High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1631/2015dismissed

State Of Punjab & ORS. v. Tejinder Kaur

2018-01-23Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

!"# $$ %&'(')!*!"+, -&%&' ."/%0%"(&1'2* 344'55%"&* 6'2*.* -7&'/!"('28%.2 33 '*4"('"& + 9 - - 9 --#

2'*'"&+ 26!:%*1%".4&%;((5; ."/%0 2%<''"%&2%;(<)%&'2&1'2'*4"('"& ===

1%55'">' !" &1!* !"&2%?).2& %44'%5 & &1' /.(>7'"& &1' 5'%2"'( #2!& .2& (%&'( ,@ !* " &1' >2."( &1%& 5'&&'2 (%&'( AA ."('2 &1' ."/%0 -'2<!)'* '(!)%5 &&'"(%")' .5'*; A@

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

2'*4"('"&D4'&!&!"'2E%*"&'"&!&5'(&2'!70.2*'7'"&%&&1'2%&'*)5%!7'( 445!)%&!"1%*%5*0''"!5'(2)"("%&!"@(%C*9('5%C!"!5!"> &1'%44'%5

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

/%0%"( &1'2* E1'2'!" % )5%!7 E%* 7%(' 0C %" '745C'' 2 2'!70.2*'7'"& 7'(!)%5'F4'"*'*!")22'(25!<'2&2%"*45%"&E!

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

&%5;'E'51!!*(.2!"> &1' *%7' C'%2 %* E%* ."('2>"' 0C &1' <'2"7'"& '745C'' !" %2!1%"(9*)%*' -.42% &1.>1!&E%*"&!"-!2%">% %7*4!&%50.& !"455*4!&%5;'E'51!

'%2"'()."*'52&1'%44'55%"&*1%*"&0''"%05'&*1E &1%& (.2!"> &1' 4'2!( E1'" 2'*4"('"&D4'&!&!"'29* 1.*0%"( ."('2E'"&

&2'%&7'"& %& -!2 %">% %7 *4!&%5; !<' !<'2 2%"*45%"& %)!5!&C E%* %<%!5%05'!"%"C&1'1*4!&%5*."('2&1' ."/%0<'2"7'"&2!"-; 'E'51!'*!('*;"'!&1'2E%* ."/%0<'2"7'"&5'&&'2DAD@?

@(%&'(AA 2'5!'(.4"!"4%2%>2%41* %"( &1''&&'2 %&'"&*44'%545%)'(0'2'&1'5'%2"'(#2!&.2&%&&1'&!7' (')!*!" (%&'( ,@ 2'<'2; !" <!'E &1' (')!*!" &1' 5'%2"'( -!">5' '")1 !" %2! 1%"(9* )%*' -.42% *!")'; !<' !<'2 2%"*45%"&%)!5!&CE%*"&%<%!5%05'%&-;'E'51!%&&1'2'5'<%"& 4!"& &!7' E1'" &2'%&7'"& E%* &%:'" %* !* &1' 4*!&!" !" &1' !"*&%"& )%*' ; &1'2'2'; 45!)C (%&'( AA 1%( & 0' 2'%( !" %<.2 &1' )5%!7%"& %* &1'2' E%* " !F'( 4!"& %**'**7'"& & !").2 7'(!)%5 'F4'"*'*

"&1')!2).7*&%")'*;E'("&!"(%"C2'%*"E1%&*'<'2& !"&'2'2'E!&1&1'E'55?2'%*"'(2('24%**'(0C&1'5'%2"'(E2!&.2&

))2(!">5C; &1' 42'*'"& %44'%5 !* (!*7!**'( "*'K.'"&5C; &1'%445!)%&!"*'':!">)"("%&!"@(%C*9('5%C!"!5!">&1'%44'%5!* %5*(!*7!**'( !"#$% &%'! &%'! , %7!& #1'&1'2*4'%:!">D2'%*"'(+ '*D #1'&1'22'42&%05' + '*D