High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4996/2011dismissed

Jind Co-Operative Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Ajmer Singh And ORS.

2015-10-08Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages

!" #$%&'()&**+" %%** ,&( -.& )! !& %

!"#

"$ /&

&,&( 0(%1'1

&!%%** &-23(.&3 *1'

&&% &.4!&.1'1

&&% 5

" % $" #$%&' ()&**+ " !&$ $ & & && 7()& **7 !&()! ) )&& %%*) !-(). &

% 82 * & "()1 " 14!&821-(). &

%82 #'*"()&'

" !8 (%!*

9& !&!%*

$&% *( &*& !

!!24&

*8%&. !% 0%&& ()&**4 !4! !&-( &

4&%&./*

*.** :( *8 %2 **4 4! &; <%&

(. 5 /*

4&%% !()&** =8&(&2 ! % & /(.% * %&. !)&' !%*

4! 14!4&-( &!.14&%&. !% &)(*& 0 %&& * %&. 4! < & )**4 . ! 4&%&. (&8 %&&4! <& )**4 !*4 4&%&.&)(*&* ! 4&%&.4!( & )!*. !%*

1 4!4&.&:(* &!. 4&%% .>**4&>& !% &/(.% !( **(.&2%* !(.(*' ! 4! 54&4&> )) % 0 %&&? (84** 14!&1 @ 4&4&> )) ! % (&8 44&> )) ! %

(84**%&&? 44&> ) ) % *. ? !4&>) . %& &.82!%*

4** 4&

& ). A!& )! - &)(*& ( $>** 4&>& @ ! 8 ! &' 4& &)(*& @ 4)' ) 0 %&&? (84** 5 !& )!- ( $>**4&>& @ 4 )' ) 0 %&&? (84** *%&. !8& - *24)4&>& 4. *%&. @ 4)' ) (&8 1 * %&. 9*8& )!1 0 )! @A(>.

)!- *24)4&>& 4&. * %&. @ @ 4 )'

) * %&. (&8

(&!3(.&- &)(*&( $ >**4&>& !8 @ @ 4 . &)(*& 4 @ 4 ) (84** %&&? .*&*21 &8& )! - ( $>** 4&>& @

!8 4.&)(*& @ 4)'

) *. ? B . 1 ) ! 8 )' & !& *%% .

& %

!'*(8.!%*

4& 4&> ) *%&. &/(.%

! 4& 8 ) % 5 < & )**4 (& )

!&4& %

0%&&? (84** *%&. )&2 #(.(*' ! &&4 !!&4&5&)(*&% 0%&&? (84** 4!!*8)1! & A!& )!4& 4&> ) ! %4 *%&. 4!!

!& )!44&> ) !&4&% * %&. (&8 % (&8 ! **4&(% 44&> ) (&8 &.!* 2& !%*

7%4& %& !&4 :( - &2 4!!%*

@ .%* %* ) **4 ) ( 4&

&.82!&*#(& $ C!!&! **)**2 4& ) (**2 %&.! 8 )-( & ! %*

& * ** :( *8 %2 **4 4!

&; <%&

(. &.!4!

-( &!%*

4&%&.D//

C!!&!( %*

8 & ( &

A&2 #$%&'1 5D/ 5 C!!&!( !%*

8 & $ - & &2%&D/ C!!&!'*(&! -(& &2 & !(D/ C!!&!( !%*

. 8* ! %& &. %*

!' *( *!%& (D/

* E /& * !& &%' ' (%%&

&*#(&1 &( ).&**%!* 1( '(& %*

82!* )! **)**2 4!( 8)' '(& ( !4282 ) & )!*. !%*

%!28 ) & ! B( 4 %&82! (& )!(& &)(. & )*21!(4 ) ! B(51 4& * ) ! !8 ) &&( &((4&4!82! &* #(& ' -(). &

:( *21 ! %*

4& !* * ** !

:( *8 %2 **4 4! &;

<%&

(. &.!4! 4&%&. =* )))&') ! &-(). &1 *%%*14!!4.82 ! *4& %%** #(& ' -(). &

& ).* ( A 1!%& %%*82 B!' &!&)(. 8!! !'*%&(!&& +& ( * &!%%** !&)(!! * %&. &.&/(.% 4&A*%&1 =&1A=&&=&. 14!!.>**)&2 !' ) :(* 1 4!&1 4& %% ( $>** *8(& ! %& * ' ( 9! ! )& &

& )& % & '*' +& ( * (&!& (8. ! ! 2&

1 &'

& )! 4 .%*. / 0%&&4&&( 1 % (84** 4&&(' 1%

(&8 4&&( % & /(.% 4&&( (& !2&

1!&4&'

& )!

!% 0%&&! 8*! !&4

. ) & *2)&4&.

@ !#(&8*4'&*>!%& % !.& A4'&1*& ( * &!%%** !.! &&' &

& )! ! 1 4!4&(%2 )!% :( 1!'8 .

& !& (! & )*& ( *1

& *!'8 %&%&

& )& ! )& & '& *%% ) !' & %&. * ' ( 84

!. 5 %&(* !&&)'! **4 ) ) &(. $ C$9*4 )!1F8*!. #*&>14!* %%& ) !4 8G1!(8.'&( (. &% % ) &$)

4** !%*

A ! !

' FGC? !

1!> )!1#! F ) &!)'

) 0 %&& A!& )! !& )! @4& )' !) (&8 / 0%&&***F ) &'& 8%*2 %> !!8 %82 )' )%& & !(

.*21%*

- ! &' ()&** !2& !%

&/(.% *%&. ' %% . *& FG$ FG$ ! %2 * 5 $ $5

?55 /*

4& . >**4&>& - &' ( $>**4&>& A!& )! 4%% ( $>**4&>&' %% . * FG$ ) &)(*& %&. %A4&)(*& !%

!& )! 4 %%

'%% . *&FG$

A!& )! * ) 4!

(&! &8&1 4& )'

) 0%&&? (84** 1 *. ? ! ) ! 8 %%& ! *)! ) &(. ! @ 4& * )' ) (&8 *%&. ) % %%& *21 &$) 4& &

&& %&' ** ! &. 8 ) !( ( '4 .%* &'

& )!! 4

&!&*' .$

) ! !8 )' ' FG$1 FG$ 1 FG$ FG$

1 FG$

FG$ 51FG$

1FG$ @ FG$ #&$G. C$ 9*4 )!1 F8*!. #*&> !()&**&*'

! G %*&*4%&%& & !)&2 .%*2 !%*

4&) & !.& %&. 14!&1 !&-( &4&)' %&. %! ! !2 4& %% ( $>** )&2 /*

4& %% .$>** )&2 ! 4 ! . ! A!& )! 4 %% &! &. .%&&28

@ ( $>**4&>&A4 !*

*!& )!4%% @

( $>**4&>&14!4 !*%!8& 4%% *%&. ( $>** 4&>& @ !4 !* *9*8& )! 4 %% ( $>** 4&>&

@ !4! *% 0 )!

A>. )!4&%% ( $>** 4&>& @ .*&*2(&!4%% ( $>**4&>& @ @ &8& 4%( >**4&>& @14!

4**&/*

-.& )!4%%

&/(.%%&&?A*%&14!! .$>** % %*

.%* 4 %%

A*%&.$>** % *%&. !4 (&!& !%*

& & !% 0%&& **8242

%&. 8(!&%2*.&! & /(.% '4 &. C$9*4 )!1

2! 4&)' .%*) & (

2 '(&. ! (* % ( !4!24&)' %&. ?)

!% 0%&& !&:('* %'& 8'!%*

B &*' . !& ! %& *21 !%*

& !%2*

$@$F9$

$ & * ! .%2* !&8%2 15

?$ 9 &%&. 1%2* (&!4

?$ &!%&. !!8 %( %2 *

?$ ** ! !& 4&%( !)!&%2* &!&

%&. !'8 ) ) & )**4 <C$!*. ! & !%2*

$ ?$&&% )!&*%2*

& &' %2 * A ! 8 %&.!24(*!'8

! %2 * @ $5

?$ ! &&% ) %2 *

?$ %%& *21 & ) ) %2 * .$>**4&>& !'&(**2!&4 &(* &)(* &)& )!.& %&. 4 C! &' & )! > %*1 !' 8 . &!4 !& !&) 4! ) !'8 %

& % B!. &&!A!& )! 8&!& !(%& !4!2!4 )' '(&8* &. 82 )' ) ( 42 %&. $(.$) &&'!% ! *4

& )! ! %&. ! ()&.**A4'&1C$%*) & 8( ! &* !% A!& )! 4! ! (%& 8( 0 )!14!*

%%& ) C$ 1 ! &$G. ! . ! A!& )! &* 8&!&

(%& (&-8! A!& )! )

(.8& %&. %& 4! ! . ). C$ (&!& ! 8 & .> )!..$>**!- ( $>** 4&>&1 ! %%& 2 %&* G. A4'&1!4%&. (&8 !8 G%& *2%& FG5?1!*& &' %2*( & A&2 #$%&' ()& ** F.%*2 .%&&2/2*14!!4&

' &.

1!&4&' )&

* %& ! *1 ( $>** )&2 4 &4 ) %2 *

?$4!!4&' !%2 * @ $5

?$1 4!&1 .$>** 4&>&4&%( )&2 !%2*

?$ &' !%2*&(%

$ ?$ !& &1 !& *& .& '$$' 4 %& )&

.$>** ( $>**4&>&14!&&4 )

& %2* =&.FG5?1%%& !!%*

4& %% ! 2& . >**

5 4&>& ** 1 !2 & ! . %2 * 4& )' %&. 1 4!&1 14!4&.*2%% ( $>**)&214&%&.!%

.$>**4&>& 4&%( !)!&%2 *

$ 4 !& &1 ! ! !2 4& )' %&. &!& !' 8 )'

) **28& .& !' * %* && %& & * '&*

* 4! !& &2*B%%&! &(* &)(* 4& %&'* ) 8( %& FG$1 A!& )!4)' ) (84** %&2 /(.% &. ! G ) % 0 %&&$(.$ (84** &)(*&%&. .*&*21 5!& )!1'FG$ !*8 )' .) (84** %&2/(.% FG$ && 5

@ % 82 ! ()& ** !4 ! !8& )!14!4%&.

&.!% (&8 !%

4!9& *%&. 1 %2* 5 $5

?$ !&*&%2*

$ ?$ & & )*& ) ! ! & 8 ) & & *& 8 '& 8'!%*

14!!'8

%*( &) &.!'&2 % ( $>**4&>&!'8 8&()! .$>** )&2'& 8'!%*

!'8

)' %& & * &. & ! & 8 > 4 4 & -2 )%2* 5 $5

?$14!&1 %*

14!4&.(! &!.1&**

!%2*

$ ?$ ! & .*(( *&'* %& %*

:(2 (&*-( !82&*

!# ( B ! & (&!'8 828!! #(& &&' )-( *( !*. !%*

8 ) & %&(*&*2 4! ( $>** %% ?

!'8 8&()! !)&2 .$>** 4&>&'& 8'!*. !%*

!&% 4&' &.!.8 &'

& )!82)' ) !.) =(&!&) !)!&%2*! ( 5 $5

.* !

14!!*&*2!4!!& &(* *4

%&'* ) !()&** !4 ! !' . ! & )*& ) 4! & & ' !%%** 1!. (

. 1! %*8 &! #(&! 4& .%*2*24)&1( $>**4&>& 8 &!2 4&%% ?&$) 0%&& * %&. ?%&. 81!2 (8 *4&%2 *! !%*

A' ) &! &&1 ! &%*.8.$%*! &&4 )* 5 $5

( !&'

$ 14!!4!%2* !%*

+& ( * & ! %%** 1 4!* * ) ! %& %%*1 ! &. ! **4 ) (8 * :( *4 $ HC!!&( &! &(. %& 1

! "!# $%"

&# & '

( ) *+ ,-

* *

, *

* *

* *" .

*/ &!

* *

* 3

@ * 3

4 @ I( & .(! !

& )& %!'8 *8&*2( 828!!#(&8*4F' !& & & %&'* )84 )& !.%*21!:(

&I( !G%* &2 .(!

!&'

& )!%&(*&& )!! 8 )'

82 B &&'! &. 8 ) (8- ! &' & )!1 ) 4&! ) &8&&2.

& ' ! ! %& !**8.& ( ( (!&' B '4 & ( $>**4&>&!'8 8&()! !)&2 .$ >**4&>&1!& &1 &'&*%% ) )& 4(* *2 )'( !%*

%&. %&4!!-( &14!!'8 8&()! &.

! )&2 ( $>** ! )&2 .$>** 4&>& !& &1 :( ! G%* ! %& G ! &' %2 * (

%& )%&)'&&(%(& .* B *%2 * ( $>**4&>&4&*! ! .$>** 8(( &!)&8 ) !24&%*'& 8'!%2* !%*

82'&( %* )

!. !)&2 .$>** 41%*

!'8

) & 4!( !& 8 ) 2 -( 8* & A 1 :( 5!*G%* &2 &&I(

& B ! '* ! %& %* (&*-( %&' &&! &(*&%&(&G !

& . ). .**1 #'*#(&!)-(& ( & #/# I( &!:( & 9! ! #(& 8*41 !' %%& ! &'&2 &)!%&%' !& &1&$%%&

!! !#(& *)**2%&.8*I(

@ &!:( :( *4 ! #(& ! & ! (8. 4!

& & .&* && B %%& ! %&' !' 8 %& && ( 8'( & * %& )%& !*. !%*

8 **4 8 ((&% 82 ( & . *(*.' !&4!. # :( *21!%%*8& .& ! . ."(). &%82! #(&8*4&(%!* & "$'

( )*%+),- !.$