High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4911/2011dismissed

B.R. Arora v. Deepak Aggarwal And ANR

2019-11-15Mr. Justice Satpal10 pages

!" "#$%$&'(")*"+ ,-

."+%/% '01 2 222

!"#$%&

"!#$%&' (&) **** 222- ! " "$ & % )+,-),''# "" ""% .

# . & '/""&& %% %,0,1),',# "2 " "" ""3""""% .

#.#"%%$ & &4" "5')6

& & "% 27 # "&" /""&& % /""&&&" "&%"&"%& %& ,+,8),,-"%%" " ""9"&' " & " "

,+,8),,-"""&&&& "" 50#:,#,,,;/

&4#,,#,,,;/" ""&&& ' " "" ""

& ""<% "&9%" <% +,,8),,-

# ""&&&&"%&

/"#.,'',),,-& <% "&

&/#""#" ""&& "%"&&"%&

/" &'7 <%

& <% ""%" <% " :'-)'8''),,-"&$ &&)" #"% " 9" '8''),,-<% &/"&$ &&)" "# $" "" "&""&&= &/&"& "&%%# " &" & % " " &"&/""$" "

" %"#$# " <% "& ,+,8),,-&%"" ">$#""" ""&& ""& "&%%9 ""

+,,8),,-#&"& ""&&% &&&"%&

/"#. " %%"",'',),,-

""""&&

" " $ 7 "" % %""""

"7 #""&&"% & &<% "&("%,+',),,-""! "

&)'8''),,- & ) " $" "

" %" " "" "" & "% >%"

%&%""&'#')#4,,;/&)%" $"% %""$ " "& " & "%"" &" ""&& ?"" & "2 "& " / ' =""&& " """" ""& "&%%@A ) =""&&""%"&"%& %& ,+,8),,-@A + =""&&"" " %" &@A 0 =""&&""%$ &',,,,,,;/ ""5':6& & " "B"#""$@A 4 =""&&"& &"" "

"%% %@A 1 =""&&% /"% &%" &" "@A - = "" $ & &% & ""%"@A : = & ) " &" % & %""" "%@A 8 "&

C$"% " " & " %"$%"

; 3"2 %""$"%%#&% %"%

%&%#%% ,+,8),,-$>$#"2 %% ""&& ""& "& %%9"& $"%#

/" &&"$"&&/#"7 "&& &

/"$""%"&""&& & ""% $#""&&#"" $#" $ &&"%" %"" 3"2 ""&&&"$" % %"" ""

,+,8),,-#&#"%% ""&& ""& "& %%#&# " ""&&&&" %""& C</'! '8''),,-# " " # $

""&&/ #"" $#"% ""&& &"$"" &%"&"%& % '8''),,- "&"%

"(+'4,%" $"! "&" ""&&%%" " " & ""&&#"%%%

""""%.

#.<&"%" %$ & ""%"5')6

& & "% !%&%"&"% & % "$ & # &" /&' "" 3 % &

" """"%.

#. " " &" /""&& " /

%/ %$ & "4""%""5')6

& & "% % 9" "2 "% &%""&$"%%9

" ""&&&"$"" ""% "& ,+,8),,- !""&&&"$ %%"" ""

" &<% "&"#" +,,8),,-;,'',),,-!""&& ,'',),,- "%"#

" %$"%%?

# % $ "%3"2 " &%7 "&$ & %

""&&9"#"&%#

% ""&& " " % %""&<% "& ,+,8),,-! ""& " ""%&) )""

3% &"&"

"7 "&&%""&"2 / " = "" ""% . # . %$ & &4#,,#,,,;/%""$ ""&& "" <% ,+,8),,-@ "" =" ""&$"% "" ""% .

# .# "% ""&" " $" ""

%@ 9"$"& #"" " "

%)+,-),''#

""""%.

#. "& "2 %#% &'

"" "% &""&&$<" %& % %""9"%"%,+',),,- C<0" "

" %" "

"& !%"#C<4#"%>$# "&% "&&<% "& %"7 "" & ) '8''),,- ! " " 7 " &" "

" )8,'),,:!&# ""&& ""

& "& " "%%!""&&#"" "& #& " % )+,-),'' &" %/ %" " " %"&"%& %& ,+,8),,->$# ""

"%$ & ""5')6

" 9"# # &"

" " 9$% &"$ &""""%

" #

% & ''

' () " ''' *

&( ) + $

'''

- . /

&( ) 0!"

# -

0!"

'''

50#:,#,,,;/

& 4#,,#,,,;/ " & " %"

$ %& &/

&)&

&'#')#4,,;/ !""&&""% "

" $ "% /& ,+',),,-"" &" "&% &" "%" " %C<0"&$ & &)$<% '8''),,- 9"$&%%"%

%&%#""""% .

#." %&%$ &

4#,,#,,,;/ 9"""&% "% &"%"%

%" >$# " " "

" % &"&"&')6

"" ""% .

D" " $" &% %"%

%&%#"""%""&&""" 516"&')6 & 4 & & "% % $ %% &"" & &% " %""&$"%%"%"&%3 % &" " "" #"&" " $" ""

%)+,-),''#

""""%.

#.# "%%& "&% " 2 " % 3 % & "& " %"&"" %"0'

& 2 %#'8':"&""

2 " &3 4 3%5$ " 6!5+/75 2% &6!5"+%("+%/%5 &6+$3 &6!5"+%

8 $($9 , :$+6$%$&#"6"#" %"6!5+/755$%2("+%/% ) +3 %5 &6 !5"+%$&$($9;;" 9 <<

-2

, =

%"& & "%%#7 " &

"7 "&# "% "" & 2 %#'8':>$#"%# %7 "&

"& "%"""%!

"7 "& " % &%" $ ""

""$&% "<&% (

" =" $" "&"%""&" %)+,-),''# """"% .

#." "%%" " "" % (")*"+ ,-

222

=";

F;( =

F;(