← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4971/2011dismissed

Manjit Singh Sandhu v. Ram Kumar Goel And ANR

2018-08-29Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry11 pages



  ! "#!$% & '



 ' '()*)+ ,  

 

 -*.*    

   /

    

 -*.*    

  +0

1%2 $!  23

#2 #*+  

 



     



 

 ! 



 

23

#2 4$   

 



  ! "

"   #  ! $% "    "  ! % "

& ' # # (  !

#

  " # "( (    ! (



!

" "( "# ! " ( " ) (

  * "+ #(

    # "    "     "         

,!

" #"     

-.  (  !

 ("

 !   "

         (

(  ,    !

( # " ,

* " "

, 

  " " ,!

/012- #(  ",

.

 ( ' #"

"



 "  ( "  %"

3.45" & "(" ## " 0     "

  #   %"       "

( "..   

  ## " 0  -"



 !"% "## " 0 

 -"

5 

 ( " %"

" #(",   

 " 6 +"

# " #(  ! (  "

    "

 (  ' #  " !

#

  # "  !"% "  "-"

 , " 

"% "

"# ,

 .

7  #    

,

 !(   ",





"% "

"# # ""

""

  (   , "  "!1 ,

 "  

  

 % "&   "! ,  .' 7- 6

8    

 " + "

 (

 # " "   .

  (  !

"% "

  ("(   

)( 

#%" 

" $   )   " "#



"(   (

(' "* " "

#  9.

/ 34 2 "  

 # "  " "

:2 "

 ("(      

 "  :5;; 34 2 "    ! ".

"  ( " " :5;1 34 

' " "( " " "

( ,

( 

"!1 ,# " "



 " < + "

"

 "  

 # "#

(    " ( "   %"  "   

"



 "  + "

"

(("

# 

#( " "



  "  

 " !  " #"  

  "

!

(" (

 " !(8 ' "( " ! ((

 " " "  

         ( "    %"  

   % "  1 ,       "



 " < + "

"

#  "!1 ,    "



+ "

"

%"   

 + "

"

"

$& "

81     6< + "

"

"



 

 " 6 + "

"

 

 "    ! $ (   *



   )      "(

 & "   !  !"% ""

"

( "



  "!

#

  "  

  %" "

(" ( "



   #

 !  "#(, "  "

"

  + "

"

 ' ( " " "( ( !"% "#   <+ "

"

#(# ! "

  .

(   , " 

"% "

"## ( (

  !(  #!

, ' ( "

   "!1 ,# 

  "

,   " (

 " !8   ! "

"

%"  "

( "..  $     ("(    (   "!1 ,' ( " ((

( " #(",    "!



( 

!"% "#  

+ "

"

    "



 " <+ "

"

(   #

#"

""



"% "#(# ""

""

 , "

 "!1 , '  ! "!1 , 



#   ! " 1"(=

,





("

 7  "!1 , 7> "

% "&  ,( ( 

8 ( 7 !

#

   "!  1 ,    %"     "    $      (("



  #(#  ! (   "    

  /012-  #  "

+     , "  

 "!  1 ,   ' 

    !

      (   "!1 ,

, (  2 , "  

 % "& 

 7  % "& *, <6.' <<<

  ( $    (  # "   

 "  !

(  -

 7$   .

 *, < .' <<<(

  ("

"

  



"    )#

"  " 



%"   "(  ( " %" 7663. 4

73<.4

3.4 '"  %""

 ,

"

 .

   1 "

(   % "&  

 " + "

"



 . " ,

 .

 6$   . ##  

     (     

     (

    .

6 

 " 

 )#!

  (   " # 

#" 

8    "( + "

"

  % "& #"

" "

    "(  "  " "/, * "( 

"   " 



 

( (  "

" 7

7  ( " " "

( ,

( , 

 (

-(  7 ", # 



             #   #     "

   ;2.

 % "&  

 "   !

("

# "  

 $   # 

    

  "    "

  "

 # " (

  * "  # !

+ "

!

  " #("

!

("

  " # 

  "(

" +  #   

             

       !

)#   "  " 

,!

"#" 

-.(!

"

""

   0( " "

' #"

, !

   ( 

"( 7 "  "   (



"( 0"(  

"9.

 

     



     

  

  

     

 

 

 !"

#$%& "

 ' 

#$%% "

 ' 

#$(# "

 ' 

#$((      

  ) 

      *   

+  

        

      

  

  

     

   



  

     

  * 

+  

     ,

        



   





    

 



   

*            



 

 * -

+  

     

    

   .

     

             

  

  

     

  



   

    

   )/ 0      1  2           

3  24    

 +

  

              

       -#+   





   





      



56+    0  #$$7& #$$7     

      ' 

  3'         788#                

            

56+ / 7





  +

  +     

*  

 

 

 

9

 , .

   

 

          .

   

 

   

      * 



    .

    





  

  

 

   

 

    

                 

      .

        

    

         

 



 

        *       

     

 .

 *     -    



+

 #+ /      

  

 

  

  

 

    

 

     

  

   

    

                  

          

*       .

-  

          

           

       9+    

/*  

     2   *

 

 

   

' + *  

      

      

  

    : "  

#$(# : "  :

 #$$6#;

#;;6* 

    

      :

    #$$&   

     

        *  - +            .  < 

  #$;8% #$;8

  

 . < 

   

   * / 

       

    + ,



     

 +

      



      

   

  *  

 

   

             

     .

    ' +3  -<  

    

  



 

       =   =  

 

    



 

    

     



/ 6      

  #

> #$(7   

  

     5("

 (343!4 ( 8 

 ""

". 

"

#( " ""

" ("



("

  " 0 # " "

"

  "

"  " # ",  "(

 ,   

  #"

"

,!

 " " ) (

, # * "/0;



7      (     "#      

  !

"

(

""  "  , " 

% "& # 

 " 1(

/0; ( ("

 "  "   " "

 " #(  ! (  "     " (    

 % "

& " ,

( ! !

 !#

.

( "    

( (         "!  1 ,  # (8#

 +   " , "



 #"

+ "

!

# "("

0  , 

!

#

  " /012- "

%"   " $   #   !

   #"

)#     ("(  "

 "!1 ,'  "( "#

! " ( " !

(

!

#

  "  ? !

#

  " (

 # 

 " ( " 7 ' " #  (

( "  " ( " " 

  %" ## "    #(

 "

    

 + "

 "

              "     

  (" ( 

 "!

    "' /0;

#(  (

"" "  

("!

   

/0; "

#(   !

   "  ((   !%"    

"  (  "          !



  "



  /0;# ! " "#

""  "    @

" "    > #"  /0 "  # "  (    

+ /0;  "

!

 ,

( ""

  ("

 "  " !

 "

 * "    ( ,  "



> ( +  # "

" "#  , "

 )#!

   ( (, !

" < .'

<<< ! (  " 

 !      " (  , #  8 ! ! + 

2 

"    <6.'

<<<#  ( +   <6.' <<<    #   $% !   

  

,  23

#2 78* $!'

9*:8);<*+ &*< 9:=>+  &*<