← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1472/2015dismissed

Union Of India And ORS. v. Manpal

2015-10-21Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik7 pages

      

!"# #$%&%'($")#* +

 '%' ',%!!',"-#*& ..//#00!'"& 1#*&2& !'/!0 ..#&/',#'"  

    

     *#&#'"( 3-*%!4!'526!*'7%!+,8$!"#+ *"-#!//#00!'"&  9-#"-#* #/*"#*&   0$!0 /!/#*& 6!: )# !004#, " &## "-# ;2,76#'"<

 )#*# #**#,""-##/*"#*&*'"< = 9-#"-#*"-#;2,76#'"&-20,)#*#/*"#,<    -#/*#&#'"#""#*& !"#'"//#!0%&,%*#$"#,!7!%'&"!' *,#*,!"#, 

/!&&#,):"-#0#!*'#,3%'70# 2,7#+4-#*#): "-# 4*%" /#"%"%' $0!%6%'7 ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%' ' !$$2'"   %';2*%#& &2

#*#,):"-#4*%"/#"%"%'#*"-#/*#&#'"*#&/',#'"4!&!004#, -# 0#!*'#, 3%'70# 2,7#+ *# #**#, " ! %8%&%' #'$- ;2,76#'" "-%&2*"%'9

>

=? !*@!"!&%-8 '%' ',%!!',"-#*&+,#$%,#,' =

 !&4#00!&!'*,#* /!&&#, %'  %8%0 //#!0  > = 

? #'&%' 3!'$"%'%'7 2"-*%":  00!-!)!, !', "-#*& 8  #*7#+ A3+ ,#$%,#,'  >

 +"!004"-#4*%"/#"%"%' #!*'#,$2'&#0 *"-#!//#00!'"&%'"-#/*#&#'"!//#!0 8#-#6#'"0:!*72#, "-!")"-"-#!

*#&!%,;2,76#'"&/#*"!%'""-#

 !*6#, *$#&/#*&''#078#*'#,):"-#*6:$"+4-#*#!&"-#4*%" /#"%"%'#*4!&#'*00#,%'&&!6% 0#&+4-%$-%&'"78#*'#,):"-# *6: #720!"%'& )2" ): "-# #'"*!0 %8%0 3#*8%$#& B"*!*,%'!*: #'&%'20#&+>=> *&-*""-#20#&-2&+"-#8#*:)!&%& "-# *,#* %& ' 6%&"!@#' !$" !', !& &2$-+ "-# *,#* /!&&#, ): "-# 0#!*'#, 3%'70# 2,7#+ %& 0%!)0# " )# &#" !&%,# # !*72#, "-!" #8#' 2',#* "-# !

*#&!%, 20#&+ "-# 4*%" /#"%"%'#* %& '" #'"%"0#, " ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%' * "-# *#!&' "-!" -# -!& &2

#*#, %';2*%#& 6*# "-!' %8# :#!*& )# *# "-# ,!"#   &2)6%&&%'   !' !//0%$!"%' !', "-!""-#4*%"/#"%"%'4!& %0#,#8#'62$-0!"#*  !//*#$%!"# "-# !*726#'"& *!%&#, ): "-# 0#!*'#, $2'&#0 *"-#!//#00!'"+%"%&'#$#&&!*:"'"%$#$#*"!%' !$"&-# 4*%" /#"%"%'#* 4!& #'*00#, ' = >C  %' "-# &&!6 % 0#& !& ! *% 0#6!' # &2

#*#, D *!$"2*# )"- )'#& 0# " #7E 4-%0# ' ,20: &!'$"%'#, $!&2!0 0#!8# %' -%& -6# "4' # 4!& ,4'7*!,#, !', &2)&#F2#'"0: %'8!0%,!"#, 2"   &#*8%$# ' =

 -# *#/*"  "-##,%$!0 !*,,!"#,C>>>-!&)##'!//#',#,!&''#B2*# -#026#%'&2$-*#/*"%&D4-#"-#*!""*%)2"!)0#G!77*!8!"#, " &#*8%$# * '"<H & /#* &2$- *#/*"+ "-# !'&4#*   "-# 6#,%$!0 )!*, %& D'" !""*%)2"!)0#+ -4#8#*+ !77*!8!"#, ,2# " &#*8%$# $',%"%' -#*#0#8!'"20#&420,*#!,!&2',#*(? I=?   %&!)0#6#'" &-!00 )# !$$#/"#, !& ,2# " 8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#&+/*8%,#,"-!"%"%&$#*"% %#,"-!"%" %&,2#"42',+%';2*:*,%&#!&#+4-%$-+ % %&!""*%)2"!)0#"8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#+* %% #B%&"#,)# *#*!*&#,2*%'78#*'6#'"&#*8%$# !',-!&)##'!',*#6!%'&!77*!8!"#,"-#*#): BB BB BB   -#*#&-!00)#!$!&2!0$''#$"%')#"4##'+ ! ,%&!)0#6#'"!',8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#J!', ) ,#!"-!',8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#+ *!""*%)2"!)%0%": *!77*!8!"%'")#$'$#,#,2%,#0%'#&%'"-%&*#7!*,

 !*#7%8#'%'"-#//#',%B4-%$-&-!00)#"*#!"#,!&/!*" !',/!*$#0 "-#&#20#&H BB BB BB K !4!*,&-!00)#6!,#%'*#&/#$" + !!'%';2*:&2&"!%'#,6*#"-!' %8#:#!*&)# *#"-# ,!"# !//0%$!"%'+* ) ,#!"-4-%$-$$2**#,6*#"-!'&#8#':#!*&+ %   !

"#* "-# %';2*: ,2# " 8%0#'$# * !$$%,#'" 4!&&2&"!%'#,+* %% !

"#* "-# 8#*'6#'" &#*8!'" 4!& 6#,%$!00:*#/*"#,!&2'

%" *,2":'!$$2'" "-#,%&#!&#*4-%$--#,%#,H 32$- 20#& $!6# " )# !6#',#, 8%,# '"% %$!"%' ,!"#, 



+4-#'&2)?*20#=-!&)##'%'&#*"#,%'20#C"# &%'&#*"#,*#!,&!&2',#*(? I"#(-# %',%'7& "-##,%$!0 !*,'"-##B"#'"  ,%&!)%0%":6!:)#"*#!"#,!& %'!0!',)%',%'72'0#&& "-# #6/0:## -%6&#0  &##@& ! *#8%#4 ): /*# #**%'7 !' !//#!0"!'2"-*%":%66#,%!"#0:&2/#*%*""-#'# 4- -!, $'&"%"2"#, "-# !*,  ' $!&# "-# !//#!0 %& !$$#/"#,!',!*#8%#4#,%$!0 !*,%&$'&"%"2"#,+"-#

%',%'7& "-# !*,&-!00)#)%',%'7'!00/!*"%#& -# #B"#'"   ,%&!)%0%": !& ,#"#*6%'#, !', !$$#/"#, &-!00)#"*#!"#,!& %'!0!',"-##6/0:##&-!00'")# *#F2%*#,"!//#!*)# *##,%$!0 !*,/#*%,%$!00: * "-#/2*/&# )"!%'%'7!$#*"% %$!"#"-!""-#,%&!)%0%": $'"%'2#&"/#*&%&"H -# ;2,76#'"& *# #**#, " #%"-#* ): "-# 0#!*'#, $2'&#0

* "-# /#"%"%'#* * "-# !//#00!'"& /#*"!%' " "-# !*6#, *$#& /#*&''#0-27-"-#&!%,;2,76#'"&,'",#!04%"-"-#20#&:#" "-# /*%'$%/0#& #'&-*%'#, "-#*#%' !*# "-# 72%,%'7 !$"*& * ,#"#*6%'%'7 "-# $0!%6 * ,%&!)%0%": %' *#&/#$"   "-# /#*&''#0 78#*'#,):"-#20#& &/#*20#=?%%+,%&!)0#6#'"%&!$$#/"#,!&,2#" 8#*'6#'" &#*8%$#+ /*8%,#, "-!" %" %& $#*"% %#, "-!" %" %& ,2# " 42',+%';2*:*,%&#!&#4-%$-%&!""*%)2"!)0#"8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#

 *#B%&"#,,2*%'7"-#8#*'6#'"&#*8%$#!',*#6!%'& !77*!8!"#,"-#*#):&/#*"-#/%'%' "-##,%$!0 !*,+"-27- "-# *!$"2*# %& '" !""*%)2"!)0# " 8#*'6#'" &#*8%$# :#" "-# &!6# -!8%'7 )##' &2

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

!*,  32$- %& "-# 8%#4 "!@#' ): "-%& 2*" %' I9 

 

=,#$%,#,' 

 ?B!%@6#,3%'7-8'%' ',%!+H 32$- %& "-#  8%#4 "!@#' %' B !%@ 6#, 3%'7-E& $!&#+ 4-#*#%' L2#&"%'  #B!6%'#, 4!&  " "-# #

#$" ? I9-#"-#* "-# *6#,

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

 %" $20, '" )# ,#"#$"#,!""-#"%6# #'"*:%'"&#*8%$#+"-#'"-#&!%, /%'%'%&%'"#*6& "-##720!"%'&!',%'&"*2$"%'& %&&2#, !', $!''" )# &2)&"%"2"#, 4-%0# #B#*$%&%'7 "-# /4#*& ;2,%$%!0*#8%#4H "'0:"-#/*%'$%/0#& 0!44-%0##B!6%'%'7"-#7*!'" ,%&!)%0%":/#'&%'""-#/#*&''#0 "-#!*6#, *$#&!*#!//0%$!)0# ""-#,%&!)0#,/#*&''#0 /!*!6%0%"!*: *$#&+)2"#8#'"-#20#& '4!6#',#,6!@#%"$0#!*"-!""-# %',%'7& "-##,%$!0 !*,!

%'!0 ' "-# /*#&#'" $!&#+ "-# #,%$!0 !*, -!& /%'#, "-!" "-#*# 4!& !77*!8!"%' ,2*%'7 "-# 8#*'6#'" &#*8%$#+ "-# &!%, *#/*" #'"%"0#& "-# /#"%"%'#*& " "-# ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%'  %' "#*6&   20# =%% "-#20#& '*#&/#$" "-#!*726#'""-!""-#4*%"/#"%"%'#*%&'" #'"%"0#, " ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%' * "-# *#!&' "-!" "-# %';2*: 4!& &2&"!%'#, 6*# "-!' %8# :#!*& )# *# "-# ,!"#   &2)6%&&%'   "-# !//0%$!"%'%'"#*6& 20#K+%&!7!%''""#'!)0#'$#+"-##,%$!0

!*, -!& /%'#, "-!" "-# %';2*: &"!',& !77*!8!"#, ,2*%'7 "-# 8#*'6#'" &#*8%$#+ "-# 4*%" /#"%"%'#* %& #'"%"0#, " ,%&!)%0%": *6 "-# ,!"#   ,%&$-!*7#   4#8#*+ "-# !//#00!'"& ,#$0%'#, " 7*!'" ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%' '0: )#$!2&# "-# 4*%" /#"%"%'#* &2)6%""#, !' !//0%$!"%' */#"%"%'#*' K



  -#$0!%6 ,%&!)%0%":/#'&%'$'

#*&*#$2**%'7$!2&# !$"%'  ' B !%@ 6#, 3%'7-E& $!&# &2/*!+ "-# %8%&%' #'$- #B!6%'#,"-#&%6%0!*!*726#'"!',$'$02,#,""-# 004%'7#

#$"(? I.9# 6!: '"%$# "-!" "-# *#0%!'$#   "-# 0#!*'#, $2'&#0 * "-# *#&/',#'"& ' "-# ;2,76#'"  32/*#6# 2*" %' 3"!"#   2';!) 1& 2*,#8 3%'7-+ >>3

>%&'"!//0%$!)0#""-# !$"& "-# /*#&#'" $!&# )#$!2&# "-!" 4!& ! $!&#   $#&&!"%'  &#*8%$#'!$$2'" !'*,#* ,%&6%&&!0-#*,#* ,%&6%&&!0 7%8#& *%&# " !' !$"%'!)0# $!2&# 4-%$- %& *#F2%*#,")#$-!00#'7#,4%"-%'"-#/#*%, 0%6%"!"%'J #0&# "-# $0!%6 420, )# )!**#, ): "%6# ' "-# "-#* -!',+"-#$0!%6 /#'&%'%'$02,%'7,%&!)%0%":/#'&%' 420, &"!', ' ! ,%

#*#'" "%'7 -# *%7-" " $0!%6 /#'&%' 420, !*%&# '0: ' !""!%'%'7 "-# !7#  &2/#*!''2!"%'*,%&$-!*7#)2"#B$02,%'7"-#$!&# ,%&6%&&!0**#68!0 *6&#*8%$# 4#8#*+ &%'$# ! /#*&' -!& !//*!$-#, ! "#* ,#0!:+ "-# $0!%6   !**#!*& 420, )# *#&"*%$"#, " ! /#*%,   "-*## :#!*& /*%* " %'%"%!"%'   0%&+ !& !': $0!%6 *6'#:$20,)#0,7#,'0:4%"-%'"-*##:#!*&

*6"-#,!"#*%7-""*#$8#*:!*%&#&%'"#*6& *"%$0# = "-#%6%"!"%'$"+>K=-#*# *#+4# %',"-!" "-#$0!%6 ,%&!)%0%":/#'&%'$!''")#,#$0%'#, *"-# *#!&' "-!" %" 4!& '" *!%&#, 4%"-%' "-*## :#!*&  ,%&$-!*7# *6 "-# *6:+ )2" "-# /!:6#'"   !**#!*& 420,)#*#&"*%$"#,"!/#*%, "-*##:#!*&)# *#"-# %'%"%!"%' 0%&H -2&+4# %',"-!""-#$0!%6 ,%&!)%0%":/#'&%'$'

#*& "-# /#"%"%'#* 4%"- "-# *#$2**%'7 $!2&#   !$"%' !', "-#*# *#+ "-# &!6#$!''")#,#$0%'#, *"-#*#!&'"-!""-#/#"%"%'#*$0!%6#,"-# &!6#!

"#*:#!*&%'"#*6& 20#K "-#20#& 9#6!:'"%$#"-!""-#0#!*'#,$2'&#0 *"-#!//#00!'"& *#0%#, 2/' ! *#$#'" *,#*   "-# 'E)0# 32/*#6# 2*" %' I%8%0 //#!0KC=

?'%' ',%!!',"-#*&8B?!%@1%;!: 526!*H,#$%,#,' KC

-!"4!&!$!&#4-#*#"-#6#6)#*

 "-#!*6#, *$#&&2

#*#,,%&!)%0%":+4-#'-#4!&'= ,!:&E!''2!0 0#!8# -# 2*" 2', "-!" "-# 6#6)#*   !*6#, *$#& 4- %& $0!%6%'7,%&!)%0%":/#'&%'62&")#!)0#"&-4!*#!&'!)0#'#B2& )#"4##'"-#!$"+6%&&%'*$66%&&%'*#&20"%'7%'!'%';2*:""-# /#*&'!',"-#'*6!0#B/#$"#,&"!',!*,& ,2"%#&!',!4!: 0% # #B/#$"#, *6!6#6)#* !*6#, *$#&-#&!%,;2,76#'"*#0!"#&" ,%

#*#'"3#*8%$##720!"%'&4-#'"-#*#4!&'/*8%&%'!'!072& " 20# =%%   "-# 20#&+ !', "-#*# *#+ ,#& '" !,8!'$# "-# !*726#'"*!%&#,):"-#0#!*'#,$2'&#0 *"-#!//#00!'" '8%#4"-#*# +4# %',"-!""-#4*%"/#"%"%'#*-!&)##' *%7-"0: 2',#'"%"0#,",%&!)%0%":/#'&%'+)2" *"-#*#!&'&"-#* "-!' "-# '#& *#$*,#, ): "-# 0#!*'#, 3%'70# 2,7# 4#8#*+ "-# /#"%"%'#* $!' )# ,#$0%'#, )#'# %"   ,%&!)%0%": /#'&%' )#:', "-# /#*%,   "-*## :#!*& /*%* " "-# &2)6%&&%'   *#/*#&#'"!"%' '

K

 '&#F2#'"0:+ "-#*# %& ' 6#*%" %' "-# /*#&#'" !//#!0 !',"-#&!6#%&!$$*,%'70:,%&6%&&#,

           !        

"#$%!        ! $")#* +

 ,&