← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1684/2015dismissed

Gursimrat Singh Randhawa v. Guru Nanak Dev University And ANR

2016-02-15Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal17 pages

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -1-    

          "#$%$&'(')*    

      



 

  *  +  ,,,,   +  ,

       ! " #   $  % &'

#!   

% (  $  

#     % ) * + 

 

, " ,!

 + ), " ,!



  ,,, -  ./    " "  " 

 #  ! #          +

-. ! /        0 ! 10

! +

-. ! &    223 0

"

 "

! 45&&56    !



 '

  !  !



.

""  ",

#

 "" " 

 "" " 

    !

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -2-       #  ! #      $    (5&54# 

7  8 ) 96& !&54 #   

!

" 

   

,   :;

; - !

 

 < :

 <    "

 223:'

 =< 

  #   '

 

 7  !

  

  !"    , 8

   

 2 !.

-..:22-/5>< 7 "-..:22-/5< # 

223:'

=; <  

:

 <""

,           !"      ""  !  

" 

 "? # @

    

 '

 =; 223 8  ! 

:

 <!



&5/-&59A

!  0

 " A #     )    :

)< ! />(   8   )   :8)< ! />( ""

,  !

     

!B#, !! , "    

 !!"      

 "  !

#

 #!



"

 0

  !

 

" #

 

 :

   < A    0    

,!

 

#     0

"





"

 '

# 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -3- " " !"  :

0 )&< 



       

,      C .

  !  " !" , 

    

 &456&5/   +   # A ) 2 A , 



  "

  .

 "

 B D1  '

E,    

  DF   E !

,  

  

     !

     '

,   

 ",      0

 

  ! 

  ! "  !

"

   !

 

:

 <

     #  " " !"   # !!"    

 :

   <  !  " " !"  &/5&&54:

0)(-8  < 

" !" , 

   "   # "

"

'

"" !"  &/5&&54:

0)(-8  <

  !!

 !  ;) F;, 

 ! A     !

 !   !  &/5&&54  &>5&&54,     !

"

 

" !"  5&5(&54:

0 )( - 8  <  #  #  " !

 # !!

! ) F  !

!

 ! 5&5(&54 545(&54,  !

"

   0

   #  # ""

,    

 ""  #  

:

 <  #

@ 

A #

" 

:

 <   ""

 

,

 !

    " "  

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -4-

 

"

     !

 #

 

!"  A  



  !



!" !

!" . #  

:

   <

    , 

, "

 "  

  "

 "        " 

'

 !!" 

:

 < !

 "

 "         # !

 

   !

 

  0

 A     "

   

"  " 

"

  #   "

 0

'

@ !



!   #  

 "  

 !

   #    A  ##

  # 

:

 <  0

 !

 "

   "

 "

5>54&54'

   ! 0

 8

   

:22-/59<:6/&<:.

,

, C,8 < +"

,

(54&54, 

   "

  ! 8

   

 2 ! .

-.. :22-/5>< :6/&&< '



 !

 !          

" '

      "

 "

  #$"      A     3

,    # 

"  "

   !

A ,

,   ! #   :

   (<

" 

0

 0

 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -5- !"  ""

" " "

"  "

 A

  . # #   

  

""

 

  

    #   #  " #!

 8  A ,      , ""    :

 (<A    (54&54:

0)/<

 A    ! 2, 

,   :

   &<  

  "" 2 

   "

 "  

#  

 

   0

   # # #  

 "

" 

0

# " 



!"  

 ,""

, 

"

# 

:

 <

,      

:

 <   !!" "

"      #.

" 

,"

 " 

  

 A@ ,

,    

 "

 

"     0  0

>54&54,  G  2-.. :22-/5H< :6/&(<     !"

 #   

  '

! , 0

! 7 "-.. :22-/5< :6/&/<,    

&54&54, 

  " 



!"  

'

  #

" 

" !!"



:

 <  "

 " 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -6-        

# ""

   !!" 

,

,  "  !!        

:

 <  ! "

 



"     

!     0

'

#

" 

:

 < 0



#  "



 # #"

" ,        0

,   "



 #  # " 

# "

A 

 0



 

:

 < 

 "

  

,   "

"



  

"   "

 , !#

    !    " 

    

0

'

!!" 

!

"

  "



 ,    # ,         

0

 !

     

 #        

     #  

 !   #!

 

 

   '

! , 0

!2

! 8

" -.. :

" 8

" < :22-/< :6/&4< 

 &954&54  0

!)#".



2:22-/&<:6/&6< 

&H54&54.



, 

      ,8

   

2 !.

-..:22-/5>< 7 "-.. :22-/5<    !    

.  

 # "

  "

 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -7- :

 <  

  ,



  !" ,

 0

A! " !+) 

!   

  

 :

   <,      #           "   "

 

 ! 7  ,&54A

  "    0#$" ,8

   

2 !.

-..:)  22-/5>< 

 

-0 "        ! !!

" B#, 7 "-..:)8 22-/5<

  "        ! 0  "   

   "      :

0 &<  #  #  '

  "      #$"    

  !" 

     "   :

0 (<   "      :

0 /< !

 8

   

 2 ! .

-.. :) 8  22-/5><          "  :

04< "    :

06< !

7 "-..:)8 22-/5< # "

"

.  ! #   

 

 I 7 , &5/  

0 ) 

     

"  "

 ! 7  ,&54 ,&54.  #     

  !  5&5(&54  545(&54   !  &/5&&54  &>5&&54  

0)(:"

 <

$ !

    "

  1

, # ,!



0" 



: " "

" <   , 0  "

 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -8-

A 2  :

 &<    2  1" 

   3 8 " ! .

 :

0 9<, # "



 ,

4J " 

 '

"

  "    !

"

 :

0&<   

 

-0"    !!!

"  8

   

2 !.

-..

  

  "    ! 0  "     7 "-.. '

, 

    "#

 ?  "

0  !4J 38 " !.

'

!

,  

#"

.  #    !  #$"   , , # 

  8) ! (69 :        @  ! /4<     ! "

    "

,     "

 + ,&5410

:

0><, 

 # #   , ", "



# 

  0  , "" &54-6    8)F ":

0H<"# , !    "

   F "         "  !    ,! 7 "#,&5/'

,""

    

!   "



""

&54-6  

7 ,&54,



 !

 

       

 "    

#$" .   

  

!   "



" ""

  " , 

    

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -9-  ! " 

   

! ,!$  " 

 2

7 "

    "

@

  #  "

.      # "

"   0  2  

" 

#  

  

    ,



 

"   0

#  

A ,   !   





        

 :

  <  # 0     # ! , !!"





     . "



""



" 

      

#" !   

&56A

!



      ,      

!      

  

 " 

   7 &54  

 "  ""  '

,   , 

  " "

     !" 

"   ! 



# !" ! #  " 

. !  ## 

7

 "

     

 #

    

 !! , ! 8  

(5&54,     

  #   "  

! "    

     

 '

8   0      "

  #

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -10-   "

"

'

  !  #"     

,  ,"



#"

      

 , ""

,       0    

:

 < #  !  !



&54->  " 



!" ,   #  # !  !"        !



&5/-9 

!"  

     '

     !   

   ""

    #   #      " !



&6&54. #   , !" , 

 "  # "

  !

 

      

  !

, 



!

 

    ,8

   

2 !.

-.. 7 "-.., 



(54&54 &54&54,"     "

!

  "

# 

 2 "

!

#   "

 

  

      8

   

2 !.

-.. 7 "-..    "# 

:

 < 2 "



!



# 

  

  "   

 "

 

 "

 "#   A   !2:

 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -11- &< 

  "

"  0 

!4J""

2 1" 

 38 " !.



 #

  '

!

,  

  " "

    "   

  ,  ,) ,   

, #   

"  #

  

, #      "        !!    &65&54 ! 

 $ 

 

,  , 

,  .

!" , 



 

   !! A, !" , 

!  ,   !   " 

 959&54:

0/<   

!"

 

   @ 

  ! 

! "      #$" , 

   

 2 ! .

-..   7 "-..,   "   A ,   #  #     "

 

:

 <, 

 

  ""

   "

 !

 

:

   <,     #

  @ 

 #  "- " 

. 

,#

 

  #$"      #

  " ,

   

 2 ! .

-..   7 "-.. .

   #$" , ""

 

0 &, !!

 "    

   

 2 ! .

-..   @ "   

, 

 -! "  '

    

-0 "  '

A     "

4J 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -12- "    4J ! 

-0    #  

" .

#$"  !7 "-..," 0 -!

 "   #   4J  "    

   "  '

!

,   !

 "    8

   

 2 .

-..     "    7 "-..  "

,   

 "

 @ " ! 95J    "     #    "

   !

  !  7  , &54  , &54 :

0 5<  #  "

"

,   #

     

    8

   

 2 .

-.. 7 "-..,

  #:

0&<  A    ,   $   " 

 !  

        , #    

   "  

   

 2 ! .

-..   7 "-..,  "   

0&,#

"    :"  !! < #  "  "

 

 "

         "     #$" ,    " , ""

   !   

 "   ,  

0&,"

" '

!



 @

 #$" ,      "    # "!

  #$" # A   !2 " 

# A   ,    #$"  !    4 :2 ! 8

" -..<,     0  "      - " 

 "     :"  !! <#  "

"

"   

#    #$" ""





(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -13-

  ,  2 ! 8

" -..,   "

  

 '

  ! !    " "  

05  #  "

 " 

:

0<, "

"

 '

"

 " 

!     8       ) ! ,   ! 2 '

#$"  "

 " 

,D" 

  !2 # AE. #  A   

8  .

#$"  !2 !8

" -.., 

#    ) !     8      

 :

  <   0  "      - 

"    . ! #    "



" 

@     

  6,# ( ":< " A   !   !

 

 "

 "

"  

  !

 !!"  A    #   

! 

    ,    .   #        #    



   "



"      #        A  

&>5/&54

 " 

     " 

   4&9   

0  "   

 

- " 

 B#,  49>

  "  

 - " 

 



 

 "

   !

 

  !     '

  

   . # 

  A         #   8 

            0



(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -14- 

 

  0

!

 



 .  

 #    ,       ,  

, 

 

    :8  8

   

<!

 

 "

 "

,# 

#

 " ,    "

. #  

"  

 

!!" A   '

  , !   !#" "

   ""  !

!

   



 # #

 #            !     "   

 "

!

,   "

  "  '

"  #



!

 

# A   ,#

@

# "-8 "  

#$"    '

!

,  "-8 "     

" 

 "   @ 

    

  

 

"    ,8

   

2 !.

-..  7 "-.., !

   #    

  ",   #    #  

 '

 #

"  !!"  , 8  

A , 

   !

 

 

0 &    ! #  

0 5,    

 

 

 '

     

   "   #

 A , ""

 

 

  "      #$"  ! 8

   

 2 ! .

-.. 

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -157 "-.. "



 # "

 #

 4J '

   

   

   , 

      #  ! ,  #

 #  

 7     + ) ,    #   



!"     #$"      ,    # 

 ""

 " 

    "      "

 3 

  !   

#$"    / 

#$"       (   6,  

! "   

#      

 #$"       4,  

   "

"    #  "

    ,  

,

!! ,""

 "

!



,!

  

   

      

 

  ,   ""

  " 

   959&54 :

0/<,  

!  1

, 

7 





 

         

:

 < #  # ! 

!!" 

 '

8  

" !0")%'1"20%3')'(#2"#')")%")#0$24"15'#,')10")% #0$2(- ..

,672$3$62#8

   *

     

    

                 

           

                   

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -16-                     

              

                     

               

       

       

  

  

                  !            

"

   

   

    #

             !                        #

       

             $      

           

      $   

             %    

                  #                                         &    

          

    

  '

(226) LPA No. 1684 of 2015 (O&M) -17- !

,  # , "



# !  #" 

# !  # 

      

 .

""  ",!

    ""

   ,,, !  



  !   45&&56 

 #!   *=