United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Urmila Rani And Others
!"# !$%&%"'()
* '% !+'+%'&,-'$!"./'01 + //!22'
3!-&,& -.%2'%4-.%256-.'+" 6!-& !&/"'+!' &
-!&!'
-.3 -7+3"$ !#"- 6!//!22' -&68'%-"-7+3"$ !#"--!&/"'+!' &'" " --,'9,.- -7+3"$ !#"--!&/"'+!' '" ::::
6!'&,-'$!"./'06&$".!,/%'//!2;%'& 6!8-+ "# 6!-%<,'2%'2%.! % %"'")+ !+
=
)+ !+
>86!-!,/"'$"./!'& %"'"#>7* 7)*=?6&<!!'8-+!+ " 6!
$2%.' &@-!&/"'+!' &'" ""'$$",' "#+! 6"#5,<6&66'+!-4 5,<6&66'+!-56-.786"6++%!+%'-"+$$%+!' 86%$6 ""A/2$!"'
-%!##$ &"# 6!$&!-! 6 "'
<", ( /.
+!$!&!+5,<6&66'+!-45,<6&66'+!-56-.8&$".%';#-". 3%22;!"6%92' "6%&6",&!%'12-,86%2!+-%3%';&$"" !- &2"8&/!!+ !8&<!%';#"22"8!+<0-/25%';6786"8&"'&!/- !." "-$0$2! # !-$-"&&%';3%22;! 6-.;-686!' 6!+!$!&!+8&<", " A!2!# ,-' "8-+&12-,7 6 %.! -,$A<!-%';"?? $.! #& &/!!+#-". 6!"//"&% !+%-!$ %"'%!#-". 6!&%+!"#12-,'+86%2!$".%'; "' 6!8-"';&%+!"# 6!-"++-%3!'<0% &+-%3!-%'-&6'+'!;2%;!'
.''!-7& -,$A;%'& 6!&$"" !-"# 6!+!$!&!+7+,! "86%$6+!$!&!+#!22 +"8'"' 6!-"+'+-!$!%3!+&!-%",&%'B,-%!&!8&&6%# !+ "%3%2"&/% 2
',-#-".86!-!6!8&-!#!--!+ "? 76'+%;-6'+ 6!' A!' "
"- %&"&/% 27"62%86!-!6!&,$$,.<!+ " 6!%'B,-%!&"'
"& ."- !.!/"- %&C7$"/0"#C*'+$622' C?8& /-!&!' !+;%'& -!&/"'+!' '" 1!-'!+8-+!+ 6!$"./!'& %"'&,'+!-(? 5-" !+& 2$,2 %"'& '',2%'$".!
)>>C D>7>7*
E#, ,-!/-"&/!$ **7 *=?
" 2%'$".!"#+!$!&!+ 7>7)=?
) !-&"'2'+2%3%';!C/!'&!& =-+
77)=?
'$".!# !-+!+,$ %"'"#/!-&"'2 '+2%3%';!C/!'&!& 7
=?
> ,2 %/2%!- !2!3!' 1"&&"#+!/!'+!'$0 7
CD>77> =?
"'&"- %,.
7
=?
* ,'!-2!C/!'&!&
7
=?
" 2!+%$2 %22& *7))7)=?
!+%$2 !%.<,-&!.!' 2-!+0 "< %'!+ <0 6! $2%.' & #-".
"3
?)7* 7 =?
.",' ;-' !+ "8-+& !+%$2 <%22& )7 =?
" 2 >7* 7)*=?
6!$"./!'& %"'%&$622!';!+"' 8";-",'+&( 6 6!$2%.' &'" '+8!-!.B"-&"''++,;6 !-'+ 6!08!-!'" !' % 2!+ "'0$"./!'& %"'6%&&/!$ 6&2-!+0<!!' $"'&%+!-!+ <0 6! "'F<2! 5,/-!.! ",- %' $&! "#
!""
#$ 86!-!%'% 6&<!!'6!2+ 6 #"-$2%.%';$"./!'& %"'"'$$",' "#+! 6"# #.%20.!.<!-7&/!-5!$ %"'>>
"# 6!" "-G!6%$2!&$ 7*
7"'20
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
%'2 -%2'+ 6%& #%'+%';6&<!!'-%;6 20;%3!'%'#3",-"# 6!$2%.' & ",'&!2#"- 6!'&,-'$!"./'0#,- 6!--;,!& 6 "8'!-"# 6!3!6%$2!'.!20'%29,.-@-!&/"'+!' '"+%+'" 63!/!-.% "/20 6%&3!6%$2!%'5 !"#,'B< !6+/!-.% &/!-C "/20%' B& 6''/-;-/6 "# 6!8-+7 6!'&,-'$!"2%$0 ''!C,-! "# 6! "##!'+%'; 3!6%$2! <!-%'; -!;%& - %"' '"?? 7 6 8& -!;%& !-!+%' 6!'.!"#-!&/"'+!' '" '+8&%'&,-!+8% 6 6!'&,-'$!
"./'0#"-/!-%"+#-".
")
'+ 6!$$%+!' ""A /2$!"'
6! -%3%';1%$!'$!"# 6!+-%3!-H%&C86%$6 8& 32%+ ,/ "
'+ 6!'$! #%'+%'; 8& ;%3!' 6 '&,-'$! "./'08&2%<2! ".A!/0.!' "#$"./!'& %"' ",'&!2#"- 6! '&,-'$!"./'0$"' !'+& 6 C8&'%'#"-. %"'-!$!%3!+,'+!- !#,- 6!-$"' !'+& 6 "##!'+%';3!6%$2!8&%&&,!+/!-.% <05 !"# B& 6''+ 6%&#$ 6&'" <!!'+%&/, !+<0-!&/"'+!' & !#,- 6!- $"' !'+& 6 %'5 !"#,'B<6!6+/%+-"+ C#-". )
"
)
&/!-''!C,-!'+ 6!$$%+!' ""A/2$!"'
'+ 6!'$!"' 6!+ !"# 6!$$%+!' 7 6! C6++,20<!!'/%+ " 6!5 !"# ,'B<'+ 6!-!%&'";-%!3'$! " 6!5 !"#,'B< #-". 6!#$ 6 6!6+ /!-.% "/20 6!3!6%$2!%'B& 6'&%'$! 6! C8&/%+%','B<2&"7 6!-!&/"'+!' '" 6+32%+/!-.% "/20 6!3!6%$2!%'<" 6 6!5 !& '3%!8"# 6!#%'+%';&;%3!'<"3!7'";-",'+#"-&! %';&%+!= ."+%#%$ %"'"# 6!%./,;'!+8-+%&.+!", '+ 6!/-!&!' //!2%&7 6!-!#"-!7+%&.%&&!+
!
H6! 6!-&/!A%';=-!&"'!+
!&="
H6! 6!--!/"- <2!
!&="