Sukhdev Singh & ORS v. H P G C L & ORS
! "# $ %
% &'()
*& "+)"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
,0"1 , , ",., " 2
"
) ,!
-- !."
34
5 ,0"&
/
, 0, "
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
),2/"
) ,!
-- !."
$ %
5 "6 ,& "+)"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
'/!)"7'2,"
) ,!
-- !."
55
5
,(!)'.
"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
,,0" 9 / 8 ," +2 2
"
) ,!
-- !."
43
5 "6 ,& "+)"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
,0"1 , , ",., " 2
"
) ,!
-- !."
:
5
,,0" 9 / 8 ," +2 2
"
" ) , -..
//"
* ,!'!
& ./"
) ,!
-- !."
34
5 ,0"1 , , ",., " 2
"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
'/!)"7'2,"
) ,!
-- !."
%
5 ,0"1 , , ",., " 2
"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
&', & "+)"
) ,!
-- !."
4 ,0"8 0'
,!," +2 2
"
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
8 ,
,7'2,"
) ,!
-- !."
535
4 !.,
'/ "
) ,!
-..
//"
* ,!'!
,0"8 0'
,!," +2 2
"
) ,!
-- !."
;# "<6/ ;,'!
)'
), "<6/ ;,'!
7'/ .& "+)
!"# #
$ ""
%%
&'()*+'(++,&*-
'
&*( $
"
&++&*+.+, *--*('&*--'-&*( /% 0 1
%
$ ""
%%
&++&*+ 2
! 32!% $
"
+-(.'
4
5!# $
"
6 + 5!%
"/
7!
%$
"
)& 7&')-& &*+ &++&*+ 0 1
#
" /% $ ""
%%
4
%
8 #
% %
$
"
6 ') &.+,&*- 91: %
:
$ ""
%%
-'-&*( $
"
( + &&*( &.+,&*- !
$
"
7&,.(& &*, &&*( 15!
%
% $
"
6 - &&*(
7'/ .& "+)= 1 ## ! #
%% "
$ 6 ++ $*+'($*-.+,$*-*--$*-*('$*-)*$ *- +'( $ *- ++, $ *- $ *( -'- $ *(
% ## ;!
$% 6 .+,$*-*--$*-*('$*-)*$ *- +'( $ *- ++, $ *-
-'*- $*( -'-$*(
'*+*-"
31
$ 7!
%%
#"!
"
$ "
$
) " # 0
"
1%
0 %
;!
31 $
1$
$ # $ ;! ;!%$ $<=>= / ?
3
#"%
$! #
$ #
"
$
$ "1$
< 6 ++$*+ '($*- %%
(*+"
31
$ 7!
7@ ,., $ ..( #"!
;!
"
#
$#"!
" #
$
% % %
31 8 A3% !"
7!
!! " # $ % *)) 7/*/ #
3
#
<
!! " & '
( % ?"
#!
3 $ 3 ;!%$
$<=< 13
! #
1 B
#
""%
%1
$% $
""
%
/ $
?
$ # 6++$*+ %%
!
8 1 =%
1
!
8 1 =%
1 % 3$!
$$
"%#%
/ "!
" # "
$
CD;!
#
3 $%% #
=
!3
$
7 "
<=>=;!%$ $
%# $
1 ?"
3
+
!
$
;!%$ $ <=>=
$"
%# $
1
!
$ # $ :!
!3
<=>=;!%$ %%
'
$
%#
$ 1 <=>=;!%$
% !
<=>=;!%$ %
%%
0 %
" <
1 ?#
!%
#
%1
(. $ =%
1 !""%1
.), 8 1
=%
1 #"
$ # !%
!
$$$
#"%1
%
%%
< "!
!
(. $ =%
1!""%1
.),!
3 =%
1
$ =
=%
%
!
!%
.-+ E !%
A
$ ..-+ /
% 8 1
=%
1 !"
"
!%
/ !%
#
$ # # # 7%!
-$ !%
" $
!
"
$
$ #
$%% !
& ' (%
' (% # ) ' (%
#
* # + , % -.
* # / !%
#
$ # # # ..,,
(.,.
+ '..
'
- *..'
**..'
- (*..+
)/ $ $=
$ !%
& / 01))2
34 5, + 6 7 , 4 '
( 7 , 4 '
(8 % :
*48
, ; ,
, 6 %%
!
$ %
% "
!% . $ !% *..'
!
"
$
%%3 #
!
& '(% <2= '(%
*9
= 34 (: ,
*9 4 ')( ' ( 2 # 7 , 4>
?= (: ,
*9
/;>,@%,A # 2 # ?= '( %
* 9
34
( ' (: ,
* 9
'(' ( 2 # 7,4>@%
?= ' (: , +
* 9
/;>,@%, A # 2 # ?= B # A
/, # # 8 8 B # 8 A '(' ('( ' ( #8 # 8 #
"
'(' ( '(' (
# #
A
# # / 3
%1
$ " # $
31
!
31" # $
%
%% :!
=
$
1 ?"
# % 3% /
%!
$
" #
" # $
" # $ # #
=
$2
7 "
<=>= ;!%$
$
1
/ 1CD;! $ " # < #"%
" # "% 1 "
$
$$
$
(.,.
, + ! %
$ " # "
$
$ #
"
<=>=;!%$ CD;!
!% .3 $%%
& ' ( .
, +
/, # A /;>,@%, "
2 # 8
7
' (
. 8
/;>,@%, " '
(
7, A /;>,@%, ," 8 A 8 . '
(
8 #
">
#
% ) CC 1 CC / $ !"
31 $ **..'
- $ " # $%% ! %
" & (
A
A
/;>,%,
2 #
, +
/;>,@%,"
. "
'
(
> , + # A
/;>,@%,8
.
"
2
( .
, +
/,8
7
'
(
'
( .
/;>,@ %, "
2 #
, + >
8 . , + 6 $ **..'
-
$ ""% 3% $ "! "
$"
/
! %
" % 3% 1$ " # %%3 $ ;!%$ $<=>= #"%
$$
1
$=
< $!
%
0
%
$ =
!3
$ " # = %%
#%%13 "
1$: ! 1$ 1 !%1 $ %%
/ #
% 3%
0 %
%%3
%1$ # $$ %$!%$%% 3
"
$<=>= ?# #"%
$+1
$ =
#
%1
0 %
$
%
3
$ $
# +'**-<
* ""
# # !
!3
$!%$%% # $
% ;!%$ %
$
1 "!
<
% "
" %
$%% $+1
$ $ ;! $;!%$ <=>= 31
%!
!
!3
%1 " #
% # / "
%% 3 $
7!
0
;!%$1$ " # $
+1
%!
+1 $ ;! <=>=;!%$ @
%
!
%$ "
%
$!%%1
! $% / ;!
$
3 $ 7!
"
$ " # $ # =
!3
% "
<=>=;!%$ +1
+1
3 !
$ #
$"
<=>=;!%$
%!
%!
;!%$1$ CD;! $
" #
!
%$ "
0
!
! !
!%
$ !%
0
$ # # # @
$ !%
*..'< 3 !%
$ #
?
$"
!
(. $=%
1!""%1
.),
3% "
3 %$ @
" # !
.3$ CD;! ?#
+1
3 !
$ !
!3
;!%$ $<=>=
%!
!
!3
/ 3 $$
**..'
31 % $$
(.,. !"
#"%
" # $CD;!
! %
" % 3% 1$" # %%3 ;! $ ;!%$ $<=>= #"%
$+1
$ =
!3
F B!
0 %
$ =
$ " #
%%
#%%13 "
1$: ! 1$ 1 !%1
$ %%
/ #
% 3%
0
%
%% 3
%1 $ # $ $$ % $!%$%% 3
"
$<=>= ?# #"%
$+
$=
< 3 $$
**..' !%
!
?
$"
!
(. $ =%
1!""%1
.),
!3
>
#
!% . $*..'
/
$ 7!
$
#
!% .3 0 1
$ # $
%1
+1
F F#
$ ;! <=>= ;!%$ $ =
#
!"" 31
"
0
+1
%!
$
<=>= ;!%$ /
$ % + 1
!
!3
< 3
%1
3
7!
! #
$
-'*- %
!
% $ # $
!
%1 %
3
!
%
!
%$ #
!
1 !! " & '
( %1 ""% 31
%
7 %@
6,.,$..( (*+< 3
! #
!! " &
'
( $$
$
1
" # $
:!
"
$
/ $
$$
$ !
!
% # +!! .8)))'D( 7/.)$+/ ;. % # +;+ 8)))+99'E+(0 + # +
$ 'B/F 2D
11)( 0 11)
3
$
<
$ % '
( "!
% 3% 1%
$
B
$$
B$
?
" # 7B / %
3
"%
$%% 3
"
?
7!
& )
$ / #8
/9:G
:G "
02=
#
:G
'
> #
8 #
G 8
:G H
8
8
:G 8
$ #8
8 A :G A #
8 A
3A
# #
#
/9:
#
A A
#A 8
# # 8
# #
#
A 8
8
> # 8
"
8
) #% %1 +;+H '
(8 %
&
1$ # #3
3
#
31%
$
< + & '
( "!
" #
"
$5 !
8 1 5
2 !"7!%
.,/ !%
$$
!%
0 1
$ # $
$ !
+1
$ ;!
<=>=;!%$ % !" ! #
"
?7!
B#*# $+, % 8'9 # /
F 010<
11( ) 108
%
$ !% .$!
3 =%
1
$ =
7 %
!
!%
.-+ ""% 3% 8 1 =%
1 <
% #% %!
$ CD ;! ;!
/ "
?7!
%
%!
% #" G H#
%!
% !
& >
8 #
# /;>, A > "
/;>,@%," . # 8
8
8 #
%
+ 7 / "
?7!
!% ?"
3
$ "
<=>= ?# 3 0
+ $ #0
$ $ *..'
?
$"
!
(. $=%
1!""%1
.),#
!% .
2! %
(.,.
+ !"
31
2! %
**..'
-
! %
!"
!% / ! %
**..'
-
?
$"
(. $=%
1!""%1
.), #
! %
?"% %
!% ./
!% %%3
2! %
$
1 !% .
3
3 % $ !% . 6 .3 "
#
=
!3
$2
7 "
<=>=;!%$
+1 ?"
G H CD" #
3
# G H 3
31 "
?7!
+1
$ ;! <=>=;!%$ / "
$
"%
G H !%!
+1
:!
=
=
!
$ G H
3
!
% $<=>=;!%$ /
31 "
?7!
B#*& '
( /
$
% $ "! "
$
" # !
%!
.3=
$2
7 #!
+1
$ #
<=>= ;!%$ / "! "
$ !%
=
4"%#8%
#!
+1
?"
$ 1 <=>= 3
# % 3% $ !
$
-
" # "
$
""
$
"
!
"
!
# " #
%%!"
" #
/ "
""
%1 % !" ! %
(.,.
+ !"
31 ! %
**..'
-
%
#"%
$+1
!%3 $=
%!
$ + 1
$ =
!3
1 #
!% 6.
$
#
"
$ !% . %%"
% ! %
1 !% /
$ $$
**..'
- $
1 "
!% 6. 3 ;! 7
;!
%1 3 % +1
3 !
$ #
<=>=I!%$ !% ""
31" # 3 #
3 $# ! 3% 1 !
16 $$
%%
1 %# " # #
$ 3 $
1 4
%
7!
%""
$ #
!
0 %
$
#
" +'**-
0 %
" **,
0 %
" %%**-
$
!3
;!%$ $<=>=%
+1
(
;!%$ % #
3
@
$!% "
! %
$"
" 0 %
1$ : ! 1$ 1 / 1 ?
$ $
# +'**- B
%
" "
$$
!$$ <$ "
" 0 %
% 1 !%% 1 "
# $7%!
$ $ **..'
-
1 $ : ! 1 $ 1
31
=
"
;!%$ % #
3
"
;!%$
?
1 !"
: ! 1 3 !
/ =
% 3% 1$;!%$ $ <=>= +1
% # # !
;! ;!%$ %
!% ;!%$1<=>= ?# 0 ?# /
$ $ ;!%$ ?"
%
%#
!
% 1 ;!%$ 3 "%
0 %
$
"! "
$
" # CD;!
!% $
"
$%%
& B "! "
$
CD" # "
$
#
!% .3 $ !
3 =%
1
$ =
7 %
!
!%
.-+ ""% 3%
, 8 1 =%
1
$+1 3
!
$ #
=
!3
<=>=I!%$ / 0 %
%%3 " $
11
: ! 1$
11 %!
$2! %
**..'
- / " #
%%3 #
%1
0 %
/ "
%%"
" %
'#
$ #
"
$
$ "1$
$%% !"
%% 3 0
31 !
" #
# #0 " #
$$
3
-'*- '*+*- "
31
(*+ !" % 3
#$
%%
1
! %
$
1 ! #
;! %%
%1 "
$
#
3
$
7 $ 1%
"
$ "1$ 3 "%
$%
>)'
), ? >7'/ .& "+)?
'
+
'
+
$ %
% .
@
0 >
J
@
" 3% J