← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/997/2018dismissed

Sajjan Kumar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-01-18The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi9 pages



      

!"#$#%&'&()  *!++!(,-.!/ 0 #"&"&(#/ 1#/'-' *"!"#!/2!(!!($"3#/' 00 #'4($#("'  )  56  * *6  56  **6

/#'#(") /*!++!(*&(738$9%!"#/"3#4#"&"&(#/ :::    ;< 3!==#(7# &( "3&' >/&" 4#"&"&( &' " ("&&%!"&(' $!"#$ ?@ ((#A-/# B 8 @ ((#A-/# 8 !$9#/"&'#.#(" $!"#$ @@ ((#A-/# B  !($ /#+#%"&( =#""#/ $!"#$ C

((#A-/# B@ ""3##A"#("7$!%!$#.&%/#%/$.!($!"#$!'#''#("&!= D-!=&&%!"&( / "3# 4'"  ''&'"!(" /#''/ ==#7# !$/#  &( "3# '-E+#%" 

=&"&%!= *%&#(%# !' !=' "3# /#+#%"&(  "3# !44=&%!"&(F%!($&$!"-/#"3#4#"&"&(#//"3#4'"''&'"!(" /#''/

==#7# !$/#  &( "3# '-E+#%"  =&"&%!= *%&#(%# &( 9&#>  "3# ((B -=&==.#("%/&"#/&!'"&4-=!"#$"3#/#&( -/"3#/4/!2#/&'/$&/#%"&('" "3# /#'4($#("' / !''%&!"&(7 "3# 4#"&"&(#/ &( "3# '#=#%"&( 4/%#'' &(%=-$&(7 &("#/9&#> !' !=' '#=#%"&( / "3# 4'"  ''&'"!(" /#''/

==#7#!$/# &("3#'-E+#%" =&"&%!=*%&#(%#E2'"!2&(7"3#4#/!"&(  "3# &.4-7(#$ ("&&%!"&(' ((#A-/#' B !($ 8 !$9#/"&'#.#("

((#A-/# B !($/#+#%"&(=#""#/ ((#A-/# B@ 

 ;< 3# 4#"&"&(#/ >3 >!' >/G&(7 !' ''&'"!(" *-E ('4#%"/

* &(!/2!(! =&%#!%D-&/#$"3#D-!=&&%!"&(&("3#'-E+#%"

=&"&%!=*%&#(%##E"!&(#$@.!/G'-".!/G'&#@H8 E#'&$#'8 &' 3=$#/  !"&(!= =&7&E&=&"2 #'"   %#/"&&%!"# / =#%"-/#'3&43#4#"&"&(#/$&$3&'7/!$-!"&(>&"3IIH.!/G'''#("&!= D-!=&&%!"&('/"3#4'"''&'"!(" /#''/' &(!=='-E+#%"'#A%#4" &(# /"'!($!''..-(&%!"&( 8!'4#/!$9#/"&'#.#("&'!'-($#/)B J''#("&!=K-!=&&%!"&(')B

 



!"   #$%&'()# '*('+)!,' -)#,.## //$,(),

!  $ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ >&"3 !" =#!'" IIH  "3# .!/G'/!(#D-&9!=#("7/!$#&("3#4&(" '%!=#>&"3=#""#/7/!$#' 88888!($ !" "3# !'"#/5' #7/## =#9#= &( "3# /#=#9!(" '-E+#%" /.!(($&!( (&9#/'&"2/!(#D-&9!=#("$#7/## /.! /#&7( (&9#/'&"2

E  ,(>=#$7#  &($&F*!('G/&" -4" !"/&% '"!($!/$

%  J!"&(!==&7&E&=&"2#'"  %($-%"#$E2"3#

(&9#/'&"2 /!("' ..&''&(8 -('#=  *%&#("&&% !($ ($-'"/&!= #'#!/%3 / '&.&=!/ "#'" !%%/#$&"#$ E2 "3# (&9#/'&"2 /!("' ..&''&( =&G# *6F* '3!== /#.!&( "3# .&(&.-. #=&7&E&=&"2 %($&"&( / /#%/-&".#(" !($ !44&(".#("!'''&'"!(" /#''/&(==#7#')

0

/9&$#$ "3!" "3# %!($&$!"#'8 >3 !/#8 / 3!9# E##( !>!/$#$ ! 3 $#7/## &( !%%/$!(%# >&"3 "3#

(&9#/'&"2 /!(" ..&''&(#/

.&(&.-. '"!($!/$' !($ 4/%#$-/# / !>!/$ 

3$#7/##  #7-=!"&(8'3!==E##A#.4"#$ /. "3# /#D-&/#.#("  "3# .&(&.-. #=&7&E&=&"2 %($&"&(  F*6F* / /#%/-&".#(" !($ !44&(".#("  ''&'"!(" /#''/ / #D-&9!=#(" 4'&"&(&(%==#7#'

/9&$#$ -/"3#/ "3!" F*6F* '3!== ("E#/#D-&/#$/'-%3!'"#/5' /7/!..#'&( $&'%&4=&(#' / >3&%3 F*6F* &' (" %($-%"#$L ;?<

#"&"&(#/ &' !77/&#9#$ >&"3 "3# %/&"#/&! / $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ !' 7&9#( &( "#B &( "3# &(/.!"&( / %!($&$!"#' " $9"&#((#A-/# 3#'!.#&'/#4/$-%#$!'-($#/)B J "1

 /&"#/&! / $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$)B

! 

/ $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ ! %!($&$!"#'3-=$#&"3#/3!9#!9#/!7#IIH .!/G'&(">"3#"3/###A!.&(!"&(' (" E#=> !"/&% / #D-&9!=#("  4/&/ " !'"#/5' $#7/## / IH .!/G' &( #!%3  "3#'#">#A!.&(!"&(''#4!/!"#=2

E 

/ $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$8 & ""!=(-.E#/.!/G'&(">#A!.&(!"&('

2 !/# $&#/#("8 "3#( "3# !9#/!7#  4#/%#("!7#' &' " E# %!=%-=!"#$ E2 $&9&$&(7 "3#.!/G'E"!&(#$&(">#A!.&(!"&('E2 ""!= (-.E#/  .!/G' &( "3'# "> #A!.&(!"&(' '*),13#==>&(7/#=!A!"&(>&==3>#9#/ 4#/!"#)B

&  !($&$!"#' 3!9&(7 IIH / !E9# .!/G' &(  / *% &( /#=#9!(" '-E+#%" !($ 4''#''&(7 3 $#7/## &( /#=#9!(" '-E+#%" "3# %/&"#/&(  7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ >&== ("!44=2!"!==

&&  !($&$!"#' 3!9&(7 IIH / !E9# .!/G' &(  / *% &( /#=#9!(" '-E+#%" !($ 4''#''&(7 3&=$#7/##&(/#=#9!("'-E+#%" '3-=$3!9#IH.!/G'&((#"3#=>#/ #A!.&(!"&(' &# 8 /#4 / =-' 8 !"/&%

&&&  !($&$!"#' E"!&(&(7 &/'" %=!'' &/'" &( "3#

(&9#/'&"2&("3#/#=#9!("'-E+#%"&(/ *%'3-=$3!9#IH.!/G'&((#"3# =>#/#A!.&(!"&('&# /#4/ =-'8 !"/&%

)'3

/&"#/&! / $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ &( %!'#  /#'#/9# %!"#7/&#' &' !' -($#/)B

4

#=!A!"&(  IH .!2 E# 4/9&$#$ /. IIH " IH  "3# .!/G' &( $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ / *%3#$-=#$ !'"#'F*%3#$-=#$ /&E#' !($ 32'&%!==2 !($&%!44#$%!"#7/2%!($&$!"#'

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

B $!"#$@@/"3#4'"''&'"!(" /#''/ ==#7#!$/# &( "3#'-E+#%" =&"&%!=*%&#(%# #"&"&(#/>!'!==""#$ ==C!($ >!' %!==#$ / ! >/&""#( "#'" / !''#''&(7 %=!&. / E#&(7 %!==#$ / &("#/9&#> #"&"&(#/%=!&.#$"3!"3#D-!=&&#$&("3#>/&""#("#'"9&$#/#'-=" $!"#$ @ ((#A-/# BI   3#/#!"#/8 =#""#/ $!"#$ C

((#A-/# B@  >!' &''-#$ E2 "3# !/2!(! -E=&% *#/9&%# ..&''&(

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

=-'8!"/&% ;@<

=#! D-! /#+#%"&(  4#"&"&(#/5' %!($&$!"-/# &' "3!" "3# 4#"&"&(#/3!'@H.!/G'&(&("3#'-E+#%" =&"&%!=*%&#(%#!' !7!&('""3#/#D-&/#.#("IIH.!/G'#3!$D-!=&&#$"3#'%/##(&(7"#'"8 "3#/#/#8 $#%=!/&(7 3&. &(#=&7&E=# ( !%%-("  !''#''.#("  .!/G' !" !"/&% =#9#= !($ !E9# &' =#7!==2 -('-'"!&(!E=# !' "3# %($&"&(  7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ %!((" E# -=&==#$ E2 3&. !" "3&' '"!7#  "3# %!/##/

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

&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ !/# %("!&(#$ &( "3# &(/.!"&( / %!($&$!"#' " $9"  &# ((#A-/#   3# '!.# 4/9&$#' / "3# %/&"#/&! / $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$  #=!A!"&( &' !=' 4/9&$#$ / 3-738 "3# 4#"&"&(#/ ( $-E" '#%-/#$ @H .!/G' &(  &( "3# '-E+#%"  =&"&%!= *%&#(%# !' !=' IIH .!/G' &( 7/!$-!"

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

($ && >3#/#&(&"3!'E##( .#("&(#$ "3!" $#%=!/&(7 "3# 4#"&"&(#/ &(#=&7&E=# / "3# !''#''.#("  .!/G' !" !"/&% =#9#= !($ (>!/$' &' !/E&"/!/2 !($ =&!E=# " E# '#" !'&$# 3#4#"&"&(#/4!/"&%&4!"#$&("3#'#=#%"&(4/%#''>&"3"3#G(>=#$7#"3# !/#.#("&(#$ %/&"#/&! / $#"#/.&(&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ !' !( #''#("&!= %($&"&(  #=&7&E&=&"2 / /#%/-&".#(" " "3# 4'"  ''&'"!

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

 -(4!=!"!E=##'&$#'8&"&'-4""3##.4=2#/"'"&4-=!"#"3#/#D-&/#.#(" !%('&'"#("=27$!%!$#.&%/#%/$9#/"3#2#!/'!'!(#''#("&!=#=&7&E&=&"2 %($&"&( ;

< %%/$&(7=28 &($&(7 ( &(&/.&"2 &( "3# $#%&'&( $!"#$ C ((#A-/# B@ "3#..&''&(/#+#%"&(7"3#%!($&$!"-/# "3# 4#"&"&(#/ ( !%%-("  "3# 4#"&"&(#/ (" 4''#''&(7 7$ !%!$#.&% /#%/$ !' 4#/ !$9#/"&'#.#(" -4" I@8 "3# 4/#'#(" >/&" 4#"&"&( &' $&'.&''#$&(=&.&(#  &'#7,.    $.:'   $.:'   !.&"  3#"3#/'4#!G&(7F/#!'(#$ ) #'F  3#"3#//#4/"!E=# ) #'F