High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4967/2011dismissed

Ravi Kumar And ORS. v. Mahesh Sharma And ORS.

2016-10-26Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

"#$$%&'&() %#*$+ #,-

".&/01"+#,$+'

22$33"(#'

4$+'0'

",$',,"+1"#,$+'

$'2(5$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&-()./'

+$'$(#) +"36"77"-5.%"#$- +#,$"22$33"(#' +01"("&(-5.%"#$- ++$'2(5$(#' 8 99999 +*,&-(

22$33"(#:23"&(#&' "+$ "77+&$.$5 "7"&('# #,$ %(%0++$(# &(5&(7'- ;,$+$*< #,$ 2+"<$+ &( #,$ '0&# '$$6&(7 5$%3"+"#&( "(5 =&(# 2''$''&(;&#,%('$>0$(#&"3+$3&$2$+1"($(#&(=0(%#&(*$&(7;($+# #,$$?#$(# @8+5',"+$&($>0"3',"+$'*$&(73$7"3,$&+'+&= ,"('( "1,"(5$+"(55$$(5"(#'*$&(7=&(#;($+'&(2''$''&(##,$ $?#$(#@8+5 ',"+$&($>0"3',"+$'#,$'0&#2+2$+#<-&$-"7+&%03#0+"3 3"(5-#,+$$,0'$'-%,"33$(7&(7#,$+5$+5"#$5 8 A

2"''$5*<#,$ ''&'#"(#33$%#+ '#+"5$'"(%#&(&(710#"#&(

&(+$'2$%##,$ "7+&%03#0+"33"(5-,"'*$$(5$%3&($5*<*#,#,$0+#'*$3; +"36"77"-3$"+($5%0('$3+#,$"22$33"(#:23"&(#&' '0*1&#'#,"# "1,"(5$+"(5 "1/01"+;$+$#;*+#,$+'"(5'(' "3"6 "1&';&$"+"';"#&$.&2+$5$%$"'$5,&1 "1,"(5$+;"'

'0+.&.$5*<#;'('"(5($5"07,#$+-("1$3<- "5"( ,"(:5$$(5"(#

-+&= ,"( (;5$%$"'$5!"(54&="<B0?1&:5$$(5"(# "1 ,"(5$+-50+&(7,&'3&$#&1$-$?$%0#$5"+$7&'#$+$5C&335"#$58

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

"1,"(5$+"##$(5$5#,$1"++&"7$5"07,#$++&= ,"("(5#,$+ 0(%#&('-"'&#&'#,$'0&%&$(#+$>0&+$1$(#3"; $ 0+#,$+ '0*1&#' #,"# #,$ 2+2$+#<"# #,$ ,"(5' "1 ,"(5$+;"'"(%$'#+"3"',$,"5&(,$+&#$5&#+1"3"6 "1,07,#,$ 2+2$+#<;"''&#0"#$5&(B"3+"-*0##,$+$3"#&('*$#;$$(#,$2"+#&$' ;035+$.$"3#,"##,$'"1$;"'(#&(B"3+"#;"'3$#*< "1,"(5$+ "(5 #,$ 23"&(#&' *$&(7#, 7$($+"#&( &( 3&($"7$ ;035*$$(#&#3$5 # '0%%$$5&(#,$$'#"#$"'2$+#,$&+',"+$33#,$'$"%#+',".$(#*$$(#"6$( %"+$*<#,$0+#'*$3;-#,0'-#,$+$&'&33$7"3&#<"(52$+.$+'&#<

$+:%(#+"- +01"( "&(- 3$"+($5 %0('$3 + +$'2(5$(# ' "(58'0*1&#'#,"##,$'$%(5C&331$(#&('"*0##,$2+$.&0'C&33 "(5-#,$+$+$-#,$2+$.&0'C&33%035(#*$36$5&(#,$2+$.&0' C&33,"'(#*$$(2+.$5(+$%+5,$"##$'#&(7;&#($''##,$&+'#C&33 "(5#,$'$%(5C&33&'#,$'"1$-&$-C:8"+$',/01"+.$(C:

0 /+&',"(/01"+$$5C+&#$+,"'*$$($?"1&($5C: /+&',"(/01"+

$7&'#+"#&( 3$+6 ,"' "3' *$$( $?"1&($5 # 2+.$ #,$ +$7&'#+"#&(

$7&'#$+$55%01$(#'%"++&$'"2+$'012#&(#+0#, 3"&(#&',".$"&3$5 #3$"5"(<$.&5$(%$++$*0##&(7#,$'"1$"(5+&7,#3<'-#,$0+#'*$3; ,".$5&'1&''$5#,$'0&#-#,0'-#,$+$&'(&33$7"3&#<"(52$+.$+'&#< ,".$,$"+5#,$3$"+($5%0('$3+#,$2"+#&$'-"22+"&'$5#,$ 2"2$+ *6 "(5 #,$ .&$; #,"# #,$+$ &' ( +%$ "(5 1$+&# &( #,$ '0*1&''&( +"77"-+-23"&(#&',".$"&3$5#2+.$(+$%+5#,$ '0'2&%&0' %&+%01'#"(%$ ,$ $?$%0#&( #,$ '$%(5 C&33- &$ 5"#$5

,"' *$$( 2+.$5 #,+07, #,$ #$'#&1(< C:8 "##$'#&(7 ;&#($''-C:$$5C+&#$+"(5C:

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

+#,$+$7&(7+$"'('-5(#&(#$(5#5&$+;&#,#,$ %(%0++$(#&(5&(7'"'#,$+$&'(&33$7"3&#<"(52$+.$+'&#<'0*'#"(#&"3 >0$'#&(3";"+&'$'+5$#$+1&("#&(*<#,&'0+#

%%+5&(73<-#,$"22$"3'#"(5'5&'1&''$5 213- +*,&

453 ()./'

,313567 85

958

,313 12"

958