Nav Rattan Garg v. State Of Haryana & ANR


  

 
  
 




   

   !"#"$%&'(



  

 

    

 





  %
 )*  + *+,
 )*  + *   ****

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes / No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes / No

3. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes / No

4. To be referred to the Reporters or not?

Yes / No

5. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes / No ****  

    !

 "#  $  



 +, - .

/ %&'
(!"     " !    )* +, )+&- .! /! " 01 !"2"!3.

""" "2" !/"
 " %)'
(!1 ! ! 3 "2 ! /  "2 " 4   2 ".!!" 21 ! " / 5 "6 ! &7 )+&8!."  .9   




  
        
  
 
 
           
  



    
  
    
     
 
     
 
   

 
 
 
    
    
        
       




     
   



 

      

       
 
 
   



 





%-'
:"!  ! !!""" ."! 12%&*&;'.!" !!/ #    %7'
:!!   1 ! "!<1"   .   2 "   " /  !   !

1 ! !

   %*'
: ! " ".!!  "  01  .

  "     ! "2  !  

  /"
 """// 4   "1

"

! "

%8'
(!4"!=

"

"$ 2 1/9 $"""> " 
/")& +& &,?+ (!.2" ."!"!1 ".! 1/"  " 522""%"! @! 522""3'  !
   " . 2 /  $ 2 522"    / ! 522""   (!  .  2.!"  " / ! 522""  (!  "  !"  /  !." 1 /" !"2 " (!!

  2  "   ""  !    1 1"  -& )+&) .!!.!" ! 2">A 1"> "

%;'
:!"" " !"5""1" -+),*9,8 "2" "  .

 )- +& &,,).!" !.2""/ 2" &)  "  (!  " "2"!5""1".!!"
  "  /  #."! !1 

" "   (!5""1". +, +) &,,?%&'!1 "  1     " /     .  "2"   (! /"  "      1"  !
   <1""  ! " .!1

!





%?'
(!".

""" "2" !/"! 
  @" "3 ."/21 ! !" 2 2.! "2/ )+&- %,'

  "  01   "  1     "" .! !/"1 !"#
 ". " !  1!!2"" " / 21! "" 

" ! "/"1  2 ""

2" %&+'

 /   ! 1 .    ! ". ! !   /   "  01     / 1! "

  2 "


 !!// " ""1 ! 1   " 1 " ""  !"2 ! /" 
   @" "3  !   1 /"!

1 !! "2 /522"" !1!" ""

  1"./  2" !"





2 ""! " (!/"
  "   " 2 ! !  .1 2 !  2! ".!. !"

! "2 ""! " .! "1 2"" !"2!

1 !1 %&&'
= .    .!  ! B
   "  "C . 2

1 1   2" .! !
 " ../

1 "D" %&)'

 !"1 "/!"51 &7 )+&8 !.

"""11/1  21A"" " (!A" "/!!"" "". "

1  &- +* )++? "    2 " "

  (!  2    &- +* )++? %&*'    " !  "  ! " " "  $E

1" 2&,;&-& &) )++;. " )* +;

)++&




 "&+ +& )++?

(! ".!" "!.

""" " ! "" ""! !  . "!" " " )++&."!/"!"
 " E!! ! !". "!1 !/"! /

!"2 =!" !1 !! ! ! "

" """.!" !!
 " . 2   ! "!"     1

 ! !   " ! "2 
   " ""! 1 ! "2. #1/!"2 " ! /" 1  ! 5"" 51     +, +) &,,? .!" ! " """! )++& (!"

 "  !/ / !   &?

+* )+&) "

   !" 2  2  "   -& )+&)  (! "2  9 2""  " " !1 1   2 " "    !   = <1"

   " 2!" ! / "2 1!" " %&-'
(!"

 ! "2  "/

1  E ) 1) 551 ! "2 1/ "/!"2"!"/9 "5""1" (!  !"  !  "2 ! /" 
   @<1""  " 3 !1 

"  ""  !"2 "21 !/". "  %&7'
= ! "

!  ! / " 1" !  "  2 " " !" .!" !"  " "2"   +0.1 , $

023  &'( 

 0.4"

023