R.K. Malik & ORS v. Bhakra Beas Management Board & ANR
!"#$%& '$%&(& )# )$ &
%!,# %# "#$% - ./)01.1 ./)01.2..1 %$&$ " %'
3$ # %+ ,!34 "$,
%"#$
"& 666 # "% -4(%"
( !$%
(&$7 "#$$""$%& "$ "# 8$$
$!
&""#$%!$%!
"$!9 : ;5 0(!*$,!
&& *"#$=% "5$"
> ?
@
$!8<"#$
"& 4#
$ * * "#$ %$5 < !
"$! @ $A(%$ -
%+ *"#$+"# ""#$ %4
+ %4( "
*"#$ 4$%$ !$%$!8< "#$+ %"+$ ","
"$ .
%"#$5(%5&$
*% *4
$= &%$B$4"$! #(*#"#$%$ &!$
< :!
<& %$-
* ! !
<&
"#$
!"#$
"&# 3$
$!
& &:-
- %4 ! *"#$&
!!$
<,<$"=$# 3$#$ %! % $!
4( &$ %"#$
"& +$% "& !# 3$* $"#%(*#"#$ +5(* $!
- - %!$%,5 $0(!*$ >#$ "#$
"& =$%$ =% * )# )$
%! #$%$
"$%%$ $%%$!" &C)))/=#$%$"#$<=$%$ !$5("$! &5$%"#$5%3 & "#$( B 8$%*
4",:
,"#$ &$%3 4$&=$%$%$*(
&$! @ :::D8<"#$%% %"+$ "= "#
$4" %+D :: ))),"#$%$ %$"=4 "$*% $& $+5 <$$&, $=# %$5&"$!8<!
$%$ "5 %" $%"
"$&E"
"$ $4"% "<) %!&F "#$ &$4 ! "& = %$4%( "$! &"
#$
( !$% "#$
%&"
"$*%< $+5 <$$&#$<=$%$* 3$ 5"
%$A$%4 *"
"$4
$% )))4
$ 4$)))4
$= &# *#$%"# "#$"
"$/&4
$,"#$
"&5"$! %)))4
$
::
,%$3 5 <&4
$&
)))$+5 <$$& %% = *= & "
$!'
!$ $*
"
4$!
"$!
D D @ $A(%$-;,"#$
"&%$G($&"$!)))" 3 $
9
"#$ &
! 4 %4(
% !
"$!
::
! 5% <$! % *% "
5%
!"
+$8( !5%+"
E!$3 &$!5%+"
"$%:E <$ %&&$%3 4$ "#$%$&5$4"
3$5&"&=#
$4( "
*"#$ !-#4 &$%3 4$ %$ !$%$! 8< "#$+ "#$ %% $5 %"+$ ", .
#$ ))), 3 !$ %$5 < !
"$! @ $A(%$ -
%+$! "#$
"&%$* %!
*%$B$4"
"#$ %&
!4
+ "#$*%( !"# !- #4&$%3 4$%$ !$%$!8<"#$+ %"+$ ",.
,4 "
8$ 4( "$! % "#$ 5(%5&$ $A"$ !
* &4
$& ! "
+$ 8( !
4%$+$ "&#$
"&4#
$ *$!"#$
!!$4 "#$)))8<
*> ?
@,=# 4##
-D8$$ !
$0(!*$3 !$"#$ +5(* $!%!$% $ % $! 4( &$ % "#$
%*($! "# " "#$ % $!
$0(!*$# &4++ ""$!*% 3$
$*
"<=#
$# *"# !-#4 &$%3 4$%$ !$%$!8<"#$
"& %% %"+$ ",.
& "
"8$4( "$! %"#$5(%5&$ $A"$ !
*&4
$& !"
+$8( !
4%$+$ "&,8< 3 * 9
"#$ %4(
%!
"$!
::
44%!
*""#$ % $!4( &$ "# &%$* %!, !
&"
4"
4 8$+ !$8$"=$$ "#$ 4$%$ !$%$!8<"#$ )))$+5 <$$& !"#$ 4$%$ !$%$!8<"#$
"& "#$ %% %"+$ ",.
>$! "
< %4$ "#$
%$&
!4 "$ "
, &"#$
$0(!*$# &% *#"
< "
4$!"# "& 4$
"#$
"&=$%$ %$4%( "$! !-#48 %"+$ ",.
, 9
"#$ &
! 4 %4(
% 4 " 8$ $A"$ !$! " "#$% "# ))) !-#4 $+5 <$$&F !"#$%$ & &"
"("%<%$*(
E23$% +$ "%!$%E4 %4(
"4( ""#$ 4$%$ !$%$! %"+$ ",.
,
%"#$5(%5&$ *% *5%
!"
+$8( !5%+"
!$3 &$!5%+"
$
"$%:E <$ %&&$%3 4$ "#$%$&5$4"
3$5&"& # &&($# &8$$ &$""
$!8<"#$. /8 $(5%$+$(%"
55$
;@ :"
$!
!$4 !$! : D,=#$%$ "= &#$ !"# " 4$ "8$4( "$! %"#$5(%5&$ $A"$ !
*&4
$& !"
+$8( !
4%$+$ "&
-@- $ % $! 4( &$ % "#$
(%"#$% %*($! "# " "#$
$0(!*$# * %$!"#$
4""# " )$ 4# "# (%" > ? ::9 '0#(%
'$%&(&#$)# #% )$
%!,!$4 !$! D # !!
%$4"$!"#$)))" 4( ""#$ 4$ "#$5$"
$%"#$%$ ,=#= $+5 <$$
"#$"
"$ .
%*% *5%
%"
+$8( !
$$ % $!4( &$ %*($!"# "=#$ "#$& +
%%$
= *% "$!" $+5 <$$ "#$"
"$ .
"#$
%$&
!4 $4"$!
+ ""$%,& +$8$ $
"&#( !8$$A"$ !$!""#$
"&# &4 "$ "
,
(%5
,
&4 "8$ 44$5"$!,8$4 (&$"#$. /8 $5$A(%"
&(5% # &4 <
!!= "# 4$4 "
8$ 4( "$! % "#$ 5(%5&$ $A"$ !
* &4
$& ! "
+$ 8( !
4%$+$ "& "#$ +5(* $!%!$%,"#$ $0(!*$# &!$
"= "#
"#$4 "$ "
&,%
&$! 8$#
"#$
"&, !$"
#(&,=$ %$ "#$5
"# +5(* $!%!$% !"#$%$ & &%$4%!$!"#$%$ ! "%$G( %$ < "$% $%$ 4$ &&$! !"#!$%
!B