High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31300/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Nk Kuldeep Singh And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$$

! %!& !"'$$

( ) )

*" +,* $ ))

) -

+,* )$ )) ) * !"#$%&'( )!*+,!-!.

%/-0.,$1+,2 )!3#4.2.!*.

%/-0.,$5-!,2$6$,+,+-3$!7 )!2.872#2.!*.

%/-0.,$5-!!$76-3%$3, - )

) -

.$ 2!-#"2,2$+37,.3,1!+,6$,+,+-3 ,2$6$,+,+-3$!72$!$+3

3+-3-53%+.

6!.'75-!,2$7$,,+3".7+%$-5,2$-!%$!%.,$%: ;33$<#!$ = .7 6.77$% &' ,2$ >$.!3$% !*$% -!0$7 !+&#3.> 0-30$!3$% 12$!$&'7,2$0>.+*-5!$76-3%$3, -5-!,2$"!.3,-5 7$!/+0$$>$*$3,-5,2$%+7.&+>+,'6$37+-35-!,2$7$!/+0$!$3%$!$%&' 2+*+3$5$30$$0#!+,'-!67;=2.7&$$3.>>-1$% &'0-3%-3+3"

,2$72-!,5.>>-5 %.'75!-*,2$!$?#+7+,$@'$.!7-5?#.>+5'+3" 7$!/+0$5-!$.!3+3"7$!/+0$6$37+-3+3,2$

/&0%/1/&23 %!

$76-3%$3, -1.7$3!->>$%+3,2$3%+.3!*';2$ A$"+*$3,=-3 B .3%1.7%+702.!"$%,2$!$5!-*-3 : $76-3%$3, - 1.7 "!.3,$% !$,+!+3" 6$37+-3 .7 .%*+77+&>$ ,- 2+* .7 6$! ,2$ $37+-3 $"#>.,+-37 2$!$.5,$!

!$76-3%$3, -1.7!$$3!->>$%+3,-$5$30$$0#!+,'-!67; 7$!/+0$= -3 00-!%+3" ,- ,2$ 6!$/.>$3, 6->+0' #6-3

.,,.+3+3",2$."$-57#6$!.33#.,+-3 !$76-3%$3, -1.7%+702.!"$% 5!-*7$!/+0$+3,2$-3.5,$!!$3%$!+3".7$!/+0$-5 '$.!7 )-3,27.3% %.'7 12+021.772-!,&' %.'7 7-.7,- *.8$,2$7->%+$!$3.&>$%,-0-*6>$,$,2$?#.>+5'+3",$!*-5@'$.!7

5-!,2$6#!6-7$-5"!.3,-57$!/+0$6$37+-3 ,2#75-!,2$7$0-3%7$!/+0$ !$3%$!$%&'2+*+3,2$ $76-3%$3, - 1.7 %$3+$% 7$!/+0$ 6$37+-3 &' ,2$ 0-*6$,$3,.#,2-!+,'5-!2+73-,0-*6>$,+3",2$!$?#+7+,$?#.>+5'+3" 6$!+-%5-!$.!3+3"7$!/+0$6$37+-3+3,2$ $$>+3".""!+$/$% !$76-3%$3, -5+>$% &$5-!$,2$ >$.!3$% !*$% -!0$7 !+&#3.> 0-30$!3$% 12$!$&'7 2$ 0.7, .

02.>>$3"$,-,2$.5-!$7.+%!$4$0,+-3-!%$!2$7.+% &$0.*$ .>>-1$%/+%$-!%$!%.,$%:2$-6$!.,+/$6.!,-5,2$7.+% -!%$!+7$<,!.0,$%2$!$+3.5,$!( <<<< <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

! "#

#$ !

%&'

( ) @ $$>+3".""!+$/$%5!-*,2$.5-!$7.+%-!%$!.76.77$%#6-3 ,2$;7#6!.= &',2$>$.!3$%!*$%-!0$7!+&#3.>0-30$!3$% ,2$

6$,+,+-3$! 3+-3-53%+.2.75+>$%,2$!$.".+37,,2$+37,.3,1!+,6$,+,+-3 &$5-!$,2+7-#!, )%456

6 !

7081/ !& %!

17 0890606 !

$ : 2$>$.!3$%0-#37$>5-!,2$6$,+,+-3$!77#&*+,7 ,2.,,2$ >$.!3$%!+&#3.>2.75.+>$%,-0-37+%$!,2.,+3,$!*7-5$"#>.,+-3

-@-5,2$$37+-3$"#>.,+-375-!,2$!*' :.3%$"#>.,+-3

- -5,2$$37+-3$"#>.,+-375-!,2$!*'

B ,2#7-3>',2$ -*6$,$3,#,2-!+,'1.7$*6-1$!$%,-0-3%-3$,2$%$5+0+$30'+3,2$ !$3%+,+-3-5?#.>+5'+3"7$!/+0$ ,2#7&',2$7->%+$!5-!2+7&$0-*+3"

$3,+,>$%,-7$$8,2$$3%-1*$3,-56$37+-3,-2+*2$7.+%$"#>.,+-37 .!$$<,!.0,$%2$!$+3.5,$! ;

)C := *+, -.

1 0

2 *3 /0

) ;

)C B=

45 0

1 6

2 )

7 )-!$-/$!

,2$)+3+7,!'-5$5$30$/+%$->+0'>$,,$! - ;=DDD;$3D->= %.,$%: +37$!,$%0>.#7$;+/= +3 ,2$ $"#>.,+-3 - -5,2$$37+-3$"#>.,+-35-!,2$!*'

B2$ !$>$/.3,6.!,12$!$-5 +7$<,!.0,$%2$!$+3.5,$! "$# $

$ &$

'( B 6$!#7.>-5,2$.5-!$.*$3%*$3,1-#>%*.8$+,0>$.!,2., !$>+$5 ?#. 0-3%-3.,+-3 -5 %$5+0+$30' +3 !$3%+,+-3 -5 ,2$ .66-7+,$ ?#.>+5'+3"7$!/+0$ +7,-&$.00-!%$%-3*$!+, 7-.7,-$37#!$,2.,.3 .!*'6$!7-33$>+7$>+"+&>$5-!.,>$.7,-3$7$!/+0$6$37+-3

$ 2$>$.!3$%0-#37$>5-!,2$6$,+,+-3$!75#!,2$!7#&*+,7 ,2., ,2$4#%"*$3,-5,2$>$.!3$%!*$%-!0$7!+&#3.> !+30+6.>E$302

$1$>2+ !$3%$!$%+30.7$,+,>$%.7

1.73-,0-!!$0,!.,2$!1.70-3,!.!',->.1.3%5.0,7

,2$!$5-!$ 3-!$>+.30$-#"2,,-2./$&$$36>.0$%-3,2$7.+%4#%"*$3, 2$!$>$/.3,6.!."!.627 .7-00#!+3,2$/$!%+0,;7#6!.=.!$$<,!.0,$% 2$!$+3.5,$! + 1 8"

+9+9*&

4 0 :

;<$

2 =

>?; *9&+99* @ = @

>?;

+993+9*7A

A 0 $

A 0 ; " ; B C=D39+9*E 97**+9*E =8

A $ =8

> /?;0 A .... ....

& =

4 0 F D / 0

/ 0 1

; < $

$ $

$ @ GH < $ 2

; < $ GH G $ ; @

IG ?

< ?

" ; ? / 0 &

&&- $ ‟

!"#

/ & $

/ 0 /0

) =

< +/+0 = 8 =+997

*9&+99*

@ *+< < @

& "

& # $

%012%13%& $&4 &

3513%136"#

0 @ /0

$ $

" ;

/ 0F D/ 0 @ 7

!7 !& 7086 % 0$ +30$,2$$<6-7,#>.,+-37*.%$+36.!."!.62 --5,2$ 4#%"*$3,!$3%$!$%&',2$ -3F&>$6$<-#!,+30.7$,+,>$%.7 !6 ! 7 !6//!! 08 ( $)% ! )6!38 5/

!$6-!,$%+3"%137#6

' 010 6.!."!.62 12$!$-5 &$0-*$7 $<,!.0,$% 2$!$+3.5,$!

-/$!0-*$7,2$%+7.&>+3"$55$0,7 +5.3'

-57#6!.$<0$6,+-3

-;+/= .7&$0.*$+37$!,$%/+%$6->+0'D>$,,$!%.,$%: ,2#7

+3,$3%$%,-1-!8.7.3-&7,.0>$!.,2$!.".+37,,2$7->%+$!0>.+*+3"!$>+$5 -50-3%-3.,+-3+3,2$!$?#+7+,$72-!,5.>>-57$!/+0$ *+

G $

+J *K&,

*= +99*

) 2$!$5-!$ ,2$4#%+0+.>/$!%+0,;7#6!.= %-$7!$3%$!3$".,$% ,2$7#6!..!"#*$3,!.+7$%&',2$0-#37$>5-!,2$6$,+,+-3$!7 ,2.,,2$ $*6-1$!*$3,,-0-3%-3$,2$!$?#+7+,$72-!,5.>> &$0-*$77->+,.!+>'

/$7,$%+3,2$-*6$,$3,#,2-!+,'

$76$0+.>>'12$3,2$2$!$+3.&-/$ #3%$!>+3$%6.!."!.627 .7-00#!+3,2$/$!%+0,*.%$+3)% ! )6!38

5/ + &/ .>>#%$%,-+3,2$/$!%+0,*.%$+32.*..#!F70.7$ %- +3/$7,4#!+7%+0,+-3+3,2$!+,-#!, ,-,2!-#"24#%+0+.>+3,$!/$3,+-3

,2#7*.8$,2$$76-#7$%0-3%-3.,+-3 -37$?#$3,>'

,2$0#*#>.,+/$$55$0,-5,2$.#,2-!+,.,+/$ 4#%+0+.>6!-3-#30$*$3,.70.!!+$%+3,2$.&-/$$<,!.0,$%6.!."!.62

*.%$ +3 ! "# ,2#7 0-*6>$,$>' 0-#3,$!/.+>7&-,2,2$7#6!..!"#*$3,7!.+7$%&$5-!$,2+7-#!, &',2$ 0-#37$>5-!,2$6$,+,+-3$!7 ,2#75-!%$3'+3",-,2$!$76-3%$3, ,2$ &$3$5+,-5,2$7$!/+0$6$37+-35-!2+77$!/+3"+3,2$ *$!$>'-3,2$ "!-#3%,2.,2$2.73-,0-*6>$,$%,2$?#.>+5'+3"6$!+-%-57$!/+0$

&$7+%$7-3,2$5#!,2$!5>+*7'"!-#3% ,2.,-3>',2$0-*6$,$3,.#,2-!+,'

+7.#,2-!+G$%,-0-3%-3$,2$7.+%72-!,5.>>

-3$,2$>$77 +3 ,$!*7 -5 ,2$ %$0>.!.,+-3 *.%$ +3 ,2$ 2$!$+3.&-/$ #3%$!>+3$% 6.!.

.7 0.!!+$% +3 ,2$ /$!%+0, ;7#6!.= ,2$ 0>.+*7-5%#.>5.*+>'6$37+-3+3.%%+,+-3,-,2$5+!7,5.*+>'6$37+-3 +5 !$?#+!$% 1-#>%&$!$7,!+0,$%5!-* .7$3/+7."$%&',2$ )+3+7,!'-5$5$30$$,,$!%.,$%

6!/1 7086 % 0$ 3.5,$!*.,2 ,2+7-#!,5+3%73-*$!+,+3,2$1!+,6$,+,+-3 .3%1+,2-&7$!/.,+-37.&-/$ ,2$7.*$+7%+7*+77$% @ 2$+*6#"3$%-!%$!

.76.77$%&',2$>$.!3$%!+&#3.> 0-30$!3$% +7*.+3,.+3$%.3%.55+!*$% : +76-7$%-5.>-3"1+,2.>>6$3%+3".66>+0.,+-3;7= +5.3' :)

) -

;

:) ) *;

'$$ 34.> 808 9/26!3< / ! "

< 808 9 0/41 "