High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9950/2018allowed

Jatinder Kumar @ Bawa v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2018-11-22Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal3 pages

!"#!$

#'()*$(+ , )!-.

#' !$(/012#/#3 #,#4# ........(' ' )!(/%,& 5(/,1, 6'#'()*1!7#8#!$)'9(/, .......(,:)!$(!'%,&

- ;< . 6 0 <6 /(,(!'- /.=,9#>#!# $?)+#'(

*)/#::3 +#!':(' ' )!(/.

,.61! !'0#1/ 1!7#8. . . <6 .% <& (' ' )!(/ #' !$(/ 012#/ #3 #, #4# 4#, +)!? +'($ #!$ ,(!'(!+($ 8> 3(#/!($ 6(,, )!, 1$@( <1$9 #!# )! .. 1!$(/ 6(+' )!,

/(#$4 '96(+' )! .(4#, ,(!'(!+($')3 *( 2:/ ,)!2(!'1!$(/6(+' )!, #!$4#, ,(!'(!+($')?#/ )1, 2:/ ,)!2(!',1!$(//(2# ! !@,(+' )!,. (' ' )!(/ 9#, ,)1@9' 9 , :/(2#'1/( /(3(#,( )! '9( @/)1!$ '9#' #, :(/ :)3 +> $#'($.A.

*/#2($8>6'#'()*1!7#8 9(9#,1!$(/@)!(/(B1 , '( ,(!'(!+(.(' ' )!(/9#,#3,)+9#33(!@($ 2:1@!($)/$(/$#'($.

:#,,($8>) !'6(+/('#/> )2(%& 1!7#8#!$)/$(/$#'($

%!!(C1/(#!$!!(C1/(A/(,:(+' ?(3>& :#,,($8>) !'6(+/('#/>

)2(%& 1!7#8$$ ' )!#3 9 (*6(+/('#/> 1,' +(#!$)2(**# /, (:#/'2(!'

1!7#8 ? $(49 +99 ,+#,(*)/:/(2#'1/(/(3(#,(4#,$(+3 !($ 8>/(,:)!$(!',. (:3>)*6'#'(4#,)8'# !($.

9#?( 9(#/$ 3(#/!($ +)1!,(3 *)/ :(' ' )!(/ 3(#/!($ 6'#'(

+)1!,(3#!$9#?(#3,)+#/(*133>@)!('9/)1@9* 3(. ,:(/:)3 +>)*6'#'()*1!7#8$#'($.A.

%!!(C1/( &

+#,( )*:(' ' )!(/*#33, ! #'(@)/>;;

, !+()**(!+(*)/49 +99(4#, +)!? +'($+#// (,$(#'9,(!'(!+(#3,).9(/(*)/( #,:(/:)3 +>)*6'#'( 9( 4#,/(B1 /($')1!$(/@)#+'1#3,(!'(!+()* >(#/,#!$4 '9/(2 ,, )!, >(#/,.,:(/ 2:1@!($)/$(/$#'($

A%!!(C1/(A& :(' ' )!(/ 9#,1!$(/@)!(#+'1#3 ,(!'(!+()* >(#/, 2)!'9 $#>,#!$4 '9 /(2 ,, )!, >(#/, $#>, #,9 ,)**(!+(4#,*)1!$')8(9( !)1,+/ 2(. (/1,#3 )* 2:1@!($ )/$(/$#'($

A %!!(C1/(A& ,9)4,'9#'+#,()*:/(2#'1/(/(3(#,()*:(' ' )!(/9#,8((!$(+3 !($)!'9( @/)1!$'9#' !7# 3/)33 ,182 ''($8>$$ ' )!#3 /(+')/ (!(/#3)*)3 +( %# 3,& +)!$1+' )*:(' ' )!(/9#,!)'8((!*)1!$,#' ,*#+')/>#,9(9#$ )?(/,'#>($ :#/)3( *)/ $#>, 49(! 9( 4#, /(3(#,($ )! :#/)3( */)2.

') .

. . (4#,'/ ($1!$(/6(+' )!)*1!7#8

))$ )!$1+' / ,)!(/, %(2:)/#/> (3(#,(& +' #!$ 4#, ,(!'(!+($')1!$(/@)/ @)/)1, 2:/ ,)!2(!' *)/)!(2)!'98>3(#/!($

9 (*1$ + #3#@ ,'/#'( #'9 !$#. 9(6'#'(9#,'#=(! !')+)!, $(/#' )!'9#'#,:(' ' )!(/9#, +)22 ''($7# 3)**(!(+>(#/,:/ )/')9 ,(3 @ 8 3 '>*)//(3(#,( '9(/(*)/(

9( ,!)'(!' '3($'):/(2#'1/(/(3(#,(.

2:1@!($)/$(/!!(C1/(A4#,:#,,($)!

A#!$ (#/3 (/#3,) , 2 3#/)/$(/4#,:#,,($)!.

%!!(C1/(&.)4

)/$(/ $#'($

A %!!(C1/(A& 49 +9 , 3#'(,' )/$(/ , 1!$(/ +9#33(!@(.

9(B1(,' )! #,') 49(!+)!$1+')*#+)!? +' ,*)1!$!)' ,#' ,*#+')/>)!#++)1!')* 7# 3)**(!+( #,:(/:)3 +>*/#2($8>6'#'(

)?(/!2(!'

49('9(/9( ,(!' '3($'):/(2#'1/(/(3(#,( *)'9(/4 ,(

(3 @ 83( 4#,+)!, $(/($8>'9 , )1/' !

% & % / 2 !#3&

!49 +9 '4#,9(3$ '9#'7# 3)**(!+( *+)22 ''($8>#+)!? +'

9 ,:/(2#'1/(/(3(#,(+#,( ,') +)!, $(/($4 '9)1''#= !@ !')+)!, $(/#' )!,# $7# 3)**(!+(.' ,')8( !)'($ '9#' *)/ 7# 3 )**(!+( :(' ' )!(/ 9#, #3/(#$> 8((! ,(!'(!+($ 8> #::/):/ #'( )1/'. 9(/(*)/( *)/,#2()**(!+( 9(+#!!)'8(:1! ,9($ '4 +(8>$(+3 ! !@:/(2#'1/(/(3(#,()!,#2(@/)1!$.))'9(/@/)1!$ 9#,8((!:/(,,($)!8(9#3*)*6'#'(.

'8( !@,) 2:1@!($)/$(/$#'($

A%!!(C1/(A& , ,('#, $(. 9(6'#'( ,$ /(+'($')+)!, $(/+#,()*:(' ' )!(/#*/(,9*)/ :/(2#'1/( /(3(#,( !? (4)*)8,(/?#' )!,2#$(#8)?(#!$:#,,*/(,9 )/$(/4 '9 !)!(2)!'9*/)2'9($#'()*/(+( :')*+(/' * ($+):>)*'9 , )/$(/.*6'#'(*# 3,'):#,,)/$(/4 '9 !)!(2)!'9*/)2$#'()*/(+( :')* +(/' * ($+):>)*'9 ,)/$(/ :(' ' )!(/,9#338(/(3(#,($)! !'(/ 28# 3') ,#' ,*#+' )!)* ,'/ +'#@ ,'/#'(+)!+(/!($. (' ' )! ,'91,#33)4($.

6 !+(2# !+#,(9#,8((!#33)4($ '9(/(*)/( #33#::3 +#' )!, 8(+)2( !*/1+'1)1,.

%0 <6 &

,7=, 9('9(/,:(#= !@)/$(/ - (, "

) 9('9(//(:)/'#83( - (, "

)