.&0 ./0 '0+,;

A?<,'+ %%$%'0 !

!06 %+!!

*,$&%>'

!*,;

A<)0,&+)*6!*&!'$'0!*+&..%000, ./'!0 @ /!

,!*

+) ,9 %) '6'/'$/ ! % .%0 7 )

7./'!'0%(+0 ./'!9, ,+7 @

/ 4'!&!* '5 +,,'!

'0 %,'6!*$

!'..!0 '+'F %'00, !+0'!

'..

//'!0I ! '!0 ,' 6+0 0, +.0 ! G

? '! ,'

5'% '0!'00, +.0( 5.'%!*0, +.

06 ./0+0, .'%0 +)!

,+% .%07 7./'!!*6 +0 ./'!7 )F

4'!&!* '5 +, ,'!

% ;

A=< '5 0 ' !0 ! !* 0,'0

,5 !0@CD('% +,'+$

!5'

!0, ./00, ./'!0 ,&*,, ,' !0$

! *'0 .9 %+ !0(!*'+09,,' 5'

,5 !0 $&0 $( 6'/&'0!* 6'%&+ '

0+ '! '00 ! !*

&5+0'!

+), ,' 5 00, /&+!0,'0+& , ,5 !0,'

%* %5 '5 ,'%'! '* +, 6 !9, !9 7'5!

!0%

)0, +!0 5'!'!( +.&0 0,'0 ! '!0'* +,,' ,+,&+

5!0,+ '%/ %00, ,&+ $( ! '!0 '5 ,'% /0

! '!0 '54&5'%9'+/(!*6'

'!0A, ! '54&5'% !05'8

'!( 0!), &/ !0,'6 5'

'!( ,5 !00+ '%0,'0 !/('* +,'! '5 ,'%,' 6 %/9!%50, %./0+09'% +0, +

0, ./00, ./'!0 C '0+,;

A?<,'+'/+5'

0 '%0,'0+& , 0!9'+ %'+ ! '!0+ &%!*.

(0, +&0'! !!

'%/ %) (,' 5'

'!'00 5.00%'+ 0!$&09 ++&'

%5 !*+9, !./'!0 5 '%8'+,90,,++!,'%'5$%,' '..%'

,5'! 0, (,' *!

0* %'! ,' ++&'

! '!0+%5 5'8!* ,5 !06 ./00, ./'!0 ++.

0,'06

5!0,+'0 %/!*0, +&0)0, ! '!0+,' 5'

,5 !0$(9'( %'+!*'9'//00, 6'!005 ), 9'+5 5$ %0, '!

,'('0'!

,+50, %9'+'%.'!

,0, 6//'* ,&+) !,+0 +05!(+*% 5.%0'!

G !0 !0!0, &!+ /%0, //'!0# ! '!00,'00,

+! ,5 !0'+0, ./'!0,'+!0 !$

!.%6 0$

%0, ./0)+!5 %0'5'$'! %0, ( '%GG#GC;7 =< '/+0,'00, ./0! +.&0 +5 !0!

0$ !0, 9!

%+,.'!

.++ ++!0, ./'!0, +!% $&00'/

0% .& '0

+&5.0!'00'

, 0'5'$'! 7 = F8!*%5'!0, %'!*/ )0,+./ '% !&

% ,'6!* +&5.0!0%&0,'/+'/+ +0, /'50, ! '!0+0,'00, ('% !

.++ ++!0, +.&0 ./0+!

G#%%50, / 05 '0, %&%'0!*,, /'50,'00, 0!9'+%'+ &%!*0,

05 %'0, %&%'0!*,)'/++0'! + 5/+, %50, .%0 7 0, F %9, !0+ '%/( !00,'00, 9'// %'+ ! '!0+!0, ./0! +.&0 9'+6 %(%

!0%*!'!

! 9'+!0 '/!*90,0, 0, 0!+0'! !*!0, ./0 //'!0I ! '!0 0!*

) ':& *5 !0 #% !'0 ,0,+&%0) &!+ /%0, //'!0,'+ &%* 0,'0'+5./ +&0%.

%5'!

!0!:&!

0!9, !0, ./'!09'+!0 !.++ ++!0, +&0.%.

%0()9'+!0 !5'!0'!'$/ '5'$'! 7 = ,'+ '%/( +0'$/+, 0, ./'!0 0 $

% ! .++ ++! 0, ./0

.%0 7 % ' ! % /'0! 0 0,

+0'0 !0+>' !*,;

A<'! '0+,;

A?<'/+/ '6 +!5'!!

% &$00,'00, 0!!0, +,'.

9'//9'+%'+ &%!* .

(0, +&0$( ! '!0+'* +,'! '5 ,'%'! 0, ./'!09'+ '

% !*/('5 ./'!0 '

0+0, !,'! )0,&+)$ !*

!0% /( !0)0, '% +' '&0,%0( +!0+&+0'!'! +&..%00,

'&+ //'!0# ! '!0 = 0

7 F '5 +,,'!

A=< +,9++*!'0&% +'..

//'!0'* +,'+'/+ '9'!+!'* +, ;

! '!0<'! 50!' 69 9 '5 ,'%;

! '!0=< '+'/+ '54&5'%;

! '!0<'! ,'%'5$%+!./'!0 5 '%8'+,3 5.%

;7 C<,'++*!'0&% + 90, %.

%+!+ '+9 //!

/& !*F'5$ % '%,'!

%,'!'! ,98 '% '*,$%!*, 0'0 !0'..

//'!0'* +,;A< *!!**!%'!

'$&06+00,

F %)0,&+)+,9+,+ ! & 0$ !*'!&!0%&0,&/90!

++ ? !0,+5'00 %+/8 %5( 0'!0, %'!*/ )% .%07 90,+0 ./'!7 @)!0

7 '! 5 5.%

7 C '5 !0,

:& '/%

% )0, 9'+..%0&!0(90,0, ! '!0+0 !(0,

'+'/+0/ $:

0!+'*'!+00, +' % .%00, F '/ 55++!

%)$&0!0,!*+& ,,'..

" 6 ! 9, ! 9 /8 '0 0, %'/

.% &

$( 0,

! '!0+)00%'!+.% +0,'00, (,'6 %9!'7 0*%! '*5,'!

!*,

/(+%+0 &+!0, ! '!0+'! )0,&+),'+'!'0&%'/ (00 +0(!0, %'6&%'0$%!*,;A<+'!'

&+ !'!

/ * $(+!0, ./'!0'*'!+0,5'! ,+$%0, % ,'+)0,&+) '+!00 +0('*'!+00, ./'!0 @ 6 !%'/

+8 .0'+ %'9,/ '! '5'$'!

7 =+% ' !% /'0!0% .%07 0, F %)0,

+!0% 5'!'!( +.&0 0,'0./0! +.&0 $ /!*+00, ./'!0'!

,5 !0&.!'.%0!@CD('% +!./00, ./'!0$ '%!* 4,'+%'?@III=5 '+&%!*4'!'/3'%/'+,'+$

!5'

$('* +, '! '5 ,'%!0,+./00, ./'!0 &%!*.

(0, +&0 &0 %'/

.% &

.'%0 +)0 +05!('0+,;

A?<9, 9'+0, !5 5$ %0, '!

,'('0'! ++!'%.'!

,0, +'

,'('0'! 0,'0>' !*,;

A<)'!

*,$&%)'/++ /!

,!* !'0&% '! +&..%0+0, ! !* &!+ /%0, //'!0% %%!*0

#)':& *5 !0 #% !'0 , 0,+&%0),'+&%* 0,'09, !0, F %,' !05'

5./'!

,'.0 %#30, *,&%0 &/ +'! % %+)1/&5 ) '! ,' !07 &

'.!0+)% .%00, F %9'+ !0% /'$/ C 0,'++.

'//($

!5 !0!

'%/ %0,'00,+% .%07 90,+0 ./'!7 @9'+!

% +.&0 !% ,'// !* '0, %)0, F '/ 55++!

% '..

'% ! 0, 90!

++ $7 '+ A= '! $%'6 0,

%++# 7'5!'0!%50, ! '!0+3% %++# 7'5!'0!$

/+ '! *%//!*!,5)5% $%*,0/('! !

/( %*

!0#./'!0A, !!+& ,./ ',' %$

!%'+ !0, &%0+

$ /9)!!0 %

!0,+ &!0+.

%5++$/ !0, +

! '..

'/ G D& //() 0 + '% 0,'0 0, ,5 !0 9'+ 5'

$( '..

//'!0 '* +, '! .%%5' % !0 '5 ,'% !9 % !0

0,%&*,,+F +)!9% !0+?0@0,0, &%0+$ /9,'

%*,0/( /& 0,'0 ,5 !000, !0@CD('% +,'+$

!0, /'! 0, ./'!0$(0, ! '!0+'! 0, (9 /'$/ 0 ,'! 6 %6'

'!0.++ ++!+& ,/'! '0 %% 56!*0, ,5 !0

)'//0, '% !0!

6 +&$+0'!0'/D& +0!+/'9'% '!+9

'*'!+00, //'!0# ! '!0'! 0, %.%%5'% !0+ =

.!* ! 6 9 0, '

0+ '! &5+0'!

+ '+ 5 !0!

'%/ %)!*%&! 0!0 % 90,0, &%% !0! !*+%

&%0+$ /9)+5'

&0++& ,)'%5!*0, 5.&*!

:& *5 !0'!

'0 @

0, /9 &%0'+9 //'+:& *5 !0'!

0, %+0'..

//'0 &%0)0,+% *&/'%+

! '..

'/) $ !* 6 '!(5 %0)+ +5++

0$ %'9!

J'*&00K

.%0 %+/ '/.'.

%+5'($ '//9 0+

:& *5 !0B + %0$ %% 00,

.%0 %+%!0B = :& *5 !0+,&/ $ .%0 !0, * +0B +