← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1478/2015dismissed

Avtar Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-07-16Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages





           !"# "$"%&'"( )("("# 

*())+","#-.%/01  $(*'2"#34(4)', 55)%%*#(, 6)',., 2(*() .#7*8(4)',  ),5#9)#(,  !

" #$% &'()*% &%("$* +  " #$% &'()*% *) ,  ---

'),)#(- '  .#7*%19$+*()1 '(4)*55)%%*#(, '*3:4*#4.::*#11 .#7*81 '(4)2(*() ''.#*#,*%19$+*()1 ''),5#9)#(; <<<<<

*) , .& 55)%%*#(,*')*33'")$)9(4)'9)'9*()9  5*,,)9 8/(4)%)*'#)92"#3%))#+41=4)')8/(4)='"(5)("("#5'))'')9*3*"#,((4) '9)',9*()9;

 ##)>.') ?!"$","#*%*#*% "+)'*#9  

@ ##)>.') ?!5*,,)98/(4)2.5)'"#()#9"#3*#*% "+)'14*, 8))#9",:",,)9 4)*+(,="(4')3*'9((4),.8:",,"#(4)*55%"+*("#8/ (4)5'"$*()'),5#9)#(,1"#(4)='"(5)("("#*#9*,=)%%*,"#(4)"#('*?+.'( *55)*%',4"("#3(4)"'=*()'.(%)(*')#("#9",5.()4)3'.#9=4"+4 4*,8))#(*A)#"#(4)='"(5)("("#*#9*,=)%%*,"#(4)5'),)#(*55)*%4*9 8))#(4*((4)*55%"+*("#,.8:"(()98/*'%A2"#34=*,="(4')3*'9((4) ,4"("#3   .(%)(  

0B    "#'   ': .(%)(  @B1



=4)')*,*')**'%A2"#34:)*,.'"#3;0>;0*+'),4*98))#)>+%.9)9 ':.(%)(@;0 B*#9"#+%.9)9"#.(%)( ;

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

,%/*)+()9"''"3*("#(4)"'")%9, #  (4)  (4)'  4*#91  '  '.#  *#,*%1  %)*'#)9  +.#,)% ')5'),)#("#3  '),5#9)#(  ;?  *'%A  2"#34  ,#    */*%  2"#341  =4 :$)9*55%"+*("#8)')(4)*.(4'"("),',4"("#3(4).(%)(1,.55'()9 (4)'9)'.#9)'+4*%%)#3)#(4)5'):",)(4*((4)%)*'#)92"#3%))#+41 *()'4*$"#3+*%%)9'*"9*$"((4)"$","#*%*#*% "+)'1.



0B=*,+4*#3)9( ;

B2*"9*=*%**#9 @B =*,+4*#3)9(@;0 B24.('*#*.'"#3*%%(4",5)'"91*55)%%*#(,4*$) 8))#"''"3*("#3(4)"'%*#9*#9(4),4"("#3(4).(%)(4*9#(,)'".,%/ *)+()9(4):$",?*?$","''"3*("#(4)"'%*#9'/")%9*#91(4.,1.'3)9' 9",:",,*%(4)*55)*% &)4*$)4)*'9(4)%)*'#)9+.#,)%'(4)5*'("),1*55'*",)9(4) 5*5)'8A*#9*')(4)$")=(4*((4)')",#'+)*#9:)'"("#(4)

/

,.8:",,"#, '  .#7*% $)#  "  (4)  *55)%%*#(,  4*9  5'),)#()9  (4)"'  +*,)  8)')  (4) %)*'#)92"#3%))#+414*'9%/*#/+*,)'3"$"#39")')#(5"#"#(4*#(4) #)*,,*"%)94)')"#",:*9).(4)3'")$*#+)(4)*55)%%*#(,4*,# '+)1'1"(4*,+:)"#(4)*"9*$"((4)*.(4'"("),8)%=(4*(#.:8)', 4*$)8))#+4*#3)91(4)')')1(4)')=*,#*:8"3."(/"#(4)*55%"+*("# ,.8:"(()98/*'%A2"#34',4"("#3.(%)(

0B':.(%)( @B18.(1"#*+((4)*'):)#("#)9#.:8)',4*$)*%')*9/8))# +4*#3)9,5)'')+'91(4)*')**'%A2"#34)(++:),(;0>;0*+'), ': 34*.'7"@;0 B*#9=*()'",#(5'$"9)9((4),*:)*,=*()' A4*%", ?0A"%%*,*=*/ # 34*.'7" ;

B1(4)"'*')*",;*+'),1 (4)')')1'*%%"#()#(,*#95.'5,),1(4)')=.%9#(8)#))9*#/ ,)5*'*()A4*%*#91(4.,1(4)*55)%%*#(,=.%9#(8)*(%,, 4)'9)',":5.3#)9"#(4)='"(5)("("#*')(4)/)*',

 *#9

@*#9#(*,"#3%)"#,(*#+)%),,,.55%/(4)=*()'4*,8))# 5"#()9.("#(4)3'.#9,*55)*%9.'"#3*%%(4",5)'"9

'(4)')*,#,,(*()9*8$)1&)9#("#9*#/)'''"#(4) '9)'.#9)'+4*%%)#3)&4"%).54%9"#3(4)":5.3#)9'9)'1(4))(()',

*()#(55)*%",9",:",,)9#,)C.)#(%/1(4)*55%"+*("#'+#9#*("# 9)%*/"#"%"#3(4)*55)*%",*%,9",:",,)9  &%("$* +    *) , 

&'+0%  &'+0% &1 23. 45 ,55 67 89 :

;9  ,55  < !

;9