← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/333/2017allowed

New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Seema Devi And ORS.

2019-05-28Mr. Justice Arun Palli20 pages

    

  !" "#$%$&' ( )*

+ ",&-$ %%./ &#"0!- 11"22 &! 3"/%.% 4""5 "3$ &-!6"/%  "%1&-"&!%  '

70 4 04  

 

 

   

 

 04*      !



   

"  

#    

$ % &% '  "

$$('

%)* +  , '-  "

 " #  # "

  . " /    

&-  " #  # "

  .  "    "  

0   

&%%%)*       "    "  # 

   1"       &  

&  ##   "

  /

''

 3 

($$  4  * "5  1" ## 

  # 6   "*! # # 7*'8*9*&228       : /#    # "*!  ## "

  "  "*!  

 /  # /# ;  "    # :! <   ;

# "*!  !

 #    ## "

=   1"   <  ;    #    *"  ;

  ##   8  ; 

>    1" 2?

!    #  

&%%%)*  " "  "!

  "

  

?8%%%%%)* !  

# "  !

   # ; !

    : /#  45 "*!  " 

 "

 #   "* !      6 > 

"!

9

@  #         " "#   A ;

  !#  ##    # " # #!

B##

C    !

;   ##    "     "*!  #   !



D    

  #  "*! !

  !

!

"   !   

'

     "!    " ;# "!

 < ;

  #     " ) "*! EE 4 5 #   #     " !

>       "    B    #  !

!

F !

!

!G "   !

B

%%%%%)* 

8 E2 !

!E  "#    !

?

> B   # # A! " <#" /"

 &$!"- &-$ &%./ &#"51 &(  $2 94$&:6 &-!6"/% &%%'

5

'$ "   

/   H>

# # #  ;     "*!    # !

!

  <   $ 0  # " # #  # ;     *< !

    ;     "   

( 0   # #   "   * F   

 

  

       

   



   

      



 !!

 

" "  # $%

           

#



    

 

    

 &  '

 $%

 !    #       

         

 $ % ( ) (*

;

%    " *" B"   /# !   

 #  I*& "!

 #  " # !

H>

#   4JB *(5 8       "* !    #  JB

*  !

!

JB

*& !

#   "*! JB

*2 C  JB

*  !

"" # .  #  #        &     !

!

JB

*8  "!

     "

& @       I*

  ;   "     :! <    "#   ;

# "*!    "*!      ## "      ;

  " ##      #  #!

*B" "!

  F G

C # # "!

  # # "  "!

  !

  !

 

<     " #     1"  ;

  ##    F; G

0 A "   #

&%%%)*  " ;     # !

 # ;# 1 /!

/  JB *?K  !

 !

   ;   #

$&&%)*  "  """

# #   "    "

  "

)   " "   B   #  2?

!   ""

B"     "

  "  "

  " " 

''

'

%)* # 8%-  "      "

H    

%%%%%)*  

%%%%%)*    "



     H B 

&8%%%)*    !

##  ! 

$$('

%)*   !

 '-   "

 #  # "

  . "     " " 

#    ,

&-  "

  

 ##  #     "*! ##  8 # #   #   # # ##  " #"            "!

!    I*

 /#  #     # #  B *B"  "!

 EE

'



        "    "  8      /

?%  3 

($$        C   E  #"E   "!

I*

 "!

"

A! 

" >   # # #    " ##   E; E      !

   1"

?

 # !  

   " "    "

       45!  4 /2  ="/5  &-  !6"/%   "26$  / &%1/! /1/ !$& &- &!6"/*4&%%(5 '

/

&

) C  " " <#"  :# 7  !$& 2&%./ &#"51 &(0!- / & (4"!6$4&% ?5

'

/

'$%  8%- " 

%-          "  "B""

" !    "      

?%%%%)*

&&8%%%)*   

$ 0   " # # "! "#   # # #  "*!    8   !

   !

4JB

*85    !

  # 0 #"     !

"      * +,#     ##   - ./  ".% 0 

&%( .

1#  *

C      ""



'

)* # F0 ="#G  !

 F7  

 G

C  " F  G   # F !G   !

  <!

   !

  # #

> B  <#" /"

 &$!"-&-$ &%./ &#"0!-46$52  $2 94$&:6 &-!6"/% &%%'

5

'$   #  <#" ",

+ &-$ %%./ &#"  %6  &$ &-!6"/% &%%2

5 '?

   # # #    #     "!

  

9     "    <#" !

   # #    !

  "! !

A!

#     "

  <!

!

  !

   #

( >       

   "     !

     " #    % %& &% ?

 "#  # !

  " 

    "      !

   %&

&% ?

C "

#      #  # '# 

&%  # 

      #  "    <#"

  = 7 C"  C#

  #" 

 * !

* "!  "  *

45 &$!"-&-$ &%./ &#"51 &(  /"54$&:6 &-!6"/%

&%%% /"9:

8&?K 4=7*C C#

5K 45 /$"&! 2&%./ &#"0!-

  &$"2 &%%%  :

2(

4=7* 1 C#

5K 45  !$& 2&%./ &#"0!-  45!4./>$!? ./ &-!6"/%

&% ?

5 '

% 4/7*< C! C#

5 45

46$30#6 &4$&:6 2$ %62   !$& 2&%./ &#"0!- &-!6"/% 4 H0 6

&$?

&%%85  &?

&% ?

4/7*< C! C#

5

&

9  !

  <#"     * 7

   #   F !

!G " ;# !          "

  !

   <#" !

 <#"  /"

 $2 94$&:6%7 %6  &$%7  4 

# 5 !

"     F !

!G "  3 

($$  !   # #   !

   

C    *"  "  :# # #  !

#   !

 "  3  #    >

#!

=" !

4> =5 >   4>5 !

"" # !

  !

!

 # # "!       !

&&  #  " !    !

   "  <#" / & (4"!6$%7  45 &2 C#  #"    "#  # # #  !   #  ## #  !

   <#" >   #       

        I*

  # !

   ;

   !    A!

  #

C    !   #   >    # #    # "!

        B ! "  "

      !

  !

  

D !

" !

  # #      " ##         "*!   8 

&

 # !  *" > #     " 

<#" / & (4"!6$%7  45   "!  # 2?

!

%- "  4 5  !

    " 8%-    

&8  # """

#

$&&%)*  "  #         

"  "   

C #  """

# 

# " # ;   " 6"  &% 8

%-  2&$$)*5   "  !

## "!

"  4#    5

8%$)* 

)   "    B  "!

" *" "#

$'2 )* 

%28?&)* !

!# "

 "  2?

! #   " *" ; 

8828$%)*  # !   E E

%%%%)*    "

4#  "

 /"



@%  :5  "&"/ 2 &%./ &#"0!-  &. 5A6.6/. 5 &-!6"/%    (8$

&% $ 

$ % &% $5

8%%%)*    

8%%%)*   B   C #  "  " 

 !  



'&28$%)*

$$('

%)*   

    !

 '-  " #  # "

   .   

&-  "     !"   "  

&'

"#   A "

 !

!" !

         !

"   !

  ;  4     85   <!

!

   

@ ! $2 94$&:6%E  45 /"

  # <#" %6  &$%E  45 * +2& "

     3  ( 4 

  5 # .         

#

    &



##6    #

      , & #       ##      #            "           "     

 (  1

 # &

    # 

   # &          7           "        

#

* "   $2 9  4$&:6%7  45    9 #

 <#" * +      #   89  3 &:;;&    7

8   ##  #  &    7    #



  #  * >      @ > >

"!

   ""

#  !

 # " F" > ?%G

> /"

  #   <#"

 4#  #     3 

(2(5  * 45  4 5  * /

?



($$ ;  !

"!

   #    !

<!

 #        

(2( 

($$ 

L# %6  &$%E  45  9 / /#E  M",&-$ %%./ &#"  4 !1 2 4$&:6 &-!6"/% &%%%

5 &?

N !

 

(2(     2 !

# # ##   ##      !

   9 $2 9 4$&:6%7   #  %6  &$ B    )#   A!

    

&?

C

 4* 75 46$30#6 &4$&:6%7  45     #        

;       "!    "

F !G  /

?4 54 545 

($$ "!

   !

<!

   4   #   5 !

#   /"

 $2 94$&:6%7 45

&$ @ # /

?

 3 

($$ /

(   "

F !G  B "    "   

(2(  * F   E  E  A "

 #   !

 #  E4 /  "#  !

  ;

  "; > "!

>  !      ;

  ## ""

 C  > " "    "!

> > I 

 >   !

# ;

   "K >  > E # 4 / "  6  3      "

# )>    !

H "  " "  # /

'

?

(

8%

88

'2* !

/

''

!

  , 

<  >K   3  * 45 !

  !

 !

"#  4 5 !

  # <     #

< 45

9#         #  # 

  "    "

E !E     "         G

4J"   <#"5 &( H       /

?



($$  * F

  5.2  #6  = #&

#     " #   . 

 " #       <   5".  #  

 #   #   # ' #   "  5 . 5.     "  "  "  #   " >  # &       #  

  ?    ##  # 

  "      #" #

< 5.     "   #

 #"    

  "      #" #

-*

BBBBBB BBBBBB BBBBBB 4J"  <#" !5       M/

?454 545N !

"   !

     !

<!

  B # #   ## 

2%  #  <#" /"

 <#" (  4 45    F # #  " !

#  6 G    !

       /



($$ A!

   !

"!

A      "!

 

C#    <#" (   4* 75 1 1&   <#" /"

 !

 A # # #   !

 4   # # #    "  "     5

<#" , 71 4      9     # # #     #  

D #     1  1  F" G F"!G F# #G   !

#  /"

 !

   4

($$5   # # # #  K  # #   !

#  #  !# #

C    # #

)    "   "!

2& <#"   #   E# #E   >

#!

=" !

4> =5 !

"" > #" #!

4>5           F !G     #        !

 4# <#" !

   # B      

($$  5     # # #   "!

 " #    "   "! C      # !

#       C#    "    # <#" /"

 , 71 4  1 1 4    >    <#" /"

 !

#  (   # # # # #   A!

   #      7 !    * 7 4 /# :#5    >    #

+ 3!

 ! <#" /"

  #   !#   C  >  #  !

 # #  #    #  1 1 4     /

?



($$   !

 # > , 71 4 #  9    <#"  

(2(  

($$   !

A (  4 45 !   # # 4#  5 # #    #   #  9E     #  !

 #   "   

 #  !

# "  !

 ;

     "!     <#" 

1 1 4

 #  #  /"

 #    9 / 9 

6 (8(2*(8( )&% $

( % &% $* F9 #  A  3>   6 ! G 4J" # /"



  <#" !5  !

 !   <#" 

 "# !

 , 71 4

/"

  9   # "

   # E <#" A     B 

C  <#"  1  1 4 # ! /"

 >  !

  "#  A !  ;#    !

!

 "K    # &

&8   "

$$('

%)*     " 

'&28$%)*   

&-   !

 "    !

  , '-  " #  # "

   .     B !        # 

( )*

+

 04 )  I ;#) D)6

I

  D)6