← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2101/2014dismissed

Daya Ram v. Sri Bhagwan And Others

2015-09-227 pages



     

  

 !"#$# "%&'

() * *+,'!"#    - ./& 01.21  ./& 01.    "!#!*, " *3%4'

5!*%"+46 ,!5)%,' ""4%*+2$ "7 + 45+46 ,!5

",'! *, "%*(9 5+46 ,!5

""!#8*+!*,  "$+!!8 '

*5++9:5.

""!#8*+!*,#, *! ""!#8*+!*, ;;;

   

'

# %9!+,'%#%*,"

-6$", 9$*+!"9 $#!<

,'!!,,!"# ,!*, ( %*#,,'!"+!"+ ,!+ 

8 "*!+ %*(9!0$+(!5)'!"!= ,'!)"%,8!,%,%* > ?  

 %9!+=

"%&'

() * "!#8*+!*, '!"!%*) # 99)!+@ *+,'!"+!"+ ,!+ 

**!A$"!-B8 ,'!%* 9%##%*!"5.

) ##!, #%+!5)'!"!

#,'!"+!"#+ ,!+

  **!A$"!-  *+ ?  B **!A$"!-8 99!6,"5 !) "% *+%##%*!"5

-- :$"( *%4%#%*5:$"( *5"!#8!6,%4!9 5)!"!"!#,"!+'! *,'

9#6'

99!*(!+,'!"+!"+ ,!+C 

8 "*!+%*(9!

0$+(!+%#%##%*(,'!"!4%!) 889%6 ,%*

->-?



%*>  ?  

 %9!+= ,'! *, >!'

4!'!

"+9!

"*!+6$*#!9 ",'!8 ",%!# *+'

4!(*!

,'"$('  ,'!  "+!"#  8 ##!+  =  ,'!  "!4!*$!  $,'"%,%!#  #  )!99  #  ,'!

%8$(*!+"+!"8 "*!+%*(9!0$+(! *,'%#6 #!5*,'!+!

,' 8"!4%$# 4%99 (!

9'

) #5  %#,"%6,  !) "%5  8"6!##  "  %99%*(  $8  ,'!  4 *,  8#,  ) %*%,% ,!+"69

,%*,,'%#!

!6,) # +!%*,'!4%99 (!!4!*8!"#*#5 %*69$+%*(,'! *, *+"!#8*+!*, 5 889%!+ ",'!8#,99!6,"5

!) "%5

,!"6*#%+!"%*(,'!68 ,%4!!"%,# 99,'!6 ,!#54%+!

"+!"  + ,!+ 

   **!A$"!  -   88%*,!+  "!#8*+!*,     (!5 %*+%*('%"!!"%,"%$#5)'%9!=#!"4%*( $*+!"    

          

     

                            

 



    

   ! "#  

$"% 

 

 

  

&    

"  %  

                 "#  '    

     

   

"  (    )  

 *   !     

  

  

    "+



   





   

-B- 

     

 



    

     ,  -       ,      -   ".

( %*#,,'!# %+"+!"5,'! *, *+*!0 9+!!8%*('5

*,'!"6 ,! ",'!8#,  "58"!

!""!+#!8 ,! 9#'!

%##%*!"5:$"( *%4%#%*5:$"( *54%+!"+!"+ ,!+? 

**!A$"!-+%#%##!+=,','! 9# *+$8'!9+,'!"+!" ,'!

99!6,"5)'%9!=#!"4%*( #$*+!"-  

    

  



          "/"

  

 )!  

 

     -      

       "    )!     2

  

   

"(    

   

 "

       



  





" 

      

   )     

    "(      )      

    3  

 "  #             



 ".

'! *, $",'!"6'

99!*(!+,'!"+!" ,'!%##%*!"

%9%*("!4%#%*8!,%,%*=!

"!,'!%* 9%##%*!"5.

)'%6') # 99)!+4%+!"+!"+ ,!+ 

**!A$"!-B5 *+,'!

- - "+!"# #)!99 #,'!%##%*!"5 88%*,%*("!#8*+!*,   # (!5)!"!#!, #%+!@ *+,'! *,)

88%*,!+  #   "    ,'!  4%99 (!  '!  6'%6!    ,'!  99!6,"

88%*,%*("!#8*+!*,  # (!5)'%6') #$8'!9+ ,'!%##%*!"5) #%*,!"

!"!+)%,'= ,'!%* 9%##%*!"

*9 *,'!("$*+,'

,%*'%#8%*%*5,'! *,) #"!!"%,"%$# ,'

*"!#8*+!*, *,'%#"!( "+5,'! 99)%*(=#!"4 ,%*#)!"! +!

,'!%* 9%##%*!"- """"    )     4 

    "         

    

       

    

   

  2

           ! "#  5   67      

  

     5   

 1'

 



         

  6    2       "!

 

   $ 

/     !       





    ) * "8  

           9        

 

            

 -         

   *   -         

 

  "( 

 





  

  )

 *    



        



-- 3    

  

   

                

        6    2  

  

      0%"0$"

00/"    6 

  

      

  

    

    

  

   ! 

    

  

     

 

   ".

*,'!)"%,8!,%,%* %9!+= "!#8*+!*, 5,'!9!

"*!+%*(9!

0$+(!4%+!"+!"+ ,!+ 

#!, #%+!,'!"+!" ,'!%* %##%*!"5.

5)'%9!6%*(,,'!6*69$#%*,'

,%*,'!8"!#!*, #!5,'!%* 9%##%*!"'

#%99!( %*,!"

!"!+%*,'!6'%6! ,'!

99!6,"5)'%6') #$8'!9+= ,'!%##%*!",) #=#!"4!+,'

,,'!

"+!" ,'!99!6,"%#)!99"!

#*!+5 #68 ,%4!!"%,# 99,'!

,!#  '

4!  =!!*  6*#%+!"!+  *+  %*+%*(  "!#8*+!*,    "!

#$%, =9!5'!'

#=!!* 88%*,!+ # (!'!9!

"*!+ %*(9!0$+(! $",'!"=#!"4!+,'

,,'!6'%6!)'%6') #!A!"6%#!+= ,'!

99!6,"+!#*, ",#$

!" " 8!"4!"#%, )'%6')$9+6 99 "

%*,!"

!"!*6!@ *+,'!)!99"!

#*!+"+!"#8 #)!99 %##%*!"'

4!=!!*$8#!,= %* 9%##%*!"*$*,!* =9!

("$*+# ( %*#,,'!

"!# %+"+!" "*!+%*(9!0$+(!5,'!

%*#, *, 9'

#=!!* %9!+ !

"*!+6$*#!9 ",'! *, "($!+,'

,%*,'%#6 #!5,'!

%* 9%##%*!"'

#"%(',9 #!, #%+!,'!"+!"# *+

-?- ,'!%##%*!"5 #=,','!#! $,'"%,%!#'

4!*,8"8!"9 88"!6% ,!+

*+68 "!+,'!!"%,# 99,'!6 ,!#5 *+'

4!6!, )"*( 6*69$#%*,'

,"!#8*+!*, %#"!!"%,"%$#,'

*,'! *, !

"*!+  6$*#!9  9#  "($!+  ,'

,  %*  #$6'  6%"6$#, *6!#5  ,'! %* %##%*!") #3$#,% %!+%*%*,!"

!"%*(%*,'!6'%6! ,'!99!6,"%* ,'! ,,!" 88%*,!*,  "!6*+9 59!

"*!+6$*#!9 ",'!

*,  "($!+  ,'

,  #!  %* "

,%*  "!6!%4!+  $*+!"  ,'!  %(',  , * "

,%* 6,5

5) # 89 6!+ =!

"! ,'!%* 9 %##%*!"5 )'%6'%*+%6 ,!#,'

,"!#8*+!*, '

+ +8,!+6!", %* 98"

6,%6!#%* '%#"

,%*#'85 *+,'%#

6,#'$9+'

4!=!!*, D!*%*,6*#%+!"

,%* >!+*, %*+ !"%,%* ,'!6*,!*,%*#>%,'"!( ,,'! %"#,6*,!*,%*5%,%#*))!99#!,,9!+,'

,6'%6! ,'!99!6,"%* ,'! ,,!" 88%*,!*,  "#'$9+*,=!%*,!"

!"!+$*,%9 *+ $*9!##,'!"!%#("

4!%99!( 9%, %*,'!"+!" ,'!99!6,"58 ",%6$9 "9

)'!*  6'%6!    ,'!  99!6,"  '

#  =!!*  $8'!9+  %*  9  =  ,'!

%##%*!"'!%* 9%##%*!"%*!A!"6%#! '%#"!4%#%* 3$"%#+%6,%*#'$9+*,%*,!"

!"!%*,'!6'%6! ,'!99!6,"*,'!("$*+ ,'

,%*'%#8%*%*5,'!,'!"6 ,!%#"!!"%,"%$#.!%#*, #$88#!+,68 "!,'!!"%,# *++!-!"%,# ,'!6 ,!#'!*9

#68!    %*,!"

!"!*6!  %#  %*   6 #!5  )'!"!  ,'!"!  %#  ("

4!  %99!( 9%,  "

8!"4!"#%, %*,'!"+!" 88%*,%*( "@")'!"!

8!"#*5)'%#%*!9%(%=9! "#$6' 88%*,!*,5'

#=!!* 88%*,!+ ##$6' 

" #,'!#!6*+6*,!*,%*%#6*6!"*!+5,'!%*

-C- %##%*!"'%#!9 '

#=#!"4!+,'

,,'! *,#%*,'! 9#=!

"!

,'!%##%*!"5%*,'! =#!*6! #$889 %* "

,%*,,'!=!6 $#!

9## "!6"+5'

4!*,=!!* =9!,6*69$#%4!9 8"4! ,'%*(%*,'%# "!( "+'!"!

"!5!"!9 *,'!= #%# ,'!%* "

,%*5)'%6') #*, #$889%!++$!,9## "!6"+5 *%* !"!*6!6 **,=!+"

)*,'

,"!#8*+!*,  '

+ +8,!+ 98"

6,%6!#%*'%#"

,%*#'84!*,'!")%#!5=!

"!

,'! "!4!*$! $,'"%,%!#5  %! 99!6,"5  %##%*!"  *+ ,'!  %* %##%*!"5* ,!"% 9)%,'"!( "+,,'! 99!(!+ 98"

6,%6!#=!%*(

+8,!+= "!#8*+!*, ) #8"+$6!+'!"!

"!5%,6 **,=! ("$*+ ,#!, #%+!,'! 88%*,!*, "!#8*+!*,  # (! *4%!) ,'! =4!5)! "! ,'!8%*%*,'

,,'!%8$(*!+ "+!"8 "*!+%*(9!0$+(!#!,,%*( #%+!,'!"+!" ,'!

%* 9%##%*!" *+"!#,"%*(,'!"+!"# #)!99 ,'!%##%*!"5+!#*,"!E$%"! %*,!"

!"!*6! !"%,%#%##!+      !"#!$%!& '

   (  *+3