High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5015/2011allowed

Surjit Singh And ORS. v. Rajinder Pal And ORS.

2019-01-24Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal8 pages

!"#$%&'

##('&&"

! ""

#$% ! "

& ))))) #('&&"*$

% ' " "" ( '! %' )*%+! , -

"(.'' $''! /*% !01!2*34 5'"*6(."" " (. "7"

%' )*%+ ! - ,

" (. ' * 6

6 )*%+ ! '+"*% 6 ' *' (. "7"

% "+ ')*!' ''% ""

7 + '"'%"

+*' 8!"'*!* 66

6 1 "7"

*' ')*!' %' '"''"! +*'%,92 &+ '

' " *3*+( )*%+ " (. ' * 4 ' "6'"' *' ' + (* .

!' *!*!1.

!* ' '%*' '! %1""

7 !'( . .'%' ''"''%'"+

+*'"".6'*.'% ' '1*' 6 ! 6! '!* ' ( (." 1 ""

'+'% ' %:'% '% *' "". %'%6'!""

'!' ""

*;;4* 9 ' '

!* - < '==6'+'" ,

--94' * ''

'! %'%!%'2' .

!'%

1 ""

7 6' + ''% " '+'. ()!' ' ' " %*'

. !! + +' !>*''+''( >'!* !' *'>"6"" + '%*' *'('%((. '+''1. '"( 6'"' *'"".6' + ' '"* %6' 62" "*" %:'%%*

! ' '

% *' 6 "* ( ! '' 1 ""

'(' '

% ""

'!' !'

'!' +'2 ' * ! %'%

*'%! ''+((!' '(. '' $"+ %%' (. '' *'' "

'( ' '

?'''&& <

' 5'% * 6'! 6 '+'

< 9 1 ""

'!' '6

< 9 6 '+' 94' " ' *

*'6'* '+' "' ""

' % '%' *' 1! .(6"' +'% '* "*! ' " & )*%+ ' * 1 "' 6 "+' *! '! ' *"" ' "!' !' 1' *6'* %'"7"

. *' (. "7"

6 ( '+' 6' ! ( '! '( "" " (."7"

6(. '%! )*%+"(.' * * ""

6* %*"

*' "+ ')*!' %' '"' (. !! '% +' ! + * ' "! ' ''%' (6 "!'' "'6.(!2'.

!' '

*' 6 !' ' . -@, 6' "'' 6 !'(.5'%*'. 94' + .%* ' * *!'' +' !

!'% !*! "7"

6!! !''' ' ''%' '% . 6 '* %' + (* ""

* '* . (.

6'% '!'. ' ')*!'' * "6'*2'%'* '6 !! + +' !6

3!+"

'! " '' @* )'!"' ' '

!* - <(. 6. +++'! -- (.5'%* ""

'!( *)(5.4' *%* ' '

?'''&& <

6'+'(.5'%*(.2'%

'6 %' " . ""! * (. !! + +' ! ' "! )*%+

)*%+! &

-@- - -@, 4' + .%*"''

.!!

!*+ " '* ''%'(6"'!''' !6'!

'%8"')*!'

6(. ' * '!

'+ % ')*!'' '( ('+' '! 4*"" '!' '*")*%+ 5=( *"+*

" "# # "

$ % 0* ! ( + )*%+ '*&'

() "$*+,-%./0 %)0 1**2 (

## "

$%*+,30,4+ 6,-$ )*%+ $ ' 5'% * 7 # #&8 8 7% # 0

) ( & " 7$%,1110,*. /+ * "'%"7"

*"" )*%+"(.""

*6'*(+''

* ( ' "' *' (' ' + ' )+('

2 %'6'

--9"(.*(/*%4 $*.'""

'!' * ;;4 * 9 '

8 ! ( * ' )*%+ ' ""

* %'% ')*!' %' '"' 8!" ' * !* 6 56 ' ' "'' . +'% 6' % " '% '

" '* ''%'(6 "' !'' ' 5 ' *( )*'

. '

* "!+"

.6'" '' @* )

4 !* "' "*""3(2 ! 1 ' ' "! "' 6 % ' ''%''"! +*'%&92 ,+ '!

*'% '*'6'!6!'%'"!'' "

6.(!2'.

')*%+!

" (. *'

44 $*. 1 ""

'!' * ;;4 * 9 ( *!! * ! '*!!6

3 ! &

' ' '.(6"' ''%'4. -@, *' "+ ')*!' %' 5('

' "! +*'% 9-, 2 + '!

*'%*' 6'!6!'' * "

' *' ')*%+! - -@,"" " (. 5('

'6'+'(.'' $''!/*% 5'"* ')*%+! &

-@-4 ' ''"*)*%+! - -@," '!' '

*' & ' ' '.(6"'5('

''*'6 '*' (.! 1 '' *'' " +2'% '' *!'"! * +2 )' $*%$ ' '

?'''&& <

%"(. ''*''4 '6'"'' ' !""

'!'*;;4 * 9 ' ' ! &

"'!' '

*' - + ('% '+' '

--915'%*2 !"'' ' +' %'% " (. ' ' * '+''% ""

'!' + " ' + * ;;4 * 9 (* . ! ' . ! )*%+

8* 3 39 0* )*%+ &

8* 3 !

. ''! ' '"* 6 2" "*" %:'%%* ! '

%'+'

''""

+!". )*%+!3 &

-@- 8* 3 39"!' ."!'' "

*'%'"!'' "''6'". '*'(' +' '%''% "

' %:'%'! '"".''"*1*' 6'+'(.' * - -@,!'' "'' 6 ' "" 6'! 6 '+' ' )*%+ ! &

-@-1* "*! "' )*%+ &

-@- *

.'+'6'"'' 1 . ! " 2!2 * %'% A*'( '!'. ' ')*!' (. !! '%+' !6'%" '* ''%'(6 "'' % %6.*('"

"7"

'""!*6'!

" *' (. !! '% +' ! + '" !!'*%*'+''*' % "+ ')*!'

. ' *)( 5. 5'% * + ++ ' @ (. 6. ++ *(3* ) ' @* 66 9 --

*3 B !

* ' @*

'C D )+

!*'(6+ "' (6"'*6+.. + !

'+ ''%'% + %* ( " '* . ''* '

. !' (. * !+" )*''!' '+' )*''!' '

6' 6 * B * "

' (." ' "< +6+'!' ' *'"'%'. * 6%'%+*()!+'(6+ "'1"

'''%(.)'

+2 *'#*+ 5('

1*%"7"

' !' '

*'"'%'*'+ ''*' *'(* . . '( . ''!

" '* ''%' * E ' * 6'

%'% 8 " ''+ ')*!' ' & '(8+'

!+"

'6'A*'+ !

) @* 56 6'

'"'% *' ' * '% .2'* '6 '

* "!! +' ! 6' % " '* ''%' ' '% ""!*6'*!

(*""

*6'* %' '%*6'%% ' !( '+(.'

* 6'

'"'% ? && <

< 9'

"!')*%+!"(. ' * "'!* . ' ''% '* ' D6 "

!+*6'!

F4' '6 + )*%+ ! " (. ""

* *

+ '* %

6 * " !" '' + % . ' "'!* . A*'( '!'.

8+''%+' !A*"' *' 6* ( 8!'' *'

'.! +2'%)*%+ %. 4 '6 6('!*'( "" '

6/*%+! , -

"(.""

* ' ' * !

*' (.

% "+')*!'''+'6' !*%* *-$*+,1 % 9250 G$H* 'I ?"2'%7 .7 ?"( .7