High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2269/2012allowed

Vinod Kumar v. Punjab State Electricity Board

2017-09-26Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry10 pages

!" "#$%$&'

( )$&*+,- . //"00 &!

)".%,% ,&1 2! !"0"#!.$#$!3 .* 4,&1 2! !"4". ./. !$&5!* "%/&*"&!

'675 5+5 ."%"&!'6

. &!4 08*9# !"8

.!:" //"00 &!

%9$&+ ,. &*:,8*9# !" .

.-$!;; .4 08*9# !"

.!:"."%/&*"&! 5+58 3 !:$% #--& 1,*;"-"&!8 %: 00 2" *$%/%$&; % 8<<< &*<= >

% #--&?,"%!$& .$%"%$&!:"%"

//" 0% :"%,2%! &!$ 0?,"%!$& 0 484:$#:&""*%!2"*"!".-$&"*8 $%

! "#$ % "

."*"! $0"**$%#,%%$&8$!4,0*2" //./.$ !"!&!$#" .!$#0"

!:" #:"*,0" !! #:"* ! !:" 5$-$! !$& #!8 4:$#: $% ."/.*,#"* %,&*".'6 :$.!3 3" .% A:"&!:"/".$*

0$-$! !$&4,0* 2";$&!.,&,&*".

!:$%#! ; $&%! 0$B"%,$!23 /.$9 !"/".%& Suresh Kumar 2017.09.27 16:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

&3%,$! "@#"/! %,$!2"

."!:"

,/."-",.!$&!:""@".#$%" $!% .$;$& 01,.$%*$#!$&23.&2": 0

!:""&!. 09".&-"&!8. &3! !"

9".&-"&!$&#0,*$&;!:"9".&-"&!

!:"! !" --, &*+ %:-$.

# ."

,0." *$&; .!$#0"

!:"#:"*,0" !! #:"*!!:"

5$-$! !$&#!8 <4,0*%:4!: !!:"0$-$! !$& . $0$&; &3%,$!23.

&2": 0 !:""&!. 09".&-"&!. &3! !"9".&-"&!8$&#0,*$&; !:"9".&-"&! !:"! !" --, &*+ %:-$.8$%< 3" .% .-!:"

* !"80$-$! !$&2";$&%!.,&,&*".!:$%#!&!:".4.*%84$!:."%/"#! !!:"%,$!% $0"*23.&2": 0 !:""&!. 09".&-"&!.!:"! !"

9".&-"&!8 %/"#$ 0/".$* 0$-$! !$&: %2""&/.9$*"*$"< 3" .%$& /0 #" !:"0$-$! !$& %;$9"&,&*".9 .$,%.!$#0"% &!:"/."%"&!# %"8!:",&1 2! !"0"#!.$#$!3 .* $0"* %,$! .."#9".3&!:"2 %$% !:".$;$& 0*"- &*&!$#" &*!:"."

!".8 &!:"2 %$% !:".*".%/ %%"*23!:" $%/,!""!!0"-"&!,!:.$!3 #&%!$!,!"*23!:"0"#!.$#$!3 .*& 00!:"%"# %"%8!:"# ,%" #!$&! ."#9".!:" -,&!: % .$%"&&/ %%$&; !:".*".%/ %%"*23!:"

$%/,!""!!0"-"&!,!:.$!3& 00!:"%"# %"%8!:".*"./ %%"*23!:"

$%/,!""!!0"-"&!,!:.$!3$% * !"*=

84:"." % !:"%,$! .

."#9".3# -"!2" $0"*& C <

C$" !". /".$* -."!: & !:.""3" .% %/". .! !:"#:"*,0" !! #:"*!!:"5$-$! !$&#!8 !:"0$-$! !$&/".$* .."#9".3 !:" -,&!$%<3" .%&!:"/."%"&!

# %"8!:"%,$! .."#9".34 % *-$!!"*03 $0"* !". /".$* <3" .% :"0" .&"*!.$ 0,.!*"#.""*!:"%,$!&!:";.,&*!: ! .!$#0"

!:"#:"*,0" !! #:"*!!:"5$-$! !$&#!4,0* //03 &*8 !:"."

."8!:"0$-$! !$&/".$*$% < 3" .%:"0" .&"*!.$ 0,.!."0$"* ,/&!:"1,*;"-"&!%/ %%"*23!:"&720",.!%$&!"./."!$&;.!$#0"

!:" &%!$!,!$& &*$ .!$#0" !:" &%!$!,!$& &*$ $% ."/.*,#"* %,&*".'D

." *$&; .!$#0" !:"&%!$!,!$& &*$ 4,0*%:4 !: !$!%4.*$&;$%"&!$."03*$

"."&!&.!$#0" !:"&%!$!,!$&

&*$ 8$!$%/.9$*"*!: !!:"! !"$&#0,*"%!:"9".&-"&! &* .0$ -"&! &*$ &*!:"9".&-"&! &*!:"5";$%0 !,." " #: !:"! !"% &* 000# 0.!:". ,!:.$!$"%4$!:$&!:"!"..$!.3 &*$ .,&*".!:"#&!.0 9".&-"&! &*$ A:"." % $& .!$#0"

!:" #:"*,0" !! #:"* ! !:"

5$-$! !$& #!8 !:" 4.*% ,%"* ." "&!. 0 9".&-"&! . ! !" 9".&-"&! "#"&!03&720"!:",/."-",.! &*$ $&!:"1,*;"-"&!

."/.!"* %

< <8# $

: %$&!"./."!"*.!$#0"

!:"#:"*,0" !! #:"*!!:"

5$-$! !$&#! &*: %:"0* %,&*".'D ' '

' ! ! ( ) *

,)! ) * !

) !! .

)

* / ) '

)

1 )! "

) ! ) )!)

) * .

)

4 5.

)

) * )

! .

) ! !

)

/ . )! )

! *

/(7,

* '

! * # +

8 (5 , 3 .$ 3 (99,/**://

;

)

)!+

;

+ < ; 0

* !

)+ )

! ( 8

) ' $#*

(999,:

** :: .

)

)!+

=(,

) .

(??=,/**77$ +

(??=, 9 ** =?

@ *> ) =(,

))!

! ( , 6(

= (,) )! 2 )

)

"(A

, ;

* '

$;9?699?

'& # B' C3B3 (99/,:**=/

D E *

- ) B'(???,=**D;

>* > > >

/(7, /(=9, * '

* )!

)

) !

! *

) * !

) "

!$%#0" . .-!:" ."% $**$%#,%%$&!: !!:"0 &;, ;"

.!$#0"

!:"#:"*,0" !! #:"*!!:"5$-$! !$&#!$%*$

"."&! .- !:"0 &;, ;" .!$#0" !:"&%!$!,!$& &*$ !!:$%%! ;"8$!4,0*2" //./.$ !"!."

".!!:"-" &$&;

%%$;&"*!!:""&!. 0;9".&-"&! &*!:"! !"9".&-"&!,&*".!:"

( "&". 00 ,%"%#!"#!$&< > &*<

!:""&". 00 ,%"%#! ."

."/.*,#"* %,&*".'D /

' * '

! )+2 @@ @@ @@ @@ @@

>E"&!. 09".&-"&!E%: 006

$&."0 !$&! &3!:$&;*&"2"

."!:"#--"&#"-"&!

!:"&%!$!,!$&8-" &%!:"9".&.6"&". 0.!:" 9".&."&". 0$&,&#$08 %!:"# %"- 32"F &*%: 00 $&#0,*"6 ( , )2 (, ;

'?/:

)2 F (

G * *

)2 (/, ?;

'F (), ! )

2 ( , (,

:7 *

! F (

* )

* ( '

,'?:= * *

2 ) !

/? ;/ *

)F (

C . !

* F (=9,H H2 ( ,

! )

! I

* * F

(),

* )

* ( '

,'?:=

# +

* * F (,

! )

* ( '

,'?:=

C . ! * F

:7' *

* !

!$%#0" . .-!:"." *$&; "#!$&< > &*<

!:"

"&". 0 0 ,%"% #! !: ! !:" 4.*% ! !" 9".&-"&! &* "&!. 0 9".&-"&!*"%&!$&#0,*",20$#"#!.&*".! B$&;%:"%",20$# "#!.&*".! B$&;%- 32"$&%!.,-"&! 0$!$"% !:"! !"8:4"9".8!:"%"

,20$#"#!.&*".! B$&;%*&! 004$!:$&!:"-" &$&; !:"4.*% "&!. 0 9".&-"&! . ! !" 9".&-"&! :"%" ,20$# "#!. &*".! B$&;%- 32"4.B$&;,&*".!:"#&!.0 !:""&!. 09".&-"&!

.!:"! !"9".&-"&!8:4"9".8%,#:,20$#"#!.&*".! B$&;%# &&! 2""?, !"*4$!:!:"4.*%"&!. 09".&-"&!.! !"9".&-"&!

&9$"4 !:"*$%#,%%$&- *" 29"8!:"?,"%!$& 0 4 %

. -"* %,/. $% &%4"."*$& 9,. !:" //"00 &! :"%,$! $0"*23!:",&1 2! !"0"#!.$#$!3 .*$%:"0*!2" 2 .."*23!$-":"1,*;"-"&! &**"#.""/ %%"*23!:",.!%2"04 ." %"! %$*" 00!:"!:."" //" 0% ." 004"*

5+5

( %B A:"!:".%/" B$&;G." %&"*"%G A:"!:"."/.! 20" "%G